|
16th June 1939, Page: 1080, Column: 1 Notes From The Coal FieldsLancashire and Cheshire[Local Correspondence.] Work was resumed on Tuesday, June 13, at Astley Green Colliery, near Leigh, where five men were killed when a series of explosions took place in the pit last week. An inspection was made on Sunday morning of the sealing of the district affected by the accident, and it was declared that the unaffected parts of the mine were safe for working. All districts in No. 1 and No. 2 pits were opened for work with the exception of the East Crombouke and the East Rams districts of No. 2 pit. The case in which serious allegations have been made regarding the working conditions at the No. 9 pit of the Garswood Hall Colliery, Ashton-in-Makerfield, Lancs, was continued at the Wigan County Police Court at a special sitting on Tuesday, June 6. The hearing was adjourned from Friday, March 31 last. Defendants were the Garswood Hall Colliery Co., Ltd., Mr. Harold Whitehead, agent to the company, and Mr. Jack Latham, mine manager. Defendants were each summoned for allowing persons to travel on a haulage road, of which the roof and sides were not secure, for failing to provide adequate means of ventilation, for failing to provide refuge holes, for failing to fence dangerous machinery, for allowing inflammable material in the mine, for failing to provide adequate means of extinguishing fire and for failing to make secure the roof and sides of the main haulage road. In addition, the manager, Mr. Latham, answered a summons alleging failure to appoint a colliery fireman in writing. Mr. Percy Butlin, barrister, appeared for the Director of Public Prosecutions, Mr. Hartley Shawcross, K.C. and Mr. Crichton, barrister, were for the colliery company, Mr. Pritchard, K.C. and Mr. Selwyn Lloyd, barrister, for the manager, and Mr. Selwyn Lloyd appeared also separately for the agent, Mr. Whitehead. At the previous hearing, Mr. Butlin strongly criticised the alleged lack of ventilation in what was looked upon as a "gassy" mine, and also the temporarily unsafe roadway between No. 4 and 5 brows, where falls of roof were said to have frequently occurred. Such falls occurred on the night of November 13 and also November 14 last, and on the second of these nights a fireman named James Duffy lost his life through gas. Mr. E. H. Fraser, inspector of mines, spoke of samples of air and gas taken on the day after the fatality, and of the unsafe conditions of the roadways, particularly the main haulage road, which was "on the move," and liable to fall at any time. It was unsafe throughout, the roof and sides he described as terrible. It was the worst continuous length of mine road he had ever seen. The condition of the haulage engine house and machinery was shocking, the machinery being unfenced and unsafe generally. Mr. Fraser also said he found the men working in unsafe conditions, travelling on the haulage road. There was lack of means to extinguish fire. A request for reports made by H.M. inspectors concerning the mine during the past three years was made by Mr. Hartley Shawcross. Mr. Butlin said the matter had been considered by the Mines Department and it was felt that it was against public interests for the report to be disclosed. Mr. Hartley Shawcross said it was essential to public interests that these documents should be read in court. He asked for the name of the person who had custody of the report, and said if he were not given the name of that person he would have to ask for a subpoena against the Secretary for Mines to produce the document the following day (Wednesday). It was decided to communicate with the Mines Department by telephone. Later there was considerable argument as to whether certain documents — the reports of the mines' inspectors for the six months prior to November 15, 1938 — were privileged or whether they should be produced. Mr. Butlin said the instructions to the prosecution were to give the defence any proper assistance, but it was not in the public interest that the documents referred to should be produced. The notice to produce documents which had been served by the defence called for all the reports made during the past three years, but now he understood that only the reports for the last six months would be asked for. In that period there were only two reports, and the two inspectors who made them could go into the witness box, and questions as to what they saw and the conditions of the mine could be asked, and anything else that was relevant. What they said in confidence to the Government Department should, however, not be disclosed. They were confidential reports from one officer to another, and if their contents were to be disclosed officers would be prevented from speaking with freedom. Mr. Butlin added that he was going to call a responsible officer from the Mines Department who would produce a written authority signed by the Secretary for Mines that it would be against the public interest that the documents should be produced. Mr. C. H. de Peyer, principal clerk in the Mines Department, then produced the document signed by the Secretary for Mines to which Mr. Butlin had referred. Mr. Pritchard said the document produced was not an affidavit. He would have thought that the paramount consideration was that the court should be informed of all matters. There was no evidence as to whether the Secretary for Mines had seen the reports and there was no opportunity for the defence to cross-examine whoever had seen them. It was, he said, contrary to all the principles of criminal law. Mr. Shawcross said the objection was taken as a general principle concerning a class of documents, and in the interests of justice defendants should have access to the reports. The court should have the opportunity of saying whether the claim to priviledege is well founded or not. The Mines Department in effect was prosecuting, and it was not right that the decision should rest with the Department as to whether the reports were privileged or not. Mr. Pritchard associated himself with Mr. Shawcross's point that the court should be the judges. Following further argument. Mr. Butlin announced that an affidavit would be produced from the Secretary for Mines saying that he had seen the reports, and whether or not it was in the public interest to