|
22nd April 1939, Page: 321, Column: 1 Colliery Explosions And Fires — IIncidence Rates Compared. In the period 1911-35 (excluding 1936) 1,016 persons lost their lives as a consequence of explosions in the mines of Great Britain. Injuries from the same cause were suffered by 2,945 persons. The Safety Commission in their Report* explain that the deaths represent not quite 7½ per cent. of the total fatalities in that period, and the compensable injuries account for little more than one in 1,500 of the total compensable injuries during the same period. While on a strictly statistical basis, therefore, explosions are among the less important causes of mining accidents, there is no other cause except fire or flood which is more capable of resulting in so many casualties in one occurrence, and it is the persistence of occasional large-scale disasters more than the never-ceasing toll of accidents from other causes which impresses on the public consciousness and conscience the danger of the miner's calling. The danger of explosion is one which in most areas is inherent in coal mining, and the Commissioners say it is a tribute to the success of the extensive precautions which are taken and the constant watch which is kept that the casualty list is relatively so light. At the same time the risk of great disaster is always present, even from the smallest beginnings, and the question whether the precautions cannot be still further intensified is one which constantly engages the attention of mining research workers and engineers. Between 1850 and 1872 the death-rate from explosions per 1,000 persons employed was halved. Over the next 40 years that reduced rate was further reduced by three-quarters, and in the 20 years between 1912 and 1932 a still further reduction of nearly two-thirds was effected, so that the average rate in the ten years 1923-32 (0.06) was less than one-twentieth of the corresponding average in the five years 1851-5 (1.28). For the last few years, however, the figures suggest that the impetus towards reduction in the rate given by the additional safeguards imposed in 1911 and 1920 had spent itself, and that new safeguards will be essential if further improvement is to be achieved and thereafter maintained. It was pointed out by the Institution of Mining Engineers that, although there continued on the average to be a reduction in the number of explosions occurring annually, the average number of killed was tending to rise, while the average number of injured. though less, was not reduced in the same proportion as the number of explosions ; in other words, the severity rate of explosions was on the increase. The Institution did not think this was to be attributed to mechanisation, unless the increased size of roads had something to do with it, but the Commissioners regard it as difficult to avoid the conclusion that it may in part be a consequence of the greater concentration of workmen in smaller working areas, and the increase in the rate of emission of firedamp and in the production of coal dust, all of which are direct results of mechanical mining. The obvious precautions against explosions, it is pointed out, are to maintain such a standard of ventilation as will minimise the risk of accumulation of inflammable gas, to keep a constant and effective watch in order that any accumulation of gas is detected at the earliest possible moment, to remove or render harmless any accumulations of coal dust, and to remove or restrict the use of any means of ignition in places where there is any possibility of danger. The causes of ignitions arranged in order of their frequency as measured by the average number of occurrences resulting in personal injury during the five years 1931-5 comprise the following : naked lights ; shot-firing ; electricity ; matches and smoking ; underground fires and safety-lamps, damaged, defective or illegally opened. There is also a small number of occurrences (about three or four per cent. of the total) which in the statistics are grouped together as "miscellaneous or unknown" this group includes the few instances for which even after exhaustive inquiry there is insufficient evidence to attribute a definite cause, and includes also instances believed to be due to metallic or mineral sparks resulting from impact of metal on rock, or to heating caused by friction. A table in the Report shows that naked lights account for nearly three-quarters of the total number of occurrences, and that the only causes indicating an increasing tendency are electricity, and matches and smoking. These comparisons are based on the numbers of separate occurrences rather than on the numbers of persons killed and injured, because (except for ignitions due to naked lights which hardly ever affect more than a very localised area) the extent of the explosion and the number of persons involved in it are governed by factors that are largely independent of the cause. The increase in the severity of each occurrence, however, applies to each class of cause except naked lights and safety-lamps. Few Explosions in France. In France, in recent years, there has been a remarkable freedom from explosions. In the ten years 1925-34, the number of explosions involving death was only 11 in France compared with 117 in this country, and in the four years 1931-4 there were no fatal explosions at all in France while the number in this country was 44. On the basis of numbers employed below ground the industry in this country is about four times bigger than in France, but even when allowance is made for this difference in size the disparity is very striking. In 1937 Major H. M. Hudspeth, then a Deputy Chief Inspector of Mines, examined each cause separately in a Mines Department report (Cmd. 5566) and came to the conclusion that the difference is due principally to the almost complete absence of naked lights in France and to the fact that French geological conditions operate against the use of electricity (or indeed of any machinery other than pneumatic picks) at the face. For shot-firing and safety-lamps the death-rates in the two countries approximate fairly closely. Major Hudspeth added, however, that "The higher the standard of the ventilation the greater must be the factor of safety against the occurrence in given conditions of an ignitable mixture of firedamp and air; and