25th March 1939, Page: 294, Column: 2
Steel Props At Coal Face
N.S. Research Committee Reports
At the meeting of the North Staffordshire Institute of Mining
Engineers on 27th February, Mr. E. H. Vallis (Investigator)
presented the report of the Safety in Mines Research Committee
on "The Use of Steel Props at the Coal Face." Extracts from
the report are appended.
Wood v. Steel Props.
Some of the relative advantages and disadvantages of wood
and steel props may be noted. Wood props are lighter, easier
to handle, may be shortened at the face, and are not as liable to
cause injury to workmen either by the props falling or the workmen
stumbling against them. It is claimed for wood props that they
give warning of roof weights and that steel props do not. Tests
have shown that this is not justified because, by the time a wooden
prop commences to "creak," it has failed under the load and is
doing very little work; thus, although the prop may be standing,
it is not truly supporting the roof and the warning comes too late
to be of much avail. Wood lids, of course, give the same warning
whether used with wood or steel props.
Wood props, however carefully selected, are not of uniform
strength, and the unexpected failure of one prop may throw
excess load upon its neighbours, causing them in turn to fail and
perhaps bring about a fall of roof. Steel props are, in general,
of a uniform strength greatly in excess of that of wood props of
similar size. For instance, a 4-inch prop of "room dry"
Scandinavian timber, 4 feet in length, will fail under a load of
from 15 to 20 tons, whilst a 4-inch external diameter steel tube,
wood filled, or a 4-inch x 4-inch steel joist prop of the same
length, will sustain a load up to 65 tons.
In wet or damp mines wood props are at a further disadvantage,
as is borne out by tests (S.M.R.B. Paper No. 72) which showed
that room dry timber is about 50 per cent. stronger than
saturated timber.
Steel props are, of course, considerably heavier than wood
props, but this difference is more or less offset, especially on
inclined faces, by the fact that new props have not to be transported
along the face every day as in the case of wood.
In case of fire occurring at the face the advantage of steel props
is obvious, and instances are on record of the complete loss of a
face having been averted as a result of the use of steel face supports.
In the use of steel props an indirect advantage in roof control
lies in the necessity for more attention to the systematic withdrawal
of props from the goaf.
Types of Steel Props.
There are two main types of steel prop : the yielding and the
rigid. Yielding props are not now in use in North Staffordshire.
Rigid steel props are of two main types — (a) a prop fitted with a
device, such as a wedge, which enables the prop to be set or
withdrawn by tightening or slackening the wedge (the wedge
prop), and (b) a prop with no such device and which must therefore
be set and withdrawn in the same manner as a wooden prop (the
plain prop).
Comparison between Plain and Wedge Props. — Tests have been
carried out to determine the setting load that can be imposed upon
plain and wedge props of the girder type. The props employed
were 4" x 4" section 4 feet in length; the floor was rigid and a
soft wood lid 2½" thick was placed at the bead of each prop.
The maximum load obtained with a plain prop was 24 cwts.;
a prop fitted with a wedge having a slope of 14° (the most commonly
used wedge) received a load of 3 tons, whilst with a wedge
of 11° slope a load of 6 tons could be obtained. These tests were
carried out in a press on the surface, but it is reasonable to assume
that steel props fitted with wedges are set more firmly underground
than are plain props. This is a matter of considerable
importance, as shown by comparative results obtained underground
where certain wedge props were set as tightly as possible
while others were set less tightly and the subsequent swinging
of the props was measured.
It was noted that the wedges of loosely set props were liable
to slip back when the load eventually came on, and they thus
did not develop the desired resistance to the convergence of the
roof and floor. No slipping of the wedges was observed in the
props set initially tight. It should be stated that slipping of
wedges in observed cases has not occurred with wedges having
a slope of not more than 11°.
A second advantage of wedge props is that they can be set
more easily at any desired angle. At a face where mixed steel
props are in use, measurements of the angle of setting showed
that, compared with plain props, the wedge props were set, on the
average, 3° nearer to the normal. This may not appear to be a
great difference, but the 3° is an average, and individual variations
were much greater.
The wedge prop is more easily withdrawn than the plain prop,
but that in itself may, in some instances, be a disadvantage.
A natural condition for which wedge props are not suited has
been observed where the roof settles down on the prop on the
release of the wedge; this roof disturbance renders the subsequent
recovery of the prop an operation requiring considerable care.
In such circumstances it has been found desirable to pull the
prop with a Sylvester at the moment of releasing the wedge.
Relative Merits of Props.
