|
23rd March 1940, Page: 289, Column: 1 Accidents And Their PreventionThese notes are based on the Mines Inspectors Reports for 1935. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies are obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office. Best Safeguard — Good Ropes and Tackle. In the North Midland Division in 1938, 193 per cent. of all the reportable accidents occurred in connection with haulage and transport, the "safety rate" being one casualty per 144,000 shifts worked below ground, or stated otherwise one casualty per 276,000 tons of mineral raised. There were 18 killed and 102 reported injured. In one accident three persons were killed and 102 reported injured. In one accident three persons were killed and three injured. This accident was due to the breakage of a haulage rope on a man riding set in a main return airway, fitted with a single track endless rope. The total length of the riding section was 3,200 yards. The road dipped inbye over most of its length, but just beyond the meetings it crossed a series of rise faults and in that section rose inbye. The cross-section of the road varied from seven to eight feet square Trains consisting of 24 tubs and carrying approximately 90 men, the tubs being low sided, fitted with seats at the ends accommodating four men, were run in two sections at an average speed of eight miles per hour. The sets were attached to the rope by screw clips fitted to the front and rear tubs. The train on the outbye section ran to the meetings where the workmen changed to the other section to proceed to the end of the road. At the same time the inbye section ran to the meetings when a similar transfer of men took place. It will thus be seen that when the outbye section was going in, the inbye section was coming out, the direction of each section being reversed for the second half of the run. A sample of the rope was examined by Dr. M. A. Hogan, of the Wire Ropes Research Committee of the Safety in Mines Research Board, who found that it had suffered deterioration by corrosive fatigue at the portions where individual strands were tucked into the interior of the rope. The deterioration reduced the aggregate strength to 27 per cent. of that of the new rope, and it seemed likely that in this condition it would be possible for an individual strand to break off and stick out of the rope during passage over a pulley. The conditions of service were severe in that two-foot diameter pulleys were used, giving a wire to pulley diameter ratio of 226. The layout and small diameter of the binding pulleys caused severe strains on the rope and would aggravate the tendency for ends of strands to become free. Since the accident larger pulleys have been put in and the distance between each pair increased. Trials are being made with a view to devising a form of brake which can be operated from the set to bring it to rest in the event of a similar occurrence, but by far the best safeguard, according to the opinion expressed by Mr. G. Cook, the Divisional Inspector, is the provision of good ropes and tackle, and attention to lay-out. An Unusual Runaway. Runaway tubs caused four deaths and injuries to six persons. The Inspector has a note on an accident which occurred in unusual circumstances whereby one man was injured. A riding train on a direct rope electric haulage had brought out the day shift men and was left at the usual stopping place about ten yards from the top of a drift dipping 1 in 6 and 600 yards long. The engineman pinned down the brake and loft the engine, satisfied that all was in order. About 25 minutes later the first of the afternoon shift men arrived at the train and 19 of them got into it in readiness to ride inbye although, at that time, neither the guard nor the haulage driver had arrived. The train began to move away and the men jumped out; as one of them fell his foot was run over. There were two backstays fitted to the train which have to be lifted to allow the train to move down the road, but it is obvious that these had not been lowered into position when the train was left by the engineman, and the only possible explanation was that the brake path had cooled and contracted and allowed the brake to slip. The train is not to be left on the hill in future. Operating the Brake Not Necessary. An interesting device to arrest runaway tubs in a forward direction, which will gradually bring the tubs to rest without undue shock, has been designed by the manager of Bagworth Colliery. The arrester is fitted near the junction of a road dipping 1 in 18 in favour of the load where sets of 20 tubs are attached to the rope of an under-rope haulage system by a clip at the rear of the set. In the event of the haulage hand missing the clip be can put the arrester into action. It consists of a hook attached to a length of rope which passes round a brake wheel of the Oldham type, the brake lever being weighted to apply sufficient pressure to bring a runaway set to rest. It is not necessary for anyone to operate the brake. Automatically Operated Door. An automatically operated ventilation door, through which 2,500 tubs pass per shift, has been designed and is in use at Welbeck Colliery. Mr. Cook says it has been found to be very satisfactory. The door, simple in operation, requires no attention other than daily oiling. It is operated by the first tub on the set which is clipped to the rope at both front and rear. The tram strikes the horizontal lever arm, and this opens the door towards the tram and against the ventilating current. As