|
23rd February 1940, Page: 1, Column: 3 Newbiggin Boy Caught In MachineryMotor Mechanic Criticised At Ashington Inquest"Elementary Responsibility"Hint Of Further Investigation The failure of a Newbiggin Colliery motor mechanic to respond immediately to an emergency summons was described as "reprehensible and improper" by Coroner H. J. Percy at an Ashington inquest on Wednesday. The death of a boy, who was caught in the screen machinery, was stated by the coroner to be closely associated with the mechanic's "failure to carry out his elementary responsibilities." The inquest, which was opened and adjourned on January 5th, when Robert Hepple, of Market Place, Bedlington, gave evidence of identification, concerned the death of John W. Peel, a 14-years-old screen boy, of 34 Storey Crescent, Newbiggin. The boy's father, Richard B. Peel, who also works at Newbiggin Colliery, said his son had been engaged in screen work for nine months. His eyesight and hearing were good, and he had no physical disabilities. Dr. W. Stephenson described how he was called to the colliery and found that in addition to Peel being fatally injured another man was seriously injured. With regard to Peel, the doctor said that death must have been almost instantaneous, and he described the terrible injuries the boy had sustained. Cloud Of Dust Edgar Allison, 20 Maitland Terrace, Newbiggin, screens foreman, stated that he was at his job on the screens when he heard a clatter of woodwork and saw a cloud of dust, near the shaker. On going to investigate he asked as to the whereabouts of the mechanic, Gordon. The mechanic could not be found and when he returned from his search he looked into No. 1 shaker and saw a pair of feet. He immediately took steps to switch off the power. On returning to the shaker he saw the boy's body hanging from the shafting in the driving pulley. He had been caught by the head. A fitter cut the belt to release the body, the boy being dead. The witness told the Coroner that five or ten minutes prior to the accident he saw Peel attending to his job at the shaker. This was his work unless he was sent to other work. Had he been attending to his own job at the shaker he could not have become involved in the machinery. The boy was a willing and eager worker. Questioned by Alderman Wm. Golightly, president of the Northumberland Miners' Association, the witness said he had known of the belt slipping before, and the defect was remedied by the mechanics. The boy had never put the belt on, although perhaps he had assisted a mechanic by picking up the belt when it was broken. On this occasion the boy went of his own accord to where the belt had slipped. Alderman Golightly: Is there not something about this boy trying to get a fitter out of some cabin to attend to the trouble? — Witness : I know nothing about that. Mechanic's Story James Gordon, motor mechanic, of Marine Street, Newbiggin, said his job was to look after the belts on the screens. Defects were reported to him and he attended to them. He was always on the job. On the morning of the tragedy he started work at 9.30 and the accident happened at 11.30. He had attended to several jobs during the morning and had gone to a cabin for his bait when Peel came and said there was trouble with the stone belt which was slipping. "I told him to go back to his work," said the witness, "and that I would attend to it in a minute. He came back again and said the belt was slipping and burning. I again told him to go back to his work. Within a minute or two I went below the shakers to have a look to see what was the matter. When I got there I found the boy trying to get the pins out of the belt. He should not have been doing that. I had just told him he should not have been there when he was caught in the machinery. I tried to get hold of his trousers or coat and I cannot remember anything else. I told him to let go of the belt. I have no memory of how I was injured myself. "I never thought the boy would interfere with the belt. I would not have allowed it in any circumstances. I had never known the boy attempt to do anything of this sort before." Mr. A. T. Jones (mines' inspector): You go to work at 9.30 and you have bait at 11.30, and then you work at the pit until 7.30? — Witness: But we have another bait time. — Did he tell you one of the belts was burning? — Yes, that is correct. "Dangerous" Mr. Jones observed that the witness had apparently been told by the boy that the belt was burning, yet, in spite of this dangerous state of affairs, he merely told the boy to get back to his work. Mr. Jones: Were you going to let the belt burn and perhaps set fire to the whole of the screens? — Oh no. "It seems very funny to me," Mr. Jones commented. The witness replied that the stone belt sometimes was not working for four hours at a time, and it was his intention to attend to the trouble when the men were going down the pit and coal