|
23rd September 1939, Page: 81, Column: 1 Notes On May ExaminationsReport of Central ExaminersThe Question Papers set at this Examination (May, 1939) have been published in pamphlet form and are obtainable (1s. 3d. net) from H.M. Stationery Office. Below we give the text of questions set at the May examinations (plans not reproduced), each question being followed by the Central Examiners' comments on the work generally of the candidates. The "comments" are in italics. The Central Examiners have compiled brief comments from information supplied by the Local Examiners, as under :— Edinburgh. — Noticeable improvements in the answering of questions, although knowledge of spontaneous fires and how to locate and deal with them not clearly understood. There was pronounced weakness in the knowledge of the Coal Mines Act and General Regulations, especially with second class candidates. Newcastle. — Standard uniformly low, although candidates showed a good practical knowledge of winning and working. Weaknesses of second class candidates were shown in machinery and surveying. Sheffield. — Candidates appeared to be better qualified, but answers to questions on explosions and fires were only fair. Weakness in ventilation, machinery and surveying most pronounced in second class candidates. Wigan. — Candidates well acquainted with modern methods of machine mining, but there was a lack of knowledge of other methods and systems of coal getting. Cardiff. — The standard attained by the candidates was poor. Knowledge of explosives and regulations governing the use of explosives very deficient. In methods of working knowledge confined to mechanised faces, no idea of working in steep measures. Second class candidates were weak in answering questions on the Coal Mines Act and General Regulations but good in regard to ventilation. Some candidates gave good answers to questions on mining machinery. Birmingham. — Some first class candidates were weak on problems of spontaneous combustion and water dangers. Safety features associated with switchgear and trailing cables not well understood. Second class candidates were weak in subjects of water dangers and spontaneous heating but were generally good on ventilation problems. Winning and Working (1st Class). (1) A shaft sunk to a depth of 1,800 feet passed through 20 feet of sand and soil, 40 feet of boulder clay, and 1,740 feet of coal measure rocks. The surface buildings to be supported are within a radius of 300 feet around the shaft. Show, by sketches, the size and position of the shaft pillar you would leave, assuming: (a) The strata to be level; (b) The strata inclination to be 20°. (50) Good answers were received from one-third of the candidates. A number confined remarks to giving a sketch and gave no measurements. A few candidates in their answers to the second part of the question incorrectly showed the pillar as being larger on the dip side of the shaft. (2) Describe briefly the general surface arrangements required at a sinking shaft where no particular difficulties are anticipated. Illustrate your answer by sketches. (40) On the whole the answers were disappointing, the great fault being lack of detail. In same cases only the arrangement of doors at the shaft top was mentioned, whereas a general description of the equipment required was asked for. Common omissions were shaft centring apparatus and lighting and shot-firing cable reels. (3) Explain the advantages of rigid and flexible guides for circular shafts. Which type would you suggest for a shaft 600 yards deep : (a) Where there is little clearance between the cages ? (b) which is not truly plumb throughout? (40) This question was generally well answered. A few candidates were of the opinion that rigid guides were not suitable for fast winding and a large number failed to mention that such guides might be made of wood or steel. Some candidates would adopt flexible guides in shafts not truly plumb, which is not to be recommended. (4) State your views as to the conditions under which each of the following is applicable on roadways to the greatest advantage: (a) Timber supports ; (b) steel props and girders ; (c) steel arches. (40) Fairly well answered, but the majority failed to enumerate the number of cases where the use of timber supports is still good practice. In answer to part (b) of the question, only a few candidates mentioned the use of the yielding type of steel prop. The use of steel arches was generally understood and recommended. (5) Give a brief account of the different classes of permitted explosives used in coal mines. What are the respective merits of high and low tension detonators? (40) Few good answers were received, the majority indicating a lack of knowledge. Some candidates confused high and low tension detonators. (6) There is a right angle turn adjacent to the top of a heavily loaded endless under-rope haulage road dipping 1 in 4. The size of rope in use is 1 1/8 inches diameter. Describe in detail the construction of the turn, giving dimensions and type of pulleys you would use and the distance apart you would place them. (40) Only one moderately good answer was received to this practical question. In most cases the methods and strength of pulleys which were suggested would be unsuitable for