30th December 1939, Page: 193, Column: 1
Specific-Gravity Coal Washing
By C. W. H. Holmes, M.Met.
Extracts from paper on "Notes on Specific-gravity Coal Washing
with special reference to the Tromp Process," presented on 9th December
at a general meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining and
Mechanical Engineers.
The conditions which must be fulfilled by any specific-gravity
process for coal washing before it can expect to be either
economically or technically successful are: (1) The loss of the
medium used to float the coal must be so small that its cost does
not exceed a fraction of a penny per ton of coal washed. (2) The
viscosity of the specific-gravity bath must be low enough to
permit of quick stratification of the particles and should remain
so over the useful range, that is, between 1.30 and 1.90 sp. gr.
(3) Vertical currents should not be employed, as they impair the
sharpness of the separation and limit the range of size that can
be treated in one bath. (4) Mechanical agitation should not be
employed, due to risk of floating up middlings or flat shale with
the washed coal. (5) The medium employed should be capable
of being readily removed from the separated products, and should
also be capable of being easily recovered from the swill water in
a concentrated form for re-use. (6) The density of separation
must be maintained within narrow limits without difficulty.
(7) The medium used must be such that it can easily be purged
of coal and shale shines.
The specific-gravity processes for coal washing can be divided
into two main groups — those employing a high-density liquid
and those in which a suspension of heavy finely-divided material
in water is employed. At the present time the use of true liquids
or solutions for the specific-gravity washing of coal is extremely
limited, and we must turn to the second group to find processes
which have found wider industrial application.
It has been recognised in metallurgy for many years that a mass
of finely-divided particles either settling in water or, alternatively,
suspended in water, behaves in many ways like a liquid having
a specific gravity greater than unity. For example, the differences
between "free" and "hindered" settling ratios are due to
this
phenomenon, which in this and in other instances is turned to
practical advantage. On the other hand, it is this same phenomenon
that limits the efficiency of classifiers and sometimes
interferes with the operation of ball-mills.
The suspensions that can be used for industrial coal washing
maybe considered in two main groups, (1) Stable and (2) Unstable.
Stability may be obtained in several ways, for example: (a) By
the selection of a solid medium which is naturally stable over a
useful range of specific gravity (e.g., Loess, Wuench) ; (b) By
means of rising currents (e.g., Chance) ; (c) By mechanical
agitation; (d) By the addition of some stabilising agent that will
procure the desired stability without at the same time raising
the viscosity to such an extent as to prohibit its use (e.g., clay in
the De Vooys Process).
So far as group (2) is concerned, it will be obvious from the
foregoing that no special means need be adopted to obtain an
unstable suspension ; if, however, suspensions are prepared
having a predetermined degree of instability and this lack of
stability is made to help instead of to hinder, then it may fairly
he said that one of the major problems associated with specific-gravity
coal washing has been overcome.
Stable Suspensions.
(a) Loess, which is a natural product of no commercial value
and which can, in localities where it is found, be had for the mere
cost of getting and freight. Loess is what one would call geologically
a "Silt," that is to say, it is finer than sand (which
would be too coarse to stay unaided in suspension) and coarser
than clay (which gives suspensions that are in general too viscous
to be useful). It is unlikely that all deposits of Loess have the
same physical characteristics as regards distribution of particle
size.
The only other natural medium that has been, to my knowledge,
employed in coal washing is clay in connection with the Wuench
process. The clay slip is agitated mechanically by means of
horizontal blades on a vertical shaft and the viscosity of the pulp
is kept within limits by taking a tapping off to a flotation cell and
removing the accumulated coal climes. This process has been
worked at a strip mine in Kansas, the clay underlying the coal
seam being used to make up the suspension.
(b) Rising currents are employed in the Chance and De Vooys
processes ; in the former case the suspension of sand in water is
definitely unstable and an upward current is employed to stabilise
it, whilst in the latter the suspension is stable and the upward
current is used for another purpose, namely, to prevent "crowding"
— that is to say, an accumulation of middlings very close to the
separating density in the suspension. The only practical consequence
of this current is that the effective density of the separation
is slightly above that of the suspension itself; thus, using a pulp
of 1.40 density the "effective" density of the separation would
be nearer 1.45. It might have a somewhat limiting effect if a
wide range of sizes were treated in the bath, but the results
obtained under industrial conditions indicate that normally this
slow upward current has no serious effect on the separation.
