|
13th January 1940, Page: 209, Column: 1 Accidents And Their PreventionThese notes are based on the Mines Inspectors' Reports for 1938. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies are obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office. Falls at Working Face. As stated by Mr. T. Ashley in his 1938 report for Scotland, a number of accidents occur each year from falls of roof between the last row of props and the coal face. One occurred on a machine-cut conveyor face at a mine in Fife, where a stripper was fatally injured. He had worked off a nose of coal and while he was preparing to set a prop to the front end of a strap a fall of fakey blaes came away from an induced break flush with the edge of the coal. The strap he was setting was over the new conveyor track and should have been set much earlier, but this had little bearing on the fall which came away between the face line of props and the coal three feet away, which was unsupported for the whole length of the face. Commenting on this accident Mr. Ashley says the roof close to the face of machine-cut faces can only be effectively supported by straps. At another mine in Fife a similar type of fall injured a fireman while undoing his shot-firing cable. The fall came away from a lype in the blaes roof running obliquely back over the waste and from an induced break coinciding with the front edge of the straps which were set systematically but leaving a space of 2 feet 6 inches unprotected for the full length of the run. An almost similar fall, 12 feet long and 2 feet 9 inches wide, caused serious injury to a stripper at a mine in Ayrshire. In this instance a vertical lype in the roof of fakes coincided with the face and while the straps were regularly set three feet apart ; here again a space nearly three feet wide was left unsupported between the front row of props and the coal. Falls frequently occur at the roadhead between the face of the brushing and the coal. A typical instance occurred at a mine in West Lothian. Straps were set regularly along the face, with the exception of the length in front of the roadhead where reliance had been placed on two props set close to the edge of the brushing. The stone fell from two "dry cutters" and injured a miner while gumming. The Inspector observes that intensive support should always be given at roadheads. On this face a distance of 3 feet 6 inches was also left unsupported where the coal had been stripped. Many other casualties were caused by falls of roof under similar circumstances, and they emphasise the necessity of supports being set close up to the face where men are working. Probably the best method to adopt, at any rate where the coal is sufficiently strong, is for the strippers to break in to the hack of the cut coal and, as the buttock is worked off, to set straps with the front end needled into the solid coal. After the machine has passed, a prop can then be set under the front end of the strap close to the coal. Re-setting Front Props. Another method sometimes adopted is to use a strap not less than five feet long, placing the front end close to the coal, supported, in addition to the prop at the back end, by a prop near the centre. As the machine advances the centre prop is removed and, after the machine has passed, it is re-set near the front end of the strap. Failure to re-set several of these front props at a mine in Midlothian resulted in an assistant machineman — who was responsible for re-setting the props — being injured by a fall of roof which came away for a length of ten feet from a lype on the waste side and a break over the front of the coal. Three straps were broken off but they fortunately protected, to some extent, the injured man from the full weight of the stone. The width required between the last row of props and the face to allow the coal-cutting machine to pass is less now than formerly, the modern chain machine requiring less room than the bar machine and very much less room than the early disc machine. This width is always of importance, but becomes more so where the roof is tender or otherwise broken, and so the type of machine used has a direct bearing on safety at the face. On short faces in steep seams worked on the strike, the roof is liable to collapse because of the want of packs and because the narrow face prevents the roof from settling and tightening the supports. Setting of Supports Delayed. Mr. Ashley notes that the setting of supports is far too frequently delayed until near the end of the shift. Supports, even if temporary ones, should be set as soon as room has been made for them, and neglect of this resulted in serious injury to a stone-mine worker at a mine in East Lothian. He and his neighbour were driving a narrow place in the coal and were in the act of needling holes in the side to erect a girder when a fall came away from an unforeseen and keen natural parting in the roof. The last support was nine feet from the face and the girder should have been erected long before. The drawing up of suitable support rules for narrow places driven in the sense stratum presents no difficulty, but