Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

11th March 1939, Page: 282, Column: 1

Notes On Surveyors' Examination

Central Examiner's Report

Of the 48 candidates attending the November (1938) examination for mine surveyors certificates 20 (41.6 per cent.) qualified in the written examination. In the practical examination there were 16 passes (33.7 per cent.), 5 at Edinburgh, 4 at Newcastle, 3 at Birmingham, 2 at Sheffield, and 1 each at Cardiff and Wigan. The percentage of candidates qualifying for the certificate in November 1937 was 29.4.

Reports from the examiners who conducted the oral and practical examination indicate that only in a comparatively few instances did the marks earned exceed to any great extent the percentage necessary to qualify. As a rule, the work performed with the theodolite was carried out with a fair measure of accuracy, but a number of candidates betrayed a lack of experience in setting and manipulating the instrument, and took a long time to complete the given test. Measuring was frequently carried out in a somewhat haphazard manner, and in one or two instances is described as mediocre. The work done in the levelling test was not so satisfactory as in recent examinations, there being a tendency in several centres to overlook the importance of adopting well-balanced sights. Satisfactory features of the examination are reports of a definite improvement in the booking of field notes and, in the majority of centres, of evidence of more careful draughtamanship. It is suggested by some of the examiners that the duties and responsibility of a mine surveyor are not sufficiently well realised by candidates, and that in several instances their experience appears to be largely confined to instruments and plotting work.

The Central Examiner reports that the average mark earned by candidates who qualified in the written part of the examination was approximately 64. For candidates who failed to qualify the average mark earned was 43. The latter shows a slight increase when compared with the results of recent examinations, but there is still room for further improvement. Even the pass mark, with an average of 64 per cent, of the possible, does not indicate any more than moderate attainment — a view which receives corroboration from the fact that only two candidates obtained 70 or more marks for their written work. Candidates, generally, still show definite lack of aptitude in tackling problems which do not lie within the range of their daily work.

Below we give the text of the questions set at the examination, each question being followed by the comment of the examiner on the general work of the candidates. The comments are in italics. Plans not reproduced. The official pamphlet containing the Question Papers (1s. 6d. net) is obtainable through H.M. Stationery Office.

Morning Session.

(1) Compulsory Question. — The plan . . . shows details taken from a Geological Survey map, and a generalised section showing the relative positions of the various seams whose outcrops are indicated thereon. Draw in your answer book — to the same scale as the plan for horizontals, and twice that scale for verticals — a longitudinal section on the line AB, showing the position of the ironstone seam in relation to the surface. Assume a thickness of 30 feet of alluvium overlying the rockhead and that the surface is level. (14)

Not more than approximately one-fifth of the answers to this by no means difficult question reached the standard which it was reasonable to anticipate. The assumption of a level surface was adopted to shorten the time required for solution, and the problem was perfectly straightforward, apart from the work entailed in ascertaining the approximate depth to No. 3 seam in the area between the two most southerly faults shown on the plan by means of a supplementary section on a line bearing approximately from south-east to north-west within that area. Only a few of the answers gave evidence of the necessity for this supplementary section having been realised. Many candidates still persist in showing the faults in the longitudinal section by a vertical line, despite what has been said in this connection in previous criticisms of work carried out in questions of this type. Obviously, such procedure entirely nullifies the value of the section for practical purposes.

(2) The co-ordinates of two points A and B are respectively as follows :—

From a station Y, observations were taken to the above points and also to another station X, as follows :—

Calculate the azimuth of YX, and the co-ordinates of X, to the nearest minute and the second decimal place of a foot respectively. (Sketch not reproduced.) (12)

This question was attempted by almost every candidate, and produced the most satisfactory answers of any question submitted. Even so, quite a number of correct or approximately correct answers were arrived at by methods which involved considerably more time and calculation than was actually necessary.

(3) A level seam of coal 6 feet thick lies at a depth of 300 yards from the surface, and is worked by the stoop and room method, the rooms being driven 15 feet in width so as to form pillars or "stoops" 120 feet square. There is situated in the surface overlying an area of the workings a water reservoir 200 feet in diameter which is to be protected against the risk of subsidence by leaving unworked 70 per cent, of the whole coal. Calculate (a) the width of the split to be driven through the centre of the pillars so as to leave the desired proportion therein, and (b) the area of the block within which it will be necessary to refrain from extracting the pillars. Assume average coal measures strata, with 50 yards of dry sand and gravel overlying the rockhead. (10)

Comparatively few candidates attempted this essentially practical question, and those who did rarely met with complete success. It was surprising to find the majority of the answers indicating an almost entire lack of knowledge of the simplest and most accurate method of determining the percentage of seam extraction when the size of the pillars and the width of the rooms have been stated. In the second part of the question the radius of the protecting pillar was almost invariably far too small in view of the conditions stated.

