Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

25th March 1939, Page: 289, Column: 1

Support Of Workings

General Statement.

As recalled in the Report* of the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines, on the average of the ten years 1925-34, 50 per cent, of the fatal accidents, 42 per cent. of the more serious non-fatal accidents (i.e., those immediately reportable to the divisional inspector), and 35 per cent. of all compensable non-fatal accidents at mines under the Coal Mines Act, 1911, were due to falls of ground. Seventy to 80 per cent. of these accidents occur at the working face, and, except for a very few accidents from falls of ground in shafts, the remainder are about equally divided between falls on roads while persons are repairing or enlarging them and falls on roads while persons are otherwise working or passing, with a slight preponderance towards the former, The divisional figures show fairly wide variations both in these proportions and in the respective accident rates, to be attributed largely, no doubt, to differences in natural conditions. One would naturally expect that there was here a large and promising field for accident reduction, but a study of the available statistics provides little satisfaction for that expectation, and in recent years, indeed, notwithstanding an intensification of research and effort, the rates display if anything a tendency to rise rather than to fall.

The basic principle of the present law relating to support is that, where support is required, it shall be systematic. In addition to being systematic, the support must of course also be adequate. There is obviously no useful purpose served in setting the supports at regular intervals if they are not sufficiently close together or individually strong enough. It may be impracticable to provide adequate support by means of props alone; they may have to be supplemented by bars or straps, or even also by cross-bars, In so far as systematic support has failed to fulfil expectations, it must be because it is still inadequate.

Except for the distance between holing props or sprags, which must not exceed six feet, the manager can fix what distances he likes, and it appears to be not unusual for distances to be fixed which are greater than the actual practice followed in the mine, or, even if they accord with practice, greater than they should be in the best interests of safety. There is a natural tendency for the workmen to rely on the distances fixed by the manager, and to have some hesitation in using their own judgment in setting supports at shorter intervals where the conditions of the roof demand it; statistics show that where a roof appears to be good too much reliance is placed in its apparent safety, and that a greater proportion of serious accidents occur under such roofs, where the distances tend to be wide, than under the more obviously insecure roofs which necessitate close support in order to keep them up.

In recent years representative committees have been at work in the principal coalfields. Some of the results of the investigations have been published in S.M.R.B. Papers Nos. 6, 12, 30, 45, 55 and 61 ; others have been embodied in papers in the Transactions of the Institution of Mining Engineers. Most of the recommendations made fall into the following general grouping: (i) The need, in a variety of respects, for more intensive support, notably by the use of bars in longwall faces, at face rippings and gate-ends or road-heads. (ii) The advantages of the stronger and systematic support of roadways by steel arches or girders, or systems of concrete or other linings, instead of timber. (iii) The importance of ensuring efficient packing. (iv) The "Timbering Notice" should define fully the system of support (including packing), and explain the methods by which it is to be applied, and should not merely specify the maximum permissible distances between supports. (v) Withdrawal of timber — the more extensive use of proper safety appliances and of temporary supports. (vi) The regular and sufficient supply of material for supports and repairs in close proximity to the place where the material is to be used.

Modern Theory of Roof Control.

In the past, the provision of adequate support has been largely an empirical matter, based on the gradual acquisition of each manager's personal experience of working under his own particular conditions. Modern research in providing information as to why certain practices dictated by experience are fundamentally sound, and why others are mistaken, inappropriate, or even bad. A real and serious difficulty, however, is that the variability in thickness and nature of the upper beds, above the immediate roof of the workings is not known. At the moment, in the opinion of Major H. M. Hudspeth, the work of research is actually going on faster than the results are being assimilated, and that is a failing which can only be corrected hy time, carefully directed propaganda and a receptive and active industry. But it is still highly desirable that work on these lines should be pressed forward, because the knowledge already gained, although extensive, is not yet such as to enable the safest methods of working to be deduced as a matter of certainty from the natural conditions existing in any particular case.

It used to be supposed that the faster a face advanced the safer it was from the point of view of roof control, but research has established that this is true only up to a point. For each set of conditions and circumstances, therefore, there is an optimum rate of advance which will provide the greatest measure of safety. The Commissioners cannot make any specific recommendations on the subject, but they hope that further research work may provide the means by which the better to deduce the appropriate rate of advance from a knowledge of the conditions. It is evident, however, that the more intensive the rate of advance, the more intensive ought to be the method of support.

