|
8th April 1939, Page: 309, Column: 1 Dust In Hard HeadingsBy J. Ivon Graham, D. G. Skinner and W. H. Walton. Extracts from paper on "The Production of Dust in Hard Headings and Means for its Suppression." Presented at 49th annual general meeting of the Institution of Mining Engineers. Apart from the anthracite coalfield, the majority of certified cases of silicosis would appear to be connected with work in a hard or rock heading. The investigation of the concentration and composition of the air-borne dust in hard headings is, therefore, of importance in the study of the environmental conditions responsible for the causation of silicosis and of means for its prevention. The paper describes studies in headings in collieries in Kent, North and South Staffordshire, Somerset, Wales, and Yorkshire, and, in particular, the effect of certain measures which are taken to reduce dust formation, such as the employment of the Hay mist projector during and after shot-firing, the use of suction ventilation combined with an auxiliary fan, and the employment of protective measures during drilling. In making gravimetric tests it is important to sample at a standard height, since the relative gravimetric concentrations at differing distances from the roof may vary greatly. In the shot-firing tests, one position of sampling was adhered to for each set of tests, except in the case of H Colliery, where sampling was also carried out in the ventilation pipe. Ventilation in Headings. A disadvantage of the use of suctional ventilation in a heading is that the bulk of the air between the end of the ventilation pipe and the face of the heading remains comparatively stagnant, and so, after shot-firing, the dust tends to clear but slowly. To show the inefficiency of the exhaust ventilating system in removing dust-laden air from the region between the end of the ventilation pipe and the face of the heading, after the firing of a shot, konimeter spots were taken, at 15-second intervals, alternately at each of two sampling points — (i) 6 feet nearer to the face than the end of the ventilation pipe, and (ii) 6 feet farther away. One minute after the firing of the shot the concentrations at these two sampling points were found to be approximately equal, the value being 26,000 particles per c.c. After a further period of 5 minutes, the concentration at the first point was 4,000, whilst at the second point it had fallen to 1,200 particles per c.c. The average values over the whole period were 12,600 and 7,400, respectively. To overcome this deficiency of the exhaust-ventilation system tests were made in which a fan, capable of blowing about 2,000 cubic feet of air per minute, was set up, on the opposite side of the heading to the ventilation pipe, in such a way that circulation of the air at the face of the heading was obtained. It was patent to the eye that there was a marked improvement in the clearing of dust from the face of the heading, both during filling and in shot-firing. It was obviously, however, much more difficult to demonstrate this quantitatively, owing to the fact that different shots produce varying amounts of dust. Two types of sampling tests were made, one in which samples were taken in the ventilation pipe and the other in which they were taken at a distance of 15 feet from the face. It was, however, impossible to start sampling until nearly 1 minute after shot-firing. In two of the tests, therefore, it is probable that the bulk of the dust had been removed in the interval between firing and the beginning of sampling. Two other tests, at 15 feet from the face, are, however, more directly illustrative of the beneficial effect of the auxiliary fan in clearing the dust from the neighbourhood of the face. The use of an auxiliary fan in routine practice would also serve the purpose of increasing the cooling power of the air at the face of the heading, a matter which may be of much importance where the rock temperature is over 85°F. and might, in fact, enable wet drilling to be carried out under conditions of comfort, whereas without the necessary movement of air this might prove impracticable. The combination of the auxiliary fan with an efficient filter of low resistance (and capable of passing approximately 2,000 cubic feet per minute) would, it is believed, be very beneficial in a heading in highly siliceous rock. The efficiencies of several types of such plant are now being tested in the Mining Research Laboratory in connection with the suppression of dust at loading points. In this connection, there is great need for a fan driven by compressed air which, while giving the required volume of about 2,000 cubic feet per minute, is free from the piercing and objectionable noise so common to practically every make of compressed-air fan. The protection of the fan from flying pieces of rock during shot-firing does not seem to be an insurmountable difficulty, and the incorporation of the fan in a stoutly-built filtration plant would probably accomplish this. Where driving is being carried out through strata in which gas may be encountered, "positive" ventilation by means of a blowing fan, or utilisation of the pit ventilation to give the same effect, is without doubt an advantage. An auxiliary fan combined with suctional ventilation, and capable of directing air to the roof at the face of the heading, should, however, ensure safety from any possible danger in respect of gas. The use of the mist projector in places where the air temperature is in excess of the given figure will, undoubtedly, render the atmospheric conditions, subsequent to shot-firing, trying unless the air-movement past the workers can be increased to a figure of something approaching 200 feet per minute. Undoubtedly, however, the best plan for obviating uncomfortable atmospheric conditions in regard to temperature is by the supply of an ample air-current for ventilating the heading. Concentration of Dust. Comparison of results of tests carried out to determine the amount of dust dispersed during loading of the debris into tubs indicates that, where no precautions