|
6th April 1940, Page: 311, Column: 1 Electric Cables And Fire RisksA paper by Mr. S. W. Melsom, prepared for presentation on the 13th March to the Institution of Electrical Engineers, dealt with the question of "Electric Cables and Fire Risks Recent Developments and Investigations." The paper was divided into four sections: (1) The fireproofing of mains cables in power stations ; (2) Fire-resisting cables (3) The fire-resisting properties of cables used in coal mines ; (4) A cold-setting joint-box compound. The third section describes a highly important series of tests made generally under conditions as nearly as possible simulating those obtaining in coal mines — an investigation made in close collaboration with H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines. The experiments show that, in the great majority of cases, the cables withstand any transient flames such as would arise from an explosion of firedamp, and generally that it is very difficult to set fire to a cable under conditions held fairly to simulate working conditions in a pit. In the case of trailing cables the tests have been carried through in some cases under conditions much more severe than can occur in practice. These tests have indicated that, to secure the maximum degree of safety from fire due to internal faults, a fire-resisting type of dielectric may be desirable, and that special provision may be necessary as regards both screening of the cable and the provision of earth-leakage protection. In his opening remarks in this section Mr. Melsom says that fires which have occurred in coal mines during recent years with deplorable loss of life have raised in some minds the question as to how far the electric cables have been responsible either for initiating a fire or conveying an existing fire from one part of the mine to another. Some time ago H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines (Mr. Horsley) inquired whether the cable makers would be willing to carry out experiments with a view to obtaining data which would answer certain specific questions. This co-operation was willingly agreed, and this section of the paper deals with the work which was carried out as the result of a research programme drawn up after discussion between a suitable Research Committee and Mr. Horsley, whose close co-operation and keen interest has been most highly appreciated. The most important feature of the co-operation has been the correlation of the methods of test with the conditions in a coal mine, the type of fire which occurs there, and the mechanical usage to which cables are subjected as part of the normal working of a coal mine. In the tests to ascertain whether the external wrappings would he capable of being set on fire, the procedure consisted in laying 1-yard lengths of the cable horizontally about 1 foot above a laboratory bench and subjecting them to the action of three bunsen burners (adjusted so as to melt a piece of 0.028 inch copper wire in 5 seconds) spaced equally round the cable at one place. Mr. Melsom explains the procedure in carrying out various tests. It may be sufficient to extract some of his more general observations, as under :— It was noted that the application of a hot external flame for about 15 seconds was necessary to ignite the compound on the wrappings of a standard C.M.A. cable, so that it seems reasonable to conclude that such wrappings would not become ignited as a result of a transient flame such as would arise, for example, from an explosion of firedamp. While the tests indicated that the wrappings treated with petroleum pitch compound were appreciably more fire-resisting than might have been expected, the next logical step was to investigate the use of compounds having greater fire resistance on the wrappings. Such compounds are already used on certain types of cable. Generally the results draw attention to the extraordinary fire-protective qualities of the armour wires. Not only are the exterior wrappings and their impregnating compound rendered fire-resisting to a high degree, but the inside of the cable is almost completely protected. The above concerns the possible tendency of the armoured cable to spread an already existing fire. The next question which arises is whether a core-to-core arc, which might arise, for instance, as a result of mechanical damage to the cable, would set the latter on fire, this in its turn initiating a larger fire. It would seem that, although a severe internal arc due to a short-circuit can ignite external wrappings which have been treated with petroleum pitch compounds, the wrappings will be self-extinguished and will not convey flame along the cable. The use of fire-resisting compound on the wrappings would obviously be a further safeguard against spread of fire but would not prevent local burning of the dielectric if the short-circuit were sufficiently severe to burst the outer coverings and admit air to the interior of the cable. Flexible Cables. Similar questions arise in connection with flexible trailing and drill cables which have an unprotected rubber sheath and are more liable to mechanical damage which might give rise to internal arcing. It was desired to obtain an idea as to the ease or otherwise with which a standard rubber sheathing would become ignited from an external source of flame of the type likely to occur in a mine. A large number of tests were carried out, and the following general conclusions were arrived at :— (1) To ignite the sheathing of a standard trailing cable even reasonably well, it is necessary to subject it to the action of a hot external flame locally for about 1 minute. (2) The rate of spread of the flame, after removal of the external source, is relatively slow — about 1 inch in 4 to 7 minutes — and this rate appears to be subsequently unaffected by variations in time of application of the external flame. (3) Armouring under the sheathing definitely increases the difficulty of burning, and in some cases renders the sheathing self-extinguishing even after 5 minutes' application of a hot flame locally. (4) Even after 5 minutes' application of a hot flame locally to an unarmoured trailing cable the sheathing was not sufficiently well alight to prevent it from being blown out by the breath without undue exertion. (5) The results suggest that the likelihood of a standard trailing cable becoming ignited as the result of a transient flame is very remote, and that even if the sheathing did become ignited the flame could be extinguished quite easily without having spread. The results further suggest that the external flame conditions necessary to get the cable really well alight are such as would arise only if there was already severe conflagration going on in the mine, in which case any secondary effect, resulting from the cable, would be relatively unimportant. In addition to the effect of external flame, tests have been made to determine the effect of a core-to-core arc. The main point which seemed to emerge was the extraordinary severity of the mechanical damage necessary to cause the arc to be started. It would seem that the use of fire-resisting sheathing would be one way of localising a fire which might be initiated as the result of an internal arc. A point of especial interest to mining works may be mentioned. The major difficulty so far as sheathings are concerned is the fact that hitherto fire-resisting properties have been obtained at the expense of desirable physical properties, such as tensile strength and resistance to tear. As the result of later developments, it is now possible to produce fire-resisting sheathing which, while not possessing such high tensile strength or tear resistance as the standard resilient tough rubber sheathing, may have sufficiently good mechanical properties to allow of their use for trailing cables used in mines. It will perhaps be admitted that the results with trailing cables, showing as they do the great difficulty in maltreating a cable so badly as to produce an internal arc, and the comparative ease with which the flame resulting from such an arc is extinguished, indicate clearly that the existing standard cables are adequate for their service. Concluding his paper Mr. Melsom says: While the laboratory experiments are probably somewhat fantastic as far as mining practice is concerned, they are important in indicating that serious consideration should be given to the use of screened cable and earth-leakage protection to give the full possible measure of protection. In particular, the effects of the arc with even small currents are worthy of attention, even admitting that the deliberately maintained arcs are most unlikely to occur under practical conditions of service,
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||