the lever is swept to one side the end of the lever passes in front of the tub but does not touch it. The sides of the tuba press against the iron how fixed on the door whilst passing through it. There is a screw adjustment on the lever arm to ensure that the door, when open, is in the correct position relative to the tram. When the last tub of the sot passes through, the door closes and is then in position to be operated by the next set. The chief factors to be considered for the successful use of automatic doors, the Inspector remarks, is the lifting of the haulage rope and clearance of haulage clips. This has been overcome by leaning the frame over the head and adjusting the position of the bottom hook. A visual signal is fitted to the door to warn persons of the approach of trains and the opening of the doors. It is advisable to put in a tram re-railer ahead of the door and also to keep the track on a uniform gradient. Controlling Travel of Coal Down Pans. Discussing the accidents attributed to conveyors and loaders Mr. Cook says the manager of Church Gresley Colliery has designed a retarder to control the travel of the coal down the pans on a face 165 yards long and inclined at 1 in 1.5. This consists of a piece of conveyor belting 26 inches wide and 7 feet long fixed to a steel pipe of 1½ inches diameter which acts as a hinge. The pipe partially rotates on a 1 3/8 inches diameter rod which is placed about 1 foot 6 inches above the belt and is attached to both the gob and face-side spill plates. By means of special fasteners and adjusters the height of the bar can be varied to suit the height of the roof above the conveyor. The retarder bangs loosely on the bar and on its underside two plates are fitted which rest on the coal in the conveyor. The action of the retarder is to control the coal on the conveyor as it passes beneath it. As the coal strikes the plates and lifts them it is turned into a safe position for conveyance down the conveyor. Retarders are placed at six-yard intervals on the conveyor, but the number can be regulated to suit varying gradients. The retarder is made so that it can be removed as a single unit when the conveyor is dismantled for flitting and replaced in the slots provided in the spill plates when the conveyor is re-assembled. Roller Under Belt. In connection with accidents as the result of persons stepping on conveyor belts whilst they are in motion, in order to cross them, the Inspector advises that, where the belt is run in a reverse direction to take material along the face, particular care should be taken to fix a roller under the belt near the tension end to prevent sagging of the belt at that point. In one instance a man was crossing a belt near the tension end as the belt was running in the reverse direction and, slipping off the hopper plate on to the belt, his weight depressed the belt so as to cause a gap of four to five inches below the cover plate and his leg was drawn under the plate. Apart from the fact that he should not have crossed the belt whilst it was in motion a roller under the belt would have prevented the accident. The fencing of the loop take-up of belt conveyers has been done in a simple yet effective way at Bilsthorpe Colliery. It consists of sheet iron plates, obtained from the sides of old tubs, which have been shaped to cover the loop take-up from the floor level to the belt rollers and to extend throughout the travel of the take-up. The plates are six foot long, fitted with handles to facilitate handling, and have two lugs fixed on the inside by which the plates are suspended from the top rail of the conveyor. Lessons Taught Illuminating. The percentage of the reportable accidents in the North Western Division which were due to haulage and transport is given as 26.4, the deaths numbering 25 and the injuries 101. These figures are an increase on those of the year 1937, being wholly due to mechanical haulage, the hand haulage accidents showing a decline. In describing some of the accidents, the Divisional Inspector, Mr. E. H. Frazer, says the lessons taught are illuminating. In one case referred to the statement is made that "from rail to bar was three feet in height and the clearance above the tub corner was only 3½ inches." At one colliery an old man, just over 70 years of age, was repairing brattice cloths in an auxiliary haulage road operated by an endless rope. He was killed by two tubs of dirt running away down a gradient of 1 in 10 when they became unhooked from the lashing chain as the rope was reversed to shunt tubs in another part. Many points arose from this fatality. Quoting direct from the report In the first place a haulage road was no place, when the rope was running, for a man who had passed the allotted span. Secondly, the brattice could have been repaired during a shift when the rope was idle or, if it was a matter of urgency, the rope could have been stopped in this unimportant haulage road for the short time that was necessary for the repairs. Thirdly, the lashing chain should not have come off the tub. The large link was simply dropped over the drawbar hook, whereas if the chain hook had first been threaded through one of the tub links, then through the big link, the chain would have been tied to the tub in a manner to defy accidental detachment. Lastly, the incline could have been protected against runaways by the installation of a type of automatic catch that operates to arrest tubs in the direction of motion if normal speed is exceeded, but does not impede ordinary motion in