the framing of rules for the proper support of stone mines or cross-measure drifts where the stratum is constantly changing cannot be made effective unless the full length of the stone mine is required to be supported. The Inspector states that it would tend to prevent falls at and near the face of stone mines where men spend nearly the whole of their shifts if two or three temporary props were set, whether the road behind the face was supported or otherwise. "Chapping" a strong stratum is far from being an infallible guide as to it being safe or otherwise. Withdrawal of Supports. Six men were killed and nine men were seriously injured during the year by falls in the waste either when withdrawing supports or when obtaining stone from the waste for packing. All occurred on conveyor faces. When withdrawing supports from the waste every care should be exercised that the props are drawn in the right sequence, that temporary props are set, and that a sylvester is used. The effect of the disturbance to the roof produced by the withdrawal of one support cannot be estimated, bet as Mr. Ashley points out the greater distance away the operator is able to be from the support being withdrawn, the greater chance there is of his avoiding a fall which may result. It is often found necessary to relieve or ease a prop before it can be withdrawn. This work which is always attended with some danger, can be obviated to a very large extent by twisting the prop as it is being drawn out, using Gawthrope's or Bennett's design of hook. A twisting pull can be given to a prop by attaching the chain so that the book is at right angles to the line of pull. The back of the hook in this instance is fitted with two prongs which grip the prop and assist in the twisting action. Still greater leverage can be obtained by the "Wrester" or one of the other similar contrivances in the form of a pipe wrench which is attached to the end of the sylvester chain. Falls in the Waste. The danger of going into the waste behind the face from which the supports have been drawn and where falls may occur at any time is apparently not always realised, several fatalities having occurred from this cause during the year under review by Mr. Ashley. In one instance a miner went into the waste for no known reason and was killed by a stone that fell from a break in the roof immediately behind the last row of chocks. In several other instances brushers and packers have ventured beyond the supported area when obtaining redd from the waste to erect buildings or packs. At a few mines rakes, with two or more prongs, fitted with handles about six feet long, are provided for the use of packers to facilitate drawing stone out of the waste, and similar appliances should be used at other mines when it is necessary to get stone from the waste. Where the waste has to be blasted to cause it to fall and to obtain building material, the shot-holes should be drilled from the face side and not from the waste side. In this way the work can be done under roof which is supported. Falls of Side. A number of accidents from falls of coal arise through under-sprags or gibs not being set in the undercut made by the coal-cutting machine. Many seams are apparently so soft that it is considered dangerous to attempt to put in gibs behind the coal-cutter because the coal falls off so readily; under these circumstances the coal probably does not require undercutting. Stretcher bars or stells are set between the last prop and the coal to take the place of gibs and to support the front of the coal, but these, the Inspector points out, should be in addition to and not in substitution for gibs. The presence of induced breaks and "backs" in the coal as well as of "falling" — a varying thickness of blaes or stone lying on the top of the coal and worked with it — all play an important part in causing these falls; experience and constant watchfulness are the best aids to their prevention. In this connection it is recorded that at one mine where accidents from falls of coal were rather frequent, improvement has been effected by the appointment of "timbermen" of experience and ability for every 100 yards of face whose sole duty is to supervise and assist in the timbering of the face as the coal is stripped off. Since their appointment no reportable accidents have occurred at this mine. Referring to two falls from the brushing face on "conveyor" faces the Inspector observes that the roof under the brushing was well supported, but in one the fall came away from between and above two stays set to the brushing face which was 12 feet wide and six feet high in hard clayey shale. Where the area exposed is so large, be says such a form of support is not sufficient, though it can be usefully employed where the brushing is thinner and narrower. Reference is made, through the courtesy of James Dunlop and Co., Ltd., to a method adopted at Cardowan Colliery, Lanarkshire, for supporting the face of the brushing in a seam with a strong blaes roof. The method of support can only be used where the sides are strong and the face can be kept well squared, and is the