Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

9th March 1940, Page: 273, Column: 1

Accidents And Their Prevention

These notes are based on the Mines Inspectors' Reports for 1938. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies are obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office.

During the year 1938 as the result of underground haulage and transport accidents, 1,018 persons wore killed and seriously injured at the coal mines in Great Britain, the corresponding figure for 1937 being 1,079. Those disabled for more than three days numbered 30,776 as compared with 33,668.

Lessons of Man-haulage Accidents.

In Scotland haulage and transport accidents were responsible for 21.7 per cent. of all the reportable casualties. One accident due to a broken rope on a man-riding haulage caused five deaths and injuries to eleven persons, the rake at the time of the accident being loaded with twenty-eight men coming off the day shift. Details of the accident are given by Mr. T. Ashley in his 1938 report. At the inquiry a formal verdict was returned, the jury adding that "the accident was caused by the defective condition of a sector of the haulage rope in use at the time."

The jock or backstay was subjected to a metallurgical examination at the Department of Metallurgy, Sheffield University, on behalf of the Safety in Mines Research Board, and was found to be of "dead soft" steel of satisfactory analysis and general structure. From the evidence of some of the men on the rake, the jock held the rake until shout the eighth hutch had buffered, after which it failed. It was afterwards found that the pointed end had penetrated through the edge of one sleeper and that been driven underneath another sleeper, two feet away, causing the jock to bend, and eventually fracture, at a point just above where it had been welded.

Dr. M. A. Hogan, on behalf of the Wire Ropes Research Committee, called attention in his evidence at the inquiry to the visible signs of wear and the marked reduction in diameter of the length of the rope near the fracture as compared with the original size of the rope, namely, the unused portion on the haulage engine drum. This reduction in size should have been apparent when the rope was examined, though, as he pointed out, nothing like the same amount of reduction either in diameter or strength was present on other lengths of the rope tested.

This accident brings prominently to the fore the need (1) for the most careful examination of haulage ropes used for riding men. The rope examiner should be provided with parallel-jaw calipers as well as with a short sample of an unused portion of the rope, so that accurate measurements of the diameter of the rope and a comparison of the diameters measured at different places on the rope can be made. In this connection, however, Dr. Hogan states that it must not be lost sight of that when pitting is taking place the loss in strength may be considerably more than is indicated by the loss in diameter of the rope, or by the reduction in thickness of the wires, because the individual wires may be practically severed by deep pits (2) for the thorough lubrication of ropes at frequent intervals ; and (3) for the drainage of roads to be as effective as possible, especially where the water is corrosive.

Following another accident, when a haulage rope broke the S.M.R.B. Wire Ropes Research Committee examined and tested the rope, and their conclusions being of extreme interest to managers, especially where haulages are used only for manriding, Mr. Ashley quotes from them as follows :

"The rope broke as a result of deterioration by external wear and internal corrosion, which had reduced the aggregate strength to not more than 224 per cent. of the strength when new. The deterioration was largely internal and the outer wires retained their full original width at the crowns so that the dangerous condition of the rope was not at once apparent on external examination. The rope had lost 87 per cent. of its diameter at the bad part, but a much largeness might have been expected in view of the deterioration revealed after the accident. It is suggested that in eases of doubt the interior of the rope should be examined by the method of unlaying with clamps.

"The internal corrosion was apparently caused by the acidity of the core dressing in the absence of sufficient internal lubricant to protect the wires. It is suggested that in future ropes the wires should have a protective coating of zinc to inhibit this internal corrosion. It is not advisable to use an external dressing which contains kerosene, as the kerosene is liable to enter the rope and leach out the internal lubricant. This would appear to have occurred in the present rope.

