|
4th May 1940, Page: 346, Column: 1 Accidents And Their PreventionThese notes are based on the Mines Inspectors' Reports for 1938. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies an obtainable through H.M. Stationary Office. Underground Fires. A fire on a main haulage road at Dumbreck Colliery took toll of nine lives, and was the subject of a special report. The origin of the fire was the intense heat produced by the rupturing of a cable. At the inquiry the jury returned a formal verdict that the men died of asphyxia, caused by the inhalation of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide. Sealing Crevices. In his annual report for Scotland Mr. T. Ashley says that in 1938 sixteen underground fires were reported as dangerous occurrences, classified thus: Spontaneous combustion, 10 at 7 mines ; naked lights or smoking, 4 at 4 mines ; electrical, 2 at 2 mines. With reference to those caused by spontaneous combustion, mention is made of the fire at Lochore Colliery. Several sections in the colliery had to be temporarily stopped while attempts were made to dig out the fire, but these were unsuccessful and it had to be sealed off. The proximity of waste made effective sealing difficult; eventually the fire was suppressed by pumping a large quantity of water, sand and limestone dust behind the stoppings. At this fire the efficacy of a mixture of limestone dust and water for sealing crevices was proved. Fire-fighting. Mr. Ashley mentions the issue in August, 1938, of General Regulations, coming into force on 1st March, 1939, and laying down for the first time in the history of mining legislation regulations of general application in regard to the provision of material and equipment for fighting fires underground and to the organisation of fire-fighting work. Readers are reminded that there are already some provisions in the Coal Mines Act, 1911, and in the General Regulations bearing on fires underground, but these only require the provision of fire-fighting appliances under certain conditions and to a very limited extent. Great experience in fighting fires underground has been gained at mines where spontaneous combustion is prevalent, and at these mines it has been found that an ample supply of water brought to the seat of the fire in pipes is the most effective method of dealing with the problem. In this connection the Inspector considers it is of interest to record that the Wemyss Coal Co., Ltd., Fife, who at four large mines work, among others two thick seams subject to spontaneous combustion, have installed over eleven miles of three-inch diameter steel pipes along the main roads in the seams liable to fire. The pipes extend into every section and spare pipes and hoses are kept in each main section so that the pipe lines can be rapidly extended. A large supply of standard length pipes, short lengths of pipes, spare joints, elbows, bends, etc., are kept at a central point on the surface and, in addition to the smoke helmets required by the regulations dealing with precautions against spontaneous combustion, self-contained breathing apparatus is kept at a station on the company's premises. Through the courtesy of the Wemyss Coal Co. Mr. Ashley reproduces the standing orders issued by the management, as under. Fife Company's Standing Orders. In the event of fire occurring underground, the following Standing Orders 'A' will be put into operation :— 1. The senior official in the section will take immediate steps to ensure the safety of the men in the section and of the men, if any, between the sections and the upcast shaft. 2. The senior official in the section will then notify the check office attendant, or his substitute, giving a short description of the occurrence and the site of the outbreak. He will also say if he wants any men sent to the section. 3. The check office attendant will at once notify the agent, manager and under-manager. 4. The senior official available will then take charge of all operations in connection with the fire and shall, if he deems it necessary, put into operation 1 to 5 of the Eighth Schedule of the Rescue Order (Regulation 17). 5. The senior official in charge will then despatch to the fire a complete set of fire equipment including hose connections, hoses, smoke helmets, reviving apparatus, canaries, sand, tools, etc. 6. The senior official in charge will then determine the length of fire pipes, bends, etc., which he requires, and shall telephone these requirements to the rescue station (East Wemyss), where rescue station standing orders will immediately be put into operation. 7. The senior official in charge will then appoint a man on the surface to be responsible for sending the pipes down the pit without delay. 8. The senior official in charge will then appoint a man at the pit bottom to be responsible for receiving the pipes and for their despatch to the section without delay. 9. The senior official in charge will then appoint a man to be in charge of the transport of the pipes from the pit bottom to the section, and that man in charge of transport will deliver the pipes to the overman of the section. 10. The section overman will then start to lay the pipes from the existing fire connection to the seat of the fire, and will see that the fire equipment mentioned in paragraph 5 has arrived. 11. A copy of these Standing Orders 'A' shall be kept posted at — Check Office, Officials' Room, Report Room, Engineers' Shop surface, Engineers' Shop underground, Under-manager's underground office, Shaft Pump Room, every Fireman's Station, Rescue Station (East Wemyss). Fires due to spontaneous combustion, Mr. Ashley points out, usually give warning of their existence long before they become a danger to the men inbye, and while promptness in dealing with them is essential, there is not quite the same necessity for speed as with fires caused by other means which may rapidly assume large and dangerous proportions. There is little doubt that the most effective way to meet the requirements of the new regulations is to provide water under pressure by means of pipes. The advantages of pipe lines are appreciated by several large firms who have commenced to fit up their mines accordingly. Observations on Care of Machines. Dealing with the question of underground fires Mr. W. J. Charlton in his Northern Division report instances a case in which some stonemen and rolleywaymen observed a glow in the haulage road and intake airway near a small air-cooled two-stage electrically-driven air compressor used to supply power for pneumatic picks. The machine was