Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

8th April 1937, Page: 305, Column: 1

Mine Haulage Problems

Some Commission Pointers

Accidents attributable to haulage operations underground, covering both persons actually engaged on those operations and persons otherwise working or passing on the roads, account for over one-fifth of the number of persons killed and about one-quarter of the number injured. A table given in the Safety in Coal Mines Report* seems to confirm the impression that the death-rate, although improving slightly, has remained almost stationary over the last fifty years, and that the combined death and injury rate, like that for falls of ground, exhibits an upward tendency in recent years. The Commissioners remark that, seeing that the consequence of modern methods of mining is among other things to provide bigger and better roads, to reduce the amount of hand and horse haulage, and to substitute mechanical conveyors (accidents from which would not, on the existing classification, be attributed to haulage) for tubs, the persistence of the death-rate and the increasing tendency of the injury rate are very disquieting, and appear to call for fundamental remedial measures.

Straight Roads and Even Gradient.

The Commissioners deal with the subject of haulage under two main heads, the first being the condition of haulage roads and track, and they affirm that it is clearly undesirable, from the point of view of both avoidance of accident and economy in operation, that haulage roads should be either irregularly graded or unnecessarily tortuous.

They recognise that some matters cannot be precisely specified in such a way as to cover all possible variations in conditions, but they see no reason why there should not be a general provision requiring them to be seen to, and they recommend therefore that every haulage road shall be required to be straight and regular in gradient and section, except in so far as the natural conditions of the strata render these requirements or any of them impracticable or inadvisable, or, in the case of roads or parts of roads made before the requirement comes into force, except in so far as the cost would be prohibitive. If the district inspector is not satisfied that this is the case as regards any road or part of a road he should have power to require the manager to effect any necessary rectification or improvement, and it should be compulsory for the manager to comply with the requisition unless he disputes the reasonableness, in which case he should have the right of appeal to the local tribunal.

Margin of Clearance.

As regards the dimensions of haulage roads, the bulk of the evidence was in favour of a statutory minimum clearance above and at the sides of the tub. The minimum clearances proposed varied from six inches to two feet, and in some cases it was proposed to lay down different clearances for different types of haulage. Having regard to the large proportion of accidents that occurs through the clearance being inadequate, the Commissioners see no hardship in requiring that something more than a bare margin be provided at the side of the roads and in certain circumstances over the top of the tub, so long as provision is made against circumstances over which the manager has no control. The amount of clearance over the bare margin will depend on the type of haulage.

They recommend firstly, that every haulage road shall always be kept of such dimensions as will allow a loaded tub to pass without the tub or the load touching the sides or roof, or the side or roof supports. Secondly (this is subject to reservation by Mr. E. O. Forster Brown), that on mechanical and gravity haulage roads there shall be maintained a minimum clear space of 24 inches on one side, between the tub and the side of the road; on animal-haulage roads minimum clear spaces of 18 inches on each side of the road and of 12 inches above the top of the tub and on hand-haulage roads minimum clear spaces of either 24 inches on one side or 18 inches on each side and of 12 inches above the tub. To guard against the floor from being obstructed by loose material falling from the tubs or from the side of the road, all the clear spaces between the tub and the side of the road should be required to extend at least from rail level to the top of the tub.

The view is expressed that these clearances can, and should, be maintained in the large majority of cases. They may appear in some respects to be drastic, but so many haulage accidents arise from lack of adequate clearance that the Commissioners feel a substantial reduction can only be achieved by fixing minima of general application sufficient to enable a person to pass a tub on the rails. As a proviso they recommend giving the district inspector power, in accordance with instructions to be issued by the Mines Department, to grant relaxation or exemption from any of the clearances proposed on being satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for so doing, and subject to any conditions he may consider necessary for safety.

The proposed requirements as to clearances should apply to existing roads as well as to new roads, subject to a reasonable period of grace being allowed for any necessary enlargement to be made.

Clearance and Lighting at Sidings.

Discussing the importance of ample space and efficient lighting being provided at places where tubs are loaded or coupled and uncoupled the Commissioners recommend that at such places a clear space of not less than 12 inches should also be required between the top of the tubs and the roof, and that both the old and the new requirement should apply where the sets or trains consist of two or more tubs. They also recommend a provision against persons being crushed between the tubs themselves when coupling or uncoupling.

As regards lighting, the efficient lighting and whitewashing is recommended of (a) Shaft insets and shaft sidings which are regularly used; (b) The top and the bottom of permanent self-acting inclines; (c) Haulage roads at all sidings, landings, pass-byes and junctions (offtakes).

