Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

21st October 1939, Page: 113, Column: 1

Falls Of Ground — I

Most Important and Pressing Problem.

These notes are based on the Mines Inspectors' Reports for 1937. The price of each Report is 1s. net. Copies are obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office.

Falls of ground at the mines in Great Britain in 1937 resulted in 436 deaths as compared with 380 in 1936, an increase equal to 15 per cent. In nun-fatal accidents reported to the Inspectors the number of persons injured was 1,516 as against 1,349, the increase here being equivalent to a percentage of 12½. The persons who were disabled for more than three days numbered 48,269, or 734 more than in 1936, representing only a small percentage increase.

In view of the importance of the problem of falls in relation to the loss of life and the pain and suffering involved as a result of the accidents, not forgetting the monetary loss to the injured and the managements, it may be permissible and serve some useful purpose to dip into the Inspector's reports and make extracts from them of more than customary length.

Timbering Distances Important.

It would not be time ill-spent if all workpersons could devote a few hours to the study of the Mines Inspectors' annual reports, in which brief particulars are presented of accidents calling for special attention. The lessons they teach are often indicated in plain terms, and occasional illustrations help to clear up any misunderstanding. Here of course summaries only can be given. Mr. T. Ashley, in his report for Scotland says the necessity of strictly complying with the timbering distances laid down by the management cannot be too strongly emphasised. On longwall faces where strippers work off the coal in stents, the face timbering is apt to be neglected towards the end of the shift when the coal between adjoining stents is gradually worked away. If either, and more especially if both, strippers neglect to set their supports a large area of roof may become exposed.

Then as regards accidents to prop drawers and brushers the Inspector says the number of falls that come away between the last permanent support on the road and the face of the brushing, shows that much more attention should be paid to the temporary support of the roof while brushing is being done. Greater use might be made of what is known as a safety girder or "horse-head." This form of protection is specially applicable in the high brushings of conveyor loading roads and also in the back brushings of main roads. Lighter types can be used in smaller roads. In some circumstances forepoling over the last set bar or girder affords useful protection, but care should be taken to support the fore end of the strap as soon as possible by a prop.

Service Props.

Temporary or service props should be set in every case where new roof is being exposed. The manager of a large mine in Lanarkshire, finding from experience that temporary supports were essential to increase safety, issued a warning to all his officials and firemen. The courtesy of the manager enabled Mr. Ashley to include part of the warning in his report as follows :

"The tendency to neglect early erection of props is apparent. Especially is this the case in the Coking Coal, where the coal is inclined to heel over from the back of the undercut. Under such circumstances, the loose coal should be immediately cleared away, and the props erected. If the permanent props cannot be set, temporary props should be set along the front of the coal.

"Where the stripper has broken into the back of the cut and is stripping along the face, a temporary prop should always be used. This should be erected at the nose of coal in advance of the stripper, and can be withdrawn immediately the permanent props are set. In order to avoid a large area of exposed roof, near the end of the shift, every miner should strip in the same direction.

"Coal requiring blasting should be spragged until the holes are bored and preparations for firing completed.

"In all cases where it necessitates pillar drawing, or removal of timber for pan-shifting, temporary supports should be set.

"Only by strict attention to the above factors can the number of accidents caused by falls be reduced, and I look to you to supervise and instruct the workmen in the important operation of timbering, so that no man will at any time be working under insufficiently supported roof."

More than 20 per cent. of the fatal accidents from falls of roof at the working face occurred in mines worked stoop and room, of which five took place at coal mines, three of them during stooping operations when new lifts had just been commenced. In stooping, the roof is nearly always broken, and this is specially the case when setting away lifts off roads which, in most instances, were driven many years previously. Under these circumstances, Mr. Ashley says, props are not sufficient support for the newly set carrying-bar at the entrance to the lift. The bar is apt to become displaced when any extra weight comes on and should be supported by hardwood chocks, or, as they are sometimes called, wood pillars. Even under roofs where carrying-bars are not usually set, pillars at the corners of the new lift would tend to steady any roof movement and prevent falls.

