27th January 1940, Page: 228, Column: 1
Introduction Of Steel Supports
At the meeting on 16th January of the Manchester Geological
and Mining Society Mr. J. F. Carr presented a paper with many
illustrations on "The Introduction and Use of Steel Roof Supports
at the Working Face." He opened by quoting from the Report
of the Safety in Coal Mines Commission the statement that "There
is a general consensus of opinion that where the conditions permit
of it, the use of steel on the coal face facilitates systematic roof
control and gives a high factor of security." Mr. Carr said that
progressive mining methods necessitate intensive and systematic
roof support and control which afford the highest factor of security,
so that very little alteration to the statement is required for it
to read "There is a general consensus of opinion that steel roof
supports should be used on all intensive faces."
To attain the full advantage in the use of steel supports it is
necessary to eliminate waste and to replace all timber on the face
by the use of steel props and bars. There is no doubt that the
introduction of steel supports, particularly at the working face,
has been a very important feature accompanying the progress in
methods of coal mining. It is essential for safety and economic
operation and can be applied under most conditions in mechanised
mining methods. At the present time there is in addition the
restriction of supplies of imported pit wood.
The object of Mr. Carr's paper was to give a practical account
of a recent change from timber to steel supports at the face. The
introduction of steel supports has been effected on four faces — two
strike faces in a Four-foot seam; one strike and one dip face in
a Six-foot seam.
The Four-foot Seam.
The two strike faces in the Four-foot seam were in the first
instance changed over to steel. The faces were advancing in
opposite directions and were cut and cleared on a 24-hour cycle.
The thickness of cover was 3,500 feet, the gradient 1 in 3½. No. 1
Face was 78 yards and No. 2 Face 190 yards in length and both
were undercut to a depth of 4' 6" in the inferior coal hand at the
bottom of the seam. The coal-cutters were fitted with gumming
devices which had an important bearing on the effective clearing
out of the holings, and the immediate use of steel sprags to support
the undercut coal. The roof was a very soft irregular shale, with
many potholes and fossil plants, whilst numerous joints tended
to further the disintegration of the immediate roof. The floor
was warrant, which lifted considerably although it had a fairly
hard crust, and was generally penetrated by the props.
Giving a statement of the conditions prior to the introduction
of steel Mr. Carr said it was obvious that, if steel props and bars
were to be used on the faces, consideration must be given to reduce
the period between the setting and the withdrawal of the props;
it was therefore decided to experiment with various methods of
packs, etc., to reduce the convergence on the face under the most
difficult conditions pending the delivery of the steel supports.
Attention was given to the quality and spacing of the packs,
and in addition rows of hardwood chocks were introduced opposite
the wastes. During the filling shift two rows of chocks were used,
one on either side of the conveyor, and as the cut was cleared a
third row was set in the new line of timber, so that when the
machine was cutting there were three rows of chocks and the
conveyor was advanced to the position between the two front
rows. During the next shift the back row of chocks was withdrawn,
to be re-set in the new row of timber. The chocks were
set on the firm floor and bricks were used to facilitate withdrawal.
The width of the packs and wastes was varied several times, and
the packs advanced before coal-cutting. Following each alteration
to the packing system convergence tests were made during the
three cuts.
The roof in the wastes fell to a greater height and more regularly
in the fourth test, and from the experience it was accepted that
the chocks had justified their use. A tendency for the roof to
weight coincided with the second test. There were signs of
improvement in the roof due to the chocks; the rearranged packing
and the fact that the props were withdrawn after three instead
of four cuts as previously, all of which, no doubt, effected a reduced
convergence. The progress, however, did not fulfil expectations.
The Author then dealt with the introduction of steel, when the
previous arrangement of packs was unaltered but the use of chocks
was discontinued, The face was equipped with rigid tubular
props. He pointed out that the great disadvantage with the
rigid tubular props is their withdrawal. It was found practically
impossible to withdraw them in a direction at right angles to the
face, although this difficulty was overcome by the use of two
sylvesters pulling simultaneously the prop and channel bodily
to the rise. This withdrawal was difficult and costly, creating
a decided tendency to drag the soft roof, causing local falls from
the edge of the waste on to the conveyor.