outcome of a suggestion made by Mr. M. Naismith, Junior Inspector of Mines. Two telescopic tubes are used, the ends of which are tapered and reinforced. The tubes are tightened into position in front of the brushing — holes having first been prepared in the sides for the ends of the tubes — by fixing a loose gland or collar on the smaller tube at the desired position, the final adjustment being made by two screws joining a loose flange in front of the gland to the flange of the larger tube. Two pairs of tubes are used in a brushing about six feet thick and the necessary amount of lagging is placed behind them effectively to cover the brushing face. The great advantage of this method is that the support is erected directly after the shots are fired and before the debris has been redd. It has been the practice at this mine for some time past to erect iron-wire nets against the brushings to prevent falls during filling operations. Use of Steel Straps. Mr. W. J. Charlton has examined the fatalities which occurred from falls of roof at the working face in the Northern Division and concludes that they indicate the need for continued attention, and in some cases a much greater degree of attention, to the method of support to be adopted in a particular condition, and to ensuring, by sympathetic but firm discipline, rigid adherence to the system laid down. In his view, on machine-cut longwall faces an essential condition of a good system of support is that planks or straps should be generally used, and that each plank or strap should be set with one end against the coal face. The method of support to be adopted in connection with the use of arcwall machines requires careful consideration. It is usual to support bord and pillar workings with pairs of gears set parallel to the face. In an arcwall place it is necessary to remove end-props near the face to enable the machine jib to be swung, and as a result there is a tendency to allow the last pair of gears to be act further from the face than would otherwise have been the case. The potential danger involved in having too much unsupported roof at the face and in removing supports to permit the swinging of the machine jib can be obviated by a system in use at Lynemouth Colliery, Northumberland. Corrugated steel straps are used across the tub way. The inbye cross-strap is supported over the under-cut and blasted coal by two longer steel straps used as runners and supported by iron hangers from cross-straps outbye. The cross-strap nearest the face is, of course, supported by props to form a pair of gears as soon as practicable during the filling. Roadhead Supports. Where top canches are taken to longwall faces, the support at the roadhead is sometimes found to be not as close as on the remainder of the face. The face may be closely supported by the fillers with planks set at right angles to, and with ends touching, the face. These supports are removed from the roadhead before blasting the top canch, and the new supports erected to the roof formed by the canch are parallel to the face. There is, in some cases, a tendency to delay unduly the setting of these more permanent supports and, in other cases, supports are not set close enough to the face. It is well known that the incidence of accidents at roadheads is higher than elsewhere at the face, and it is quite obvious that the support of the roadhead should not be less close than elsewhere. Where top canches are necessarily taken to the face, the system of support to be adopted should be carefully considered, and such effective steps taken as arc necessary to ensure that it is adhered to. The system of support of ground at roadheads should include effective support for the brow and sides of any top canch taken. So far as brows are concerned, every canch brow should be supported with inclined stays, as well as upright supports, irrespective of the nature of the stone. Falls on Roads. Two fatalities illustrate the need for careful support at roadway junctions. In one instance a 12-foot steel girder set across a junction supported the ends of wood bars. A pony, attached to a full tub, stumbled against, and dislodged, one end-prop of the girder, and a putter who was sitting on the limbers was killed by a large fall of roof. In another instance a road junction was supported by a 10-foot crossing-girder on which rested four wood balks. The girder was supported by two props at one end and by one at the other. Two stonemen, who were engaged in taking off side stone to make room for air-tubes, set a middle-prop to the girder while the stone was being taken off, then later, to facilitate filling the stone into tubs, decided to withdraw the middle-prop. One of them was knocking it out when an extensive fall occurred and killed the other. Efficient support of the ends of crossing-girders or balks is so important, Mr. Charlton avers, that it should not depend upon props, which are easily broken or dislodged. In the case of main road junctions the crossing-girders should be carried by brick walls or piers and in other circumstances hard-wood chocks — filled with stone — should be