When a face is machine-cut the depth of the cut is one of the principal factors that determine the rate of advance. The deeper the cut, also, the greater the area of roof which is left without effective support, until the coal has been removed and the artificial supports erected in its place. It is clear that our knowledge is not yet sufficient to enable the optimum depth of cut in any particular set of circumstances to be determined. The Commissioners recommend, however, that in drawing up the detailed support rules, the manager should be required to specify the depth of the cut for each machine-cut face, in order that the district inspector may have an opportunity of objecting to it, if he considers it prejudicial to safety. The manager would, of course, have the usual right of appeal against any objection that he thought unreasonable.

Support Rules.

The notice made by the manager under Section 50 (4) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, is commonly called the "Timbering Notice," but the Commissioners prefer to call it the "Support Rules," as, being a better designation, seeing that so much steel or other material is now used instead of wood. In their opinion the support rules should constitute a complete specification of the system of support laid down by the manager, and should deal separately with the faces, the road-heads and the roads in each seam. If in any seam there are such variations in roof conditions or methods of work as to call for differences in treatment, the differences should be specified. The rules should be illustrated by plans and sections or diagrams ; the provision of models on the surface should be considered where practicable, particularly as regards the system to be adopted at places of special importance such as road-heads, in order that the details may be fully understood by the workmen.

A copy of the rules should be kept posted in a prominent position at the pithead, and a copy of so much as applies to his district should be kept posted at each deputy's station, and given to the deputy or any other official concerned with the supervision and practical application of the system laid down. A copy should also be sent to the district inspector. Any subsequent amendments should be notified at once in all these quarters,

The Commissioners have noted with interest the practice at some mines of supplying the workmen with illustrated cards or folders, describing the system of support in simple language. They believe that the issue of practical notes in this form is likely to be of much more value than accrues from the distribution of books containing extracts from the abstract of the Act and regulations, as is at present required under Section 88 of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, and heartily commend the practice for the consideration of those managements who have not already adopted it.

Support at Working Face.

In view of the number of accidents that happen under roofs which are believed to be good, the Commissioners recommend that the roofs at all working faces shall be required to be systematically and adequately supported, irrespective of natural conditions. In their view the fixing distances between supports ought to be shared between the managers and the inspectorate, that is, the manager should be prohibited from fixing a distance greater than the datum except with the consent of the inspector or by award of the tribunal. They propose that the datum be fixed at four feet for the interval between each row of props, between adjacent props in the same row, and between bars, and at three feet for the interval between the front row of props and the face. They also propose that the maximum distance between holing props or sprags be reduced from six feet to five feet.

The Commissioners fully appreciate that the use of bars may be impossible or undesirable in certain natural conditions, such as very thin seams or undulating roofs, and they agree that any enactment on the subject should include provision for exemption by the district inspector where the conditions are unsuitable, or where, owing to the natural strength of the roof, they are unnecessary. Subject to this power of exemption, they recommend that in all longwall faces the systematic use of bars to support the whole width of the roof at the working face should be compulsory, throughout the whole length of the face. In considering applications for exemption from this requirement, the inspector's decision should be final. In workings other than longwall faces, if the inspector thinks the conditions such as to require the use of bars, he would have power to require their use under the general provisions of Section 50 (5), and the manager would retain the right in such cases to appeal against any such requisition that he considered unreasonable.

Where props are used without bars, it is essential, except where the props are set with some special object such as to induce a roof break, that they should be provided with proper lids in order to ensure stability, and the Commissioners recommend that the law should provide accordingly. The best course is for an adequate supply of lids of the correct dimensions to be provided by the management, but in some instances it is customary for the workmen to cut their own lids on the spot. In either case the Commissioners are of opinion that it should be made obligatory for the dimensions of the lids to be used to be specified by the manager in the support rules.

The continuous stowing of the wastes, providing it is well done, offers great advantages in many cases in the interests of good ventilation, but to be of any value for the purpose of roof control the stowing must be packed as tightly as possible to the roof, and a pack which consists merely of material loosely thrown back into the waste, even if it is faced with a good-looking wall, is useless from this point of view.

