1st July 1939, Page: 404, Column: 1
Correlation Of Coal Seams
Examination Procedure Explained
At the meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining
and Mechanical Engineers, on 10th June, Dr. Arthur Raistrick,
M.Sc., presented a paper on "The Correlation of Coal Seams
by Microspore-content, Part II. — the Trencherbone Seam, Lancashire,
and the Busty Seams, Durham." The first part of the
investigation was described about four years ago, and suggestions
were made as to the possible application of the study of the
microspore-content of coal to the problems of correlation of coal
seams. Examples of the investigation of seam samples were given
from several seams and localities in Northumberland. The
earlier work had suggested that the examination of the microspore
content of the coal of one seam, over a wide area, might be of
importance in establishing the correlation, and in bringing to
light difficulties and factors not prominent in correlations made
only over a short distance. In his present paper Dr. Raistrick
describes such an examination of two seams, the Trencherbone
Seam of Lancashire and the Busty Seams of Durham, carried out
some time ego. The examination of the coal of these seams at
a great number of localities (the Trencherbone from 28, and the
Busty, Top and Bottom, from 52) was made possible by the very
generous co-operation and help of the officers of the Fuel Research,
Coal Survey. Mr. N. Simpkin, of the Lancashire and Cheshire
Coal Research Association, kindly provided prepared (¼ inch
averaged) samples of the Trencherbone Seam, and Dr. J. R. Jones
of the Fuel Research, Coal Survey, Northumberland and Durham,
responded with similar samples of Busty Seam, coals from County
Durham.
The Trencherbone Seam.
Among the coal seams of the Lancashire coalfield the Trencherbone
coal is one of the most constant and most valuable. It lies
a little below the middle of the Middle Coal Measures, separated
from the Wigan Four Feet Coal above it, by various distances up
to 200 feet. It is a widespread seam and has received many
different names in different areas in the St. Helens area, the
Roger Mine, Top Roger, and the Wigan Nine Feet are synonyms,
and in the Oldham area it is often called the Oldham Great Mine.
The position of the Trencherbone is checked over much of the
coalfield by the presence of a "mussel-band" in the roof, containing
as characteristic fossils Carbonicola os-lancis with C.
rhomboidales, C. aff. similis, C. cf. communis, and
C. cf. ovalis.
The Trencherbone Rock, which lies only a short distance above
the coal, frequently descends and cuts out the "mussel-band"
and in may cases takes out part of the coal in a "wash-out."
These abnormalities, however, are local in their occurrence and
interfere little with the correlation of the seam.
The seam is made up of several component bands of recognisably
different coal ; usually in the area dealt with by Dr. Raistrick
in his paper the following sub-divisions are present, taken from
floor to roof — Bottom Coal, separated by a dirt-band from the
Bright Coal, then Top Hard Coal, and at the top of the seam
three poorer quality sub-sections, the Bacon, Clod, and Callis.
These sub-divisions characterise the seam over most of its area
and each is generally present even though the total seam varies
in thickness between, approximately, 4 and 9 feet.
For the microspore examination of this seam procedure was as
follows : Averaged whole seam samples were received with only
a laboratory number, and with no clue whatever to their locality.
When separations had been made and microspore counts had
enabled the general seam diagrams to be drawn for 22 samples,
the numbered diagrams were returned to Mr. Simpkin who placed
them in order by localities and provided a map showing their
distribution over the coalfield. The peculiarities of distribution
at once apparent suggested the desirability of further averaged
samples from certain areas, and of sub-section samples from a
few localities. This second batch again were supplied by number
only, but their localities were known approximately from the
discussion of the previous results. In order to obtain comparable
results, the whole of the separations of both Busty and Trencherbone
coals were made in the same way, i.e., the coal was crushed
to pass a 30-mesh solve and treated for 48 hours with Schulz
solution, then after repeated washings extracted with 10 per cent.
potassium hydrate solution. Two portions of the washed residue
were mounted, the first taken immediately from the well-shaken
residue, the second taken after 30 seconds settling of the mixture.
First slides tend to be dirty, but including everything present in
the separation they were useful as a check on the cleaner second
batch which was used for the counting.
The Busty Seams.
The Busty Seam is the principal coal between the Harvey
(Beaumont of Northumberland) and the Brockwell Seams, and
at a few areas is a single seam, 5 to 6 feet thick. Occasionally it
has two thin bands in it and the presence of these is generally
accepted as characteristic of the seam. In most areas of the
Durham coalfield one of the bands thickens, and in places where
it is more than 20 feet thick the two sections of the seem are
known as the Top and Bottom Busty Seams. In general, a Top
and a Bottom Busty coal are distinguished over most of the
Northumberland and Durham coalfield, and at. nearly all the
localities examined the two seams have been sampled. Difficulty
has been experienced with samples from West Durham, where the
Busty is a high-rank coal and the separation of spore material
has been tedious and often difficult.
Across the coalfield the volatile matter in this coal ranges
between 27 and 39 per cent., and this wide variation in rank of
a single seam has perhaps given the investigation of the spore-content
added interest and value.
As in the case of the Trencherbone Seam, the samples examined
were received under a laboratory number, localities being considered
later during the plotting of the results.
Following reference to the microspore diagrams Dr. Raistrick
said it was interesting to find that in Northumberland, around
Morpeth, the seams below the Beaumont correspond very closely
with those he had described in most parts of Durham and the
Tyne area, and that the Top and Bottom Bustys of Pegswood
are similar to the "Stone" and "Five Quarter" of the Tyne
area.
Above these is the "Harvey" (of Pegswood), which is like the
Top Busty of Marley Hill, then a few seams between that and the
Beaumont, which are not unlike the Tilley. A similar succession
is shown for Stobswood, where the Widdrington Yard Seam
appears to be the equivalent of a seam between the Beaumont
and "Harvey" of Pegswood, and can probably be taken as the
Tilley. The Widdrington Five Quarter and the "Harvey" of
Pegswood are then the equivalent of the Top Busty of Marley
Hill.
Great difficulty in this work of correlation has been experienced
with the group of seams between the Busty and Beaumont, which
have proved very similar in spore content but variable both in
position and thickness. The recognition of the Tilley horizon,
however, and its frequent approach to the Top Busty, clears up
some of the difficulties. There is sharp contrast between time
constancy of seams such as the Beaumont and true Busty, and
the group of inconstant and variable seams between them.
Correlation by microspores can be carried to considerable
distances in the constant seams, but beyond local comparisons
soon becomes very problematic among the inconstant seams. If
it is realised that these two types of seam reflect very different
physical conditions of formation, the one depending on very
uniform widespread coal swamps, with little earth movement to
interrupt events, and the other belonging to a period of instability.
with differential subsidence in various parts of the area, it will be
clear that any method of comparison will need modification from
one to the other.
The "instable" seams, such as the Tilley, are subject to
splitting at irregular intervals and to rapid variation in the quality
and thickness of their coal The more stable seams are more
constant in character, usually being associated with "mussel"
or "marine" bands, and with a very constant roof and floor. The
total interval between adjacent "stable" seams remains fairly
constant over wide areas, or changes gradually while the instable
seams may occupy rapidly varying positions within that interval.
The change from conditions of stability to instability are usually
associated with abundant "wash-out" phenomena.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Jones, J. R., Dr. | | | |
| Raistrick, Arthur, Dr. | | | |
| Simpkin, Neville | | | |