Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

25th March 1939, Page: 293, Column: 1

Silicosis — Preventive Measures

By The Late J. S. Haldane, F. Haynes, A. Shaw, and J. Ivon Graham.

Extracts from paper on "Silicosis and its Prevention," presented at the 49th annual general meeting of the Institution of Mining Engineers.

Many questions relating to silicosis remain in a very controversial state, and with them the nature of the measures required for preventing the disease. Even what seemed the well-established connection between the disease silicosis and inhalation of free silica has recently been denied on mineralogical grounds by W. R. Jones. In this paper the Authors endeavour to put together and interpret the existing data, including numerous observations which they themselves have made on men and animals, and on the composition of inhaled dust in relation to the effects which follow it.

Means for the prevention of silicosis must include the reduction of dust in the air which is breathed by the miner, particularly when work is being carried out in highly siliceous ground. In the following the means for doing this are only briefly described. Dilution with ample quantity of fresh air forms probably the simplest way of reducing the dust concentration.

It is well known that drilling with pneumatic hammer drills is responsible for much dust, hot fortunately means for the prevention of the dispersion of this into the atmosphere are now readily available for either dry or wet drilling.

Wet Drilling.

Where drilling with water can be employed, this is the most effective method and probably the simplest for keeping dust out of the atmosphere. The ordinary water-fed drill, in which the water passes under pressure through a hollow drill-steel and is projected on to the cutting edge of the latter, often produces dust which, although not visible to the naked eye, may, nevertheless, be formed in sufficient quantity to be harmful (thus engendering a false sense of security). Tests in the Mining Research Laboratory have shown that, even with a comparatively new drilling machine, leakage of air may take place down the drill-steel to an appreciable extent, whilst, when the machine is worn, leakage may be considerable. This air reaches the rock during impact of the drill-steel, and the resultant effect is practically the same as if no water had previously been sprayed on to the rock, the leakage of air being charged with very fine unwetted dust particles and expelled to the atmosphere. By adopting a water-feed which admits the water through a side hole in the drill-steel, dust formation during wet drilling may be altogether prevented, provided the quantity of water used is, say, 30 gallons per hour, when using the customary hand-machine.

Owing to the deleterious action of water upon shale, to increase in humidity, and to the lowering of the cooling power of the air in hot workings, wet drilling may sometimes prove objectionable or even impossible. In such cases either a foam-drilling equipment or a plant for the collection of dust during dry drilling may be employed.

In the former a thick foam is forced through the drill-steel from a closed vessel by means of compressed air. The foam appears to bind completely the dust formed by the drill-steel and the mixture flows from the mouth of the borehole as a thick sludge. Tests have shown with this method of drilling that the dust dispersed into the atmosphere is almost negligible, while the amount of water used is only about 1 gallon per hour.

Dry Drilling.

Several efficient dust-traps for use in dry drilling are now available and all have this in common: the dust is removed from the vicinity of the mouth of the borehole to a fabric filter (housed in a metal container) by means of a vigorous air-current, which is usually induced by an ejector situated in the filter-container and worked by compressed air. The development of this type of dust collector is due primarily to Captain P. S. Hay, who, working on behalf of the Safety in Mines Research Board, produced an equipment which by numerous tests proved to be highly efficient. Experience has shown that a larger container should be advantageous, e.g., a size capable of holding all the fine drillings for one shift, which may mean the fine dust from about 75 feet of drillings. Such a capacity would reduce the possibility of the dispersion of some of the fine dust during the removal of the drillings from the filter-container.

Great care should, of course, be taken to ensure that each bag containing the drillings is properly fastened and either sent out of the pit or thoroughly wetted and buried underground.

The amount of the fine dust formed when drilling with pneumatic hammer-drills, and also the total amount of free silica in this, may be appreciably reduced by the use of well-sharpened and correctly hardened drill-steels. With a rotary drill the amount of dust thrown into the atmosphere is very much less than with a pneumatic drill, and for the same length of hole the amount of energy absorbed will only be about one-seventh of that required by the percussive drill. Hitherto only the electrically-driven type of rotary drill has been found capable of doing satisfactory work in hard rock. Although little dust is dispersed into the air at the time of drilling with the rotary machine the drillings contain an appreciable amount of very fine particles, and, therefore, as in the case of the dust-trap, all cuttings should be wetted or removed to prevent dispersion of fine dust into the atmosphere in the subsequent operations of shot-firing and filling. Since it has been suggested that his position and the physiological strain of holding a rapidly pulsating machine weighing about 30 lb. renders the driller especially liable to inhale a large quantity of dust, it will be advantageous, where possible, to relieve him of the weight of the machine by an automatic feed or by the simple form of support suggested by Captain P. S. Hay.

Dust after Shot-firing.

