25th March 1939, Page: 296, Column: 1
Oil Versus Coal
In an address to the West of Scotland Association of Foremen
Engineers, Mr. McKinstry, managing director of Babcock and
Wilcox, referred to the "oil versus coal" controversy. He said
that on purely commercial grounds a good case could be made out
for a large number of merchant ships using oil either for steam
raising as in Diesel engines continuing to do so, but he was of the
opinion that there was a certain class of tramp merchant ship
which could be equipped with light high-speed steam propelling
machinery, mechanically stoked coal-burning boilers, and electrically
driven auxiliaries, which could be run with the highest
economy.
At the recent meeting of the British Corporation Register
Mr. Robert Strachan said, with regard to coal-fired ships the
application of mechanical stokers with self-trimming bunkers,
in combination with either Scotch boilers or watertube boilers,
was a development in the right direction. This made use of our
natural fuel supply (coal); reduced the stokehold personnel, and
ensured a more constant steam supply, resulting in higher boiler
efficiency. The fuel consumption for all purposes would be in the
region of about 1.0 lb. per s.h.p., and when the relative cost of
oil and coal was considered it would be realised that the day of
coal was not yet over for marine propulsion so far as the merchant
ship was concerned.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| McKinstry, — | | Managing Director | |
| Strachan, Robert | | | |