A short trial was arranged with wedge props, after which a
number of the sylvester easy withdrawal props were introduced
for trial, and installed opposite a waste. Easy release and withdrawal
were obtained with this type of prop from the start; the
collapse of the head provided a clearance of 3 to 4 inches between
the top of the prop and the underside of the channel, even after
movement had taken place and the immediate roof had "followed."
This enabled a normal sequence of withdrawal in the following
order, a back prop first, then the front prop, with a chain attached
to the channel for pulling it out either by hand or, in the case
of it being buried, by a sylvester. Moreover, the need for setting
timber for protection was no longer required. The two strike
faces were then fully equipped with this type of prop, and no
further trouble in the withdrawal has been experienced ; the roof
conditions at the faces improved and breakaways from the waste
edge — due to pulling props and channels out simultaneously —
did not arise.
The Six-foot Seam.
After the Four-foot seam had been fully equipped the change
to steel was arranged for the Six-foot seam. The conditions on
the dip face were that the roof was stronger, hut the floor was
very soft and did not offer sufficient resistance to the penetration
by the props. Moreover, the face advanced slightly across
measures dipping at 1 in 3. On the strike face the section of coal
was not as thick as on the dip face, and the roof and floor were
both fairly good, but the inclination was 1 in 2.4. It was realised
that the handling and setting of a steel bar together with a 5' 9"
steel prop, top-heavy due to the wedge headpiece, was a matter
of considerable difficulty on this gradient and farther, the floor
was inclined to be slippery, with the danger that accidents would
arise if props were knocked out, or fell whilst being set.
The face was therefore set out fully mechanised on a 24-hour
cycle, equipped with 5' 9" wedge props and 4' 6" corrugated bars.
Corrugated bars were selected as they are lighter to handle when
set under these conditions, and in order to keep the setting under
proper control instructions were given that this work was to be
done by three men. Each man to obtain the help of higher and
lower side neighbour when about to set a bar; in addition a floor
barricade was erected against the higher side of it when completed.
Hardwood chocks together with chock releases were also used,
and a waste pack was built between the two roadside packs.
The roof broke down regularly, and in small pieces from the
commencement, so much so that, in order to obtain efficient
packs, bag packing was introduced. Very little difficulty was
experienced on this face, and the only change made was in substituting
channels for the corrugated bars, which in addition tended
to steady and maintain the props in position whilst being set.
Checking System.
The checking system adopted requires that every steel prop
on a face is marked with a letter and a number, and that each
prop be erected in the correct relative position on the face. The
letters and numbers are painted on the web of the prop in black
against a white background. The numbers denote the row of
props at right angles to the face, and the letters the row of props
parallel to the face.
When a prop is missing its number is known, and that number
is an indication where to look for it; if a prop is damaged the
replacement prop is marked with the same latter and number
as the damaged one. By this means a continuous cheek is kept
by the fireman in charge of the face, and recorded in a book.
Every month the props in each section are checked by a senior
official, and quarterly a complete inventory is taken, surface and
underground, from which all losses are computed.
The advantages of steel on the coal face are permanency and the
elimination of the daily trouble and expense of transporting and
handling large quantities of timber underground ; this is particularly
costly and inconvenient where the measures are highly
inclined. On the other band, steel props and bars may be uneconomical
if losses are high, but with efficient organisation and
a proper system of checking losses can be controlled. More
steel props are lost through being laid on the floor and buried,
than by leaving them undrawn in the wastes.
In the statement of his conclusions Mr. Carr stated that on
all faces it was found necessary to accommodate the height
reduction or convergence which took place whilst the props were
set, by inserting a wood pad to act as a compression piece.
The steel resulted in a marked decrease in face support cost.
The use of steel on the faces for nearly all purposes, such as
props, bars, cutter sprags, etc., makes the absence of timber
very much felt, as there is no broken timber available for such
purposes as backing behind the arches, or building it in packs
to help to stabilise the walls (very often done in steep measures),
etc. In such cases corrugated steel is used behind the arches
on the main roadways, and deal timber is sent for hacking in
other roads. Bags filled with dirt are used in the pack walls
where required.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Carr, J. F. | | | |