6th April 1940
Some Dust Problems Of Coal Mines
By John Smellie, Ph.D., A.R.T.C.
From paper presented at the March meeting of the Past and Present
Mining Students' Association — Wigan Mining and Technical College.
The dust problem of coal mines may be divided into two main
parts: (1) The problem of air-borne dust and its physiological
effect on workers; and (2) The problem of deposited coal dust,
its dangers and treatments to render it innocuous. A great deal
of time and money in research and experiment has been devoted
to these problems recently, and much really good work has been
done. Many very important questions, however, still remain
doubtful or unsolved altogether.
Physiological Hazard.
From the physiological standpoint the great amount of dust
of all kinds produced in mining operations must be kept to the
lowest possible limit. When the dust concentration of the
atmosphere is dangerous and cannot be improved hy alteration
of the machine or method, and where trapping of the dust is
impracticable, then protection must be afforded to the worker.
The dread disease due to dust inhalation is, of course, silicosis.
It is defined as a pathological condition of the lungs, due to the
breathing of small particles of silicon dioxide, and has long been
known in the gold mining industry of South Africa. The high
incidence of the disease among men in this country, who cannot
claim to have been exposed to dusts containing a high percentage
of free silica, is still a matter of great controversy among mining
and medical men.
From a review of recent literature on silicosis in this country,
several important points emerge, and these are :—
(1) Silicosis is a difficult disease to diagnose. Other diseases
such as phthisis, tuberculosis and bronchitis complicate matters.
X-ray photographs are necessary.
(2) A "work-history," or a history of exposure to dangerous
silica dust, is necessary for a complete and proper diagnosis.
(3) Most of our cases come from the South Wales coalfield,
and particularly the anthracite region.
(4) No stone-dusting is done in those collieries with a high
incidence of silicosis.
(5) Geological evidence shows that the silica content of the
rocks associated with the anthracite seams is insufficient to account
for the high rates compared with other collieries. It would appear
therefore that in the majority of the silicosis cases in this country
there is a cause not yet fully understood.
Remedial Measures.
The greatest danger of silicosis in coal mines is to those workers
employed in hard headings, tunnels, sinkings and rippings in
hard rock with a high free silica content. Methods of reduction
of the fine dust produced in the occupations mentioned are :—
(1) The use of rotary drills, where practicable. In very hard
stone, of course, these drills are unsuitable. Drillings are coarser
than those made by percussive drills, and there is a better
opportunity of catching the borings at the mouth of the hole
and preventing their dissemination later.
(2) The dust traps are designed for use with compressed air
percussive drills, and a typical example is the pyrene trap. A
practical trial in a rise heading in rock gave the following results :—
Weight of dust collected from 10½ feet of hole = 16 lb. 10 ozs.,
which is about 60 per cent. of the theoretical weight. The
remainder must escape at the start of the hole and during drilling
via the suction hood.
About 50 per cent. of the weight collected is less than 240 mesh,
and would constitute a dangerous atmosphere, especially when
it is known that the free silica content is 66 per cent.
Wet drilling is another method of reducing the dust produced
by drilling, but for several reasons it is not very effective.
Foam has been tried as an alternative to water, but modern
opinion is inclined to favour the dry dust trap.
(3) Many lectures have been given on the use of the mist
projector, a device intended to be used to settle the dust and
fumes quickly in dead ends. There is no doubt that it is effective,
and the worse the ventilation the more effective it will be. The
use of this device in any of its forms, either with or without the
addition of soluble oil, is to be recommended as a means of quickly
settling large quantities of dust suspended in the air after shot-firing.
(4) Ventilation is often cited as being a cure for the problem
of air-borne dust. It is true that in a brisk ventilation heavy
concentrations of dust are swept away rapidly, and at the face
in dead ends a good ventilation is necessary. Dust in circumstances
like these should be treated like a gas. Too much ventilation,
however, aggravates the dust problem in other ways.
For tunnel work there is the alternative of exhaust or forcing
ventilation. Forcing ventilation is best for the face as face
workers are in a clear atmosphere, and the fumes and dust from
shots are more quickly cleared away. Outbye workers are
generally more able to wear respirators than face workers.
(5) Apart from the remedies enumerated for reducing the
amount of dust, there is still left the respirator for those who
cannot avoid a dusty atmosphere. The new Mark IV respirator
is the most efficient design, and should be used where any risk
of dangerous dust exists in addition to the remedies already
mentioned, and not as an alternative.
Respirators are a boon to many of the underground workers
such as coal-cutters, loaders, etc., but two rather practical points
arise here.
Firstly, there is a natural antipathy on the part of workmen to
wearing the respirator. In many cases it is slung around the neck
and not worn over the mouth. This happens because the average
workman is not aware of the type of disease he is being protected
from. Symptoms are not immediate — like excessive heat or
humidity; the time-lag may be about five years or more.
Secondly, there is the question of servicing the respirators.
