|
8th April 1939, Page: 311, Column: 2 Central Appeal TribunalIts Constitution and PowersThe first case to come to a hearing before the Central Appeal Tribunal was the appeal by the Newcastle-upon-Tyne and Gateshead Gas Company, referred to elsewhere in this journal. The Tribunal consisted of Mr. Norman Daynes, K.C. (chairman), Mr. E. Furnival Jones, and Dr. A. W. Pickard-Cambridge. In his opening statement the chairman referred as follows to the circumstances leading up to the constitution of the Tribunal and the powers which have been conferred on the Tribunal "It is widely known that since the passing of the Coal Mines Act, 1930, the production, supply and sale of coal from coalfields in Great Britain have been regulated by a central scheme and a number of district schemes. The central scheme has been administered by a central Council. Each district scheme has been administered by an Executive Board. Complaints with regard to the operation of a scheme have been made to a Committee of Investigation. Each district has its own Committee of Investigation. A Committee of Investigation to which a complaint has been made has had to consider whether there has been any act or omission of any persons in respect of their functions under the scheme of such a kind that it was having or was likely to have an effect contrary to the public interest or ought not to be permitted on the ground that it was unfair or inequitable. "So far the procedure has not been altered. I come now to the alterations made by the Coal Act, 1938. Before that Act was passed the next step lay with the Committee of Investigation. If the Committee thought that the complainant had made a case, whether under the words 'contrary to the public interest' or under the words 'unfair or inequitable,' it used to lie with the Committee to make representations with respect thereto to the Executive Board or the other persons having power under the scheme to rectify the matter. If upon such representations being made the matter was not dealt with to the satisfaction of the Committee it used to lie with the Committee to refer the matter to a single arbitrator. The arbitrator in default of agreement was to be appointed by the Board of Trade. "The position, therefore, was that in the case of a complaint as to the Operation of a scheme the Executive Board were not bound to the decision of a Committee of Investigation unless such decision was confirmed by an arbitrator. Further, if a Committee of Investigation declined to go on to arbitration then (subject to a right of appeal by leave to the Railway and Canal Commission) the last word in carrying the matter further rested with the Committee. Moreover, if the Committee rejected a complaint the complainant had no right to go to arbitration by way of appeal. "The position has now been substantially changed. The Coal Mines Act, 1930, has been amended by the Coal Act, 1938. As amended it provides in effect that the Executive Board or other persons having power under a scheme to rectify the matter complained of shall henceforth exercise their functions under the scheme in conformity with the decision of the Committee of Investigation. The power of the Committee to refer the matter to a single independent arbitrator has been repealed. In its stead this Central Appeal Tribunal has been constituted. To this Tribunal not only any person aggrieved by the decision of a Committee of Investigation but also the Executive Board charged with the duty of administering the scheme, or the Central Council, may appeal within a specified period. It does not matter whether the complaint is endorsed by the Committee or rejected. There is still the right of appeal; and the Committee will no longer be a party to the arbitration. "The Coal Act, 1938, also provides that all evidence taken by the Tribunal shall, except in so far as it relates to any particular business or undertaking, or unless the Tribunal for any special reason otherwise decide, be taken in public. In addition to the parties to the arbitration the Tribunal have power to hear any person whom they may think it proper to hear. "Finally, I may point out that it is the duty of the Tribunal to report the decisions of the Tribunal to the Board of Trade; and the Board of Trade have full powers for enforcing the decisions of the Tribunal."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||