16th December 1939, Page: 179, Column: 1
Health Of Coal Miners
Silicosis Investigations
Commenting on the question of work at high temperatures in
the Nineteenth Annual Report of the Industrial Health Research
Board (H.M. Stationery Office, 6d.), it is suggested that a scale of
equivalent warmth is needed not only for normally clothed
persons but also for the lightly clad. Miners working in deep and
hot mines are commonly stripped to the waist, and the recent
Report of the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines refers
to the need for a scale of warmth which will apply to such conditions
and to the necessity for more research on conditions of work
at high temperatures.
[In the section dealing with deep and hot mines, it may be
recalled, the Commissioners recommended that the Mines Department
should make general regulations which would require the
management to have systematic readings taken and recorded by
a competent person with a kata-thermometer at appropriate
points on working faces where the wet-bulb temperature in the
return air exceeds, say 78° Fahr., and the air velocity (as indicated
by the statutory air-measurements) is less than 150 feet per
minute. The regulations would provide, among other things, for
readings to be taken if necessary at points where men are at work
out of the sweep of the air-current and for their appropriate
interpretation, and for readings falling short of the requirements
laid down to be reported to the district inspector, who would also
have power to take check readings at other times in such mines
if he thought fit, or to take readings in other mines if he had
reason to believe that the cooling power of the ventilation was
inadequate. In any case where the ventilation is found to fall
short of the required standard, the management should be given
a reasonable time, according to the circumstances, in which to
effect the necessary improvements . . . Further research into the
subject should be actively pursued and the results should be kept
under review by the Mines Department with the object of
substituting some better standard if one can be found.]
Referring to dust and pulmonary disease the report of the
Industrial Health Research Board says that the large scale
investigation into chronic pulmonary disease in coal miners has
been actively continued. This inquiry is directed by the Industrial
Pulmonary Diseases Committee of the Medical Research Council.
Dr. T. Bedford and Dr. C. G. Warner, both of the Board's staff,
are assisting in observations on environmental conditions, i.e.,
estimations of size and number of dust particles, and collection of
data on the temperature, velocity and humidity of the air. In so
far as these are not necessarily similar in different pits, the
variations may be found to bear some relation to the occurrence
and development of pulmonary disease.
The problem at issue is that though coal miners have long
been known to suffer from the form of chronic pulmonary trouble
generally grouped under the term "pneumonoconioses," it has
only within recent years become apparent that they may become
disabled by chronic pulmonary disease which does not fall within
the accepted definition of "silicosis." It is for them an economic
misfortune that whilst scheduled silicosis is compensatable, there
are forms of chronic pulmonary disease closely resembling silicosis
which are not. It is for science a misfortune that there should be
a disability so closely resembling silicosis which it cannot authoritatively
differentiate. The distinction, which may or may not
turn out to be valid, at present depends on radiological diagnosis —
and thus an attempt is being made to relate so far undifferentiated
forms of pulmonary disease to the known facts about silicosis.
Every factor, therefore, clinical or environmental, is being
examined.
On the administrative side, an investigation of this scope
demands-and has received — the co-operation of officials in other
Government Departments — in particular the Home Office and the
Mines Department, and of organisations of employers and workers:
on the scientific side, it has entailed the co-operation of the
physicist, chemist, geologist, mining engineer, physiologist, radiologist,
clinician, and statistician. Thus, the work already done
has included tests for respiratory efficiency, for the concentration
of nitrous fumes, for the solubility and analysis of dangerous dusts,
as well as relevant experimental studies.
The physical state of coal miners — with special reference to
their pulmonary condition — is being examined in pits which have
experienced a high incidence of silicosis and other forms of
pulmonary disease as compared with pits with a low incidence of
those diseases, and according as the miners work hard or soft coal
in damp or dry pits. The nature of the rock strata in each pit
is being examined chemically and petrologically.
It goes without saying that the problem is a difficult one, for
the occurrence of pulmonary disease in coal miners is not easily
related to environmental and working conditions which vary so
widely from place to place. Large numbers of miners have
already been submitted to clinical and radiological examinations,
and the results have been analysed with reference to their working
histories and environmental conditions.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bedford, T., Dr. | | | |
| Warner, C. G., Dr. | | | |