In considering the relative merits of wedge and plain props
the weight of the head of the wedge prop becomes an important
factor in thick seams where a prop of 6" x 5" section may be in
use. Three men are often required to set such a prop in inclined
seams whereas a plain prop may be set easily by two men.
Tubular props of 5½" diameter are in successful use in a seam
8 feet in thickness and girder props of 6" x 5" section arc also
in use. A plain prop of 6" x 5" section and 6 feet in length
weighs 150 lb., and its efficient setting becomes a matter of some
difficulty. Further, if such a prop should be knocked out or should
otherwise fail and strike a man the consequences may be serious.
Although wedge props have certain advantages, the present
tendency in the North Staffordshire coalfield is towards the more
extended use of plain props on account of their simplicity, ease
of handling, absence of protruding parts, less liability to damage
and lower initial cost.
Prop Sections. — Props of tubular section and of girder section
with parallel and with incurved flanges are in use in North
Staffordshire. Weight for weight, the tubular props are the
stronger, easier to handle, less likely to cause injury through
persons knocking against them, and they are, in general, taken
to more kindly by the colliers. They must be filled to prevent
buckling under load and generally a wooden core is used, which
has the advantage of being lighter than sand.
H-section girder props are more commonly used. The chief
advantages of this prop over the tubular section are that it can
be straightened more easily and that the caps and feet can be
shaped at the colliery, thus enabling props to be made from the
straight portions of damaged and disused steel arches. Various
shapes of foot can be tried at little expense in order to find that
which best suits the conditions.
General Observations.
The particulars of installations of steel props given in the
report show that, in seams up to a thickness of 8 feet and
inclinations up to 1 in 3, there is no single limiting factor to the
successful use of steel props.
In thicker seams and at higher inclinations the weight of steel
props compared with that of wood renders their setting a matter
of considerable difficulty.
Within the suggested limits, conditions unfavourable to steel
props are (1) A varying thickness of seam; (2) A weak roof with
a strong floor.
At a face where the seam is liable to vary in thickness by more
than, say 6 inches, it is obviously impracticable to use the ordinary
type of rigid steel supports. This is a condition where a prop
which permits of length adjustment, and not too complicated in
design to stand up to the rough usage of pit conditions, would
be acceptable.
At faces with a weak roof and a floor which the prop does
penetrate, the prop heads are forced into the roof and their withdrawal
becomes a matter of difficulty and danger.
Where the extent of roof and floor convergence between the
setting and the withdrawal of the props is such that the props
are forced either into the roof or into the floor so far that they
cannot be withdrawn with reasonable ease, the introduction of
steel props of any design is not likely to be successful. It may
he that in such circumstances an adjustment in the sizes and
spacing of the packs, together with close supervision to ensure
that the walls are well built and the interior stowed tight, will
so reduce the extent of the height reduction as to permit the
withdrawal of the props without undue difficulty.
When considering the installation of steel props it is advisable
first to measure the height reduction, and when found to consider
how it may be accommodated. The convergence may be met
either by the crushing of wood lids or bars, or by the penetration
of the prop into the floor. It is not desirable for the thickness
of a lid to exceed 6 inches, and therefore any height reduction
in excess of (say) 4 inches must be accommodated by floor penetration.
The design of prop foot to permit the required penetration
and no more must then be considered since, if penetration
be excessive, the prop will not only be difficult to withdraw but
will not offer adequate support to the roof.
Very careful supervision is required to ensure successful results,
both with regard to the systematic setting and withdrawal of
the props and the careful checking of the quantity to ensure
against possible losses. At the collieries where steel props have
resulted in the most marked decrease in the cost of face support
the props, are counted and reported upon daily, following which
the attention of the persons concerned is drawn to mislaid props
before they are beyond recovery.
Accidents. — Figures are not available on a sufficiently large
scale to show the effect of the introduction of steel props upon the
accident rate. The possibility of men being injured owing to
striking or being struck by a steel prop has been noticed and
another possible source of accident is a prop flying out from under
a steel bar, but this does not occur provided a wood pad not less
than 1 inch in thickness is placed between the prop and the bar.
In view of the more uniform and greater strength of steel props
as compared with wood, and of the fact that they bend rather
than break, together with the more adequate supervision and
systematic setting and withdrawal that is likely to follow their
use, the Committee are of the opinion that the use of steel props
under the conditions indicated in the report has resulted in better
working conditions and a reduction in the number of accidents
from falls of ground at the coal face.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Vallis, E. H. | | Investigator | |