"This accident draws attention to the peculiar danger of ropes used exclusively for hauling men. On this type of duty the maximum tension occurs with a full load of men and failure is likely to take place under the most dangerous conditions. Winding ropes, and ropes used for hauling men and mineral, are subjected to the maximum tension by a load of mineral, and this constitutes a daily loading test. Since the mineral load is usually well in excess of the load with men failure is unlikely to occur when raising men. In view of this consideration, it is suggested that ropes used exclusively for hauling men should be kept in service for only a short period and should be subjected to particularly stringent examination while in use.

It is suggested that the length of service of a rope on the present incline should be limited, say, to 12 months — when taken. off it can be used up on a mineral haulage on a flatter gradient."

Unlaying Ropes with Clamps.

The method of unlaying with clamps referred to above is quoted by Mr. Ashley as follows :

"Experiments in internal inspection during service — A 46 feet length from the capel side of the fracture but 11 feet next the fracture was cut off at the laboratory as it was partly unlaid and showed broken wires.

"The remaining 35-foot length was held at each end in a vice and two oak clamps were fitted about ten inches apart. The clamps were made of 2-inch by 2-inch section and consisted of a 2-foot 6-inch length bolted to a ten-inch length with a circular space between them three quarters of an inch in diameter. These were tightened up to grip the rope, one was held steady and the other revolved round the rope through 270 degrees. This unlaid the rope over the ten-inch length and enabled the condition of the wires against the fibre core to be clearly seen. The strands were also slightly loosened during the operation and the condition of the wires inside the strand could be seen with some difficulty. Further unlaying of the rope would normally loosen the wires in the strands, but in this particular case the wires were so reduced at their crowns that they showed signs of failing in torsion with further unlaying. The rope was then laid up again. One outer wire failed at the crown during unlaying. Very little force was necessary to unlay the rope and the clamps were held in place by spun-yarn during photographing. The effect in another part of the rope of unlaying to 360 degrees caused numerous outer wires to fail in torsion at their reduced crowns and a large amount of corrosion product fell from the rope.

"Similar tests were carried out with another rope of much the same size but showing less severe deterioration. This rope could be unlaid to 360 degrees without permanent distortion or other damage. Thus, this method can be used for the inspection of the interior of a rope during service and will cause wires to break only when they are seriously reduced or fatigued, in which case the rope should in any case be removed."

The length of the dook on which the men rode was 920 feet and had an average inclination dipping inbye of 1 In 3, the steepest length, 310 feet long, having an inclination of 1 in 2, commencing about 370 feet from the point where the men got on to the carriage. The road was straight and laid with rails weighing 45 lb. per yard.

Runaways.

Mr. Ashley states that 44 per cent. of the fatalities and 16 per cent, of the persons injured in connection with mechanical haulage were caused by runaways. Most of the runaways were caused by clips failing or by lashing chains slipping, sometimes without any apparent cause. The running back of the tubs would have been prevented in several of the cases if a monkey or swinging block had been installed close above the clipping on benches.

It is necessary that a stop-block should not only prevent a tub from moving after the tub has been brought to rest but that it should also be capable of stopping a moving tub. To fulfil this, the block must be fixed and permanent.

The failure to carry out ordinary routine work, especially in haulage operations, may result in serious consequences to others. An occurrence referred to by the Inspector showed that the runaway switch would have been more effective if it had been placed further away from the stop-block and that on steep roads temporary means to prevent runaways should be set up prior to attempting to re-rail tubs.

The stop-block and runaway switch or warrick at the top of any main-rope haulage road should by preference be interconnected so that neither is open at the same time. The combination is a much better safeguard against runaways than a stop-block and a runaway switch which are operated independently.

In a method adopted at a mine in Fife to prevent backward runaways the hinged crosspiece is kept horizontal by the chain but is free to move in the direction of travel of the tubs ascending a gradient but, if struck by a runaway, it is prevented from moving back by the outer upright.

Mr. Ashley points out that forward runaways, that is, runaways in the direction of travel down an incline, can be arrested or derailed by the provision of "jazz" rails or by a device operated by the first axle of the tub which, if it passes slowly over at the ordinary speed of haulage, merely depresses the device, but if violently struck, as by a runaway, raises another part of the device which catches against the back axle of the tub and holds it.

