|
4th November 1939, Page: 138, Column: 1 Falls Of Ground — IIThese notes are based on the Mines Inspectors' Reports for 1937. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies are obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office. Coal-cutting and Coal Falls. In his 1937 North Western Division report Mr. E. H. Frazer directed attention to the fact that falls of coal and side, although accounting for fewer deaths, caused as many serious non-fatal injuries at faces as falls of roof. At one time roof falls were by far the more to be feared than coal falls, but it appears that either so much attention has been devoted to methods of supporting roofs and so little to keeping up the coal face, or else modern methods have increased the danger from falls of coal, that there is now little to differentiate the numbers of accidents due to each cause. In his opinion the alteration has been due to the introduction of coal-cutting machines into the thicker seams, in conjunction with the installation of conveyors, producing long straight lengths of undercut coal up to six and seven feet in height, whereas, in the past, coal-cutters were largely confined to thinner seams. He says it seems desirable that increased attention should be paid to the question of affording adequate support to cut coal whilst, of course, not relaxing any precautions concerning support of roofs. Indeed, the two matters are somewhat related, because to hold up undercut coal also tends to keep up the roof. Spragging immediately behind moving coal-cutting machines is one point to watch, but in thick seams it is necessary to support the upper portion before a machine passes. The usual method is by horizontal struts from the front line of props, but they are apt to be displaced unless something is provided to prevent them slipping down. There are now on the market devices which can be fixed easily, at any desired height, on either steel or wooden props, to act as shoes for sprags above the coal-cutting machine; but where wooden props are employed it seems a simple matter to Mr. Frazer to nail a cleat on to the prop below the strut after it has been driven tight. Ragging coal from the front, after removal of sprags, is a prolific source of accident. Where it is practicable, the practice of breaking in to the back of a cut and working from the end of the coal should be adopted. Only one sprag should be removed at a time. Not only does this method give greater safety from falls of coal, but it enables colliers to be working most of their time under the last exposed and, therefore, least broken roof. Turning to supports of roof, he assumes it will be conceded that in many cases of serious accident props have been reeled out. Not so many instances occur of accident due to failure to set supports, or to breaking of props. To increase the stability of supports it has been suggested that props in a row should be laced together to afford mutual lateral rigidity. Another method, evolved by Mr. Walter Sylvester, of Tunstall, utilises rigid, yet easily withdrawable, steel props under wooden bars to support continuous chains of corrugated steel straps. This system, to which Mr. Frazer directs attention, supports the roof in directions parallel with, and at right angles to, the face, and has the advantage that further straps can be slipped over the wooden bars to give protection in advance of the last setting, because there is a narrow space above the bars which just gives room for steel straps to be pushed through and to project over the cutting track. The arrangement has much to commend it, and marks the first considerable advance in roof support at coal faces since steel props were introduced; it has disadvantages at present, in that it is costly and, in the initial stages, apt to take a considerable time in erection, though this latter difficulty is overcome with a little practice. The Inspector hopes that managers will give the system a trial, because the tying together of settings gives a more stable erection than either props and bars, or props and lids. Defective Practices. Careful note was taken of the occupations at the time of accident of persons killed or injured by falls of ground. It emerged that 13 per cent. occurred whilst disturbing supports (setting and withdrawing); 36 per cent. whilst disturbing strata (getting, coal-cutting and ripping); and 51 per cent. whilst otherwise working or passing. Many of the falls of coal occurred because men stood in front of coal to pull it down instead of working front the rise side with a pinch bar. Mr. Frazer details an accident exposing a number of practices not in accordance with good mining which occurred to a shot-firer at a Lancashire colliery. The man's duty was to fire shots in canches of a conveyor face before the night shift rippers arrived, and he had reached a place where a slant was approaching a dummy road and there was only a distance of eight or nine feet between them. Shots were to be fired in each. The face was rising at 1 in 8 and the two roads were almost level. A wrong sequence of operations was practised, i.e., the face was cut before packs were