(c) Mechanical agitation as a means of stabilising a suspension
can only be effective, and at the same time have no limiting effect
upon the accuracy of the separation, if it has practically no work
to do in achieving its end. The aim of every gravity process
is to approach as closely as possible to the static conditions
obtaining in a float-and-sink test carried out in the laboratory,
and if the agitation is at all violent these ideal conditions are not
fulfilled, with the result that eddy currents will upset the distribution
of the near density particles into their correct products.
(d) The retarding effect which clay has upon the settlement
of fine suspended solids has long been known in metallurgy, its
influence upon the separations effected in classifiers and upon the
rate of settlement in thickeners being a common source of trouble.
Indeed, in coal washing itself it is found that clay is the main cause
of inefficient settlement in slurry cones. Additions of clay therefore
provide another means for stabilising suspensions of finely
divided solids in water, and it is by this means that the suspensions
of barytes employed in the De Vooys process are prevented from
settling out too rapidly to permit of their use in that process,
which, of course, demands a high degree of stability in the suspension,
as any appreciable settlement in the separating bath
would cause an accumulation of middlings at intermediate levels
in the bath.
Unstable Suspensions.
In regard to the use of unstable suspensions, the very fact that
a suspension is unstable postulates higher densities in the lower
than in the upper layers, which, in turn, means that particles of
intermediate density must accumulate in the suspension unless
they are continuously removed, and for the moment it must be
assumed that this is the case.
The Tromp process is the only one that purposely employs an
unstable suspension, and the solid media that have been used are
magnetite and burnt pyrites, although tests have shown that a
number of other cheap ferruginous materials are equally suitable.
There is no magic in the use of iron-bearing minerals ; other
materials may be used, provided that they are sufficiently dense
to give the desired density at the bottom of the bath without so
high a solid content as to impair the fluidity. Quartz could be
used, provided that the density of the suspension at the bottom
of the bath did not exceed about 1 1.40. Materials with densities
of 3.0 and 4.0 could be used in cases where the maximum densities
required in the suspension did not greatly exceed 1.55 and 1.65,
respectively.
The rate at which the magnetite settles depends on the average
size of particle, and this forms the initial means of controlling the
range of specific gravity from the top of the bath to the bottom.
Some means must be provided for removing middlings from the
intermediate levels in the bath so as to prevent any accumulation.
The Tromp Bath.
The accompanying illustration shows a diagrammatic arrangement
of the Tromp bath. The raw coal is fed to the bath at a
and falls beneath the surface of the suspension, the clean coal
floats up to the surface and is continuously removed by the push-plate
scraper b over an inclined slot screen c ; the refuse sinking
right through the suspension is extracted by means of the draining
elevator d. Particles of intermediate density are continuously
moved across the bath by means of slow horizontal currents of
suspension I., II. and III., and are finally extracted by means of
scraper e, together with a certain amount of the suspension.
The circulation of the streams of the heavy medium is effected
by means of compressed air lifts, and arrangements are made so
that circulations I. and II., or II. and III., can be mixed in any
proportions in order to obtain the requisite densities at the clean
coal-middlings and middlings-refuse separating levels.
A certain amount of magnetite, together with such small
quantity of coal and clay shines as are formed, adhere to the
separated products, and it is therefore necessary to spray them,
first, as regards the clean coal to improve its appearance, secondly,
to recover the magnetite, and, thirdly, to prevent any accumulation
of slimes in the system which would, of course, ultimately
increase the viscosity. All the separated products are sprayed
with process water, that is to say, water that has been clarified
in the plant itself, and the clean coal is given a final spray with
clean make-up water.
The catch tray under the middlings screen is divided so that the
suspension flowing over with the middlings is returned directly
to the Tromp bath, the balance of the suspension being sprayed
off at the end of this screen.
