23rd March 1940, Page: 298, Column: 1
Firedamp
By Supt. F. J. Johnston, M.I.M.E, of the Durham and
Northumberland Collieries Fire and Rescue Brigade.
Extracts from paper read before the Associates and Students'
Section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical
Engineers.
Early History.
Until the year 1776 no distinction was drawn between "inflammable
airs" from different sources. In that year Volta discovered
that the gas issuing from marshes (marsh gas) differed from that
obtained by the acids on metals (hydrogen), in that it required
four times as much oxygen for combustion and yielded carbon
dioxide gas and water as a result thereof.
In the year 1805 Dr. Henry of Manchester proved that the
gases obtained by the distillation of coal contained two distinct
gases — light carburetted hydrogen and a heavy carburetted
hydrogen.
The name of methane was given to marsh gas by one Hoffman
at a much later date.
In 1807 John Dalton of Manchester studied closely the composition
of the carburetted hydrogens. It was here that he first
got his ideas of the atomic theory.
In 1815 to 1819 Sir Humphry Davy carried out researches on
flame in response to an appeal from the Sunderland Society for
the Prevention of Accidents in Coal Mines, in consequence of a
disastrous explosion on 25th May, 1812, at Felling Colliery,
involving the loss of 92 lives. The direct outcome of these
experiments was the invention of the miner's safety-lamp ; they
also greatly extended our knowledge of flame and explosions
and can be rightly regarded as having laid the foundations of all
subsequent investigation on the subject. From his experiments
he deduced that a certain heat was required for the ignition of
the gas, and that unless that heat is passed on continuously from
one layer of gas to the next there cannot be continuous propagation
of the flame through it. Hence he concluded that by sufficiently
cooling the explosive mixture it should be possible to prevent
the passage of flame. We all know how he came to use the wire
gauze after trying narrow tubes and layers of metal.
Chemical Composition and Properties.
Firedamp is the name given to mixtures of methane and air
found in the air of coal mines. It has the same chemical composition
as marsh gas, which is found exuding from decaying
carbonaceous matter in marshy ground.
Methane is the first of the hydrocarbons known as the paraffin
series. Other compounds of the series are ethane, propane,
butane, etc.
The gas is colourless, tasteless, and odourless, although some
miners aver that they can detect the gas by its smell. This
smell, when present, is due to the admixture of small quantities
of the higher hydrocarbons such as ethane, etc. It is lighter
than air, its specific gravity being 0.559. Methane is not a toxic
gas, and is one of the few gases which are physiologically inert
such as nitrogen and hydrogen. If the 79 per cent. of nitrogen
at present in the air we breathe were replaced by 79 per cent.
methane there would be deleterious effects. In practice in mines,
however, where there are high percentages of methane there will
be deficiency of oxygen, and therein lies a great danger to
respiration.
The most important property of methane is its explosive
property or inflammability. It has an explosive range of between
5 per cent. and 15 per cent. ; the most explosive point or the
point where perfect combustion takes place is somewhere about
95 per cent.
The minimum ignition temperature of mixtures of firedamp
and air is about 510°C. If out of contact with a heated surface
it lies between 650 and 750°C.
If the gas is previously heated, such as passing through heated
strata, the mixture is more easily ignited and will explode feebly
at a lower percentage, somewhere about 3.5 per cent. This is
important when dealing with gob-fires. Further, the minimum
ignition temperature under such conditions is obtained between
7 and 8 per cent. and not at 9.5 per cent. which is the mixture
for complete combustion. An interval of time elapses, known
as the "ignition lag," between the instant the inflammable
mixture attains the ignition temperature and the presence of
flame. The lag is quite appreciable, and in some cases amounts
to several seconds.
Where a fire exists in a gassy mine great care must be taken to
prevent the combination of factors which might cause an explosion.
By knowing the factors of pressure and temperature, and taking
analyses on the spot, one is able to tell by reference to the chart
whether it is possible to have an explosion or not.
Certain mixtures are capable of forming explosive mixtures
if mixed with air. In such cases great care must be taken to see
that an excess of air is not admitted. Breathing apparatus have
to be worn to allow men to work in such atmospheres. Other
mixtures are explosive if the temperature of ignition is present,
and such mixtures must be kept clear of fire.
Ignition by Electric Sparks. — There are two kinds of electric
spark — inductance sparks and capacity sparks. If an electric
spark is analysed it is really found to consist of a series of rapid
flashes. The first flash, usually 1/20,000th of a second duration,
is succeeded by a series of considerably less bright flashes. A
measure of the spark energy may be taken as the value of the
primary current. A much lower current is required for ignition
by an inductive spark than a capacity spark; also, the most
easily ignited mixture is somewhere about 8.3 per cent.