The Commissioners think the law should require that, if packs constitute part of the system of support, the packs must be well built, suitably spaced and made tight to the roof, and the manager should specify fully the system of packing in his support rules. The specification should include particulars of the maximum distances between adjacent packs and between the packs and the face, the minimum width of the packs, and the method of construction.

In view of the differences in natural conditions and methods of work they do not think it is practicable to lay down a maximum distance of universal application between the face and the packs, nor to provide for packs to be of certain minimum dimensions, whether according to the height of the seams (as suggested by some witnesses) or otherwise.

On the question of temporary supports the Commissioners recommend that the manager should be required to specify in his support rules the maximum distance to which any part of the face may be advanced from the front row of props before a temporary support shall be set. This distance cannot be fixed at more than three feet without the district inspector's consent, and it will ordinarily be less than the interval between the front row of props and the face. The enforcement of any rule as to the setting of temporary props is pre-eminently one of those matters which must depend on the exercise of adequate supervision by the officials on the spot.

Support of the Face.

In the foregoing the Commissioners have been dealing mainly with the support of the roof. The face itself, however, also requires support, and they recommend that there should be a general provision requiring all overhanging coal or clod to be adequately supported, and also that, if the systematic support of the coal face is necessary, the manager should be required to specify in the support rules what type of supports is to be provided and at what intervals they shall be set.

In addition there should, the Commissioners suggest, be the following over-riding provisions, that: (e) when a face exceeding four feet in height is being under-cut by machine, it shall be supported systematically in advance of the cut, and shall remain so supported after the machine has passed; (b) where longwall faces exceeding five feet in height are not to be under-cut, they shall if vertical or worked to the rise, unless exempted by the district inspector, be supported systematically except where and whilst coal is being got.

They have recommended that the props or sprags set in the holing under the face shall not be at a greater distance apart than five feet. For longwall faces cut by machine they consider that the holing sprags should be required to be made of iron or steel or of properly shaped hard wood.

Support of Road-heads.

Statistics show that at road-heads and gate-ends in longwall working there is a marked concentration of accidents from falls of roof. In addition to greater man-density this is also due in part to its greater area of exposed roof which makes the road-head a weak point in the defensive system of roof control, and to the additional risks involved in the advance of the face ripping.

In normal circumstances the road-head is that part of the working which lies between the face ripping and the face. But sometimes the face ripping is carried in advance of the packs right up to or partly up to the face, and occasionally even into a winning heading beyond the general line of the face. In other cases the face ripping may be some distance outbye along the road, in which case its treatment will not need to differ from other road rippings. For the purpose of precautions against coal dust (General Regulations of 30th July, 1920), and of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order, a road is defined as ending at a point ten yards from the coal face. The Commissioners suggest that this definition be adopted for the present purpose, and that the road-head be so defined as to comprise all that' part of the mine, bounded in width by the width of the road, extending for ten yards from the working face, and including the face of the ripping canch or brushing if within that part.

Except in seams worked by bord-and-pillar without top ripping of the roads, the systematic use of bars, set not more than three feet apart, should be compulsory for supporting that part of the "road-head" (as above defined) which lies between the working face and the face ripping, if any, unless exemption has been granted by the district inspector on grounds of impracticability. For that portion of the "road-head" further outbye, between the ripping lip (if any) and the end of the road-head, ten yards outbye from the face, the system of support will, of course, normally be the same as that laid down by the manager for the support of the roads in the same district, and as regards the distance between supports, the maximum proposed below for roads (six feet) should apply.

Support of Roads.

Having considered circumstances referred to in evidence the Commissioners do not think it would be reasonable or practicable to require that all existing roads shall be systematically supported throughout. They are of the opinion, however, that there have been cases where too much reliance has been placed on the apparent strength of a roof which looks good, but which is not really so safe as its appearance suggests, and they recommend that, in the case of existing roads or parts of roads which are unsupported on the date of new legislation coming into force, the district inspector should be given power to require them to be supported (subject to the right of the manager to appeal to the local tribunal if he considers that the inspector's requirement is unreasonable). The inspector could exercise that power, for instance, if he knew from his experience of other mines that the roof of the road in question, though it might not have caused any accident in a particular mine, was inclined to be treacherous elsewhere. The same principle could be applied to extensions and branches of such unsupported roads under similar natural conditions. As regards extensions of other roads or any newly-formed roads, however, the Commissioners see no hardship in requiring compulsory systematic support throughout, unless specific exemption is granted by the district inspector, having regard to the natural conditions of the strata. They recommend that wherever roads have to be systematically supported they should be supported across the full width and that the distance between the supports should in no case exceed six feet.

