Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

18th November 1939, Page: 146, Column: 2

Falls Of Ground — III

These notes are based on the Mines Inspectors' Reports for 1937. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies are obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office

Roof Control.

Noting the fact that in the Cardiff and Forest of Dean Division there were 77 fatalities and 264 serious reportable non-fatal accidents from falls of roof and sides impelled Mr. J. Macleod Carey to refer again at some length to this vitally important question. He said: The subject of roof control, and the determination of the type of both temporary and permanent supports and the manner of their application is, without doubt, the most important single factor to be considered in the successful planning and working of a coal seam. With good roof control, successful working, free from dislocations and hindrances of continued falls, can be practically assured; and for economic reasons alone, its attainment justifies considerable expenditure of time and money. From a safety consideration successful roof control is of primary importance, and given the assiduous attention which it demands will result in a reduced accident rate, not only from falls of ground, but from the many other causes contingent on bad roof conditions. This is especially true at and near the working faces, where the man-density is greatest, and where the fundamental principles of roof control must be put into practice at the earliest possible moment after the extraction of the coal.

The control of roof depends upon a number of factors, the principal being: (1) The nature of the roof itself. (2) The thickness of the seam and the depth at which it lies. (3) The existence of contemporary or old workings in seams above or below, and the line of advance relative to these workings. (4) The direction of the natural cleavage relative to the line of face. (5) The rate of advance, together with the rigid observance of the correct cycle of operations. (6) The quality and quantity of packing. (7) The type of temporary supports and the manner of their application in the area between the wastes and the face. (8) The time factor, i.e., the time which elapses between the exposure and support of the roof. This applies to both the temporary and permanent support.

In the coalfield of the Cardiff Division the roofs above the seams vary in nature from soft shale to hard rock, and as far as temporary support is concerned no hard and fast rules can be laid down. Each set of conditions should be carefully studied, and experience is the best guide as to the type of support to be employed and the manner in which it should be applied. But so far as permanent support is concerned the Inspector says there can be no two opinions. The whole object of roof support is to control, so far as possible, convergence between the roof and floor, and this can only be achieved by interposing between them a medium which offers the highest possible resistance to the subsiding roof mass and to the tendency to upward movements of the floor. In this connection it must be the stowing (in conjunction with the floor itself and the roof beds immediately above), which forms the ultimate support for the general mass of the strata ; and in addition, it must essentially be the principal control during the earlier period of subsidence. Convergence there must be, but the lower its rate and the smaller its amount, the better will be the conditions of the face, and as the amount and rate of convergence are so largely controlled by the packing, it is evident that the importance of stowing of the highest possible quality cannot be over-estimated.

It is essential, in order to secure the maximum benefits, that the stowing should be done as soon as possible after the extraction of the coal, and delay in this respect is fatal to satisfactory roof control. It is obvious that the earlier the packing is introduced the greater will be its thickness, and the sooner does it begin to offer effective resistance to subsidence. This is specially true in the thicker seams, and large scale movements can occur in both roof and floor unless the packing is introduced at the earliest possible moment and kept as close to the live face as is compatible with safe working.

Further, Mr. Carey is still of the opinion that, in the South Wales coalfield at least, the stowing should be complete, i.e., continuous as well as tight, with good, solid crosswalls at frequent intervals and finished off tightly under the roof. He is well aware of the attempts made at several collieries to improve the quality of the stowing by building it into solid packs, improving the quality of the retaining walls and increasing the number of crosswalls, and if only this form of stowing were continuous he should welcome it as a decided step forward. He is not unmindful of the difficulties which arise in connection with the provision of an adequate supply of packing material, its storage during the coal-getting shift and its ultimate transport to, and handling in, the faces, but these difficulties must be faced, and the results will, the Inspector is convinced, fully justify the time, trouble and expense involved. At most mines, the building of rubbish into packs has merely meant the development of "strip packing" and the leaving of intermediate empty spaces, a practice which — the question of gas emission and ventilation apart — he does not regard with favour.

Accidents at Roadheads.

It is generally accepted that most accidents from falls of roof occur at roadheads, and efforts have been directed towards securing more adequate safeguards at these places, but Mr. Carey sees no essential difference between a recognised roadhead and the front of a five-yard waste which is strongly supported on either side by packwalls, except that at the roadhead extra supports are set to protect the men working in the vicinity, whilst at the front of the wastes all supports are withdrawn. This withdrawal of supports without the subsequent stowing of the wastes, he says, can only result in increased stresses in the roof beds and the inducing of fresh breaks more or less at right angles to those already induced by the removal of the coal. Examination of the ripping lips at roadheads almost invariably shows induced breaks at the sides running parallel with the road, and many accidents are due to triangular shaped stones falling out from these induced fractures.