Detection of the Gas.
Firedamp may be detected in percentages up to the lower
limits of inflammability (about 5 per cent.) by the appearance
of a "cap" or blue halo over the oil flame. The size of the cap
varies with a number of factors which should be considered when
estimating the percentage of gas present. This is one of the
oldest and is still the most reliable and practical method of
detection.
In 1812, John Buddle of North of England fame records the
effects on a candle flame where a "cap" was shown. Previous
to that period (the safety-lamp was not invented until 1815) it
is recorded that a pitman could tell by the colour of the sparks
from the steel mill what percentages of gas was present. The
higher percentage of gas present the more blood red colour the
sparks became.
To prevent the luminosity of the oil flame obscuring the pale
blue cap of burning gas, the oil flame is lowered until only of
an inch is visible. The height of the cap depends upon the size
of the wick used and the fuel producing the flame. The larger the
wick and the higher the temperature of the flame the higher the
cap will he. When using a fuel such as alcohol, benzine or
hydrogen gas the height of the cap is much greater than when
burning ordinary colza oil.
The wider the wick used the higher the cap will be, and the
percentage of gas present may be judged from the basis that
when the cap is an equilateral triangle the percentage of gas
present is 2½.
Special Detectors.
Several principles have been tried as a means of testing for
firedamp. One used is based upon the rate of diffusion of gases
of different densities.
The Ansell detector was one of the first on this principle,
constructed in the form like an ordinary pocket watch where the
percentages can be read off on the dial. The presence of moisture,
carbon dioxide and coal dust has effects which tend to render the
instrument, inaccurate. Strange to say, the only automatic
detector at present approved by the Mines Department is based
on this principle — the Ringrose Firedamp Detector.
The Gulliford detector is not accurate in action. In this
detector, by means of a switch a platinum filament is heated in
the presence of the gas, and the filament fuses when the percentage
of firedamp rises to a dangerous proportion. The fuse would
then have to be renewed.
Another detector was evolved some time ago which detected
firedamp by the difference of sound in air and gas. It was called
the firedamp whistle.
In the Leiving detector, the percentage of firedamp is detected
by comparing the brightness of two glowing filaments, one of which
is enclosed in an airtight vessel while the other is exposed to the
atmosphere. By means of two mirrors actuated by a screw on
a scale the percentage of firedamp could be read. This appliance
was accurate enough, but was clumsy and awkward to carry
about.
In the Concordia detector lamp, a small flame lamp burning
benzine is attached to the side of an ordinary electric lamp, the
benzine lamp being ignited when desired by a filament heated
from the battery of the electric lamp.
In the McLuckie detector the principle used in gas analysis
is adopted. The gas is burnt on a heated filament. The steam
or water vapour formed is allowed to condense and the contraction
in volume recorded on a liquid in a U-tube gauge. This is a very
accurate and useful instrument — beyond the average pitman's
requirements, but may be recommended to colliery managers
who have to make analysis in doubtful places.
In the Thornton-Gray lamp the brightness of filaments burning
in gas and air is recorded on a small photometric window. In
the automatic type the filaments are heated automatically every
two minutes, and if firedamp be present at any predetermined
figure the electric lamp is extinguished. This is quite an ingenious
and simple arrangement and has much to recommend it.
The Leon-Montlucon detector was brought to this country
recently from France, and appears quite good. In this we have
a Wheatstone Bridge attached to an ordinary electric lamp.
Two of the arms of the bridge are exposed to the atmosphere
while the other two are sealed. The difference in the resistance
of the arms when they are heated can be measured on the ammeter
attached. The deviation is practically proportional to the
percentage of methane present. The Ceag firm have a detector
on the same principle called the Ceag-Montlucon detector.
The M.S.A. detector is an American adaptation of the Wheatstone
Bridge idea. It is small and separate from the electric
lamp.
The modern tendency seems to favour the simple safety-lamp
method, and a small safety-lamp is attached to the electric lamp.
The Ceag gas detecting lamp is of this type. The Oldham is of
the same type. They are simple and effective.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Dalton, John | | | |
| Davy, Humphry, Sir | | | |
| Henry, —, Dr. | | | |
| Hoffman, — | | | |
| Johnston, F. J. | | Superintendent | |
| Volta, — | | | |