The underflow from the end of the middlings screen and from the
clean coal and shale screens, consisting of a very dilute suspension
of magnetite, is fed to a slurry sieve where any gritty material
coarser than the particles of magnetite is removed. The dilute
underflow from the slurry sieve is pumped up to the clarifying
tank, where the initial rate of settlement of the magnetite is high
and, in consequence, clarified water can be obtained without
difficulty. As the magnetite falls to the bottom of this cone its
rate of settlement naturally decreases, but there is no difficulty
in thickening it up to densities in excess of those required in the
process.
Automatic-control Gear.
In the plant as originally installed, there was no difficulty in
maintaining a constant density in the suspension at the two
separating levels, but it was necessary for the plant operator to
check from time to time the density of the three circulations in
order to make sure that no variation had occurred. In order to
overcome this possible objection, automatic-control gear has been
devised and has been in successful operation for some months
with a view to maintaining a constant density in the thickened
pulp returned from the clarifying cone. This arrangement is
shown diagrammatically. It consists essentially of a balance by
means of which the flow of pulp from the cone back to the process
is continually weighed. The moving parts of this balance are
shown in heavy lines, whilst the various pipes and vessels which
are involved are shown in light lines.
The operation of the mechanism is as follows : The thickened
pulp from the clarifying cone enters by pipe 1, at such a rate that
it is continuously overflowing through pipe 14. It enters the
weighing vessel, 4, from which it flows continuously from the
bottom outlet, 5, as well as from the top, 6. The restricted outlet,
5, is necessary in order to prevent the fine magnetite settling out
in the vessel, and this portion is returned to the clarifying cone.
The overflow from the weighing vessel passes between the partitions
41 and 42 when the suspension is of the correct density and
is returned to the process. If, however, the suspension is too
light, the balance-weight, 12, will lift the vessel, 4, which will
discharge its top liquid over the partition, 41, whence it will be
taken back to the bottom of the-clarifying cone for further concentration.
If, on the other hand, the suspension has too high a density,
the weighing vessel, 4, will sink and pipe 33 will force some of the
clarified water flowing continuously through pipe 31 into the
vessel, 13, in sufficient quantity to counteract the rise in density.
Under these conditions the high-density suspension cannot go
back to the process because the chute, 7, will then be below
partition 42 and the pulp will go back to the clarifying cone.
The medium having correct density passes down pipe 43 into
the surge tank before being returned to the process. This tank
is float-controlled so that, when the necessary store of medium
of the correct density has been accumulated, the valve feeding the
automatic density-control device is shut off and does not reopen
until the level of suspension in the surge tank has fallen to a
certain extent.
At the end of the washing shift the raw feed is shut off and the
plant is kept in operation for a few minutes in order to give the
slowly-moving middlings time to cross the bath and to be extracted
by the middlings scraper. After this has been done the whole of
the medium is drawn from the separating bath into a storage
tank immediately below it.
At the beginning of the shift the suspension is pumped back
into the system by means of a specially-designed pump, and this
is, in fact, the only time that a concentrated suspension of magnetite
is handled by a pump, all the handling during the operation of
the plant being effected by means of compressed air lifts so as to
avoid wear and tear. The only pumps in continuous operation
are those handling the swill and spray water.
Some Benefits Claimed.
Regarding benefits derived from the greatly increased accuracy
of separation that can be obtained with this modern washing
process, when compared with jigs, for example: In the first place
a higher yield of washed coal for an equivalent ash-content is
obtained, because specific-gravity washing enables the heavy
high ash sinks that were formerly found in the clean coal to be
exchanged for a larger. quantity of lower ash material which
formerly went away with the refuse, and the higher the percentage
of middlings in the raw coal the greater will be the increased
yield of clean coal for a similar ash-content.
Secondly, the ash-content of the washed products will be more
uniform in fact, and will appear to be even more so because there
will be an entire absence of pieces of high ash material, which
with normal washing and small samples are the most fertile
source of complaint.
Thirdly, there will be an increased yield of screened sizes due
to decreased breakage during washing, and this has been the
subject of careful and continual checks at Domaniale where,
as the result of changing over from the old system to the new one,
the increase in the recovery of 80-15 mm. nuts has amounted to
11 per cent.
Finally, the absence of degradation is reflected in the appearance
of the washed coal, which is not only free from unsightly pieces
of middling and flat shale but the nuts retain their corners and
look much more attractive than the normal Baum-washed coal.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Holmes, C. W. H. | | | |