Falls of Side.

The large number of accidents from falls of side at the working face demands close attention of managers and officials regarding the direction of face advance and the method of spragging the coal and the support of the side generally. Most of the accidents were caused by falls of coal and to a lesser extent by falls of "falling" bands of blaes or stone overlying the coal. Subsections 2 and 4 of Section 50 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, require holing props or sprags to be set as soon as practicable, and that they shall be set at regular intervals which shall in no case exceed six feet. These requirements are not always duly carried out.

The safety of the stripper or foreman, when getting the coal, depends to a great extent on the method employed and the position occupied. Mr. Ashley says a wrong method of getting the coal was employed by a stripper on a conveyor face in a seam 3 ft. 9 in. thick, including a 10-inch thick dirtband interbedded in the seam 10 inches from the roof, where a short nose of coal remained to be worked off. The stripper evidently suspected that the band between two stalls was liable to fall and, instead of taking it down, got another stripper to hold his hand on the dirt band while he removed the coal from underneath with a pneumatic pick. The dirt band fell and injured him.

A number of accidents arose from standing on the low side instead of the high side, or in front of instead of at the side, of the coal to be taken down. The stance taken is of great importance in the many highly inclined seams in Scotland.

At a mine in Stirling, the use of an old breaker-prop, left in by the side of the roadside building, as an anchor prop when drawing a coal-cutting machine into the road caused a fall of side, which injured the machineman. The Inspector says this accident draws attention to the necessity of setting proper anchor-props, as well as to the danger of not withdrawing roadside props after the buildings are erected. These props only tend to cause breaks in the sides of the roads resulting in falls as settlement takes place.

In his "General Remarks" on support of roof and sides Mr. Ashley says that one of the advantages of steel supports on roads, especially steel arches, is that the risk of fire is reduced, and the risk could to a very large extent be entirely eliminated if sheet iron, instead of wood lagging, was used over the arches.

Steel arches often suffer from distortion at refuge holes, but this can be reduced, if not wholly obviated, either by setting two arches strapped together on each side of the refuge hole, or by inserting a small arch to form the entrance to the refuge hole.

Notes in Brief.

An analysis of the accidents showing where they occurred is given in the Northern report by Mr. W. J. Charlton, who emphasises the fact that a coal-cutter machineman follows a dangerous occupation, for he has often to withdraw props to allow the machine to pass.

The use of steel straps instead of wooden ones would reduce the risk of falls of roof, but unfortunately the introduction of steel supports at the working face is often looked on with disfavour by the workmen. In a Durham colliery a machineman removed props from under the face ends of wooden bars which were against the coal in front of the machine and to each of which three props were set. A large stone broke down three bars at the middle props and the machineman was killed. The manager's subsequent attempt to introduce steel bars was stoutly resisted.

Machinemen must make careful examination of coal or overlying ramble and get down any which seems insecure.

The Inspector declares the practice of ragging coal off the face instead of breaking into the back of the cut and taking a jud to be a bad one. On such a face a filler set a middle prop to a steel bar but no end prop. When a weight came on, the prop was discharged, and he was killed.

When appliances are available, by the use of which a prop can be withdrawn from a safe distance, it is a great pity that men should run an entirely unnecessary risk.

Work on enlarging or repairing roads is inherently dangerous, and at every stage calls for an amount of deliberation which is not always easy to give to it. The men engaged on such work -are chosen on account of their experience, and confidence in them is generally justified. The most important precaution which should be taken is to strengthen the supports on either side of a place where repair work or enlargement is to be carried out.

Crossing-girders, or balks, in settled ground are usually supported by brick walls. Mr. Charlton says it is very necessary that a grossing-balk carrying a number of transverse members in any situation, should rest on some support which cannot readily be discharged if struck by tubs, or through ordinary weighting of the roof.

Need for Thought and Care.