produce them. Mr. David Coatesworth, senior inspector of mines, who accompanied Mr. Fraser into the No. 9 pit of the Garswood Hall Colliery on November 15, when they investigated the conditions following the death of James Duffy, the fireman, described the conditions of the haulage road as "terrible," and said props and bars were broken and displaced, refuge holes had been crushed in, all of which must have been done months before. There was no fencing on the haulage engine near which was inflammable material such as wooden props, chocks, etc., and there was not adequate fire extinguishing apparatus. A submission by Mr. Pritchard, when the case for the prosecution was concluded, that the summons against Mr. Latham alleging failure to appoint a fireman in writing should be dismissed, as there was no evidence of a breach of the section, was argued against by Mr. Butlin, but succeeded when the bench gave defendant the benefit of the doubt and dismissed it. Jack Latham, the defendant manager, giving evidence, said the accident to Duffy had happened when he (defendant) arrived at the pit at 6.30 a.m. He was informed that a fall had occurred leaving a cavity in the roof in which there was gas, and that Duffy had climbed on to the debris of the fall to look for gas in the roof, having only his electric lamp. Duffy should have tested with the flame lamp which was supplied to him for the purpose. Defendant returned to the surface after inspecting the place and testing for gas, but went below ground again at 7.15. The pressure was still heavy and he gave instructions for the men working near the fall to be brought out and put on repair work. During the previous week-end the weight had disturbed the engine which "absolutely went mad." The drum of the engine was jammed into the roof of the roadway. The weight prior to the death of Duffy had caused a brick wall, part of the engine house, to collapse, and that revealed a packing of chocks of wood built long ago outside the wall as a protection against the roof for the wall. The engine house was built before his time. There were means for extinguishing fire — bags of sand. There was in fact no danger of fire from a haulage engine which could not be worked. Regarding ventilation he said he never received any complaints from the men working there, and he contended that the ventilation was sufficient, adding that it would have been an easy matter to increase it if it had been necessary. In the length of roadway referred to — 259 ft. — there had been three good refuge holes, but during the repair work the previous week-end some refuse had been shovelled into them. Cross-examined by Mr. Butlin defendant said the ventilation there was natural, cold air going along the floor, and the heat of the coal combining with it. The pit might be considered a gassy mine compared with the generality of Lancashire mines. There had been an explosion in that mine, but it was not a big explosion, although unfortunately 26 men lost their lives through it. He contended that the system and amount of ventilation were quite adequate. Mr. Fraser recalled to give evidence on the summons regarding failure to make secure the roof and sides of the main haulage road, said he knew that an inspection of the place was made on November 15, also by Mr. Chamberlain and Mr. Hughes, both of whom were appointed by the workmen to make the inspection on their behalf, and a copy of their report was sent to him. Answering Mr. Pritchard witness said Mr. Wilton, the sub-inspector, having examined the place on October 19 last, had made a report and sent it to him, but witness could not say whether he had read it or not. Mr. Shawcross, protesting against the failure of the prosecution to call Mr. Wilton as a witness, said the owners were really ignorant of the actual conditions obtaining in that pit, and he himself on their behalf wished to obtain all the facts which could be given in evidence. It was the duty of the prosecution to call all available evidence, yet Mr. Wilton, who had submitted a report on an inspection he had made in the pit, had not been called even, though he was actually in court. Mr. Butlin said it was only for the first time the previous day that the prosecution discovered that Mr. Wilton had made a report within the material period. He had then closed the case for the prosecution but if the bench now desired to have Mr. Wilton called as a witness he would be so tendered and could be there during the day. Evidence for the defence was then given by a number of witnesses, including Albert Clough, under-manager at the pit, Joseph Patmore, fireman, James Henry Bradshaw, night shift fireman, John Henry Storer, afternoon shift fireman, Joseph Brookfield, collier, William Smith, engine house fitter, Emrys Tattum, shotfirer, John Read, timberman, and Mr. William Sword, who at the time of the alleged offences was general manager for the collieries. Mr. Sword said that to describe the condition of the haulage road as "terrible" was the language of extravagance. There were 20 bags of sand near the engine house. The ventilation was good. When witness sat down on the ground in the place he could plainly feel the movement of the air. Mr. Pritchard submitted that the whole of the evidence given went to show that until the accident the whole of the level was sufficiently ventilated as required by the Act, and there was no evidence before the court that there was any gas in the level prior to the accident. He submitted that no case had been made out against Mr. Latham regarding the ventilation or the refuge holes, which beyond the shadow of doubt were there. After commenting on the prosecution not having called Mr. Wilton, the inspector, as a witness Mr. Pritchard asked that all the summonses against the manager be dismissed. In addition to the summonses alleging failure to appoint a fireman in writing, the bench also decided to dismiss three further summonses against the manager, namely, alleging failure to fence dangerous machinery, allowing inflammable material in the mine, and failure to provide adequate means of extinguishing a fire. The case was further adjourned until June 30 when the bench will announce their decision on the four remaining summonses against the manager.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||