|
29th July 1939, Page: 17, Column: 1 Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — VOccupational DiseasesA section of the Report* of the Safety in Mines Commission is devoted to consideration of occupational diseases of coal miners. As regards the diseases scheduled under the Workmen's Compensation Acts, the burden on the mining industry, whether viewed from the standpoint of the suffering and loss caused to the persons employed or in terms of the amount of compensation paid, is far higher than in any other major industry. A table is given showing that per thousand persons employed in 1936 the compensation paid was £585 8s. 9d. In industries employing 7,606,066 persons the average was £73 1s. 7d. The occupational diseases to which miners are susceptible fall into three groups, viz. : Nystagmus, Silicosis and a group of inflammatory diseases, Beat hand, Beat knee, Beat elbow and Synovitis of the wrist, which can conveniently be referred to collectively as "Beat" diseases, together with a group of other diseases at minor importance. Nystagmus. The Departmental Committee on certain questions arising under the Workmen's Compensation Acts explained in their 1938 Report that: "The word 'nystagmus' means simply the abnormal movement (oscillation) of the eyes : and miner's nystagmus is the disorder characterised by abnormal movement of the eyes which occur amongst miners working underground. Oscillation of the eyes is of the essence of the disorder, and the evidence laid before us is to the effect that the condition cannot properly be described as one of miner's nystagmus unless oscillations either are or have been present." Since 1931, when the total of cases in receipt of compensation reached its peak, there has been a gradual fall in the total incidence of the disease. The number of "new cases" in each year, which exceeded 3,000 in 1930, had fallen by 1936 to about half that number, while the "old cases" have steadily declined since 1932. The lag as regards the latter is no doubt, due to the fart that, as explained by Dr. S. W. Fisher, the period of incapacity in nystagmus cases is often prolonged. The disease is associated more particularly with safety-lamp mines, very few cases having occurred in mines which are worked by naked lights. The Third Report of the Miner's Nystagmus Committee, published in 1932, confirmed an earlier conclusion that the fundamental cause of the disease is the low standard of illumination under which miners in general work. In 1934 the Mines Department took action, by way of the Coal Mines General Regulations (Lighting), with a view to raising the general standard of lighting in safety-lamp mines, by requiring that persona employed at the face and at other specified places shall be provided with lamps satisfying certain minimum requirements in regard to lighting performance, by measures to encourage the wider adoption of fixed and other forms of electric lighting otherwise than by safety-lamps, and by provisions in regard to the whitewashing of sidings, junctions, passbyes, engine rooms and similar places below ground. The Departmental Committee which recently considered questions arising under the Workmen's Compensation Acts found in the evidence submitted to them a remarkable degree of agreement" that in safety-lamp mines the electric cap lamp is the best form of illumination for use at the coal face, because it accompanies the wearer wherever he goes and automatically directs the light in the line of the wearer's vision and "this fact of itself makes it a valuable safeguard against nystagmus." They expressed the hope that "an effort will be made by the Mining Association to persuade owners to provide cap lamps in suitable cases, and that in those mines where the owners offer to provide cap lamps as an alternative to ordinary lamps the Mineworkers' Federation will use its influence to induce miners to use them in their own interests." As regards the further improvement of mine lighting which the Committee urged as the future objective, the Commissioners are informed that most of the types of lamps approved by the Mines Department in pursuance of the current Lighting Regulations have a lighting performance (when new) substantially in excess of the minimum laid down in those regulations, and that substantial improvements have been effected in the lighting performance of both flame and electric safety-lamps since the regulations were made. By the invention of more efficient lamp bulbs, for instance, the light which can be obtained from modern electric hand-lamps has already been raised by as much as 30 per cent. above the level attainable in 1934. It is not altogether clear how far the Committee took these developments into account. Although it may not yet be possible to determine the exact relation between the recent decline in the incidence of nystagmus and the improvements brought about in mine lighting, yet it appears significant that this decline has been, broadly speaking, contemporary with a period in which lighting problems have attracted greatly increased attention and some substantial technical advances have been made. The Commissioners have made recommendations with regard to the extension of fixed lighting on main roads. As cases of nystagmus are found among persons who work on the roads as well as among face workers any improvements in road lighting are likely to lessen the liability of road workers to contract nystagmus as well as their liability to accident. The conclusions of the Home Office Departmental Committee are accepted and support given to their recommendation that the improvements already effected in underground lighting