used wherever practicable. Conveyor Face Falls. In Yorkshire falls of ground accounted for 57 per cent. of the fatalities during 1938. Mr. H. J. Humphrys refers to a large number of falls occurring when the last portion of a length of coal is being taken down, showing that greater care is needed at this stage of the operations. Gross breaches of rules are seldom found, but attention should be concentrated on getting supports set a little earlier than at present. A collier was killed whilst cutting coal to make room for a bar at a buttock, a catch prop being dislodged. The buttock made an oblique line with the working face. Had it been square with the face, the bar would have been set sooner and the stone which fell supported. It is suggested that this practice should be adopted wherever possible. A collier was killed by a fall 18 feet long when the last 12 feet of coal between two buttocks was pulled over. This last piece of coal is often the most dangerous, and an attempt should be made to visualise the position which will arise when it is extracted. In this instance, the distance between bars was 18 feet and the fall extended over this length, three catch props set in it being discharged. In the view of Mr. Humphrys other bars should have been set before the coal was pulled over, and an attempt should have been made to avoid pulling over such a long length of coal at one time. A deputy and collier were killed as the last nine yards of coal was almost extracted. The roof for the entire length of the face was supported by bars, with the exception of this nine-yard gap, and the fall terminated where the bars began. The remedy appears to be the earlier setting of bars, which was probably possible here, or getting the coal in such a manner that a gap of such length would not be formed. The Doncaster District Coroner is reported to have said at the inquest, "All I need say is that it does appear significant from the plan, and from the evidence, that this fall extended over a distance of 27 feet where no bars were set. There has been some argument as to whether bars could be set earlier, but, taking a commonsense point of view, it does seem that some scheme could be devised so that bars can be set earlier, and so prevent similar accidents. No doubt the men working there did their best, but we have to look ahead and try to prevent similar accidents." A coal-cutting machineman, dressing down the face in advance of the machine, was killed by a fall of roof in the 2-foot 6-inch space between the front row of props and the face. The Inspector describes the accident as typical of many. The basic cause is the induced break either at the immediate coal face or slightly in advance of it. The cutter track is subject to intense stresses, particularly during the approach and passing of the machine, and the system of support should provide for the support of this part of the face by bars wherever this is possible. Obvious Precautions. A repairer was preparing to extend a waste pack at the working face. He had taken out three props, and was cutting away the roof over a bar which he proposed to take out, when a fall of roof occurred. He was alive for an hour whilst his rescuers were attempting to extricate him, when a further and larger fall occurred which killed him. If the pack had been built in sections, Mr. Humphrys says, it would not have been necessary to take out so many props at a time, and in any case temporary props should have been set in accordance with Section 52 (11 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911. The roof was known to be tender and the depth was more than 900 yards, so the need for extra precaution was apparent. A collier, building a waste pack in a seam 5 feet 6 inches thick, was killed by a fall of roof coal 12 feet long and 11 feet wide, which reeled out several steel supports, and overran three chocks, one completely and two partially. The investigation of the accident disclosed two matters to which the strongest exception is taken. The pack being built was due for building on Friday night. Owing to absenteeism this was deferred until the following Monday night shift, when the accident occurred. Packing, as the Inspector remarks, is a matter of primary importance, especially in a seam of this thickness at a depth of 750 yards, and if packs are uncompleted on the night shift they should be finished on the ensuing day shift. Natural forces will not await man's convenience. The other matter was the use of full length steel props as lids, which he says is contrary to commonsense and all sound practice. A collier was killed immediately after be knocked out with a hammer two props under a ripping lip in order that a shot could be fired. It was the rule at the colliery that all such props should be withdrawn with a safety contrivance and their use was advised by slogans posted at conspicuous places. Nevertheless, the deputy and the shot-firer made no effort to enforce the rule on this particular occasion, notwithstanding that it is a duty imposed on the former by Section 52 (2) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911. A