it seems clear that there is in France a broad general relation of cause and effect between a high statutory standard of ventilation and a low accident rate from explosions." Naked Lights and Explosions. Accidents caused by naked lights were responsible for 73.3 per cent., of explosions from all causes in the years 1931-35. These accidents are confined to those arising from the use of naked lights for purposes of illumination. They result from the ignition of small accumulations or pockets of firedamp, generally in cavities or in the neighbourhood of faults, in mines in which the occurrence of firedamp in any quantity is relatively rare. Most of them occur in the Scotland and Northern Divisions where the proportion of persons employed in naked light and mixed light mines is much higher than elsewhere. The obvious way of further reducing their occurrence is to require the more general use of safety-lamps in place of naked lights. In consequence of the recommendations in the Second Report (1909) of the Royal Commission on Mines, the Coal Mines Act, 1911 (Section 32 (1)) provided more explicitly than had previously been the case for the use of locked safety-lamps in seams in which the ventilation failed to ensure a certain standard of freedom from inflammable gas. Previously there had only be en general provisions requiring the use of locked safety-lamps in any place where, owing to the presence of inflammable gas, or the likelihood of its presence in the vicinity, the use of naked lights would be dangerous. The provisions of Section 32 (1) (a) are not sufficiently effective in practice, owing to the standard of ventilation laid down not being high enough to require the use of safety-lamps in many of the mines in which they are in fact used throughout because the management think it necessary to do so in the interests of safety. When the danger from gas is sporadic and intermittent-small and perhaps transitory accumulations in cavities in the face workings of the rippings, here to-day and then not again until next week-it is clear that a safeguard which is based on averaging the firedamp content in the return airway over a lengthy period of time cannot be effective. A survey of the return air from nearly 3,000 ventilating districts, carried out by H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines in the years 1930-2, showed that nearly 70 per cent. of these districts had a firedamp content of less than per cent. All these districts were in mines in which safety-lamps were used, and it is evident that a good many of the managements concerned had set themselves a higher standard in this matter than the law required. The Commissioners say it would be only in accordance with well established principles to bring the law at least into conformity with general practice, and so deal with those few managements who follow the letter of the law rather than the standard of good practice set by the industry. If the provision is retained it should not be based on averages, nor should it be limited to ventilating districts. Moreover, there are various consequential provisions applying to mines in which safety-lamps are required to be used, such, for instance, as those relating to the examination, unlocking and re-lighting of lamps (Section 34) and the right to search workmen for contraband (Section 35), which create difficulties, both for the managements and for the inspectors, at mines in which, though safety-lamps are used, it cannot be held that their use is legally required. Certain considerations lead the Commissioners to have serious doubts whether the law relating to the use of safety-lamps is framed at present on the right principle. The underlying principle of Section 32 in its present form is that naked lights can safely be used except in certain circumstances (which in the nature of the case cannot be defined with any real precision) where their use is likely to be dangerous and where, therefore, the use of safety-lamps is required. That is accounted for, no doubt, by the historical development of the present situation; but it would seem to the Commissioners to be more appropriate and certainly safer to provide that safety-lamps shall be used in all mines except in those where the use of naked lights is safe. The obligation should be on the owner or management to prove that the mine can safely be worked with naked lights and not on the inspector to prove that it is dangerous to do so. It is recommended that Section 32 (1) be amended on the following lines: No lamp or light other than a locked safety-lamp shall be allowed or used in any seam unless : (a) the seam is one in which no inflammable gas has been seen on the lowered flame of a flame safety-lamp in any road or working which has not been abandoned; or (b) an exemption from the use of safety-lamps has been granted by the district inspector in accordance with general regulations. Shot-firing Accidents. During the twenty-five years 1911-1935 the estimated number of shots fired has increased by nearly 12 per cent., and it is gratifying to find that there has been no corresponding increase in the number of explosions attributed to shot-firing, but rather a tendency in the opposite direction, though unfortunately, in common with other causes, this has been accompanied by an increase in the average number of casualties per explosion. That the number of ignitions from shot-firing is relatively less than it used to be is no doubt to be attributed mainly to the great expansion in the use of permitted " explosives, to the increasing safety factor in the permitted explosives themselves, and to the substitution in some instances of other methods of bringing down coal. It has been pointed out over and over again in the annual reports of the mines inspectors that there could be few, if any, accidents from the use of explosives, whether from ignitions of firedamp or other causes, if the requirements of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order were strictly observed, and that the occurrence of accidents is in itself prima facie evidence of some breach of the Order. The problem of ensuring a higher standard of practice in the matter of shot-firing therefore demands full consideration, equally with the question of what further safeguards, if any, can be devised to reduce the risk of an ignition occurring