such a heavy duty. Many candidates showed a complete lack of knowledge on the subject. (7) In some coalfields in Great Britain igneous intrusions are found. What is an igneous intrusion, what forms does it take, and what are the effects of it on coal seams ? (40) A few exceptionally good answers were received, but in the majority of cases the answers showed a somewhat scanty knowledge. Ventilation (1st Class). (1) The plan . . . shows an advancing double unit conveyor face with loader and one loading point. A large quantity of coal is loaded each day. How would you arrange the ventilation of the face, the loading point, and roadways? Show on the plan, by conventional signs, all necessary means of distributing the air-current. (50) The answers differed very much. In many cases some roads were not utilised for the passage of air-currents, and in others alternate roads were made intake and return, thus increasing the chances of leakage. In many examples the lower roadway was used as a return, which is undesirable. In some cases air-crossings were used, though not necessary. Some candidates provided for reducing the velocity of the current near the leading point, but only a few made provision for the abstraction of the dust from the ventilating current near that place. (2) Give a list of the gaseous impurities usually met with in an air-current in a mine, placing them in the order of their importance. State the properties and physiological effect of each and how they may be detected. (30) Correctly given as a whole, but often the order of importance was ignored. The method of detection was well known. (3) In addition to portable lamps, what other methods are adopted for lighting fiery mines? Give a description of each, stating the advantages and disadvantages. (30) Some rather sketchy answers but many showed practical knowledge of this subject, including newly introduced methods. (4) What do you understand by "geothermic gradient" and what effect has it on ventilation ? What is your estimate of its amount, and which mines are most affected by it? (30) The condition of the section of the earth's crust from the surface to the plane of constant temperature was often wrongly described, but the lower and more important part was well understood and the effect on deep mines also. (5) If a current of 200,000 cubic feet per minute of air is produced by a fan at a mine with a water-gauge of 4 inches, what is the air horse-power? What power must be applied to the fan if the efficiency of this installation is 70 per cent. ? Indicate the effect of increasing the power applied by 30 per cent, when the mine conditions remain the same. (30) The air horse-power and the indicated horse-power were always correct. The new quantity was rarely stated correctly. (Cube roots appear to be a difficulty.) Many correctly showed that an increase of per cent. in power produced an increase in quantity of 9 per cent, only. (6) What steps would you take in the roadways to increase the air-current at the working faces of a mine ? Indicate the chief causes of the air losses usually sustained, and state in detail the steps which you would take to remove or reduce them. (30) Well understood and treated. Some pointed out that usually only about 30 per cent, of the air reached the faces. There was a tendency to stipulate that main airways should have a standard area (100 square feet often mentioned). (7) Give a description of a ventilating fan installation suitable for a large mine with a current of 300,000 cubic feet of air per minute at a water-gauge of 5 inches. Mention all important details of the installation, particularly the means of reversing the air-current. (30) Some good answers, the newer axial flow fans being a favourite installation. Machinery (1st Class). (1) A direct rope haulage is driven, through gearing, by a 150 h.p. motor (3-phase, 3,000 volts, 50 cycles), with wound rotor and sliprings. The motor makes frequent starts on full load torque and must be able to run at creeping speed (at full load torque). Describe the switchgear for starting, protecting and especially for controlling the motor, and state how you would specify the external resistance for the rotor circuit. (38) Good diagrams were often given showing switchgear for protecting and controlling the motor. A reversing switch was often omitted and some candidates introduced a transformer, whereas the motor was intended to be run at 3,000 volts. Beyond stating that a variable resistance consisting either of liquid or metal would be used in the rotor circuit, few candidates dealt with the question of the specification of the resistance for dealing with frequent starts and a creeping speed. (2) A colliery receives electric power from a power station 25 miles away. The capacity of the transformer at each end of the transmission line is 750 k.v.a. Explain the advantages of a high power factor for this system. Power is used by motors driving fans, pumps, and haulages. How could the power factor be raised ? (28) The advantages of a high power factor were well described by many candidates. Candidates instanced synchronous motors, synchronous induction motors, condensers and phase advancers, as means for improving power factor with various types of motor. (3) A 3-phase