Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

9th September 1939, Page: 66, Column: 1

Notes On Surveyors' Examination

Central Examiner's Report

The Question Papers set at this Examination (May, 1939) have been published in pamphlet form and are obtainable (1s. 3d. net) from H.M. Stationery Office.

At the May (1939) examination for surveyors' certificates 74 candidates presented themselves and 24 qualified in the practical examination, the percentage thus qualifying for certificates being 32.4. The candidates present at each centre, the number who qualified, and the percentage of passes were: Edinburgh, 19, 7, 36.8 ; Newcastle, 16, 5, 31.3 ; Sheffield, 17, 4, 23.5 Wigan, 1, 1, 100 Cardiff, 9, 4, 44.4 Birmingham, 12, 3, 25.

Compared with the May examination last year, the number of candidates showed a decrease of almost 13 per cent., but there was practically no falling off in the percentage qualifying for the certificate, and the Central Examiner says it is exceedingly satisfactory to record that the excellent figures of the examination held in November last have once again almost been equalled. As a general rule, candidates did their best work in the morning paper — the geological question in particular being exceptionally well answered — but only in a comparatively few instances was the standard of work maintained throughout the afternoon paper.

The average marks earned by candidates who qualified in the written part of the examination was 67 — an improvement of 3 marks on last examination. On the other hand, candidates who failed to qualify averaged only 38 marks — a poor total, and 5 marks lower than in the preceding examination. That is the one disconcerting feature of the examination on this occasion, for it clearly indicates that the attainments of a very considerable proportion of the candidates who come forward are definitely far short of the standard aimed at by the Board.

Not the least satisfactory feature of the examination was the success enjoyed by candidates at the Cardiff Centre, where for a long time results have been disappointing.

Regarding the oral and practical examination reports from the Practical Examiners indicate at several of the centres no more than a moderate degree of attainment in certain of the instrumental and other tests which comprised this part of the examination. In the tests with the theodolite — particularly that given underground — manipulation is almost invariably described as being slow, and on occasion as being indicative of lack of practice and experience. Fortunately, the work was generally accomplished with fair accuracy. The test with the dumpy level was, as usual, generally satisfactorily performed, adverse comment being confined to three centres where certain candidates failed to realise the advisability of having well-balanced sights. On the other hand, the field notes are severely criticised by several examiners, who record in certain instances an entire lack of method. In the office test, the draughtsmanship was not always up to the standard expected, and in several centres is described as poor.

One examiner, of many years' experience, sums up his comments by stating "that it would be of a great advantage to candidates if they could be persuaded to take a broader view of their duties and a keener interest in associated subjects." The Central Examiner has frequently been led to make similar comment in dealing with the work done in the written part of the examination.

Comments on Answers.

In the reproduction of the text of the questions set at the examination the plans, etc., have been omitted. Each question is followed by the comment of the Examiner on the work generally of the candidates. The comments are in italics.

MORNING SESSION: (1) Compulsory Question. — The plan . . . shows surface contours at vertical intervals of 100 feet, from which there has been projected a longitudinal section on the line AB shown on the plan, and drawn to the same scale as the latter. The section also shows the position and thickness of certain beds as proved by examination of the outcrops and by boring. Draw on the plan the outline of the outcrop of the beds marked "Millstone Grit." (14)

There were many excellent answers to this geological question, which was compulsory. As a general rule, the only point calling for adverse criticism in the answers was the fact that the majority of candidates failed to observe that the lines defining the superface and subface of the Millstone Grit beds were not exactly parallel to each other. As a result, the method of solution adopted could not produce a strictly accurate answer.

(2) Two underground roadways AB and CD are to be connected by a curved roadway having a radius of 200 feet. The azimuths of AB and CD are respectively 21 deg. 50 min. and 300 deg. 10 min., and the co-ordinates of B and D are as follow :—

Calculate: (a) How far each roadway must be driven to meet the tangent points; (b) the length of the new roadway BD. (12)

Answers were no better than fair, rather less then 20 per cent. of them being correct or approximately so. As a rule, the position of the tangent points was determined with reasonable accuracy, but only a comparatively few candidates correctly calculated the length of the curved part of the new roadway — a result due in many instances to the adoption of a method of solution which was far removed from being the most straightforward.

(3) A cross-measures drift is about to be driven from a point at the dip end of a main haulageway which commences near the shaft bottom, is approximately half a mile in length, and has a more or less uniform dip of 9 inches to the yard. The level of the starting point of the drift in relation to Ord. Dat. is to be determined with the maximum of accuracy. A surface bench-mark unaffected by mineral workings, approximately 1 mile distant from the shaft — which is 720 yards in depth — is available for reference. Describe fully, but as concisely as you can, how you would carry out this work. (10)

Answers generally were fairly satisfactory. A number of candidates lost marks by neglecting to state that they would check the result obtained when levelling from the bench-mark to the shaft mouth by a levelling in the reverse direction. There were also several instances where it was proposed to adopt trigonometrical methods of levelling in the dip haulageway with, obviously, only a perfunctory knowledge of the work entailed.