Loading points are included in the recommendation, and the Commissioners attach so much importance to the value of good lighting in preventing haulage accidents that they would make the provision of efficient lighting, though not necessarily the use of whitewash, apply right up to the working face, instead of, as in the 1984 Regulations, excluding the 100 yards nearest to it.

Recommendations are made the purpose of which will be to ensure rigidity and stability of the track, one being that when any existing rails are replaced or new rails laid down, only rails of British Standard specification shall be used.

As to the support for the rails the following requirements are recommended: (i) Flat-bottomed rails shall be secured with suitable fish-plates having four bolts which shall be kept tightly screwed up. (ii) Bridge rails newly laid or re-laid shall be laid with guides, or other means shall be adopted to ensure the maintenance of the correct gauge. (iii) Guide rails shall be used on mechanical haulages on curves of less than 30 feet radius, and if the speed of haulage exceeds three miles per hour on curves of less than 60 feet radius. (iv) The distance between the sleepers shall not exceed three feet, provided that a period of three years (subject to the like power of extension or exemption as above) may be allowed for relaying tracks where the distance between sleepers at present exceeds this figure. (v) All newly-laid wooden sleepers shall be of adequate length, and in section shall measure not less than 6 inches by 3 inches on mechanical haulages, or 5½ inches by 2½ inches on other haulages.

Ropes and Drawgear.

Though the accidents caused by breakage of haulage ropes and drawgear are relatively small in number, their severity has been shown to be disproportionately high, hence the following recommendations :—

(a) Materials. — After an appointed date no new haulage ropes or drawgear should be installed, or replacements made, unless manufactured of material either conforming to the appropriate British Standard specification in force at the time or approved by the Board of Trade for the purpose.

(b) Heat-treatment. — Once at least in every 12 months drawgear should be annealed or given other proper heat-treatment and be thoroughly examined by a competent person, but the Commissioners should be prepared to exempt drawbars from this requirement (seeing that they cannot always be readily detached from the tubs for the purpose), and any existing couplings not capable of being detached from the drawbars. The method or methods by which heat-treatment is to be applied shall be specified in regulations.

(c) Loading. — In order to guard against excessive loads being imposed on the rope or drawgear, the manager should be required to specify in a written notice for each haulage system in the mine the maximum number of tubs (in the case of endless-rope haulages also the number of tubs per set) to be hauled, having regard to the circumstances in which the system is operated.

(d) Use of Limbers. — Where animal haulage is employed, a limber or other rigid form of attachment should be required to be used on any road where the gradient exceeds 1 in 20, that is, on which a tub will normally gravitate. This recommendation may necessitate greater clearance being provided at bends and curves in mines where chains have hitherto been in use, but the Commissioners do not regard that as a sufficient reason for retaining them.

(e) Design of shackles. — Where shackles are used, they shall be so designed and made as to prevent the pin, if properly inserted, from rising accidentally. A sufficient period of grace should be allowed for the replacement of existing shackles that do not comply with the requirement.

Safety Devices.

References are made to the provisions in sub-sections (2), (8) and (4) of Section 46 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, to provide against injury from runaways. The view is expressed that no person should be permitted to work in any place where he is exposed to risk of injury from a runaway tub, unless he is protected by some contrivance or device, which should be automatic where practicable, capable of stopping or diverting the runaway. When protection has to be afforded for persons working regularly in a particular place, the contrivances should be of the positive type, that is, always effective except when deliberately made ineffective; and at the top of inclines, and elsewhere when practicable, they should also be of the double or interlocked type, so that when one part of the device is withdrawn the other is in operation and vice versa. It may be necessary to provide other forms of protection at places where the persons to be protected are only casually or periodically working, as for instance, when engaged on repairs.

The modification of Section 46 in detail would be rather outside the Commissioners' terms of reference, but they recommend that the whole section be reviewed by the Mines Department and recast, and that the Department should consider whether the present limitations in the Section as regards the system of haulage are not in some respects too narrow. They see no reason, for Instance, why the provision of stop-blocks at. the tops of inclines should only be required for gravity haulages, or why the law should not require appropriate precautions of this kind to be taken where necessary on endless-rope haulages.

They recommend that at coupling places where sets or trains consisting of two or more tubs are coupled or uncoupled there shall, unless the tubs are so designed as to prevent persons from being crushed between the ends, be kept and used suitable devices for safeguarding persons when coupling or uncoupling.

In main or main-and-tail rope haulages the coupling or uncoupling of tubs in motion should be prohibited, except where the tubs gravitate to a landing or to the pit-bottom and it is necessary to uncouple the rope while the tubs are moving and still have sufficient momentum to reach the end of their journey.