either direction. Such catches were used over 30 years ago, to Mr. Frazer's knowledge, but they are rarely seen in Lancashire. They are manufactured now of such simplicity and reliability that when installed they can almost be forgotten until they arrest a runaway. The Inspector's Offer. At another mine a haulage hand was killed by a runaway empty tub at the bottom of a self-acting Incline rising at 1 in 4½. It became uncoupled from a set of seven ascending the jib when three tubs in front of it left the rails. In this case also the Inspector observes, there were many defects. The human element was temporarily at fault, in that the man had not attached the drag, though he was a conscientious worker. The warwick arrangement was unnecessarily complicated — a length of rope between it and a bar above would have served the same purpose — and the tub became oncoupled far too easily. It is astonishing, adds the Inspector, how often the accidental uncoupling of tubs is treated as a normal concomitant to haulage operations. There is no need for accidental uncoupling ever to occur, and Mr. Frazer says he will be pleased to supply any colliery manager in his Division with a design for safe and cheap hooks and links if the manager will promise to give them a trial. Interpretation of Mines Act. Mr. Frazer recalls that in an earlier report he made a comment concerning trivial excuses offered to justify walking on haulage roads with ropes in motion, and he now says there was no justification for another man who had been repairing in an endless-rope road where the speed was only 1½ miles an hour and the gradient was slight. This man had finished work well before time and was told by his chargeman to take some tools to the next cross-cut outbye and wait. The chargeman lashed some tubs of dirt to the rope, but his assistant, instead of walking, put the tools on top of a tub, hung his lamp on the side and stole a ride, though he could have walked quicker. He was caught by a low bridge of roof in an otherwise high road and his spine was fractured. During the year under review other cases have come to light of managers believing that because a youth is employed at a landing or junction on a main haulage road to receive and despatch tubs he is a person employed on the road in connection with the haulage, within the meaning of Section 43 (1) of the Coal Mines Act, and, therefore, entitled to walk on the road whilst the ropes are in operation. The Inspector says this does not appear to be a correct interpretation of the sub-section, which is intended to cover rope-runners, persons travelling with trains in order to clip and unclip them at the correct places, pulley-greasers and other persons who must perforce be in the road whilst the haulage is moving to attend to their duties. It cannot be intended to refer to persons travelling to and from their stations. Complicated Gadgets Not Favoured. Mr. J. McCleod Carey reports 30 deaths and 99 persons injured during 1938 in the Cardiff and Forest of Dean Division as the result of haulage and transport accidents. This represents 24.6 per cent. of all reportable casualties. There were no fatalities during the year while men were walking to and from their work. This Mr. Carey regards as a most satisfactory result of the arrangements made regarding the walking times at the commencement and end of shifts. At first, as might be expected, little difficulties arose. A few men would persist in leaving their work earlier than the time arranged, or an official would make an effort to get his last journey out and run it a few minutes late, but gradually these difficulties have been smoothed out, and we read that it is now a very rare occurrence to find men travelling haulage roads while the machinery is in motion. Matters connected with haulage claim the particular attention of the staff, and they are very quick to perceive and check any faulty practices. The provision of haulage safety appliances is generally satisfactory throughout this Division. No complicated devices are in use, reliance being placed on the simpler appliances which are of robust construction and well maintained. No accidents have occurred through failure either to supply or to make use of these devices. As stated in previous reports, Mr. Carey is not in favour of overloading haulage planes with complicated gadgets which often fail to function when required, and he finds that the simpler devices, provided they are soundly constructed, properly maintained, judiciously placed and their use at all times insisted upon, are sufficient to afford adequate protection to haulage workers. A suggestion of the Inspector's which has been widely adopted is the provision of portable stop-blocks for repairers on haulage planes, and there is no doubt that this has contributed materially to the protection of these men. At some collieries every repairer is supplied with two blocks, and during inspections on repairing shifts it is pleasing to see that they are being used. The conditions in which haulage operations are carried out are gradually improving, although it is a matter for regret that this improvement is not reflected in a reduced accident rate. One would imagine, concludes the Inspector, that improvements in any direction would be bound to result in a reduction in the number of accidents, but the plain fact is that several accidents have occurred where conditions could hardly be bettered, as the result of simple slips or small errors of judgment.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||