9th June 1939, Page: 1043, Column: 1
Workmen's Compensation Commission
"Miners get very low pay, but their risk is higher than anyone's,"
asserted Mr. J. L. Smyth, of the Insurance Department of the Trades
Union Congress, in the course of his questioning of Sir Arnold Wilson,
M.P., who resumed his evidence before the Royal Commission on Workmen's
Compensation, sitting at Thames House, Millbank, London, S.W.1, on Thursday,
Sir Hector Hetherington presiding. Sir Arnold answered that he
thought the transport industry was more prone to accidents. The general
occupational mortality rate, as worked out by the Registrar-Genera1, he added,
was a more reliable guide than the general accident claims.
Mr. J. L. Smyth asked if it were perfectly true that the mining industry
had at least twice as much compensation paid it as any other industry, and
twice as many accidents. — Sir Arnold replied that in order to
compare properly it was necessary to begin by cutting out certain types of
accidents. If the average wages of a miner at the face — a particular
group of men who are most liable to accident — were taken in full
employment, and not one who was under employed, it would be found that his rate
of pay compared favourably with other types of employment where the accident
rate was high.
Continuing, Mr. Smyth asked the witness if it were true that 75 per
cent. of the accidents occurred to 25 per cent. of the total exposed to the
risk. — Sir Arnold replied that he did not regard those statistics
as thoroughly satisfactory. He would not accept that as a general application
to industry as a whole. That statement was based upon a very small number of
figures in a very few industries. He would contest it emphatically in the
mining industry, and contest it in the shipping and the dock industries. It was
far more applicable to the transport industry, and far more applicable —
mostly to injuries of a minor sort — in machine shops.
Mr. Smyth said he was only reporting the findings of independent
research inquiries. He had heard the statement made by members of the Medical
Research Council, and he had heard if so often that he was beginning to think
it was true. One had got to depend upon those inquiries from time to time for
the only data they had on the subject.
In answer to Mr. R. R. Bannatyne, the witness agreed that a large number
of the accidents in industry occurred within a limited number of industries.
Mr. Smyth said that did appear to point to the necessity of complete
rehabilitation; did it give the idea that people were returning to work before
they were properly fit, and were therefore more prone to accidents? —
Sir Arnold replied that he was most anxious for complete rehabilitation.
Mr. Smyth suggested that people were injured over and over again, and
that this was because they did not yet enough to remain out of work and
rehabilitate themselves. They got back to work before they were ready, and was
it not likely in view of that that they would be worried ? — Sir
Arnold said he knew of no evidence whatever. He did know that in the
R.A.F., if a man had an accident the immediate cure was to go up again to
recover his morale.
Mr. Smyth retorted that R.A.F. men were looked after, and were not
likely to be hurried back to work. He repeated that worry and under-nourishment
might lead to liability to a further accident. — Sir Arnold
replied that the facts at his disposal did not support the thesis. London
Transport employees, he added, who were on full pay following accidents, and
were not likely to be hurried to return to work, were just as liable to further
accident.
Questioned further on the subject of rehabilitation, Sir Arnold said he
was anxious for complete rehabilitation, and said he was confident that
industry could afford to give the best treatment. It was not so much a matter
of cost and of "burdening an industry," as a question of organisation
outside the industry.
Mr. Smyth asked if witness suggested that the workers should contribute.
— Sir Arnold replied that he had suggested in his memorandum that
the workers should contribute from ½d. to 1½d. per week. Mr.
Smyth asked if the risks of the job should be taken into account in the
compensation paid. — Sir Arnold replied that that was done now. No
insurance scheme was sound, and no administration was sound, he added, unless
the men and the employers were jointly represented on the administration, and
if the men were to have a real interest in it, they should contribute
something. Further on this point, Sir Arnold pointed out that the Durham
Miners' Association had a joint committee to deal with the scheme in their
case, and he thought it would be found that it worked all right. Mr.
Smyth said Durham miners had a joint committee that settled claims
certainly, but they did not contribute. — Sir Arnold replied that
if the workers did contribute they would be in a far stronger position than
they now were. If they did contribute, they would have a controlling voice.
Mr. Smyth went on to suggest that if the workers were to contribute to
the scheme, then their wages should be adjusted, according to the risks to
which they were exposed, and in order to allow them to pay the levy.
The chairman asked if witness suggested a differential contribution. That
should be borne by the employer. Did witness suggest a flat rate for the
workers? — Sir Arnold said, yes. As an example of his scheme,
Sir Arnold said that seven million men at 2d. per head per week, and
four million women, at 1d. per head per week, would bring in about £5
million a year. This would cover the basic liability for compensation at a
considerably higher scale than at present for all workmen, leaving a sum
approximately equal to be raised by the employers in the seven principal
industries in which approximately all accidents occurred.
Sir Arnold went on to advocate the setting up of training centres for
the rehabilitation of injured workmen. In his experience, he said, to the
average man, six months study and continuous instruction at an unemployed
training centre was of more benefit than three years apprenticeship. He had
seen some astonishing results from these centres, and he knew from his own
experience of attending these centres that they produced really good work.
Mr. Smyth asked if witness was suggesting that the Ministry of Labour
training system was equal to years of apprenticeship. — Sir Arnold
replied that he would say it was as good as five years in some industries.
— Mr. Smyth retorted that it was a strange thing then that the
Ministry did not ask for more than 10d. per hour for the trainees when they
went out on to the labour market.
Sir Arnold went on to suggest that the miners' mutual indemnity should
run their own rehabilitation centre, and that the iron, steel and shipbuilding
industries should likewise have separate training centres. All the
rehabilitation centres should, in his view, be subject to some control by the
proposed (in his scheme) workmen's compensation commissioner, with the
Ministries of Health and Labour holding a "watching brief."
Evidence was then tendered by the Ministry of Pensions, and the Commission
adjourned to take further evidence.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bannatyne, R. R. | | | |
| Hetherington, Hector, Sir | | President | |
| Smyth, J. L. | | T.U.C. | |
| Wilson, Arnold, Sir | | M.P. | |