In the Yorkshire Division sixteen persons were killed in 1937 by falls of side at the working face, and Mr. H. J. Humphrys says that all the accidents occurred in the thicker seams, fourteen of them taking place in the Barnsley Seam. An examination of these accidents reveals that whilst the majority were unavoidable, others could have been avoided by more thought and care. In one instance a collier who was attempting to pull down coal with a ringer required assistance. His mate went to help but passed between the coal being pulled and the front row of props, instead of behind the latter; the coal came over and crushed him against the props. Another accident was caused by taking out a sprag, set to holed coal, with a ringer. A Sylvester prop withdrawer was at hand and should have been used. In yet another instance a collier was getting down coal, which came away unexpectedly. He was standing in front of a prop which prevented his retreat and was killed.

Of the fatal roof accidents three occurred in pillar working and thirty on longwall faces. Of the latter seventeen occurred on conveyor faces, four on faces where coal-cutting machines were in use and the coal filled into tubs, whilst nine occurred on faces where there was no machinery.

The Inspector draws attention to accidents which occurred during or immediately after the withdrawal of roof supports. In one instance a prop was being withdrawn from the waste and the Sylvester prop withdrawer was anchored to a prop nearer the face. The latter, being less tight than the prop in the waste, drew out, and the roof from which the support had thus been withdrawn fell, and instantly killed the man operating the prop withdrawer. The bad practice of anchoring to roof supports has been denounced times without number, and only three weeks before the fatality, had been detected and condemned at this colliery by one of Mr. Humphrys's staff, who requested that a specially set, inclined, anchor-prop should be used for the purpose. He says it should not be necessary to draw attention to such a malpractice in these days, but as, unfortunately, it is not an isolated instance, the need evidently exists.

A collier was killed in the waste whilst cutting a wooden prop with his pick. There was a Sylvester prop withdrawer and twisting device within ten feet of him. In another instance a machineman was assisting to turn a coal-cutting machine at the face. Without setting temporary supports to secure his safety, as required by Section 52 (1), he knocked out a steel prop with a hammer and was instantly killed by the fall which resulted. Special long bars should be provided and used to support the roof where coal-cutting machines are to be turned round.

A collier, during the withdrawal of timber, stood to shine a light for his mate, two feet behind the last row of props under roof from which supports had just been withdrawn, when the roof fell and killed him. Another collier was killed at a ripping lip by a fall of roof from under which he had knocked out the supports with a hammer. A Sylvester prop withdrawer was only 15 yards away.

An Unusual Fall.

In the only accident in the Yorkshire Division during the year involving the loss of more than one life, three men were killed. It was the first fatal accident from a fall of roof at the working face in the 30 years' life of the colliery. The locus of the accident was at the extremity of a hand-worked longwall face which was being rapidly shortened by a 66-foot downthrow fault which made an angle of 150° with it. The section of seam worked was 6 feet 3 inches thick, with a 2 feet 6 inches coal roof. The fall occurred while four men were at the fault side putting a sand seal in an old gate. It was a very unusual fall, for although it only extended for a distance of five yards from the fault side, it consisted of breccia and small stones which came from a cavity some 30 feet high, and it overflowed along the face engulfing the three men whose bodies were not recovered for some fifteen hours. Two of them died from suffocation and one from a fractured skull.

The fall seems to have been due to an unfortunate combination of circumstances, for the fault had been stripped for 460 yards without mishap. The structure of the fault was unusual and the wide place formed by the junction of the old grate, airway and face was supported entirely by props and bars, which, as the circumstances proved, were insufficient. After the accident the thickness of coal worked next the fault was reduced by 1 foot 6 inches and an additional thickness of roof coal was thus left to support the strata above. The breadth of the pack along the fault side was substantially increased and this end of the face advanced so that the face line was more nearly square with the line of the fault.