generally should only be regarded as a step forward, and that there should be no slackening of efforts to achieve still further advances in technical development and no hesitation in applying these developments so as to ensure a progressive improvement in the lighting conditions underground. Silicosis. Dr. S. W. Fisher described silicosis to the Commissioners as a disease of the lungs due to the inhalation of dust containing free silica, and this they believe to be the generally accepted view of the medical profession, despite certain hypotheses recently advanced by others that some other minerals may play an important if not the only, part. But whether the irritant in the dust is free silica or something else, there is no doubt that exposure to dust, and particularly to fine dust, is the fundamental element in the causation of the disease. It is also generally agreed that the irritant property of the dust does not arise from physical characteristics, such as angularity or hardness, but from the fact that the dust particles dissolve in the lung and the harmful solution thus produced initiates the process of fibrosis. It is for this reason that bronchitis, broncho-pneumonia and other diseases which impair the dust-eliminating function of the lungs are often thought to be contributory. The exposure to dust usually extends over a long period of years before definite signs and symptoms of the disease appear, but when these signs and symptoms are recognisable the disease fends to progress, especially if associated with pulmonary tuberculosis. Dr. Fisher's evidence is quoted as follows "Apart from the signs elicited by clinical examination, X-rays are essential in the diagnosis of the disease. In a typical case in the early stage and uncomplicated by any other lung disease, the X-ray picture shows discrete small spots (two to five millimetres in diameter). These are the shadows of nodules which are demonstrable in the lung after death and are characteristic of the disease. As time goes on these separate nodules become more numerous and blend with one another forming masses of fibrous tissue seen in the X-ray film as patches of dense shadow of varying sizes. When the disease is far advanced large areas of the lung become practically solid and airless. The encroachment on the lung by this slow development of fibrous tissues results in breathlessness which in advanced cases is moat distressing." The Commissioners have been unable to obtain comparable statistics relative to the incidence of silicosis in other coal mining countries, but such statistics as they have obtained indicate a high incidence rate among coal miners in the Ruhr district of Germany. A good deal of evidence was presented to them showing that, despite the large amount of research work, there remains on the medical side much to be investigated concerning the actiology of the disease, and on the mining or preventive side much to be explained concerning its peculiar incidence in this country, before preventive measures can be formulated on the basis of exact knowledge and proved facts. Thus it was thought at one time that only persons who were or had been engaged for long periods in driving "hard headings" in siliceous rock were affected and that the disease was mainly due to inhalation of the very fine dust made in boring the shot-holes, but it is now known, as Mr. J. M. Carey put it, that "Some men who have got silicosis have never worked on a boring machine in their lives," but have been exposed to dust elsewhere exactly how, or in what Occupation or part of the mine these men have contracted the disease remains, however, to be determined. The incidence of silicosis In Great Britain exhibits a most remarkable geographical irregularity. Both Sir Alfred Faulkner and Mr. T. Ashley pointed out that 90 per cent. of the eases certified have come from the South Wales coalfield, and the former referred to this as "one of many facts about the disease in mining for which as yet there is no fully satisfactory explanation." At the other extreme, although a good deal of driving in stone is done in the Northern coalfield and in Scotland, the Commissioners were informed that only two cases were certified in Scotland during 1937, only one in Durham and none at nil in Northumberland. Mr. Ashley added that nearly two-thirds of the South Wales cases have occurred in the Swansea Division, and that the incidence is much higher in the anthracite mines in the west than in the steam coal collieries in the eastern part of the coalfield, and is increasing. Again, there are marked differences between the incidence of silicosis at two or more collieries within a short distance of one another: "You may have two pits in apparently identical circumstances, one of which will have a large amount of silicosis, and the other will have none, and nobody can explain why." A further question not yet resolved is what kinds of dust ought to be regarded as dangerous from the standpoint of silicosis. It has been feared, for instance, that the stone dust applied to underground roadways as a precaution against explosions might be a source of danger in this connection, but this supposition is countered by the observation that the incidence of silicosis is highest in anthracite mines, in which no "artificial" stone dust is applied to the roadways. Instruments for Measuring Dust. The production of dust of a kind which may be inimical to the health of the workers is inevitable in certain mining operations, notably the drilling of shot-holes in stone or rock, the firing of shots, and the subsequent handling or loading of the fallen debris whether the resultant fouling of the