advanced. The rise side pack of the dummy gate was 16 feet from the face, and after the face had been cut there would have been 19 feet from the back of the undercut to the pack wall. The low side pack of the slant was 12 feet from the face, and no packs were built on the rise side of the slant and the low side of the dummy gate. Wooden stacks were built at intervals along the rise side of the slant and, between them, thin walls of stone were erected to keep the road tidy. Unfortunately, the Inspector says, a stack that should have been erected about 20 feet from the face had not been built. Props had been withdrawn during some previous shift from the places where the shots had to be fired, leaving three rows set, and creating a breaking-off line similar to one in front of a waste. Indeed, the place where the shot-firer had to work was very similar to a waste — it was 24 feet wide between packs and all supports had been removed. No breaking-off props had been set at the sides of either road to confine shots to the work they were intended to perform. Just prior to the shots being fired the coal-cutting machine was approaching, casting its effects before it in a normal way. The machinemen heard the shots exploded separately and resumed cutting. Immediately they heard a cry and found the shot-firer buried by a roof fall between the slant and the dummy roads. The effect of the approaching machine and the shots had brought down the bridge of roof between the two roads. It is presumed that the shot-firer had been making an examination, or was going to make one, to see the results of the last shot, when he was killed. Continuing his discussion of this accident Mr. Frazer adds "It was contended that the man had no right to be in that place because it was virtually goaf. That may have been so, in the circumstances, but he had no option. He could not travel on the face side of the pans because the coal-cutting machine blocked the way. He could not travel on the pans because at that place the upper of two conveyers in tandem delivered on to the lower one and there was insufficient height. Nor could he pass between the second and third rows of props because a stack was erected there. Both roads had been rendered unsafe by the shots recently fired, so the only place left was the space between the two roads. Be it noted that, although the shot-firer was not supposed to travel, other men would have to venture there to build the stack that ought to have been erected two or three days before. Such a combination of defective practices it has rarely been my misfortune to encounter, though it would be difficult to say that any one of them was illegal." M. and S. Figures Disappointing. Deaths from falls (34) in the Midland and Southern Division accounted for nearly 54 per cent. of the total from all causes underground, and as regards persons seriously injured (107) the percentage was 48. Mr. E. Rowley regards the figures as very disappointing. There were 38 falls of side and 24 falls of roof on machine faces, and 23 falls of side with 82 falls of roof on hand-gotten faces. Probably the smaller number of accidents from falls of roof on machine faces is largely due to better roof conditions, the result of the straightness of the face and the more systematic and rapid advance, as compared with hand-gotten faces. The number of falls of side on machine faces is greater because more coal is underholed at one time than on hand-gotten faces, and it is usually less well supported from failing away. Some Recommendations. At the working face eight persons, and on roadways three persons, were fatally injured as the result of falls of side; the total of eleven being one more than in 1936. Fifty-eight persons were injured in non-fatal accidents; this is the same number as were injured in the previous year. The majority of these accidents occurred at the coal face in seams of a thickness of over four feet, and were due to inefficient spragging and to the lack of care in avoiding coal which was either being, or about to be, taken down. Mr. Rowley says it is very disturbing to find that of the 69 persons killed and injured from falls of side, no less than 45 were pikemen and stallmen. In view of the fact that both from age and experience these two classes of workmen are the most competent of coal face workers, he says this heavy incidence of accident, particularly on conveyor faces, is far too high and is a matter calling for the most careful attention of colliery managers. In this connection he strongly advocates :— (1) The systematic support of the face itself (in addition to cutter chocks, where such chocks are used) in seams of upwards of four feet in thickness, or where the coal is worked to the rise at more than 1 in 12. (2) The reduction of the maximum interval between holing sprags to five feet. (3) The limitation of the face to such length that, allowing for reasonable stoppages, the work can be completed without undue hurry or risks. (4) Efficient supervision. (5) Strict discipline. The Inspector is confident that, if these recommendations were generally adopted, the number of accidents from falls of side