Two separate accidents occurred on machine faces where the coal was loaded out from buttocks; in each a pair of buttocks advanced towards the other until they met. In each instance the removal of the last piece of coal was accompanied by a contravention of the timbering rules, and it was a portion of this length of roof that fell and caused the accident. The Inspector emphasises that the effect of taking down coal should be anticipated and the coal should ho worked so that a breach of rules is not created. In such circumstances it is better to timber up to one side of the buttock and let it st-and when only a few feet remains to be loaded out, the remainder being worked from the other side.

High Percentage of Falls.

Accidents from falls of ground accounted for 60 per cent. of all the reportable accidents which occurred underground in the North Midland Division in 1937, indicating, as Mr. G. Cook says in his report, that the problem of reducing the number is still the most important one facing the officials and workmen, and that still greater energy needs to be applied to it. He adds that the large number of accidents due to falls of coal is very disconcerting. Many of these accidents could have been avoided by reasonable care. In far too many cases men were killed or injured by not observing the simple precaution of standing clear of coal they were attempting to bring down, or by using a pick when, by using a bar, they could have stood farther away from the coal and given it room to fall clear. In fact, the Inspector proceeds to say, there were 26 accidents due this cause alone. Another prevalent cause of accident was that men did not see that they had a clear line of retreat whilst they were performing such work, and took up a position where props or tubs prevented them getting away.

Then spragging does not receive the attention it should; in some instances no sprags are set, and in others, where sprags have been set, the method, or perhaps a better expression would be the want of method, of withdrawing them, left much to be desired. Sometimes too many sprags were withdrawn at one time, and sometimes the person withdrawing them took up a position in front of the coal about to be got down. Proper means of withdrawing sprags should ho provided and used. Hammers should not be used for such a purpose. The proper use for a hammer is to drive, and make tight, the supports, and not for knocking them out.

A further bad practice referred to by Mr. Cook is to use improvised timbers such as prop ends for sprags and nogs. Specially prepared material should always be used and an adequate supply should always be available.

Accidents due to falls of roof fall into a different category. Unlike the coal which has to be brought down the roof has to be kept up. Supports to it have, therefore, to be of a more permanent nature, and care should be exercised to see that they are put in at the proper intervals and not set in a haphazard manner. A more liberal use of bars should be made, especially on machine-cut or conveyor faces.

Suitable lids should be placed on all props whether of wood or steel, no matter whether the prop is under a bar or to the roof itself. This is specially important where steel props and steel bars are used.

"Experience" Not Always Reliable.

All these points have been stressed time and again, Mr. Cook says, but since so many of them appear to be disregarded with the result that accidents follow, they must be repeated. Reliance cannot be placed on experience alone unless it has a bias towards safety; frequently men of long experience are deceived and involved in accidents — the roof must be supported, and supported systematically, at the earliest practicable moment if it is to be controlled and accidents avoided.

In his 1936 report, reference was made to the transition period between the older methods of mining and the present mechanisation systems, during which there had been accidents due to the lack of experience in the newer methods, and the hope was expressed that when this passed there would be some diminution in the number of accidents. Whilst these hopes have not yet been realised Mr. Cook thinks this is probably due to the fact that the transitional stage has been much longer than was anticipated. Experience as to the best methods is still far from complete, and systems which have been found to be successful at one colliery do not necessarily lend themselves readily to another; changes have therefore to be made to suit the conditions, the result being that some mines have not yet evolved a permanent system.

At the same time he is unable to advance any convincing justification for the accident rate from falls in his Division being in excess of all other Divisions, and the position calls for special effort on the part of every official to see what improvement can be effected at his own colliery. It is only by individual effort that the district rates can be reduced.

Falls While Withdrawing Timber.

A stallman required a prop, and instead of going along the face to get one he took a hammer and knocked out a prop in the waste. He was buried by the fall of roof which followed. In the first place, the Inspector points out, it was not necessary for the man to withdraw the prop as there was a sufficient supply on the face, and secondly, he should have used a Sylvester instead of a hammer.