atmosphere is or is not likely to be harmful to the persons employed depends, not only upon the nature of the dust, but very largely upon the quantity of air-borne dust present — the duet concentration — at any place. Instruments for measuring or estimating dust concentrations have therefore been devised, that now most commonly used being the konimeter invented by Sir Robert Kotze in South Africa. For the purpose of fixing a maximum permissible dust concentration, Captain Hay explained that the Mines Department had adopted an arbitrary standard based upon the recommendations of the South African Miners' Phthisis Prevention Committee, viz., a reading of 300 particles per cubic centimetre on the Kotze konimeter, but that the Department uses the Zeiss konimeter which is 50 per cent. more efficient than the Kotze instrument and with which the corresponding reading is 450 particles per cubic centimetre. In other words the inspectors, when Interpreting the results of "dust counts," regard any count up to 450 particles per cubic centimetre as justifying the assumption that the atmosphere is fit for men to work in, but any count in excess of this figure is regarded as an indication of the need for measures either to reduce the dust concentration or, if that is not possible, to protect the persons who are exposed to that concentration. it must be recognised that konimeter readings are not an absolute measure of the quantity of dust present in the atmosphere, but they afford a convenient means of estimating the relative purity or dustiness of the air, and the konimeter is a handy instrument for mine use. No criticism of the foregoing standard of air purity was expressed in evidence. Until some better standard can be devised, therefore, based perhaps upon determinations with a more accurate instrument, the Commissioners think the present standard should be continued. They proceed to say that although dust of any kind may be unpleasant if present in heavy concentration, the undisputed fact that silicosis occurs in some mines but not in others, although the conditions as regards dust are apparently similar, seems to compel the presumption that, in so far as dust is a causative factor, some kinds of dust are dangerous to health and other kinds are by comparison innocuous. On that presumption precautions which are absolutely necessary in one mine or one set of conditions would be quite unnecessary and could not reasonably be enforced in another mine or under another set of conditions, With our present limited knowledge how can the "dangerous" mines or the "dangerous" conditions be defined in a statutory enactment? It is abundantly clear from the records of silicosis cases in the Mines Department, and where the disease is prevalent the Commissioners think it is fairly generally accepted, that it is the persons employed in driving stone or cross-measure drifts (in which through ventilation is impossible at the face) who are peculiarly liable to contract silicosis if so employed for any considerable time. It does not necessarily follow (though they believe there are some who would assert) that all work of this kind is dangerous to health irrespective of the rock through which the drivage is made, but it will be evident that no clear distinction can confidently be drawn at present between one kind of rock and another. On the other hand they can see no practical difficulty in applying the most complete precautionary measures in all these "hard headings," and, pending further research, they do not consider that any serious hardship would be caused by a general rule to that effect, irrespective of the nature of the rock. From the further fact, which is now no longer in dispute, that other classes of workmen are liable to contract the disease, it is clear that in certain mines at least the taking of precautions must extend beyond the driving of stone drifts to work in other parts of the mine which involves the production of fine stone dust, and even to persons not so engaged who are exposed to dust carried along the airways by the ventilating current. In the present state of knowledge, the Commissioners think that the mines in which this need exists can only be determined empirically on the basis of (a) the actual occurrence of the disease among the persons employed at a mine and (b) other mines or areas in which the natural conditions and the conditions of work are sufficiently similar to justify the Mines Department in believing, in the light of the best information available, that precautionary measures are necessary without waiting for a case of silicosis to occur. Methods of Protecting Workmen. The principal methods and appliances that are available for protecting the workers against the inhalation of dangerous dusts fall into two broad categories, via., methods of working and appliances for collecting or suppressing the dust as near as possible to its source, and respirators for protecting the respiratory organs of persons who are forced to work in dust-laden atmospheres. Where collection and suppression methods are practicable they are obviously preferable, because they attack the evil at its source, to any method which aims at enabling persons to work in dust-laden atmospheres; moreover, as Captain Hay pointed out, "if a man were working with a respirator and producing quantities of flue dust, he would be protected, but that fine dust would be carried to other places, where men might breathe it who were not provided with respirators." Hence, while Captain Hay expressed the opinion that the wearing of an efficient respirator would give as good protection as the other preventive measures he had