further point noted in the report is that although the safety contrivances were provided on the scale of 15 for 21 stalls of 35 yards each, the nearest was in the next stall when the accident occurred. It is advisable to have one for each stall, for when they are passed from stall to stall it is possible to have a gap of several stalls without one, even when the provision is on the scale mentioned. "Manner" of Setting Supports. Whilst little exception can be taken to the intervals fixed for roof supports under Section 50 (4) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, except that separate provision is not generally made for the support of roadheads, Mr. Humphrys indicates that insufficient regard is paid in the posted notices to the "manner" in which supports are to be set and advanced. Apart from the legal requirement he regards it is a vitally important matter, closer attention to which might have prevented some of the accidents which have occurred. In machine mining it can be assumed that a break hading backwards will be formed at the back of each cut. A natural break hading forward and intersecting the induced break will result in a fall unless the ground is adequately supported. The support of the newly exposed panel of roof, under which most of the men employed at the face are working, at the earliest possible moment is thus an urgent necessity and every effort should be directed to this end. Frequently an admirable system of support is devised, but, as pointed out in the report, its erection is deferred until one meets the anomaly that the conveyor track is better supported than the roof under which the men are actually working. The best system of support, Mr. Humphrys adds, is by bars extending to the coal face, which should be erected as soon as sufficient coal is extracted. This system of support should embrace the cutting track and the bars should not cross the major weight breaks, but be erected entirely under the newly exposed panel of roof. This support should be erected as soon as sufficient roof is exposed and the face men should work under its support and not, as often happens, under a long length of roof supported only by catch props. Play for Safety. Six persons were killed while getting coal or taking down stone. In this category was the death of a collier who was holing under a rock intrusion when a portion of it fell on him. He was relying on a single short sprag. Mr. Humphrys says it has been pointed out many times that no holer should rely on a single sprag, and the addition of a long sprag might have been the means of saving a valuable life. The same remarks apply in the case where the seam 5 feet 6 inches thick with an overlying clod 1 foot 1 inch thick was taken. A 12-foot length was being holed and the maximum depth attained was 18 inches when the fall occurred. Only a single sprag was set. The Pontefract District Coroner, in commenting on this fatality, is reported to have remarked, "I am afraid all we can hope to do in a case of this description is to say something or do something which may avoid a recurrence of the same set of circumstances, and it seems better to play for safety than to take any undue risks" — words which the Inspector cordially endorses. A collier was killed when cutting holed coal from which the sprags had been removed after an unsuccessful attempt had been made to lever it down with a bar. The sprags should have been replaced immediately. Another collier met his death in a somewhat similar way except that he commenced to deepen the holing without re-setting sprags after an attempt to take down a 12-foot length of coal holed to a depth of three feet had resulted in four feet being brought down. Such accidents, in the view expressed by Mr. Humphrys, may also be considered to reflect on the officials immediately in charge of the men concerned. One is tempted, he says, to ask if this was the first occasion on which the men concerned or others in the same district had adopted these malpractices. Their occurrence does at least indicate the need for increased vigilance on the part of the official in charge and the need for more safety propaganda. A ripper was killed and another injured by a fall which occurred whilst their rescuers were attempting to extricate them from one which had occurred a few minutes earlier. A gate, which had been driven almost parallel to the working face and supported across a portion of its width by five-foot channel bars set on 5-foot 6-inch legs, was being enlarged and supported by steel arches as it was to serve as the loading gate of a conveyor face being opened out at right angles to the opening out face. A 35-yard length required completing when the new face was required for coal production. After a few turnovers, four men were cleaning up spillage and lining up when 26 feet of this length collapsed and four bars were displaced. The supports were not strutted or laced, nor was the covering wood used, or the small stuff of which this fall was composed, the Inspector concludes, would most likely have been held.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||