Probably the greatest dust concentrations in the atmosphere of hard headings are found during shot-firing, and, as there is always the danger that men may return to work at the face before the dust and fumes have been removed by the ventilating current, it is clearly desirable that every effort should be made to clear the atmosphere at the earliest moment. The effect upon the bronchi and lungs of small concentrations of nitrous fumes is a matter which is at present under investigation by one of the Authors, but it is not yet possible to say how harmful the concentrations are to which workers are exposed in the hard headings and other underground places where much shot-firing is done. The experiments of Irwin, Robson, and King have given a clear indication of the possible danger from exposure to the combined effect of silica-dust and nitrous fumes. A practical way for the suppression of these after shot-firing is by the employment of the mist projector designed by Captain P. S. Hay in conjunction with the Mining Research Laboratory. The mist projector may be fixed into a 5 or 10 gallon drum to facilitate handling, or, preferably, into an open tank of larger capacity. It should be placed 12-15 yards back from the face of the heading and started up about 2 minutes prior to firing the shot, and allowed to continue for a further 6 minutes or so thereafter. In this way the heading is filled with a mist of droplets much outnumbering the dust particles and effectively wetting or attaching themselves to the latter, with the result that the dust rapidly settles out of the air. The high efficiency of the mist projector has been proved by numerous tests, and is the greater the smaller the heading and the lower the ventilation. The addition of soda and of wetting agents, including soap, has been shown to have advantages, the former for the fixation of the nitrous and nitric acids formed during the firing of the shot, and the latter for the more efficient wetting of the fine particles of dust. The risk of dust inhalation after shot-firing and, in fact, from the other operations in a hard heading, may be minimised by means of suctional ventilation provided an auxiliary fan be also employed to stir up the air near the face of the heading, since the air-pipes can rarely be taken nearer than about 7 yards from the face. The use of the mist projector, using, as it normally does, about 150-200 cubic feet per minute of free air which is projected into the heading with considerable force, serves a similar purpose in stirring up the air. An efficient filtration plant in conjunction with the auxiliary fan should prove to be of further advantage in reducing the dust concentrations.

Undoubtedly the hazard from dust may be much reduced by the employment of much better ventilation than has been common in the past. Further, the dilution of air, containing a relatively high concentration of free silica, by a large quantity of air containing a non-siliceous dust, may have beneficial results apart from the mere dilution of the free silica.

In the other principal operations in a hard heading, namely, the filling of the debris into tubs, the only practical means for dust allayment would seem to be efficient spraying, from time to time, of the heap of broken rock with water or water plus a wetting agent. Where the temperature of the heading is much higher than 85°F. the use of a solution of calcium chloride or other desiccating agent for such work should be advantageous.

The operation of filling stone or coal into tubs entails a high expenditure of energy and consequently is accompanied by deep breathing. With such concentrations there is an increased tendency to breathe through the mouth with greater risk of dust inhalation. As a last and effective means of defence against the latter, the wearing of an efficient respirator covering the nose and mouth is advisable. The Mark IV. respirator, designed and very carefully tested at the Chemical Warfare Laboratories, Porton, on behalf of the Department of Scientific and Industrial Research, fulfils the necessary requirements. It is now being manufactured on a commercial scale and the claims for its efficiency have been confirmed by Jones. The desirability of wearing a respirator in any dense concentration of dust (even of coal) is made clear.

Summary.

It is suggested by the Authors that the term silicosis should only be applied to a fibrotic condition of the lungs found in individuals with a history of exposure to dust containing a high proportion (about 50 per cent. or more) of free silica, such as fibrosis, which is very generally progressive, carrying with it a marked predisposition to tubercular infection. They feel that clinical and radiological examination should not be regarded as sufficient basis for a diagnosis of silicosis unless there is a history of exposure to dust of respirable size having a high free silica-content.

Although a large number of colliery workers in the South Wales anthracite coalfield have been certified as silicotic, the working histories of the cases show that the men have not been subjected to highly siliceous dust, and the phthisis death-rate among the coal miners, as shown by the Registrar General's Occupational Mortality statistics, is not significantly higher than in the general population of the district.

The incidence of bronchitis among colliers is discussed and reasons suggested for the high incidence of bronchitis in the anthracite area. It will be clear that any circumstance tending to the production of bronchitis or similar lung trouble should be obviated. A very important factor is the subjection of the body, when hot and moist after exertion, to rapid cooling as, for example, often occurs when riding in spakes against cold intake air. The possible harmful effect of nitrous fumes is also mentioned.

The theory put forward by W. R. Jones, that sericite-dust is a cause of silicosis, is discussed, but is not found to be in accordance with the facts.

The physiological response of the lung to inhaled dusts is described, together with the mode of elimination of such dusts, and suggestions have been made as to the reason why some dusts are harmless while others are harmful. It is emphasised that the inhalation of excessive amounts of any dust will cause pulmonary damage.

Analyses of rocks and of dusts of respirable size produced during mining and other industrial operations are given, and the relation between the free silica-content of the rocks and dusts and the incidence of silicosis discussed.

It is important, in view of the facts presented, to reduce dust concentrations to a minimum, particularly on the working of highly siliceous rock.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Graham, J. Ivon      Whos Who Page
Haldane, John Scott      Whos Who Page
Haynes, F.      
Shaw, A.      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print