For efficient operation and hygiene the respirators should be
brought out of the pit daily. The lamp cabin is a convenient
place for handling. There the respirator can be washed, brushed
and disinfected and the valves put in order each day, and re-issued
with the man's lamp,
At some collieries this system. is in operation, and the men have
got into the habit of bringing them out daily. A fuller realisation
on their part of the danger of silicosis and its kindred diseases
would result in a greater use being made of the Mark IV respirator.
Instruments for measuring dust concentration have developed
much in recent years, and their necessity will be appreciated
when one considers that the dangerous dust which penetrates
the inner recesses of the lungs is invisible to the naked eye. Few,
if any, colliery companies have an equipment of modern dust
sampling instruments or laboratory facilities for dealing with the
samples. For the proper measurement of improvement or
alteration in dust concentration after installation of a dust trap
or other dust reducing device, a Konimeter or similar instrument
is required for routine work. Such an instrument might
profitably be included among the ventilation instruments of a
coal company.
Dust Suppression at Source.
The problem of coal dust as an explosive agent has long been
with us — roughly 40 years — and to-day it is as bad as it has ever
been, We have certain remedies, it is true, but recent events
and recent findings of research have cast some doubts on the
effectiveness of these remedies.
It is evident that the reduction of coal dust at its source is
the surest and most economical way of reducing the menace.
Considering the amount of work that is done in roadway enlargement
and in the improvement in ventilation systems to deal
with gas, the amount of thought and experiment expended on
dust suppression is negligible. By "dust suppression" is meant
the reduction of dust formation at its source, and this must not
he confused with dust control, or the controlling of dusty atmospheres
outbye from the coal face.
It will be agreed that the hulk of the fine dust is produced
at the coal face by the operations or coal-cutting, shot-firing,
and filling out of coal, and it is in this sphere that I feel there is
much room for improvement.
Although much fine dust is produced while cutting, the greatest
amount is possibly liberated while the coal is being filled out on
to conveyers.
Coal-cutting.
In several papers on the subject of dust I have read that sharp
picks will reduce the amount of fine dust produced. In order
to find out to what extent this was so, I had several tests made,
and the results are shown in the accompanying tables (Tables
1 and 2).
Chain speed, haulage speed, and pick sharpness and spacing,
do not appear to have such a great effect. The aim, of course,
is to have as few picks as possible, the minimum chain speed
and the maximum haulage speed.
Tests taken with and without gummers nearly always show a
reduction in the amount of -¼" coal, and it is safe to assume a
reduction of fine dust also. The atmosphere behind the cutter
is generally clearer too. Now that the "gummer" has proved
its worth, the time has come for further and mere earnest efforts
to wet the kirvings as they are made with water or other wetting
agent. The spiral gummer provides an excellent place for such
a start to be made. The Americans, it may be noted, have
persevered with water on the jibs for many years.
Where coal is reduced to fines as in coal-cutting, dust will
always be produced in quantity, and the laying of this dust and
its attachment to the larger pieces is a matter which will strike
at the root of the whole problem of coal dust suppression and
collection.
Shot-firing is another operation which reduces coal and produces
fine dust. Much dust in the vicinity is always raised by the
concussion.
Other less violent means of bringing down coal and stone such
as hydrox, cardox, or coal-bursters produce less dust, but their
use is generally governed by more important considerations
than dust production.
Dust Control in Atmosphere.
This is a large problem in itself and has been given much
consideration recently.
Return Airways. — Filtering the return air has been suggested,
but this is hardly a practical solution.
The system of spray-barrages is the best method available at
the moment when used in an airway of large area.
At Loading Points. — Prevention of access of air-currents to the
stream of coal at a transfer point is remarkably efficient, and is
the simplest method of dust control. At loading points this
principle can be applied in conjunction with any of the many dust
traps now on the market, whether of the wet or dry type. Very
dusty atmospheres exist around a loading point when large
tonnages are dealt with, and much still remains to be done in the
design of efficient hoods which will allow tubs to be filled properly
and safely and yet allow the dispersed dust to be sucked into
the deposition chamber or apparatus.
My own personal view is that, while water mists are effective
up to a point, a dry filler trap will be the ultimate perfect solution
when fitted with a strong fan and large cyclone or labyrinth.
Much of the responsibility in the matter of dust at gate belt
ends and gate end loaders should be placed on the owners.
Electrical manufacturers can make motors dust-proof, drip-proof,
flame-proof, etc., and why not gate end leaders? Much of the
work done to date in the application of hoods and filters to these
machines has been done by colliery managers.
Intake Airways. — In constricted intakes there is a continual
deposition of dust blown from tubs. Even where the tubs are
steel and dust-proof the amount of coal dust blown off the tubs
is considerable. I have experimented with tub covers of steel,
but these were found to be impracticable on account of the
irregularity of the tubs and the peculiar conditions of some of the
ever-rope haulages.
The best solutions, to my mind, are the provision of large
intakes or parallel intakes to reduce air velocity, the elimination
of constrictions as far as possible, and the wetting of the tub tops
before they start on the main haulage.
The recommendations of the Royal Commission refer to this
point, and a reversion to the old system is advocated.
Whether or not a stable foam could be used to cover the coal
tubs is a question mainly of cost.