What is known as the "Rollo" is In use at some of the mines owned by Bairds and Dalmellington, Ltd., Ayrshire. When the rocker is struck normally it is pushed over by the tub axles and then being unequally balanced falls back into position, but should the rocker be struck violently by a runaway the back end of the rocker is caught by the back axle of the tub, the copper rivet is sheared, and the arm attached to the rocker is pushed forward. This, by means of levers, opens the hinged rail and the tub is derailed.

Some Useful Pointers.

Extra width between the two lines of rails and plenty of height is needed on endless-rope haulage roads where persons are regularly employed snibbling tubs or examining and tightening haulage clips.

The lack of height at the delivery ends of gate conveyors, where the empty tubs are taken inbye of the conveyor end, always needs care on the part of the haulage hands at what is also a busy place. Plenty of width and good lighting tend to reduce the risk of accidents at these places.

The danger of unprotected gearing is not sufficiently realised. In relation to this, Mr. Ashley says that, however good the general outside fence may be, all gear wheels require to be covered by a complete casing of strong sheet iron. This excludes all possibility of persons being caught by the teeth, and at the same time prevents danger from the spokes of the wheels. It may be that foolish actions cannot always be guarded against, at the same time nothing should be neglected that may safeguard persons who probably do not recognise the danger and whose desire usually is to assist in the work.

The provision of separate travelling roads avoids the necessity of men having to travel on the main mechanical roads at all, but where this is impracticable the haulage should be stepped at a reasonable time before the end of the shift to give the work men the opportunity of reaching the shaft bottom at the time they are due to commence to ride.

At a mine in Fife, a shelter, consisting of a cabin in the side of the road, has been provided at the bottom of a surface mine where the men can sit and wait in safety and to some extent in comfort, until the time arrives for them to ascend the mine. This course could be followed with advantage at many mines.

Need for Protective Devices.

In the Northern Division 28.1 per cent. of all reportable casualties occurred in connection with haulage and transport. Reporting some instances of runaways on mechanical haulages Mr. W. J. Charlton, the inspector in charge, notes in one case that it was unfortunate that the bell-push was not situated in a refuge hole to which it was moved after the accident. In another he remarks that the well-known "jazz-rail" runaway arresting device might with advantage be more widely used. Following a fatal accident to a youth of 18 the Widdas type interlocking chock and runaway switch was installed at the incline top, and the Inspector recalls that this device was invented many years ago by the manager of a colliery in the North of England and he expresses surprise that it is not more widely used in his Division. The chock and switch are interconnected so that one or the other is always in the effective position, and he is sure that its use in every situation where it is applicable would avert many accidents.

Whilst on this question of runaways, he proceeds to say that some comment on the application of Section 46 (4)(a) of the Coal Mines Act is appropriate. Where mechanical haulage, other than endless rope or endless chain, is used, this sub-section requires runaway switches or similar contrivances if the gradient exceeds 1 in 12 and where the use thereof is practicable. There would appear to be still some doubt as to the scope of this requirement, some people apparently being of the opinion that it is met by, say, landing chocks or switches at the top of inclines. The purpose of such devices is to prevent runaways, but they are not effective in preventing an accident after a runaway has occurred. Cases are found where a runaway switch or similar contrivance is not provided on the rise side of landings at the foot of inclines.

Coupling or Uncoupling Tubs.

On a full road which dipped outbye at 1 in 72, a shaft lad, aged 17, was killed. He was uncoupling sets of three full tubs, and detaching the clips which secured the last tub of each set to an undertub endless rope moving at a speed of one mile per hour. The lad either experienced some difficulty, or slipped while uncoupling the first tub of a set, and his head was crushed between the top of the first tub and a top canch brow some six feet outbye from the normal coupling point. Mr. Charlton appeals to all colliery officials to make an attempt to anticipate the difficulties likely to be encountered by persons attaching or detaching tubs from ropes, and to take the action necessary to avert potential danger from difficulties.