A stallman took a hammer, knocked out a prop in a pack hole, and was killed by a fall of roof. Ringers and chains were used for withdrawing the timber in the seam, and one was near to the place. In the past it had sometimes been necessary to uncap or "headloose" props before using the ringer and chain, and it may be that the man was doing this. Mr. Cook considers a ringer and chain an antiquated appliance for such a purpose; a Sylvester is much more powerful and safer for the work. Sylvesters should be provided and their use made compulsory for withdrawing supports.

The necessity for putting in temporary timber before taking out existing supports is shown in the following accident

A miner was instructed by the deputy to replace three bars by longer ones so as to make more room and to set foresets under the existing bars before attempting the work. Instead of following the instruction he took out one of the short bars, and while in the act of setting a longer one in its place a fail of roof occurred and he was injured.

Falls on Roadways.

There were 13 fatal and 31 non-fatal accidents during the year caused by falls of ground on roadways. The majority of such accidents occur where repairs or enlargements of the roads are taking place, therefore particular attention should be given to such places to see that before the ground is disturbed in any way sufficient temporary supports are erected to ensure that the roof does not collapse where the actual work is being done or beyond or behind it. It is only reasonable to expect that where the roof and sides have settled down on the existing supports there is a danger that if these supports are withdrawn a fall of ground will follow. Accounts of typical accidents are given by Mr. Cook indicative of this danger, and two of them are reproduced to show that it may become necessary in changed conditions to support roadways already in use, although supports were not considered necessary at the time the roads were made. Owing to new faces being turned away in close proximity, the subsidence due to these faces had affected the roof of such roadways.

A conveyor face had been commenced 20 yards away from, and running parallel to, the main plane. A dataller was working on a portion of the road which had previously been thought not to require support, when a fall of roof occurred, and he was fatally injured. In the cavity made by the fall it was afterwards seen that the weight-breaks following on the opening up of the new face had extended over the roadway.

In the other case, where again it had not been considered necessary to support the roof of a branch road, a timberman was struck by a fall of roof. The fall was no doubt due to a new face having been started away from the main road, the subsequent weighting of which had weakened the roof at the junction of the branch road and the main road.

Cycle of Operations.

To illustrate the benefits, both in better roof control and working conditions, that can be obtained in some mines by lengthening the cycle of operations at faces, the following description is given of a 48-hour cycle.

A very successful system of working a conveyor face on a 48-hour cycle has been introduced in the Deep Soft Seam at Annesley Colliery, where four double-unit faces, varying from 130 to 360 yards, have been developed on this method of-working; The seam is three feet thick with a soft floor. All four units are organised on the same lines and one side leads the other by 24 hours.

On the first day of the cycle the day shift takes off a web of coal of 4 feet 6 inches to 5 feet which is brought down by hand and filled onto conveyers, leaving the soft floor, 2 feet to 2 feet 6 inches thick, as a bench. The roof over the conveyor track is supported by bars, and that of the filling web by short props or "brobs" set on the bench. On the afternoon shift of the first day the conveyor is dismantled and stacked in front of the wastes.

The night shift which fellows is confined to the ripping of the roads. The second day shift then takes up the floor bench, fills it into wastes, puts on the packs, withdraws the timber and prepares the new conveyor track.

The following afternoon shift erects the conveyor in the new track, and the face is then ready for filling off as at the beginning of the cycle. The remaining night shift is spent in back ripping, etc. The other side of the unit follows the same cycle 24 hours later.

The same men work on the same shifts each day. Those engaged in filling coal on the first day shift take up the floor dirt, pack and withdraw the timber and do all the work connected with their own length of face on the second day; whilst the men who dismantle the conveyor re-erect it the following day, and the rippers work at both rippings alternately. It has been found that with this system of work no shuts are required in the coal or floor dirt, and shot-firing is only done in the ripping. Better control of the roof has been obtained than was the case before this system was introduced.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Ashley, Theodore    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Charlton, William John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Cook, George    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Humphrys, Herbert John    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
21 Oct 1939  Falls Of Ground — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
04 Nov 1939  Falls Of Ground — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
18 Nov 1939  Falls Of Ground — III (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print