|
16th June 1939, Page: 1081, Column: 2 Notes From The Coal FieldsScotland[Local Correspondence.] An inquiry into the accident at Manor Powis Colliery, Causeway-head, Stirling, on March 25, when four miners lost their lives, opened at Stirling on Friday, June 9, before sheriff-substitute J. Dean Leslie. The evidence of the manager of the pit occupied most of the day's hearing. The inquiry was conducted by Mr. C. C. Cheyne, procurator-fiscal. Also present were Mr. A. Ferguson, solicitor, Dunfermline, for Manor Powis Coal Co. ; Mr. Thomas Cassells, M.P., solicitor, for relatives of deceased ; Mr. R. J. Edwards, senior inspector of mines (East Scotland) ; Mr. T. Ashley, divisional inspector of mines ; Mr. J. M. Harvey, H.M. deputy chief electrical inspector of mines ; Mr. Andrew MacAlpine, president of the British Deputies' Federation, and secretary of the Scottish Association, representing the firemen ; Mr. James Barbour, Plean, Stirlingshire Miners' Union ; and Mr. R. Johnstone, Larbert, chairman of the county union. First evidence was by widows of deceased men and by a sister, also by doctors. Medical opinion was to the effect that generally death was due to severe burns and shock. J. V. Spence, manager of the colliery, said the accident occurred in the evening in No. 2 pit. He produced a plan of the workings and spoke of the nature of the airways and of the place where the men were working at the time of the accident. They made an examination of the cable, he said, but at first could find nothing wrong. They then tested it electrically and found a small hole not more than ¼ in. in diameter. It had penetrated the insulation, which was burned. Witness at this point produced the actual piece of cable to which he was referring. With regard to the volume of air circulating, witness said that in this particular section it was a little over 3,000 cu. ft. per min., which was ample. The firemen's reports were generally "clear" or "good." Witness went on to explain that at the cross-cut between Nos. 2 and 3 headings there was a brattice screen to direct the ventilation, and that it was in good order. On the night of the accident several men who were working had been employed on the day shift. They were helping to brush a crossing between No. 2 and No. 3 headings. There were nine men altogether working overtime. Witness said the pit bottomer appointed was John Cargill. He was the person appointed to give signals. Cargill was not present on the day of the accident. When he arrived at the pit and went underground, continued Mr. Spence, he found signs of fire. The brattice screen at the cross-cut had been partly burned, but there was no appearance of force. The extent of roadway covered by the flame would be about 70 ft. Witness made an examination for gas shortly after he arrived, but found none. There was no fall from the roof. Asked if he had formed any opinion where the gas that ignited came from, witness said he thought it must have lodged or been emitted in between No. 2 and No. 3 headings at the face. There were three "faults" in the area, and their effect on the ventilation made the susceptibility to the emission of gas very much greater. Witness stated that the shift the men were engaged in started at 6 o'clock in the morning, and was due to finish at 12.30. Six of the men were still working when the accident happened at 7.45, but that was not, in witness's opinion, in contravention of the regulations. When the accident occurred the men were fixing up a live cable with a voltage of 400. Witness could not tell the age of the cable ; their records did not show. He denied that its appearance indicated it to be a very old cable. In his opinion, it was quite a good one. No inspection without the use of electricity would have shown the defect. Witness admitted that under date, February 11, 1939, there was an entry in the fireman's book, "strong feeder of gas in Nos. 2 and 3 headings, of 20 level. These places fenced off, remainder of section clear." Since then, he explained, the ventilation had been entirely changed. In reply to Mr. Ferguson, witness spoke of gas having been cleared away from the section before the accident. His explanation for the ignition half an hour later was that there must have been a sudden outburst of gas. It was something abnormal. Any gas before the ignition did the men no harm. The immediate cause of the accident was a flash from the cable. The explosion was described by one of the men who was injured, C. Rougvie (51), oversman. Cross-examined by Mr. Cassells, witness declared that adequate precautions had been taken to see that plenty of air was travelling round the face. He was asked if he considered it good mining practice to have men working at a live cable, he replied that he did, and that he still held that opinion. In answer to Mr. Ferguson, who asked if he could explain the ignition of gas, Rougvie stated : "I think it was due to a sudden issue of firedamp from the face owing to the crushing of strata, and the strong velocity of air blew the gas down before dilution took place to the point where the cable had earthed. When the gas met the cable there was an ignition." Witness added that he thought the men would not have been harmed by the amount of gas if there had been no ignition. The quantity, he thought, was very small. On Saturday the jury found that no one was to blame for the ignition of gas. Thomas Arbuckle (51), the fireman who was on duty at the time of the gas ignition, was warned by sheriff-substitute J. Dean Leslie that he need not answer any questions which he thought might incriminate him when he went into the witness-box. He explained that he made an examination before the back shift started and found no gas. On one occasion during the shift he found gas present in both headings, and