It is recommended that all pulleys, sheaves or rollers used in connection with rope haulages shall be securely fixed, and (except sheaves at the side of the road or rollers in the middle of the road which merely support the rope without altering its direction) shall be securely fenced unless in such a position or of such construction as to be as safe to every person employed as they would be if securely fenced. It is also recommended, as a precaution against fire, that the use of wood (unless made non-inflammable) for the construction, replacement or repair of the frames of haulage pulleys, sheaves or rollers be prohibited.

Maintenance and Supervision.

The Commissioners recommend that there should be a general provision requiring all tracks, tubs, machinery, gear and other appliances used in connection with haulage to be maintained in an efficient condition, and that Section 66 (b) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911 (which requires the manager to appoint competent persons who shall at least once in every week examine thoroughly the state of the machinery, gear and other appliances of the mine which are actually in use), should be extended so as to cover specifically tracks, tubs and ropes. It should also be made clear, in case there is any doubt on the point, that the various contrivances provided under Section 46 are included in the expression "gear and other appliances," for it is most necessary that steps be regularly and frequently taken to ensure that such contrivances are in proper working order.

Travelling on Underground Roads.

After reviewing the conditions of travelling haulage roads to get to and from work the Commissioners propose that travelling on foot on any haulage road on which the haulage is worked by gravity or mechanical power shall only be allowed in the following cases and under the following conditions: (i) In the case of the main body of men in any shift travelling to or from their work, if the haulage system on any section of the road is stopped while the men are in that section or in any other section where they might still be in danger from it. (ii) In the case of men (other than the persons excepted by Section 43 (1)) travelling to or from their work at other times, if either the haulage is stopped as in (a) or the speed of the haulage does not exceed three miles per hour and the gradient does not exceed 1 in 24, and a clear space of at least two feet is provided on one side.

The first part of this recommendation, that is, as regards the main body of the shift, would be absolute. The second part, however, might be subject to exemption in certain circumstances. The requirement in the second part as to the provision of a clear space would, of course, be redundant if the general recommendation that there should be a clear space of at least two feet at the side of all mechanical or gravity haulage roads is adopted.

Understanding that certain of the requirements as to the dimensions of refuge holes, in sub-section (3) of Section 44, sometimes create difficulty in practice, and having considered the representations made, the Commissioners are prepared to recommend that the width, instead of being required to be "as near as may be three feet," might be "not less than two feet six inches or more than three feet six inches," and that, in roads supported by steel arches, the height need not be more than five feet, instead of "not less in height than the height of the haulage road at the point where the hole is, or six feet, whichever is the less." As regards the first of these points, the object of the proposed concession is to allow some tolerance on the permissible width to allow for its variation due to crush.

It is admitted that the height of the travelling roads, where reasonably constant, may have little direct hearing on safety, but it may have a considerable influence on the alertness of the men on reaching their working places, and it cannot be good for health to have to walk long distances in a stooping position. The Commissioners do not think it would be unreasonable to require that in all new travelling roads, and in all existing travelling roads within a period of three years, the minimum height from the sleepers, if any, shall be five feet, provided that, if the manager contends in respect of any part of a road that this height cannot reasonably be required, he may apply to the district inspector for exemption, or, in default of agreement, may appeal to the local tribunal.

Means of Egress.

After reviewing proposals regarding alternative means of egress, the conclusion is arrived at that it would be desirable to make it compulsory for the workmen (accompanied and guided by an official) to travel by the alternative egress periodically, unless the district inspector is satisfied that the circumstances render it unreasonable, in which case he should be empowered to assent to other arrangements being substituted. Also, the alternative egress from every part of the mine should be kept clearly and adequately signposted at every junction. The deputies should be required to report on the condition of these signposts after each occasion on which they travel that way. Seeing that in some emergencies the men might have to find their way out without lights, it is suggested for managers' consideration that experiments might be made with the use of self-luminous paint for the purpose of making the direction signs visible in the dark.

As to travelling on the haulage itself the Commissioners have somewhat reluctantly come to the conclusion that they are not able to recommend that the practice of run-riding on mechanical haulages be altogether prohibited, but they think that, in addition to being limited to speeds not exceeding three miles an hour as at present, it should be subject to the additional requirement that there must be a clear space of not less than 24 inches above the tub and on both sides of it.

As regards riding on horse-drawn tubs or trains, they think it necessary to differentiate between the "gun" which is commonly used in South Wales, and the various types of limbers used in other districts.