described, "I would never advocate the use of a respirator as a preventive measure, but merely as a second line of defence, where the dust suppression methods could not be applied." For instance, the dust arising from the firing of shots in a ripping close to the face may be carried by the ventilating current a considerable distance along the face. If then the face workers need to be protected against inhaling that dust, either shot-firing must be carried out when no one is employed on the face, or the persons at risk must be provided with respirators. The former alternative may not always be practicable. In the latter case, it is true that following each shot the time of exposure to a dangerous concentration of dust will be short, but it may he repeated several times during a shift, and if the dust is likely to be dangerous to health, the temporary use of respirators is at present the only practicable precaution. Recommendations. The Commissioners recommend, in substitution for the requirements of Section 78 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, a provision that:— (i) In any mine — Where any cross-measure drift is being driven, or any shaft (including staple pit) is being sunk, the dust concentration in the air shall be kept below a prescribed maximum (i.e., at present 450 particles per cubic centimetre as determined by a Zeiss konimeter) by a method or methods of dust prevention approved by the Mines Department. (ii) In mines in which there is a liability to silicosis — i.e., mines in which silicosis has been contracted and any other mines or areas scheduled by the Mines Department as being mines or areas in which precautionary measures are necessary — Where any work is being done in stone or rock, the dust concentration in the air shall, where practicable, be kept below the prescribed maximum by a method or methods of dust prevention approved by the Mines Department; or, where this is impracticable, the persons working in stone or rock and all persons working in the immediate vicinity on the return side shall wear an approved type of dust respirator to be provided by the mine owner. At all mines to which the foregoing provisions apply, representative tests should be required to be made, at such intervals of time as the district inspector may approve, of the dust concentration in the air at all places where drilling or shot-firing or the handling or loading of loose rock is being carried on, and the results of such tests should be recorded in a book to be kept for the purpose. The tests should be made with a type of konimeter or other instrument approved by the Mines Department. As handling or loading fallen rock debris is apt to raise considerable quantities of fine dust into the air, Captain flay recommended that all loose rock should be thoroughly wetted before removal, or alternatively that the men engaged in removing it should wear respirators. The Commissioners concur in this recommendation so far as regards the handling or loading of loose rock in the course of driving cross-measure drifts and of sinking shafts. They recommend a rule, applicable to all mines without exception, making it an offence for any person to work or pass, except for the purpose of making an examination, in any place after a shot has been fired in that place until the air has been effectively cleared of dust and fumes. Beat Diseases. Under this head the Commissioners include Beat knee, Beat band, Beat elbow and Synovitis of the wrist. All are inflammatory conditions caused in different ways, the first three having continuous or repeatedly applied pressure as a common factor in conjunction with some source of infection, and the last being brought about by sudden strain, unusual exercise or repeated jarring (as in using a pick, especially a pneumatic pick against hard rock or coal). These diseases rarely have any fatal results, and when promptly and properly treated the period of disablement is not prolonged, but, as Sir Alfred Faulkner pointed out, the total number of cases among miners is large and tending to increase. At the request of the Mines Department, this group of diseases was the subject of an investigation in 1924 by the Medical Research Council. The investigators recommended that the chief steps to be taken for prevention were to guard against repeated small injuries so far as possible, to keep the skin clean and the general health good and to secure prompt first-aid treatment in all cases and proper surgical treatment when needed. Dr. Fisher said that the continuance of a large number of cases under this heading need not be viewed too pessimistically, for "it should be kept in mind that during recent years workmen have been strongly encouraged to take care of even minute abrasions and it may well be that many more cases are now reported." At the same time he agreed that a reduction in the number of cases is largely a matter of educating the individual workman to protect himself against small injuries and to obtain treatment when he suffers such injuries, and he was of opinion that educational work on these lines should be actively continued. Where pithead baths are available, their regular use should help in the avoidance of inflammatory conditions of such severity as to lead to "beat" disease. In view, however, of the upward tendency in the incidence of beat knee and beat elbow in particular, and as some 13 years have elapsed since the issue of M.D. Circular No. 14, the Commissioners think that renewed attention should be drawn to the recommendations contained therein. * Cmd. 5890. 7s. 6d. net. H.M. Stationery Office.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||