would without doubt be reduced. More Deaths Due to Roof. Falls of roof caused 21 fatal accidents resulting in 23 deaths, increases of 8 and 10 respectively. Mr. Rowley had hoped the improvement of the year 1936 would be permanent. He gives examples of typical accidents some of which are reproduced below :— A loader was shovelling dirt from under the ripping lip at the face of a narrow heading, when a block of the ripping stone 7 feet 6 inches long by 6 feet 6 inches wide and 3 feet thick, fell and killed him. The ripping was supported by props and lids, two of which were reeled out by the fall. After the accident it was found that a glassy slip extended over the upper surface of the stone which fell. The slip had not been seen previously, although an examination had been made by the overman and two stallmen only a few minutes earlier. It is a fair assumption that had the roof been supported by steel straps instead of trees and lids, the accident would not have happened. On a machine-cut conveyor face in a seam nearly six feet thick, the bottom two feet had been removed, leaving the upper four feet supported on sprags. To bring this down two sprags were removed and a shot fired. As this failed to do its work properly, two more sprags were taken out. The coal then dropped exposing an area of roof eight yards long by about eight yards wide. In this space a dolly prop and a skeleton chock were set on the fallen coal, but a short time later a block of stone 11 feet long by 6 feet 6 inches wide and 2 feet thick fell from the roof between a natural slip and an induced break running roughly parallel with the face. The dolly prop was displaced, and a "getter" who was just moving to take shelter from another shot, was fatally injured. The removal of so many sprags was a mistake. While loose coal was being loaded from along the rib sides at a four-way junction, the roof collapsed and killed two men, a third having a narrow escape. The junction was supported, at intervals of three feet, by wooden bars, above which was a wooden cog consisting of five rounds of timber. The collapse appears to have been caused by the displacement of one of the bars by a piece of" drawn" coal which one of the men pulled off a corner with his pick. The sudden release of the bar caused it to swing round and dislodge props under two other bars. The junction should have been supported by chocks. "Bump" in Staffordshire Mine. Two colliers were killed by a "bump" in a heading in a Staffordshire mine. The accident occurred in an area which was first worked many years ago and abandoned. Considerable difficulty is said to have been experienced from bumps, particularly in the two main roads which were known as the "bumping" roads. A short time prior to this accident it was decided to return to the area, and a pair of roads 75 yards apart were set out to cross the old roads at right angles. When these roads had advanced to a point about ten yards beyond the second main road, conditions were considered to be favourable for establishing a connection between them, and so a split was commenced by drivages from both sides. These drivages were seven feet high and seven feet wide, with their floor in the Sawyer section about four feet from the base of the seam. They were supported by wooden bars at intervals of from 2 to 3 feet. Inbye of this point the main roads were supported by heavy section steel arches. It is customary to drive such splits parallel to the line of the cleat, but in this instance, owing to existing old roads, this was not possible and the split was at an angle of about 25 degrees. Although driving was carried on from both sides, only one side was worked at a time. No heavy bump took place until the day of the accident, at which time a further distance of eight yards remained to be driven to establish the connection. On this day, while two men were working in the No. 8 Heading on the afternoon shift, an exceedingly heavy bump occurred in the floor, which trapped them, lifted their tub up to the roof timbers and practically wrecked the drivage throughout its entire length, as well as the crossing and a portion of the main road. In spite of strenuous efforts it was not until two days later that the bodies of the unfortunate men were reached. As the result of a careful examination of the uplifted floor three small pits were sunk, and proved the existence of a bed of soft fireclay between the base of the Thick Coal and the Heathen Coal, and a thinning of the strata from about four yards to two feet. The Heathen Coal too was very much thinner than usual and inferior in character. Situated immediately below this latter seam was a smooth bed of strong blue binds, which had not been affected by the bump. It would therefore appear that the cause of the bump was the piling up of pressure between the two seams, until it suddenly overcame the resistance the resistance of the strata. In the light of this evidence the management decided not to leave down any of the Thick Coal in such drivages in future, and to support all the roads in this district with steel arches.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||