As regards temporary supports and the supply of materials for supports on roads, they recommend that temporary supports should be erected whenever any work is being done in the repair of the roof or sides of a roadway, or, when a fall has taken place, before the debris is removed, and that at any place where road repairs are to be carried out, an adequate supply of suitable material should be provided on the spot before the work of repair is commenced.

Withdrawal of Supports.

Section 52 (2) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, makes the use of a safety contrivance compulsory for withdrawing any prop in the waste or goaf. The Commissioners think it would be practicable to insist on the use of a safety contrivance in certain specified places in addition to the waste or goaf. For instance, a safety contrivance should always be used for the withdrawal of any prop or sprag set against the coal face itself, or of any support from a pack-hole (that is, a place where a pack is about to be built). when any ripping is about to be taken down, and when any road support is being withdrawn, unless the supports in question are purely temporary ones on which there is little or no weight.

In effect, this would mean that no support, other than a temporary support or a support to the roof of the working face or a holing sprag, shall be withdrawn from any pert of the mine except by means of a safety contrivance, and it is recommended that such a provision be substituted for Section 52 (2). The working face should be defined for this purpose as extending from the face of the coal to the last row of props or chocks for the time being, or to the front line of the packs, or for a distance of 12 feet, whichever is the least. It should be made clear that the provision proposed is not intended to imply that it is considered safe to withdraw any temporary support or any support to the roof of the working face without a safety contrivance. This is far from being the case. But agreement is expressed with those witnesses who held that the proper methods of withdrawing such supports must be left to the judgment of the competent workmen concerned, subject always of course to the general supervision and instructions of the deputies.

The Commissioners are strongly of opinion that no safety contrivance should be used unless it is of a type approved by the Mines Department, and that a sufficient number of the approved contrivances should be provided, wherever required, by the owner of the mine. This recommendation that only appliances of approved types should be used, and that they should be provided and maintained by the owners, would ensure the use of up-to-date apparatus, and would bring this particular matter into line with the general principle already operating as regards other kinds of safety gear.

Cmd. 5890. 7s. 6d. net. H.M. Stationery Office.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Hudspeth, Henry Moore, Major      Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
18 Dec 1935  Safety Of Mine Workers, Royal Commission Personnel (The Yorkshire Post)
04 Jan 1936  Personnel Of Royal Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Feb 1936  Royal Commission Operating (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Feb 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Some Points in Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Mar 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Deputy's Prayer (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  Safety In Mines, Inspectors Offer Suggestions (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  First Hand Studies (The Science and Art of Mining)
20 Jun 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Reason Given for More Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
18 Jul 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Midland and Southern Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Under-Managers Give Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Swansea Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Recommendations for Scottish Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Northern Division Conditions (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Cardiff Area (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Dividing Divisions into Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
10 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, New Conditions Created (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Firemen's Associations (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Evidence of Research Stations Director (The Science and Art of Mining)
21 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Major Hudspeth's Evidence on Researches (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Under-managers' Views before Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  The Personal Factor (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Officials' Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
02 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Medical Problems Considered (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Feb 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, More About Silicosis (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Feb 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Mar 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Managers' Statement (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Mar 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 Apr 1937  Mine Haulage Problems, Some Commission Pointers (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Apr 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Mineworkers' Federation (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 May 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Mining Association's Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Jun 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dust Prevention Methods (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dangerous Conditions or Occurrences (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Education of Mine Workers (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Dec 1938  Mines Safety Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Dec 1938  Safety Commission's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Problems For Mining Community (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Development Of Safety Legislation (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Mines Safety Bill Proposed (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Feb 1939  How Mining Industry Has Changed (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Mar 1939  Colliery Ventilation (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Mar 1939  Support Of Workings (The Science and Art of Mining)
22 Apr 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 May 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — II, Shot-Firing Standards (The Science and Art of Mining)
03 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — III (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — IV, Safety Organisation at Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — V, Occupational Diseases (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print