(4) In order that a theodolite may be used accurately to measure horizontal angles, it must fulfil certain requirements. State fully these requirements, and thereafter describe the manner in which, by correct manipulation of the instrument, a horizontal angle may be measured with the maximum of accuracy. (8)

This question was a favourite, and answers generally were satisfactory.

(5) Sketch and describe the instrument known as an "optical square." State clearly — (a) the principle on which it is constructed; (b) how you would test its accuracy; and (c) how you could allow for a slight error of adjustment in using the instrument in the field. (8)

Surprisingly few candidates attempted this question, and still fewer of these who did so gave entirely satisfactory answers — the sketches, in particular, being frequently very poor.

Afternoon Session.

(1) Compulsory Question. — The plan . . . shows the position of two winding shafts and certain roadways in a level seam 500 yards in depth, the shafts marked No. 1 and No. 2 being each 16 feet in diameter. Another seam, which lies at a depth of 440 yards from the surface, is about to be opened up and developed, and it has been decided to sink upwards from the lower to the upper seam, at the point A, a staple pit 10 feet in diameter, and thereafter to drive a communication road in the upper seam to No. 2 shaft, as shown on the plan. You are to be held responsible for the accurate carrying out of this work. State fully: (a) What preliminary surveys you would make, and the instruments and equipment you would require. (b) How you would set off the staple pit, and maintain its verticality during sinking; and (c) how you would correlate the upper seam to the lower in order to ensure an accurate connection to No. 2 pit. Illustrate your answer by a sketch or sketches where necessary. (14)

This question had as its basis workings which were drawn to give practically ideal conditions for the work required. While there were a number of excellent answers, candidates generally failed to appreciate the ease with which a tied-in traverse in the lower seam workings could be made so as to satisfactorily establish a base, in the vicinity of the staple pit. The suggested methods for plumbing the latter frequently indicated the lack of what was necessary in this connection. Several candidates suggested correlation by magnetic methods which, in this particular instance, were not satisfactory.

(2) The following traverse notes were taken along a level underground roadway :—

It is desired to straighten the roadway, and to lay out a centre line passing through station A and another point 3.66 feet due east of station E. Calculate the distance to the centre line at the stations B, C and D respectively to enable the centre line to be accurately set out. (12)

Answers generally were not so good as they ought to have been, and many candidates were obviously unacquainted with the most accurate and straightforward method of carrying out the work involved.

(3) Undernoted are data relating to the four sides of an irregularly shaped field :—

The points A, B and D are level, and the point C is 12 feet higher than these points, the slope being uniform to a line joining B and D. Calculate the volume of ground to be excavated so as to form a uniform level surface continuous with A B D. Assume that the material will remain vertical along the edges of the excavated area. (12)

This question was not generally attempted, and not more than seven or eight accurate answers were obtained. The solution first of all necessitated a calculation of the length of the line CD, and candidates frequently went astray in doing so.

(4) A mineral field contains a seam of anthracite coal which has bean proved by three bores A, B and C, and it has been decided to sink a shaft at another point D to work it. From the undernoted data, calculate the depth from the surface at which the shaft will intersect the seam.

A favourite question, and one which yielded a fair proportion of satisfactory answers. As in others, the method of solution adopted frequently involved calculations far more involved and laborious than were actually essential.

(5) The co-ordinates, in feet, of a bore-hole put down to intersect a seam are as follows :—

The depth of the hole as measured is 900 feet. Calculate the direction of the deviation and the amount thereof in inches. (5)

Another favourite question, which was generally accurately answered.

(6) In laying out a railway curve AOC the undernoted details were taken: Apex angle ABC = 154°13', and apex length OB 17.23 feet. Calculate, in square yards, the area of ground contained between the arc of the curve and its two tangents. (8)

This question was attempted by roughly one-half of the candidates, and only five correct or approximately correct answers were obtained.


Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
27 Aug 1938  Board For Mining Examinations (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Feb 1939  Examination Results (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Mar 1939  Notes On Surveyors' Examination, Central Examiner's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Mar 1939  Where Certificates Were Obtained (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Mar 1939  Notes On Managers' Examinations — I, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 Apr 1939  Notes On Managers' Examinations — II, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
22 Apr 1939  Notes On Managers' Examinations — III, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print