Belt not Running Properly.

In order to demonstrate to some conveyor drawers, whom he held responsible, the reason why the belt was not running properly, a deputy removed the top cover-plate from the return end of a mothergate belt conveyor. The belt had been "sticking" and finally came to rest before he removed the cover-plate. He was stooping to pick up the plate with a view to replacing it, when a conveyor drawer passing from the face to the mothergate, stepped on the bolt-covered end roller. The belt moved as he stepped on it and his leg was drawn between the two rollers. The deputy was remiss, in the view of the Inspector, in that he failed to give a "stop" signal to the driving end of the belt. The attendant there was trying to get the belt away and he, unfortunately, succeeded just as the drawer stepped into the open tension-end box. With a view to averting a similar accident, a locking device was evolved which consists of a small diameter roller mounted eccentrically, and so arranged that when free to move it falls into such a position that it wedges the conveyor-belt against the main end drum. The belt is prevented from moving as the wedging effect increases with the pull exerted in the belt. In the ordinary course of working, a dowel pin forming part of the cover-plate keeps the roller clear of the belt. When the cover-plate is removed the small roller falls into effective position.

Opinion Still Held.

Examining the report by Mr. H. J. Humphrys on the Yorkshire Division it is seen that of all the reportable casualties 26.7 per cent. were due to haulage and transport. The classification of the latter shows that 91.2 per cent. of those that proved fatal and 87.4 per cent. of the non-fatal accidents were avoidable.

When a stoneman, 65 years of age, was about to attach a drag behind a set of eight tubs of dirt which had been drawn apart from other tubs, on a gradient of 1 in 44, to make room for this to be done, the 3/8-inch diameter rope became fast at a rail joint and broke. The set ran back and fatally injured the stoneman. The rope had been in use three months.

In his report for 1936 Mr. Humphrys stated "In my opinion the 3/8-inch rope is not sufficiently robust for underground haulage conditions. If the rope is damaged its strength is almost negligible. The breakage of 3/8-inch ropes has been the cause of numerous accidents in the past and very few are now used. I should like to see them entirely eliminated." In his latest report his comment is brief: "I still hold this opinion."

The rope was examined by Dr. M. A. Hogan, who found that it had failed as a result of excessive external wear, which had caused a reduction of at least 60.7 per cent. in aggregate strength.

Clip Bolts.

A corporal was killed when six full tubs can away on an endless haulage with a gradient in favour of the loaded tub. The tubs were attached to the rope at the rear end by a Smallman clip which slipped as the rope was brought to a sudden stop. Investigation revealed that a pipe 3 feet 8 inches in length had been threaded over the clip handle and that the additional leverage had stretched and deformed the bolt. In connection with this Mr. Humphrys refers to a report by W. A. Johnson of the Safety in Mines Research Board, who estimated that a force of 70 lb. at the end of a three-foot pipe puts a load of 13.8 tons on the bolt. He also found considerable variation (from 0.17 per cent. to 0.32 per cent.) in the carbon content of the steel in the bolts he examined, some of which were supplied by the makers and some from other sources. It is suggested that the use of pipes in this way is generally unnecessary if proper attention is given to the adjustment of the clip, but where used, the length should not exceed two feet. A suitable carbon content for the steel should be specified when ordering the bolts. The higher content carbon steel is considered more suitable.

Double Jack-Catches.

Reference is made by Mr. Humphrys to a set of ten full tubs attached to an overtub endless haulage running back after travelling 85 yards on a gradient of 1 in 15, owing to the lashing chain slipping, and, colliding with some stationary tubs, fatally crushing two haulage hands. The runaway train ripped out three jack-catches spaced 25 yards apart, which obviously were not strong enough for such a heavy load. A double jack-catch in use at Bentley Colliery is fixed to a substantial frame which also carries the rails, and it would be impossible to dislodge it without also deranging the track. With a jack-catch of this type the accident would not have occurred. The Inspector also refers to the double jack-catch being tried out at Dinnington Main and Rossington Main Collieries. This jack-catch forms part of the rail track and the passage of tubs in the proper direction depresses it to rail level. If, however, the tubs run back, this does not occur and the tubs are arrested. If they run back with sufficient force to dislodge the jack-catch, the length of rail, of which it forms an integral part, goes as well. It is claimed as an advantage that the jack-catch acts on the tub wheels and not on the axles, and the space between the rails is not obstructed.