Riding Men by Mechanical Means.

The practice of riding men by mechanical means to or from their work underground is extending and is likely to grow still further as the working faces get further from the shafts. The Commissioners wish to encourage it, and, while it is clearly necessary that there should be adequate precautions against accident, the need to avoid anything that might have the effect of unnecessary restriction should be borne in mind. At present, however, the statutory requirements in this matter hardly go far enough.

It is recommended that the raising and lowering of men in inlet or outlet slopes should be distinguished in the statute from winding in vertical shafts and that such raising or lowering on slopes, together with all man-riding underground, should be treated primarily as "haulage," though some of the winding precautions might properly be applied on the steeper gradients. For the purpose of regulating such riding, the existing specific provisions relating to man-haulage should be gathered together, and there should be other specific provisions either in the Act or in general regulations, with such distinctions as are appropriate to meet different degrees of gradient.

It is held that additional requirements should be included in the provisions relating to man-haulages. Some of the suggested requirements contemplate that certain items such as the maximum load, the life of the rope and the maximum speed will vary according to the circumstances of individual cases. There is nothing to preclude other modifications, or additional provisions, being made if the district inspector or the mine management or the workmen concerned consider it desirable, under the procedure applying to the establishment of special regulations in Section 87 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911. For instance, at Clifton Colliery, near Burnley in Lancashire, there is a unique system of man- haulage, of which some of the Commissioners obtained first-hand experience in the course of a visit to that mine. This is on the endless-rope haulage on which each man travels independently kneeling on a fiat-surfaced bogie. Each bogie is fitted with a box for carrying tools. In many respects the requirements proposed would not be applicable to this system, but there is no reason why it should be discontinued, and there would be no difficulty in making suitable special regulations to fit such a case.

Conveyor Roads.

The use of conveyors for transporting coal along the roads to a loading point some distance outbye of the face is a modern development for which there is no specific provision in the Coal Mines Act, 1911. The recommendation is made that a clear space of not less than two feet be required between the conveyor and one side of the road, on the same side of the conveyor throughout its length, and that no conveyor road shall be less than four feet in height, whether or not it is subject to the limiting dimensions which it is proposed should apply to airways. If the conveyor road is also a travelling road its height must, of course, not be less than five feet.

No need is seen to restrict travelling on foot in the clear space beside a conveyor in motion, but travelling or standing on a moving conveyor (including a face conveyor) should be prohibited.

It is further recommended that every conveyor, exceeding 30 yards in length, shall be provided with some proper means of communicating distinct and definite signals from any point along the conveyor to the person operating the engine. The adoption of this recommendation would involve appropriate additions to the uniform code of signals prescribed in pursuance of Section 53 (1) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911.

* Cmd. 5890. 7s. 6d. net. H.M. Stationery Office.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Forster Brown, Edward Otto      Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
18 Dec 1935  Safety Of Mine Workers, Royal Commission Personnel (The Yorkshire Post)
04 Jan 1936  Personnel Of Royal Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Feb 1936  Royal Commission Operating (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Feb 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Some Points in Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Mar 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Deputy's Prayer (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  Safety In Mines, Inspectors Offer Suggestions (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  First Hand Studies (The Science and Art of Mining)
20 Jun 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Reason Given for More Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
18 Jul 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Midland and Southern Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Under-Managers Give Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Swansea Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Recommendations for Scottish Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Northern Division Conditions (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Cardiff Area (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Dividing Divisions into Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
10 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, New Conditions Created (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Firemen's Associations (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Evidence of Research Stations Director (The Science and Art of Mining)
21 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Major Hudspeth's Evidence on Researches (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Under-managers' Views before Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  The Personal Factor (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Officials' Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
02 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Medical Problems Considered (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Feb 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, More About Silicosis (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Feb 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Mar 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Managers' Statement (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Mar 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 Apr 1937  Mine Haulage Problems, Some Commission Pointers (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Apr 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Mineworkers' Federation (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 May 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Mining Association's Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Jun 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dust Prevention Methods (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dangerous Conditions or Occurrences (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Education of Mine Workers (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Dec 1938  Mines Safety Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Dec 1938  Safety Commission's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Problems For Mining Community (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Development Of Safety Legislation (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Mines Safety Bill Proposed (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Feb 1939  How Mining Industry Has Changed (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Mar 1939  Colliery Ventilation (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Mar 1939  Support Of Workings (The Science and Art of Mining)
22 Apr 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 May 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — II, Shot-Firing Standards (The Science and Art of Mining)
03 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — III (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — IV, Safety Organisation at Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — V, Occupational Diseases (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print