|
Chester-le-Street ChronicleArticle from the Chester-le-Street Chronicle, 28th July 1939 Chester Moor Colliery Cage AccidentMan dragged up shaft and fatally injuredQuestions at Inquest on Signal RapsCoroner W. M. Patterson, sitting with a jury, held an inquiry in the Miners' Institute, Chester Moor, on Thursday of last week, into the death of James Hodgson Hutton (51), of Neil House, Chester Moor, who died on July 17 following injuries [received] at Chester Moor Colliery [where he] was employed . . . previously. Sidney Hindmarch, of Lime Street, Waldridge, a joiner employed at the colliery, said that at 7 p.m. on July 13 he was at the shaft bottom in the Busty Seam waiting to go to bank. With him were Hutton and a man named John Smith. The cage was then at the Low Main Seam and Hutton shouted up the shaft for it to be sent down. Hutton then gave three raps on the signal to let the engineman know that they wanted to "ride". Answering the Coroner, witness said he and the other man got into the cage, leaving Hutton outside beside the rapper. "Hutton then rapped the cage away, and as he was about to enter the cage he slipped and his left leg was caught between the [cage] and the shaft guides," he said, and answering a question from the Coroner, he said the cage moved away immediately after Hutton slipped. Witness said that Smith and himself then shouted to the onsetter at the Low Main Seam to stop the cage, and apparently the engineman had got one rap from someone, probably the onsetter at the Low Main seam, because the cage stopped 50 or 60 feet up. CAGE HAD TO BE LOWERED Hutton was dragged up that distance and when the cage stopped, witness and Smith tied to release his leg, but found they could not do so, and all they could do was to ask the onsetter at the Low Main to have the cage lowered again, and this was done. The Coroner: "This all happened simultaneously with his slipping as the cage went away?" Witness: "Yes." Witness said he thought Hutton should have been in the cage before he rapped. Mr. Brown, H. M. Inspector of Mines: "Was the signal of '3' acknowledged by the banksman?" Witness: "No." "Were the lights burning at the shaft or were you relying on ordinary hand lamps?" "The lights were burning." "Had Hutton acted as onsetter before in your presence" — "No." "Who suggested that he should rap the cage away on this occasion?" — "Well, he was in charge." Did he suggest that you should get [into the cage and that he] would rap it away?" "Yes." "Are you quite sure that the order of the signals given by Hutton was '3' and '1'?" "Yes." "Did he make use of any cautionary signals to let the engineman know that he was leaving the bottom?" — "No." "What caused this man to slip?" — "I could not say." "Were you facing in his direction?" — "No." Did he pass any remarks about attempting to recover his lamp?" — "No." QUITE CONSCIOUS WHEN RELEASED "Hutton was quite conscious when released. Did he offer any suggestion as to how the accident had happened?" — "I did not hear him." "Hutton knew of the wire extension to rap himself away?" — "He had used it before." Answering Mr. Clayton Coulson, the manager of the colliery, witness said it was quite safe for a person to rap the cage away from the inside. Mr. E. Cowen, representing Durham Miners' Association: "When you shouted for the onsetter was there anything to prevent the onsetter from seeing the men away?" Witness: "The onsetter for the Busty seam was in the pumphouse 20 yards away." Answering a further question, he said that he had never been in the cage with Hutton to see him use the safety rapper. John Nicholson, of Poplar Street, Waldridge, the winding engineman at the pit, said that at 10 minutes past 7 he was told that a man had been injured in the shaft. Ten minutes previously he had received two signals — one of "3" from the Busty for the men to ride, then "1" to take the cage away. Coroner: "Have you any instructions to wait before you take the cage away?" — "No." "If individual men are to get into the cage do you get any difference in signal?" — "[No] the same as given by [. . . .] FEW SECONDS WAIT AFTER RECEIVING SIGNAL "If you get the same signal how do you know the difference?" — "We do not; we just make the usual practice of waiting a few seconds after we receive the '1' signal." Continuing, witness said that after the cage had got into motion he got another rap of '1' from the Low Main to stop the cage and later received '5' from the Low Main to go gently down. Answering questions by the Coroner, witness said he did not know how long Hutton had been employed there. The extension wire for rapping had been on the cage all the time he had been there and that was nine years. Mr. Brown: "What sort of signal do you get from the Low Main to mean that men want to ride?" Witness: "6 raps." "Then you got '3' from the Busty then '1'? — "Yes." "Did you not get a '2'?" — "No, not on that occasion." "Is it usual to move away before getting a '2' signal?" — "We should have a '2' from the banksman to know that he is at his post." Answering further questions by the Inspector, witness said he did not know how far away the banksman was from his post; a wall prevented him from seeing him. He waited just under a minute after getting the '1' signal. Inspector: "How long did you wait?" Witness; "Well, about 30 seconds." Answering the Inspector, witness said there was no cautionary signal in use at that pit to say that the onsetter was riding, but he had worked at other collieries where such a signal was in use. Inspector: "When you get a cautionary signal then you take extra care?" — "Yes." FIRST ACCIDENT OF ITS KIND AT THE PIT Mr. Clayton Coulson at this stage told the Coroner that there had never been an accident such as this at the pit. They had no need for a system of safety signals rapping and they had a safe signal which could be operated from inside the cage after the gates of it had been closed. This was by an extension cable on the rapper and he considered it to be the better method. "If a man had a few moments to spare after rapping he would probably do something else and still rush for the cage at the last moment." he said. The Coroner: "Should there not be something like a collaboration between the engineman and the men below?" Mr. Coulson: "The Colliery Company are prepared to do anything suggested for safety." Mr. E. Cowen: "I am given to understand that there is another wire besides the ordinary rapping wire?" Nicholson: "Yes." "Does the brakesman know when either of these are being used?" — "No, we are unable to tell which one has been used." "Did you get any answering signal from the banksman when you got the raps for men to ride?" — "No, it was not necessary for the banksman to interfere with the cage as only one cage is worked all day." "What do you mean when you say the banksman should give a signal?" — "When the ordinary cage I use is at bank we get the signal, but at that time the dummy cage was at bank and the signal was not necessary." BANKSMAN'S EVIDENCE Thomas Winn, of Lime Street, Waldridge, the banksman, stated that he heard the signal "6" given, meaning that the cage had to be lowered from the Low main to the Busty, then the cage was lowered and three raps given from the Busty. He did not reply to that signal. H. M. Inspector: "Why?" Witness; "I was busy unloading a cable from a tram." Continuing, Winn said the cage moved without a rap signalled from the top to the onsetter. He was ten or eleven yards away from the rapper and was too far away to give the customary "2" to the engineman. Inspector: "Don't you think it is your first duty to attend to the rapper and leave the cable alone?" Witness: "The cable was too heavy to leave with the other men who were with it." Answering Mr. Coulson, witness said that after he heard the "3" rap he was making to go over to give a signal back when the cage began to move. Further questioned, witness said [the?] absence of his signal did not in {any?] way [. . . .?] Mr. Coulson: "[. . . ?] men are riding that you do not [signal?] to the brakesman?" Witness: "I do it regularly, but did not do so on that occasion." NOT MANY "ODD JOBS" TO DO "Do you get many odd jobs to do?" — "Not many — loading timber and such like. These men came with the cable and asked for help to take it off." Mr. Coulson: "Having got three raps and being too busy to answer back, have the men continued to rap until they got a reply?" Witness: "On other occasions yes, but not on this occasion. — "They should wait for that '3'?" — "Yes." Mr. E. Cowen: "In your opinion the onsetter and banksman should be present when men are riding?" Witness: "Yes." [". . .] were not on this occasion[. . .?"] "No, the onsetter was at the pumphouse." Reading medical evidence that death was due to shock and toxaemia following laceration of the left thigh, the Coroner said it was rather remarkable that the injuries were so slight after the man had been dragged up the shaft for 60 feet then lowered down again. Summing up, the Coroner said they could not entirely remove the blame from the man himself as he must have known the safe method of signalling, especially when the witness Hindmarch, a much younger man, knew about it. "Even though these safety devices are there for their protection they have to be saved from themselves," he said. A verdict of "Accidental death" was returned.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||