Precautions Overlooked.

Brief accounts are given of derailments, in one of which a deputy lost his life. It appears that in a long man-riding train attached to an endless rope, one of the centre carriages had been taken out for repairs. As the train was being drawn outbye at six miles per hour with a shift of men, the carriage immediately in front of the gap formed by the missing carriage became derailed. A deputy riding on this carriage jumped off with the intention of giving a signal, but he stumbled and fell into the gap and was run over by the three following carriages and instantly killed. The Inspector says the accident could have been avoided by any one of the following ordinary precautions, namely (1) closing of the gap by moving some of the carriages or by providing a spare carriage; (2) a pull wire system of signalling that could be operated by any person on the train; or (3) the deputy remaining on the train and passing a verbal message to the conductor who was provided with a fork for giving signals from the train.

What Investigation Has Shown.

Sufficient particulars are given to show how other accidents could have been avoided, and under the caption "conveyors or loaders" Mr. Humphrys mentions that there were five deaths as against a clean sheet in 1937. Two of the cases may suitably be given.

A ripping contractor was struck and instantly killed by flying fragments of metal from the casing of a 15 horse-power compressed air turbine. The rotor ran away and burst by centrifugal force owing to excessive speed. The turbine was placed alongside the belt conveyor it was driving, which, unlike the types which are placed under the conveyor, afforded no protection in such circumstances. The air pressure was 80 lb. per square inch and the turbine was pulling in slack belt and so running light at the time. The governor and air-filter had been deliberately removed by a fitter from this and other conveyor turbines some time previously, and so there was no automatic check on excessive speed. Inquiry showed, according to the Inspector, that this malpractice had also occurred at other collieries.

In a later accident a haulage hand was killed in almost similar circumstances. Slack belt was being pulled in so that the turbine was nearly running light. This time the governor mechanism was rendered useless owing to a split pin coming out. The normal running speed of these turbines when under load is 2,000/3,000 r.p.m., but without the governors the speed, when running light, can quickly run up to 15,000/16,000 r.p.m., at which speed the rotor will burst and may be projected through the cast iron casing.

Investigation has shown Mr. Humphrys points out, that safety can best be assured if the following precautions are taken :—

(1) Enclosing the governor mechanism completely to prevent interference. (In some models the governor spindle projects through the casing and can be pushed back by hand to race the turbine).

(2) Placing the air filter in the governor housing in such a way that the air circuit is not complete unless it is in position.

(3) Securing the cover over the governor housing by screws (of the Hole-Chrome or Allen type) and padlock.

(4) Making the governor non-adjustable and so dispensing with the movable nut and split pin which worked loose.

(5) Providing an independent speed control (trip-gear) operating well above normal running speed and well below the bursting speed of the rotor (say at 5/6,000 r.p.m.) which will cut off the air supply.

(6) Making the rotor of cast iron with an admixture of nickel.

(7) Making the casing of these smaller turbines of steel as in the larger coal-cutter motors.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ashley, Theodore    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Charlton, William John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Hogan, A. M., Dr.    S.M.R.B.  Whos Who Page
Humphrys, Herbert John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Johnson, W. A.    S.M.R.B.  



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
13 Jan 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Jan 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
09 Mar 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 Mar 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 Apr 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
20 Apr 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
04 May 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
18 May 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Jun 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Jun 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Jun 1940  Accidents And Their Prevention (The Science and Art of Mining)
03 May 1941  Explosives And Their Substitutes (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print