(4) For the purpose of correlating an underground traverse with the Ordnance Survey Grid North of the district, magnetic observations were taken simultaneously underground and on the surface. The notes thereof are as follow :—

Draw such conclusions from an analysis and study of the above details as you think are justified, and thereafter calculate the azimuth of the underground base in relation to Grid North. (8)

Surprisingly few candidates attempted this comparatively simple question. The point to be noted in working out the solution was the evidence of "local attraction" in the magnetic readings obtained from lines 7 and 16. It was assumed that candidates who had experience of this class of work would probably have encountered similar abnormal variations, and that they would accordingly decide to ignore the results obtained for the two lines above referred to.

(5) The sides of a triangular area of ground are respectively as follow : AB, 635 links; BC, 800 links ; CA, 938 links. It is proposed to lay off a straight line DE parallel to the side AB in such position that the area of the enclosure ABED will equal 1½ acres. Show how you would determine the position of the line DE. (8)

This question was attempted by practically every candidate with somewhat disappointing results, less than one-third of the answers being correct or approximately correct.

AFTERNOON SESSION: (1) Compulsory Question. — The following. are the notes of a traverse run in the upper workings of a mine, A being a plumb-wire in the centre of a vertical shaft, and AB a level cross-measure drift which has been driven to intersect a coal seam dipping uniformly due north at 1 in 1¾.

In a new cross-measures drift 100 yards vertically below AB, a draft AX has a horizontal length of 100 feet and an azimuth 181° 20'. It is proposed to drive a straight roadway from X to a point Y in DE produced, which is to be level until it intersects the seam and thereafter is to rise therein at an inclination of 1 in 4. Calculate: (a) the azimuth of the proposed roadway XY; (b) the distance from X at which it will intersect the seam; (c) the slope length of the proposed roadway in the seam; and (d) the distance EY. (14)

Answers to this compulsory question were not nearly so good as they ought to have been, only six candidates recording an accurate, or reasonably accurate, solution. The problem was by no means difficult. Indeed, the only point calling for a little initial thought was the determination of the angle between the line of full dip and the new heading so as to give the latter a gradient of 1 in 4.

(2) The plan . . . shows surface contours at vertical intervals of 5 feet, and the plan of a proposed colliery building. The site for the building is to be excavated at a level of 22 Ord. Dat. to such extent as will leave a clear space of 6 feet between the east, north, and west wails thereof and the bottom of the slopes of the excavation — which are to be 1½ horizontal to 1 vertical. To save excavation the north-west corner of the slopes is to be "coned." Draw on the plan the bottom and top of the slopes and make an approximate estimate of the volume of excavation. (12)

Approximately 70 per cent, of the candidates attempted this question, and about one-half of them gave answers which ranged from moderately good to good. The remainder were for the most part quite inaccurate. The rough estimate of volume of excavation which was asked for was rarely satisfactory, and only a very few candidates appear to have any idea of the simplest and most accurate method of making such a calculation.

(3) The undernoted readings were taken with a fixed hair tacheometer theodolite on a vertical staff. The instrumental constant is 100. Calculate the horizontal distance and difference in elevation between the two staff stations. (10)

This straightforward problem in tacheometric calculation was not generally attempted, with the exception of candidates at Newcastle and Cardiff, in each of which centres the answers were, as a rule, satisfactory.

(4) The major part of an area of ground which, on plan, covers approximately 20 inches square at the junction of the eastern and southern marginal lines of the 25 Ord. Map Blankshire XXIV. 8 is about to be adopted as a site for new public works in a depressed area. Information is required as to the extent to which mineral working has taken place under the site in the past. Local sources of information have been tapped, and it is believed that at least two seams have been extensively worked throughout the area in question. You are instructed to examine the Catalogue of Abandoned Mine Plans for possible additional and more reliable data. State, with a sketch, what you would look for in that catalogue, and indicate fully what you might expect to find. (8)

Answers to this generally attempted question were somewhat disappointing. It was framed to test the candidate's knowledge of the particulars recorded in the catalogue above referred to, and in many instances it proved that the candidate had no accurate knowledge of the relationship between the area covered by a particular 25" Ord. sheet and the squares on the corresponding 6" maps referred to in the catalogue.

(5) An area of ground in the shape of a segment of a circle is about to be acquired for a housing site at a colliery. The area to be acquired extends to two acres, and the straight boundary which forms the chord subtends an angle of 60° at the centre of the circle. What is the radius of the circle? (8)

Only about one-half of the answers were correct. In a number of instances there was evidence of confusion between a "segment and a "sector."

(6) The sketch . . . shows a seam of coal which has been subjected to displacement by two faults of the dimensions indicated thereon. Calculate the length and gradient of a cross-measure drift to connect the seam between the points A and B from the details shown on the sketch. (12)

Answers on the whole were good, although in some instances the method of solution adopted entailed considerably more calculation than was actually necessary.


Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
11 Feb 1939  Board for Mining Examinations (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Aug 1939  Examination Results (The Science and Art of Mining)
09 Sep 1939  Notes On Surveyors' Examination, Central Examiner's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 Sep 1939  Notes On May Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 Oct 1939  Notes On May Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
21 Oct 1939  Notes On May Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print