if by some neglect or mischance a breach of the statutory requirements has been committed. Substitutes for Explosives. Examining the question how far it is possible to substitute other methods than explosives for bringing down coal, or rock, and whether the voluntary adoption of substitutes, which so far has made comparatively little progress, could be stimulated by legislative action, the Commissioners say there are instances where advantage can be taken of the natural conditions, such as weighing and cleavage, to get down coal, or even rock, without recourse to anything more powerful than, ordinary tools wielded by hand, such as the pick, crowbar or hammer and wedge or feathers. But if more substantial mechanical assistance is required the list of alternatives is not a long one : it comprises various forms of pneumatic picks, various forms of hydraulic wedges, and certain devices depending on the sudden release of compressed gas. This last group comprises the appliances known as Cardox and Hydrox Cartridges, which differ from "explosives," in the ordinary sense, chiefly (for the present purpose) in the fact that the low temperature at which they work renders them incapable of igniting firedamp. At present Cardox and Hydrox cartridges are regarded as "explosives" for the purposes of Section 61 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911 (although, strictly speaking, only the heaters and initiators are explosives within the meaning of the Explosives Act, 1875), because if they were not so regarded there would be no means of regulating their use. The Commissioners recommend that this technical difficulty be overcome by extending Section 61 to cover, as well as explosives, "any appliances designed to produce a similar effect," and so provide for Cardox and Hydrox and inventions of similar character being separately regulated if necessary. They also recommend that the use of such appliances be encouraged to the fullest possible extent compatible with safety by giving them relief from such of the provisions relating to explosives as the nature of the appliance renders inapplicable or unnecessary. The Commissioners recognise the difficulty of defining any general conditions under which the use of alternatives might be required by statute. They hope that the inspectors will continue to do all in their power to encourage trials with alternatives and to secure their adoption where practicable, and hope that the inspectors efforts in this direction will be facilitated by the relaxation of the present precautions which the Commissioners have recommended for Cardox and Hydrox and similar approved appliances. Relative Safety of Permitted Explosives. During the last 25 years there, has been a constantly progressive turnover from non-permitted to permitted explosives, the number of shots fired with the former having been approximately halved while the number fired with the latter has been approximately doubled. At the same time, a number of important witnesses expressed the opinion that the use of permitted explosives should be required in all seams in which safety-lamps are used (whether required to be used or not), and in view of the advantages, from the point of view of consistency, simplicity and safety, that would ensue, the Commissioners recommend that this course be adopted. It may be, however, when experience has been gained of the results of systematically measuring the firedamp content in the return air from each district, that it will be found possible and preferable to make use of these results for more precisely defining the conditions under which the use of permitted explosives should be required. The tests to which explosives are subjected before being put on the permitted list are designed to secure as high a factor of safety as possible when shots (up to the maximum permissible charge) are flied in the presence of inflammable gas or coal dust, but the conditions of test not as rigorous as the conditions of use may sometimes be, and in particular it is known that a permitted explosive can ignite firedamp if it is detonated in direct contact with an explosive mixture. This condition may arise in practice if the shot-hole crosses a break in the strata, or if the shot-hole is so heavily overcharged that the rock breaks down in such a manner as to expose the charge before the whole of it has detonated. It seems likely that many, if not most, of the explosions resulting from shot-firing with permitted explosives have been the consequence of charging and firing holes in or near which there were undetected breaks. A good deal could, and should, be done by the management in providing shot-firers with proper tools for the detection of breaks and seeing that they are properly trained in their use. But according to evidence received from the Safety in Mines Research Board, and from Messrs. Imperial Chemical Industries, Ltd., the most practical safeguard against both this risk and that of overcharged shots is the use of sheathed explosives. It has been concluded that the sheath increases the factor of safety four times, though it must be admitted that this test does not represent any condition actually met with in shot-firing and does not necessarily provide any basis on which to draw conclusions as to what would happen when the charge is confined or partly confined in a shot-hole. But the conclusion is supported by the practical experience available. In Belgium half the consumption of explosives in coal mines is sheathed, and there has been no ignition of gas or coal dust with sheathed explosives in that country since they were first introduced, ten years or more ago, in the course of which, it is understood, about 13 million pounds have been used. In this country sheathed explosives were first used in 1933. By the end of 1937, it is estimated that over 14,000,000 pounds had been used, without an ignition of gas or dust. On this consumption at least six ignitions might have been expected with ordinary permitted explosives seeing that, in the seven years preceding 1934, there was on an average one ignition for every 2.3 million pounds used. These figures provide the strongest possible argument for requiring all permitted explosives to be sheathed. * Cmd. 5890. 7s. 6d. net, H.M. Stationery Office.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||