stopped and a small quantity of oil found to be burning on top of a valve casing. Subsequent investigation showed that there had been burning on some sections of the radiator intercooler, and it seemed probable that the fire originated in an explosion or ignition of vaporised oil in the intercooler. The occurrence was in itself trifling, but seemed to be of considerable importance as indicating a potential danger which might, in other circumstances, have more serious consequences. For the benefit of other users of similar machines the Inspector offers some observations on the installation and care of the machines. The compressor-house should, of course, be constructed solely of non-inflammable materials, and care should be taken to keep it free from accumulations of oil or other inflammable material. It should be so arranged that a cooling air-current passes through, and so that the air supply to the machine inlet filter, in particular, is as cool and clean as possible. The number and severity of bends in the supply mains should be reduced to a minimum. The recommendations of the manufacturers regarding the type of oil to be used, the frequency of oil changing and the intervals between the examination and cleaning of valves and intercooler sections, should be observed. In some cases these recommendations may be based on the assumption that the machine will be worked only during one shift daily, and it seems obvious that when machines are being worked almost continuously (as they sometimes are) the recommended intervals should be correspondingly reduced. It would appear that, in the case of some machines, heat is not dissipated so quickly or so effectively as in the case of similar machines working in comparable conditions. In any case of difficulty the manufacturers would, doubtless, be glad to advise. Special attention should be paid to the provision of fire-fighting aids in such situations. At a Durham colliery, a small fire was discovered by deputies, who quickly extinguished it with stone dust from a supply kept at hand for use in such circumstances. A tail rope drum-roller was mounted on the inside of a curve in a wood frame set in a brick wall. Some trouble had been experienced with the roller and a wagonwayman had removed it for examination with a view to remedying the cause of the trouble. He found the spindle had been fast and it was hot. The deputies were passing when they detected a smell of burning and investigation by them disclosed that the end of an old balk at the back of the roller was smouldering. The importance of keeping hauling sheaves running freely is, of course, apparent, as is also the advisability of making sheave frames of iron. Some Yorkshire Fires. Yorkshire had ten underground fires or heatings. None was extensive, but as Mr. H. J. Humphrys reports even a small fire in a safety-lamp mine may have serious consequences. His remarks on four of the fires are reproduced, indicating briefly the cause and what might be done to prevent recurrence of accidents. When a small electric drill was being withdrawn from a shot-hole which had been bored, a flash occurred where the cable entered the machine plug. The sheathing of the cable caught fire but this was quickly extinguished by stone dust. No other damage and no personal injury resulted. The breakdown was due to breakage of the conductor at the point where the cable was sharply bent, a strand of one conductor piercing the insulation of another core and causing a momentary short circuit. The cable had not been secured to the plug in the manner designed by the makers. At the same colliery, whilst an electrical coal-cutter was at work, the driver noticed a wriggle in the trailing cable near the pommel and then a hissing noise. He gripped the cable, found it working inside and gave orders to switch off in the gate as he believed — rightly — that the cable was about to burst. The flame which followed set on fire two canvas bags on the top of the machine, but the fire was extinguished within two minutes by two buckets of stone dust. Subsequent examination showed that the cores had been displaced at several places along the length of the cable, and this may have caused some of the conductor wires to break and the ends to be forced through the core insulation. A fire occurred in a main and tail haulage house situated alongside a main intake airway about 100 yards from the downcast shaft. The driver noticed flashing of the brushes of a 60 horsepower, direct current, motor. He cut off the current and sent for the electricians, and three arrived shortly afterwards. When the current was switched on again the sparking was pronounced and adjustment of the brushes failed to reduce it. The resistance was suspected, and when the heavy cast-iron cover was removed the oil in the tank was seen to be smoking, and it then burst into flame. The current had been cut off about ten minutes. An unsuccessful attempt was made to replace the cover and the three men were driven from the haulage room by the intense heat. Fire extinguishers and stone dust had no effect on the flames, which continued for nearly five hours, when the oil had all been consumed. The fire was due to the fact that the resistance was overworked and consequently overheated. It had been smoking shortly before the fire and there was evidence that it had been running hot for some years. It should have been replaced by one of higher rating. The lubricating oil of a compressed-air driven turbo-motor driving a gate belt conveyor fired and was observed burning over the surface of the motor casing. A deputy who was standing there immediately extinguished it with stone dust or the consequences might have been serious as 26 persons were at work on the face. The speed of the motor was 1,200/1,500 r.p.m., and it was found that the ball bearings in the governor ball race had seized and the resulting friction had ignited the oil, which had a flashpoint of 400/415 degrees Fahr. After the occurrence the governor was found to be dry, but whether this was the cause or the result of the friction it is not possible to say. It is desirable that the gears should be so designed that the inlet valve is closed when the governor is not functioning. Small Pipes Less Effective. In the North Midland Division water pipes have been put in at a number of the mines to cover long lengths of roadways, and this method is being extended. The Divisional Inspector, Mr. G. Cook, considers that this is by far the most effective provision against fire risks and should be installed wherever it is possible to