have been taken to suppress the dust either during drilling or shot-firing in a dry heading, the concentration of dust which men are liable to breathe may be relatively high. The results given, of course, are very variable and simply give an indication of what may be encountered. When conditions are damp, either naturally or on account of systematic use of the mist projector and of wet drilling, the amount of dust raised during shovelling of debris is very small. The use of the mist projector after shot-firing will help very markedly, of course, in the reduction of dust during the subsequent operation of loading tubs. Where for any reason the mist projector cannot be employed or spraying of the debris is, on account of the temperature conditions, found to be objectionable, respirators should be worn by the men. The Mark IV. respirator, designed and thoroughly tested by the Chemical Defence Department of the War Office on behalf of the Department of Scientific and Industrial Research, is undoubtedly the most suitable respirator for use when heading through highly siliceous rock. Where the strata consist of shales containing only 30-35 per cent. of free silica, experience would indicate that the danger of lung trouble is very slight, unless very high concentrations of dust are breathed. In such cases the simple type of gauze and cotton-wool filter used by the men at H Colliery no doubt protects them from harm. A number of respirators worn by the men in this heading were examined and the dust retained in them separated and weighed. The quantity varied from about 0.1 gin. to over ten times this figure, the mean daily average being approximately 0.4, with extremes of 0.8 and 0.14 gm. respectively, whilst for shot-firers the mean daily average was 0.139 gm., with extremes of 0.76 and 0.03. One test for size frequency on a typical separated dust showed that 37 per cent, by weight of the dust consisted of particles less than 1µ. Summary. Experiments illustrate the concentrations of dust in the chief operations involved in the driving of hard headings, namely, drilling, shot-firing, and filling. The tests included gravimetric, konimeter, and thermal-precipitator measurements. The last gives a numerical estimation of particles, whilst the method adopted for evaluation of the konimeter "spots" is such as to give a measure of the cross-sectional area of the particles. Thus, in the effect of particle size the konimeter results would be affected to a less extent, depending on the square of the diameter, whereas the gravimetric results vary as the cube of the diameter of the particle. It is perhaps not without interest to note that any action in the lungs based upon solubility will probably depend upon the surface area rather than upon the diameter of the particle. The tests during shot-firing indicate that a greater quantity of the dust is usually dispersed into the atmosphere during the firing of the first shot than is the case in the subsequent shots. This is presumably due to the dust which is produced during drilling and applies more especially when dry drilling is employed. The use of the mist projector during and after shot-firing is shown to be beneficial in reducing the concentration of dust in the subsequent filling Operation as well as in the actual blasting. The effect of the mist projector has been found to be most pronounced in headings where high concentrations of dust are encountered and where the area of cross-section is relatively small. The results obtained from tests underground in which a small quantity of wetting agent was added to the water supplied to the mist projector, were not very conclusive, but tests carried out in an experimental gallery on the surface showed a definite advantage when a wetting agent was employed. The use of wet-drilling methods reduces the amount of dust raised during shot-firing, and especially is this the case in dry headings. In headings which are naturally wet, little dust is produced during shot-firing, even when no precautions are taken. The ventilation of headings and the inefficiency of exhaust ventilation, in that the bulk of the air between the end of the ventilation pipe and the face may remain relatively stagnant, are discussed, and means for overcoming this, by the use of an auxiliary blowing fan, is described. The results obtained with such an arrangement are shown to be promising, and the advantage which might accrue from the use of such an auxiliary to the ventilation in hot places, with wet drilling, is pointed out. The possibility of combining the auxiliary fan with a highly efficient filter is envisaged for headings which are being driven in highly siliceous rock. In tests carried out underground during wet drilling advantage of this over dry methods was well demonstrated. The results of carefully controlled tests carried out on the surface are given, and show that by using an external water feed, supplying to the drill about gallon per minute, satisfactory results may be obtained both from the drilling point of view and in the reduction of dust. Konimeter tests have shown the advantage attending the use of a Pyrene dust trap, where dry-drilling methods are advisable or preferred. It has been found that, during filling, appreciable concentrations of dust may be built up, especially where the heading is dry and where no precautions, such as wet drilling and the use of the mist projector during shot-firing, have been taken. Tests have also been made in which the average concentrations, during a number of periods of from eight to eleven days working in a heading, have been obtained, and the advantage which attends the use of wet drilling again shown. In these latter tests sufficient dust was collected to admit of analysis, and the free silica-content was shown to be approximately the same in all the samples, the heading having advanced during the period of the tests by about 350 yards. The need for the wearing of respirators by workmen employed in headings, especially in highly siliceous rock, is emphasised.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||