The tendency to the formation of a triangular section of roof by induced breaks parallel with, and just in advance of, the face is well known, and is a fruitful cause of accidents "between the last row of props and the face" ; and if this is considered in conjunction with further breaks, similar in nature, at right angles to the face at roadheads and in front of the packs, the Inspector says little further explanation is required of several accidents which have been caused by stones, shaped like the frustum of a pyramid, falling without warning from between supports on well timbered faces. These disjointed pieces of roof are undoubtedly formed by two distinct sets of induced breaks, and are ready to fall, and in fact many do fall, the moment the support of the coal is removed from them. Generally, these breaks are not immediately discernible, and the stones are often held in place more or less by surface cohesion, but loss of cohesion through rapid or irregular subsidence causes them to drop out without the slightest warning, oftentimes with tragic results.

A considerable reduction in convergence, and consequently in the number and magnitude of induced breaks, can be achieved by the introduction of temporary hardwood or steel cogs, between the packs and the face, especially on machine-cut faces and in front of wastes. These cogs should be provided with patent quick-release members so that they can be withdrawn and advanced as required. Their value is fully recognised at a few mines, and satisfactory results have attended their use.

Mr. Carey further says it must be recognised that, however efficient the stowing may be, it is not of itself sufficient to control properly the subsidence of the roof, and reliance in the first instance must be placed on the temporary supports in the area between the packs and the face. These supports should be set at the earliest possible moment after the coal has been removed or undercut, and should be of such a nature that they afford sufficient resistance to the subsiding roof until the packs can be advanced. The actual mode of support can best be determined by local conditions and previous experience, but an important factor to be borne in mind is the necessity for covering as great an area of the roof as possible in order to afford support for loose or disjointed ground.

Supporting Undercut Coal.

The Inspector is afraid that on machine-cut faces the importance of supporting the coal and roof immediately after the passage of the cutter is not sufficiently recognised, and neglect in this respect means that valuable time is lost and irreparable damage done. The path left for the passage of the cutter between the supports and the face is usually 3 feet in width, and the depth of the undercut generally 4 feet 6 inches. This means that a span of 7 feet 6 inches is unsupported during a period of violent disturbance, and it is small wonder that in many cases roof fractures develop at the back of the cut. All undercut coal should be immediately supported by square chocks driven into the cut, and in every case temporary roof supports should be set immediately behind the cutter. If this practice were regularly followed Mr. Carey is confident that a substantial reduction in accidents would accrue.

Falls of side at the working face account for a high proportion of both fatal and non-fatal accidents, and he is satisfied that many of these could be avoided by a more rigid observance of the Regulations regarding the setting of sprags. This applies with special force to the support of undercut coal as mentioned. When sprags are set against overhanging coal or clod they should be well stamped into the floor and capped with good lids. It is bad practice to set sprags so that they are dependent upon the stability of another support, such as "butting" them against the foot of a roof prop. In such circumstances the Inspector says the discharging of the sprag is quite likely to dislodge the prop and bring about a fall of roof as well.

Typical Accidents.

Of the reportable "falls" accidents in the Swansea Division in 1937, 79 per cent. occurred at the face, 11 per cent. on roads while repairing or enlarging, and 10 per cent. on roads while otherwise working or passing. Under prevailing conditions 54 per cent. of the accidents were deemed unavoidable.

Mr. P. S. Lea gives brief descriptions in his report of typical accidents, four of which are appended.

A collier and his assistant were packing the debris from a ripping shot, the collier being on the right, and his assistant on the left side of the stall. A fall 7 feet long, 4 feet wide and 1 foot 6 inches thick occurred suddenly and killed the collier. The fall came from a slip on the face side, an induced break on the goaf side, and a loose end at the road side, and reeled out two props. The slip and break could not be seen, it was said, prior to the fall. The ripping had been blown right up to the coal head and more support should have been given to the loose ends.

A collier's assistant was in a kneeling position drilling a shot-hole when he was struck by a fall of clod two feet square and four inches thick. The clod here is found immediately over the coal and is usually kept in line with the coal, but in this case the collier had left the piece of clod up and did not support it.

A repairer and his assistant were sent to remove a low bar at the inbye end of a double parting 12 feet wide. The fireman told them to set three temporary props and they did so. One of them then proceeded to cut out one leg of the bar with a hatchet and whilst he was so engaged a fall occurred, killing him. A sylvester prop-drawing appliance was at hand and the fireman had instructed them to use it.

A fatal accident occurred to a shackler who was walking along a road behind a journey of empty trams. A fall of roof occurred and buried him. The fall was 10 feet 6 inches long, 10 feet wide and 5 feet 10 inches thick, and consisted of small crushed material. It reeled out three bars but did not break them. If the bars had been strutted together it is probable they would not have been reeled out.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Carey, Joseph Macleod    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Lea, Paul Salthouse    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
21 Oct 1939  Falls Of Ground — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
04 Nov 1939  Falls Of Ground — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
18 Nov 1939  Falls Of Ground — III (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print