drawing had slackened. Coroner : Why was it that when you gave me your evidence in chief you did not mention that the first time the boy came he mentioned burning as well as slipping? The witness admitted that the boy had mentioned burning as well as slipping. Coroner: When the boy reported to you that the belt was burning — which you agree was a serious state of affairs — why was it you then said to the boy that he should go back to his work and you would attend to it in a minute ? The witness repeated that it had been his intention to attend to the trouble immediately when the pit was "running slack." Coroner: How long was it after you sent the boy away that he returned to tell you the belt was burning? — In about two seconds. — How long did you wait before going to see what was the matter? — About two minutes. Mechanic Questions Alderman Golightly: Are you sure the boy did not accompany you to the scene of the accident? — He did not. — Was he not screaming when you arrived? — No. — But you must know something about how you happened the accident? — I have not the faintest idea. I only remember hitting my head. — The chargeman says the belt frequently comes off? — Yes. — Have you ever known this boy try to adjust these things himself ? — Never. Manager of the colliery : Your duty as a mechanic is to attend to any complaints received immediately you receive them? — Yes. — Have you been given any instructions from any official that you can wait two minutes before attending to a complaint of any kind ? — No. John George Smith, screener, of 31 Collingwood Road, Newbiggin, said at about 10 o'clock he saw the boy at his work at the handles of the shaker. Trouble developed with the running of the belt and it was then he noticed that the boy was not at his usual place. The chargeman began to make inquiries about Peel, who could not be found. The stone belt had now stopped and then he saw Gordon, the mechanic, go down the steps followed by the boy Peel. Coroner : You have no doubt in your mind that the two of them were walking quite close to each other? — Witness : No doubt at all. Witness added that Peel was a careful workers and one of the finest little boys on the screens. The Coroner then gave Gordon the opportunity of cross-examining Smith on the statements he had made alleging that the mechanic and the boy were together. Gordon, however, said he did not wish to ask any questions. Coroners Comments Reviewing the evidence, the Coroner said : "This is certainly a very lamentable state of affairs, and it is a case which obviously will require further investigation by a different authority, but as far as the duty which falls upon me is concerned I have to record the cause of death and indicate any irregularities — if they exist — which may have led to the cause of death. "I am quite willing to accept the explanation given by Gordon that he did not intentionally attempt to mislead me when he gave to me in his evidence in chief the bare statement that the boy reported to him that one of the belts was slipping, while omitting to tell me the much more serious statement that belt was not only slipping, but was burning. "I make every allowance for Gordon, who is ill owing to the injuries he sustained in the accident, because of his condition he may have inadvertently omitted to tell me the whole of the statement made by the boy and I will allow his evidence to be corrected. "Immediately there follows the extraordinary sequence that, having been given the grave and serious message, he chooses to sit calmly continuing his bait, and alleges that he told the boy to go back. He did this a second time after the boy had reported that something was burning. "I am quite anxious to believe that it may be the result of Gordon's injuries that his mind has been confused, but there can be no question but that in the clear recollection of Mr. Smith, which Gordon did not challenge, that he accompanied the boy, thus showing that Gordon's statement that the boy preceded him was untrue." The Coroner continued: "I don't think more reprehensible and improper conduct on the part of a responsible man could be imagined than that after receiving an emergency message like this he should, on his own statement, choose to sit quietly back instead of at once getting up and attending to his serious duties. He preferred to go on with his meal, which could have waited a hundred times before a duty of this sort. "It is simply beyond my comprehension," the Coroner declared, "and in my opinion the cause of this lad's death must be left very closely at the door of Gordon's failure to carry out his elementary responsibilities." The Coroner recorded that the cause of death was "multiple bodily injuries sustained by the deceased having been accidentally caught in the screen belt whilst following his employment as a screener on January 5th, 1940."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||