as he thought the ventilation was a bit slack he shouted down to a roadsman to get No. 20 level door shut. When he made his last inspection at 7.30 p.m., approximately 15 min. before the accident, there was no sign of gas. Arbuckle said he made a further inspection after the accident, but he could not say if there was gas in No. 2 and 3 headings then. On Sunday morning he discovered a cavity in No. 2 heading, but there was no sign of gas in the cavity. Mr. R. J. Edwards, senior inspector of mines (East of Scotland), questioned witness about going with him to where the cavity was sometime about midnight on Sunday. Experiments carried out by witness along with Mr. Edwards in an endeavour to get an accumulation of gases at the face of Nos. 2 and 3 headings under certain conditions were described. In one of these experiments, when the door of No. 20 level and the brattice screen controlling the air current were left open for two hours and 13 min., No. 3 heading was found to be full of gas down to within 12 in. of the cross-cut. Arbuckle agreed that that was a dangerous accumulation of gas, and that if workmen had been there he would have got them out and cut off the electric current at the panels. Under cross-examination by Mr. Tom Cassells, Arbuckle admitted that the nature of the face was faulty. Gas would not actually gather while the ventilation was taking its proper course but, where there were breaks, gas did gather if the ventilation was not proper. He denied a suggestion that his test was a careless one because be knew there was no oncoming shift. Asked if it did not amount to this, that the air supply going up and down No. 3 heading was not sufficient to dissipate any accumulation of gas, witness replied that at times in that shift he found the ventilation was inadequate to allow men to work in it and pass in it. He said that if it had struck him that there was a possibility of sparking from the electric cable he would have immediately cleared the men out of the section. The fact that a test of the cable in No. 3 heading after the accident disclosed an earth fault was stated by Mr. George Denholm (42), chief electrical engineer at the colliery. The cable was about eight to 10 years old. Two colliery electricians stated that they had tested the cable in the course of the afternoon and found the results satisfactory. W. Courtney (36), chain runner, one of the five men seriously injured but who since recovered, told how he had gone towards the end of the shift with D. Berrie and A. McHattie (who both died) to tie up the cable at No. 3 heading. They were right on the plate at the junction of the cross-cut at No. 3 and were in the act of tying it up when the blast came. Courtney could not say where the defect in the cable was, but the flames seemed to come down No. 3 heading. J. V. Spence, manager of the colliery, was recalled on Saturday at the request of Mr. Cassells with reference to a statement made by him at Friday's hearing, that the pit bottomer had deserted his post on Saturday night. The manager was asked if it was not within his knowledge that instructions had been given to the pit bottomer that immediately all his men had been raised to the surface he was entitled to go to the surface too. He replied that the bottomer would be allowed to do so, but said it was not within his knowledge that the general practice was that the pit bottomer's work on Saturday finished at, roughly 10 minutes past six o'clock. Three hundred and fifty miners have been thrown out of work for an indefinite period by a fire which destroyed plant and machinery valued at £10,000 at Dean Colliery, Kingseat, Dunfermline, belonging to Kingseat Colliery Co., on Saturday, June 10. This is the third fire which has broken out at the same part of the colliery and at the same time during the past month. It started about 1 p.m., shortly after the colliery had ceased work for the day. Only the winding engineman was at the pithead at the time. Within 10 minutes the whole of the structure carrying the winding gear was ablaze. Four men employed on repair work were in the pit when the fire occurred, and although in no danger they were brought out, as a safety precaution, by Mr. Alexander Gray, mine manager, who entered the pit by way of the escape outlet. At that time no smoke was found at the pit bottom, 500 ft. below. Water had to be pumped from Loch Fifty, half a mile away. Mr. Thomson Smith, company's agent, could give no definite information as to how long it would be before the pit resumed operations. As the charred buildings and winding gear constitute a danger, they are to be demolished. Kinneil Cannel and Coking Coal Co., Ltd., a subsidiary of Lochgelly Iron and Coal Co., Ltd., has decided to re-open the shaft of No. 4 pit, Snab Bo'ness, in order to work the coal to the south, an area which has not hitherto been tapped. No. 4 pit was closed 13 years ago. It lies adjacent to the old ironstone workings which were in full swing when the blast furnaces at Kinneil were in operation many years ago. The pit was closed during a period of dull trade in the coal industry, but since prospects are favourable to-day, and as there is known to be lying dormant a large area of coal, 7 ft. thick, at a depth of 100 fm., it has been decided to develop the seam. For that purpose there has been installed modern machinery, including up-to-date conveyors. The coal will be conveyed in hutches from the Snab to the company's pithead at Furnaceyard where it will be classified for marketing. It is understood that a total output of from 1,200 to 1,500 tons per day is aimed at by the company. As the developments proceed, an additional 100 men will be employed. Meantime, three shifts have been arranged for 50 men.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||