27th January 1940, Page: 240, Column: 2
Toad Stories
Readers may be interested in the following note from the WIGAN
OBSERVER published just fifty years ago :—
Possibly the miners and stone-workers in this district are not
of so imaginative turn of mind as their fellows in other portions of
the country, for so far we have not had it recorded that one of
them has brought to light one of those pre-historic toads, supposed
to have been locked up in a block of coal or stone some time before
the Flood. Mr. Osmond Jeffs, in the "Research," shows the
absurdity of these "finds." He mentions several recent cases
in which miners and others are alleged to have seen the lively frog
jump out of a cavity broken into by the pickaxe. At Shield Muir
Pit, at Motherwell, we are told that thirty "or forty" young frogs
were found in a cavity in a block of sandstone, 330 feet deep.
But the best of these tales comes from Birkenhead, where, "to
the great dismay of the housemaid, who was making the fire, on
breaking open a lump of coal, a live toad jumped out on the
hearthrug." All these entertaining stories Mr. Jeffs dismisses
unceremoniously. "Geologically speaking," he says, "the
presence of live toads in coal is discountenanced, because no toads
are known to have existed on the earth during the carboniferous
period and the changes which the rocks have undergone since
their formation (to say nothing of the lapse of time) render it quite
impossible that any living organism could be so long preserved
as the narrators of these 'toad stories' would have us believe."
But apart from these considerations, it is clear from the experiments
made by Dr. Buckland that toads do not possess that
capacity of living without food and air attributed to them by the
popular faith. The Dean had twenty-four of these unfortunate
creatures placed in air-tight cells made in blocks of solid limestone
and sandstone, further guarded by a double cover of glass and
slate. They were then buried in his own garden. Most of these
were dead at the end of the first year, and none survived the
second. Four toads enclosed in holes cut in the trunk of an apple
tree and plugged so as to exclude insects, all died within a year.
Whatever else may be said of these experiments, they are decisive,
and justify Mr. Jeffs' conclusion that 'prehistoric' toads can be
found at the present day alive on emerging from solid blocks of
coal or other mineral is not found to be based on evidence of any
scientific value whatever.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Buckland, —, Dr. | | | |
| Jeffs, Osmond | | | |