do so. In one or two mines small diameter pipes were tried, but it was found that the pressure loss due to the length of the pipes so reduced the quantity of water available that it was not effective, and the small pipes are being replaced by larger ones. At large mines pipes of a less diameter than three inches may not be adequate for such a purpose, and when considering the size of pipes regard should be had to the ultimate distance the water has to be conveyed as the workings extend towards the boundaries of the mines. Manager Designed Water Tank. Commenting on the coming into force of the Regulations, Mr. E. H. Frazer of the North Western Division points to the demand upon any mine employing 100 or more persons underground that a water supply shall be kept ready for immediate use with efficient means for delivering it promptly in adequate volume where it is needed. In mines with long haulages, which may be compulsorily stopped when a fire occurs, and in mines with steep gradients where tubs of water could not be man-handled, he says the only way of complying with the words "immediate," "prompt," and "adequate," is by high-pressure water pipes. Following a brief statement that there were three ignitions of firedamp in machine undercuts at mines in the Division, assumed to have been caused by sparks from machine picks, Mr. Frazer says that in order to deal with a fire resulting from an ignition of this description, Mr. E. Small, manager of Shelton Deep Colliery, North Staffordshire, designed a water tank, to be superimposed upon a coal-cutting machine, for the purpose of making a jet of water available at short notice. It holds 16 gallons and is totally enclosed, except for an inlet pipe for compressed air and an outlet pipe for water. There is attached, but coiled in a separate box on top of the machine, 20 feet of hose with a nozzle. When air pressure is turned on to the tank a jet of water 27 feet effective radius is forced from the nozzle, and plays for about 2½ minutes at 6 gallons a minute. The radius of action is 47 feet from the machine. Valves Operated by Detachable Handle. The Cardiff and Forest of Dean Divisional Inspector, Mr. J. Macleod Carey, deals briefly with three dangerous occurrences in connection with conveying machinery. Two of them were the result of what he is "tempted to describe as lack of common sense in the fitting of stop-valves in compressed air columns feeding conveying machinery." In one of the cases, a frictional fire occurred in connection with a face conveyor belt when nobody was in the district concerned. Advantage was taken of the pit being idle to substitute some four-inch pipes for two-inch pipes serving a hauling engine 50 yards back from the delivery end of a face belt conveyor. These pipes also delivered air to the motor of the conveyor belt; the entry of air to this motor being controlled by a valve operated by a detachable handle which had been left in a horizontal position with the valve shut. So long as the air pressure was maintained the valve remained shut, but on release of pressure the gravity of the handle caused it to fall into the vertical position, thereby opening the valve. This happened when the air was shut off at the main valve to allow the work of substitution to proceed. When the work was completed the main valve was again opened, thus admitting air to the conveyor motor. Some hours later the motor was discovered running and the belt burnt right through although the fire was out. The belt had been prevented from travelling by a fall in the middle of the face. Valves operated by such handles, in the view of the Inspector, are a real source of danger in connection with belt conveyors. General Observations. The foregoing excerpts and comments bearing on underground fires should serve a purpose in directing wider attention to conditions not always closely considered, and the references may be completed by quoting some general observations made by Mr. E. Rowley in his Midland and Southern Division report, as follows :— Wherever possible brattice should be replaced by doors on haulage roads, but if brattice must be used it should be of the best quality non-inflammable type, and should be frequently renewed. In any case where naked lights are used the men should be trained to handle them with care, far too frequently one sees men standing with their acetylene lamps on their caps with the flame impinging on a wood bar or prop, or candles left burning stuck to a prop by a lump of clay — a practice which contravenes General Regulation 115. Such occurrences raise the question as to whether the use of naked lights should be prohibited. At the end of the day shift a collier whilst putting on his jacket, placed his acetylene lamp on top of one of the side-walls between two girders, with the result that the flame caught some of the lagging. The collier failed to notice what had happened, and it was not until nearly two hours later that a motor attendant stationed some 50 yards inbye noticed a smell of burning and found the timber smouldering. A good supply of water being available nearby, the fire was very quickly put out, but had it not been discovered and dealt with so quickly, the consequences might have been very serious. Regulations the Bare Minimum. Fire may occur in almost any mine and at any part of a mine. Anybody who has had experience of a fire underground knows that speed is of the utmost importance, and that a fire leading to the loss of a whole district and possibly of life, might have been overcome within a few minutes at the beginning if only proper fire-fighting equipment, with men trained in its use, had been available. The requirements laid down in the new Regulations should therefore be regarded as the bare minimum. The equipment should be on the most generous scale, and the personnel thoroughly trained in their duties. Possibly it might do good to arrange competitions between the fire-fighting teams of the different collieries on similar lines to the ambulance competitions. Generally, it may be said that a good deal of work has been done through the district rescue committees towards standardising the necessary equipment. In this connection one colliery has evolved a very excellent practice of posting up sketch plans at suitable places showing the position of the fire stations and equipment, the lines of water pipes together with the pressures and types and sizes of hose couplings, cocks, etc. It is a practice which, Mr. Rowley hopes, will be generally adopted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||