Function of Incombustible Dust.
Despite our efforts to reduce the formation of coal dust and our
efforts to prevent its dispersion, a certain amount will still be
deposited in the roadways, and we are obliged by Statute to treat
it in some way to render it innocuous. The use of incombustible
dust is a case of an evil used to fight an evil, but it is the method
generally adopted. Other methods such as consolidation of the
dust to prevent its dispersion by chemicals, mud or cement, are
only capable of limited application.
Although some roadway dust mixtures may comply with the
regulations in regard to percentage of incombustible matter,
this is not always a criterion of safety. It is the percentage or
proportions of the various dusts which rise and form a cloud in
an explosion which is the all-important feature. The condition
and intimacy of mixture of the dusts are of great importance.
The formation of a cloud in intimate mixture with the coal
dust is the action expected from an incombustible dust and,
therefore, apart from its heat-absorbing capacity it must be capable
of rising and dispersing easily and intimately with coal dust under
the same disturbing forces. That stone dust did fail to rise was
the important fact that emerged from the enquiry held into the
causes and circumstances attending the explosion at Haigh Pit,
Whitehaven, 29th January, 1931. The finding was that "The
explosion was spread throughout the district because of the
dampness causing the limestone dust to hind and not rise and
intermingle with the fine coal dust which lay upon it."
Factors Affecting Incombustible Dust Efficiency.
Any stone dust can become inefficient for the purpose originally
intended if it is not given proper treatment, or is not of the proper
type. The "efficiency" of the dust comprises such properties
as specific gravity, fineness, dispersability, moisture content and
chemical composition; all these factors have a hearing on the
"efficiency" of the dust. A dust may become inefficient because
of its hailing up or caking, or because it has absorbed a high
percentage of moisture. All dusts absorb moisture, and the
amount absorbed varies from dust to dust, depending on their
composition. The amount varies with the temperature and
humidity of the atmosphere, but tests show that the amount
absorbed from a mine atmosphere is not of any consequence
and does not unduly affect the dispersing power of the dust.
Caking. — It is in the case of a dust being thrown on wet strata
and then drying out that the greatest danger lies. Samples
would show this dust to be dry, yet it would not be dispersable.
Balling. — A phenomenon (physical) apparent in all finely
ground powders is the tendency for the dust to form spherical
aggregates. It is due to the size-grading of the dust, and can
be eliminated as a rule by the introduction of a proportion of
larger particles. Its practical effect on dispersion is small.
The new Regulations now prescribe a slightly coarser dust than
formerly.
Dispersion Test. — This test shows clearly the effect of fineness
and moisture in the "cloud density" produced under standard
test conditions. It shows clearly that, for dust mixtures which
cannot be sieved owing to their wetness, an analysis is practically
valueless.
Bearing in mind also that water has a selective action on stone
dust, and hardly affects coal dust, the combined use of stone dust
and water should not be practised. The stone dust must be
dry to be of any use. The dispersion apparatus is shown in
FIGURE 1.
Movement of Dust Layers. — Dispersion values only tell half
the story in the matter of cloud formation, as in actual practice
the dusts have to be swept up from a layer and not blown out
of a tube. Tests have shown that (1) Coarse dust is more easily
moved than fine dust; (2) Coal dust is swept off the top of stone
dust; (3) When stone dust is on top the coal dust is prevented
from being raised; (4) In a very thick layer of stone dust only
the top layers are swept off; (5) A rough dust surface is best
for dust removal.
The recent Coal Dust Regulations have embodied some of
the findings of research into the efficiency of stone dusts and
particularly in the matter of size of the incombustible dust, the
dispersion test and the depth of sampling.
It might be argued that stone dust, being twice as heavy as
coal dust, cannot dilute coal dust or intermingle with it under the
forces of an explosion. For in a 50/50 shale coal mixture the
surfaces of the particles (assuming equal fineness) are about in
the ratio of 2 : 1, or 2,000 square feet per lb. as against 1,000
square feet roughly. However, up till now, no more suitable
substance has been found. Allowing for the many factors which
tend to affect the incombustible dust, the policy should be to have
at all times an excess of incombustible matter with the stone
dust on top.
It is in the region of the coal face where coal dust is being
continually deposited that the danger lies. Also, it is in this
area that there is the greatest risk of the inception of an explosion,
and where the explosion would possibly be in a weak or unstable
condition and would tend to disturb the surface layers only. A
lighter dust in this vulnerable area would be an advantage if
one could be found.
Systematic Treatment. — To follow a regular routine in sampling
and treatment is essential, and proper plans are a necessity so
that a true check can be kept.
FIGURE 2 shows a typical stone dust zone plan (350 yards)
to comply with the 10 samples per mile requirement. The zones
are divided into six equal parts and coloured according to the
system indicated on the plan.
In summing up, we are relying more and more on the stone
dust remedy, although we have recently experienced several
failures. A higher standard of stone-dusting is being attained
with the use of greater quantities of dust. The mine atmosphere
will become more dusty and conditions will not improve unless
we get down to the prevention of dust formation at the coal face.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Smellie, John | | | |