induction motor with wound rotor takes power at 2,000 volts between phases and develops 75 h.p. The efficiency is 88 per cent, and the power factor 085. What is the stator current in amperes ? If the rotor volts between phases are 300 what is approximately the rotor current? (28) Most candidates obtained the stator current correctly. A good proportion proceeded to get the current in the rotor by treating the motor as a transformer. Additional marks were given where it was recognised that not all the losses would occur in the rotor. A number of answers were spoiled by gross mistakes in arithmetic — mistakes which could have been detected by checking the calculations. (4) The water to be pumped at a colliery varies between 100 gallons per minute for five summer months, 250 gallons per minute for six months and 320 gallons per minute for one winter month. The head from all causes is 300 feet. Electric power of 3-phase type, 400 volts, 50 cycles is available. Give a specification in outline of the pumping plant that you would install, bearing in mind that it is desirable to keep down the demand for power. Do not deal with switchgear. (28) A number of candidates prescribed a pump of capacity equal to the highest feeder, in some cases with a duplicate standby pump. This did not comply with the requirement that the demand for power mast bc kept down. A number of candidates proposed to use two pumps, one for the summer duty, the other for the intermediate duty, and both working together for the one month of heavy duty. This arrangement was accepted, especially if a third pump were added as a standby. Centrifugal or turbine pumps were usually chosen foe the duty. Sonic candidates calculated the number and diameter of impellers, the size of suction and delivery pipes and the horse-power of the driving motor. (5) How do you calculate the size of the two cylinders of a steam-winding engine ? 'lake the case of a shaft with a wind of 300 yards, with two cages, weighing, with loaded tubs, 3 tons, and, with unloaded tubs, 2 tons, and drum 10 feet diameter on the crankshaft. The steam pressure at stop valve is 90 lb. per square inch and the winding ropes weigh 3 lb. per foot. (28) There was confusion in the calculations of the cylinder sizes of a winding engine. A number of candidates proceeded correctly on the basis that one piston might have to start the cages. A number used the stop valve pressure as the mean effective pressure on the piston, but in many cases a pressure lower than the stop valve was taken as the mean. In using the expression "PLAN" a common mistake was to take "N" as the number of revolutions of the engine instead of the number of strokes. Again, it was often forgotten that there are two cylinders, so that if "N" is the number of revolutions it must be multiplied by four to get the effective strokes. Some candidates equalled the torque set sip by the ropes to the torque at the crankpins. Others found the work done on the ropes in one revolution of the drum and equated this with the work done in the cylinders. A number of candidates gel lost in the calculations and reached no solution. (6) A Lancashire boiler at a colliery is 30 feet long by 8 feet 6 inches diameter, with flue tubes 3 feet 6 inches diameter. Coal of poor quality is burned. Quote a possible figure for the heat value of the coal in British thermal units per lb. What weight of the coal per hour might be burned in the boiler ? What weight of water per hour might be evaporated to steam at 120 lb. per square inch ? How often would you expect to clean the boiler fires ? (28) A common error was to quote the heat value of coal as about 1,000 instead of 10,000 heat units. Bad mistakes were made, such as giving a weight of water evaporated less than that of the coal burned. (7) Compressed air is brought to a heading in 2-inch screwed and socketed mild steel pipes and is fed to a portable drill by a ¾-inch flexible hose. Describe in detail and sketch the assembly for coupling the pipe to the hose including a ¾-inch plug cock. It must be easy to uncouple the hose so that it may go with the drill. (28) The answers to this question were poor. Some candidates abandoned the ¾-inch plug cock specified amid used either a 2-inch cock or an automatic self-closing valve connection. There were numerous impossible arrangements and few good sketches. (8) How may the speed of a steam engine be kept constant within close limits ? How may the output of an air compressor be controlled to suit the varying demands of a colliery ? (28) A ball governor was most frequently given for controlling the speed of an engine. Many candidates had in mind a winding engine where the problem of speed control is different from that of an engine running continuously. Most candidates showed the governor controlling the steam inlet by throttling. Only one candidate mentioned control by altering the point of cut-off of the valve. In dealing with air compressors most candidates referred to air receivers. They had in mind the smoothing of the demand from the air compressors, but it was not on answer to the question. A number of candidates instanced gear for closing the air inlet to the compressor on the air pressure becoming excessive.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||