Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

11th March 1939, Page: 273, Column: 1

Colliery Ventilation

Consequences of Mechanisation.

The greater part of Chapter V. of the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines Report* is concerned with the adequate dilution and removal of inflammable gas. It is agreed that one of the consequences of modern mechanised mining in a gassy mine is an increase in the rate of emission of inflammable gas for a given length of face. With rapidly advancing mechanised faces the volume of gas to be dealt with in a given time from the same length of face may be several times greater than the emission with hand-got work in the same seam, and if the total length of face in work remained unchanged the amount of ventilation required to deal adequately with the additional gas would be correspondingly increased. On the other hand the faces are usually shorter, straighter and easier to ventilate effectively, and the effective stowing of the wastes may be facilitated by the use that can be made of mechanical conveyors in the transport of packing material. The airways, being fewer in number and further apart, also present less opportunity for leakage and, if necessary, can he made bigger; and, though it may be more difficult to maintain them in good condition and keep pace with the face-advance, other considerations are involved, at any rate on those airways used for haulage, which require these difficulties to be overcome, quite apart from the question of ventilation. Mechanisation also facilitates the application of the principles of systematic roof control, which may have the effect of minimising the emission of gas by reduction in the fracturing of the strata ahead of the face and which in any case should ensure less unforeseen interference with the ventilation from falls. Also the various factors which affect the emission of gas, such as the rate of output, the amount of coal-cutting, and the convergence between roof and floor, should be under better control in mechanised working. In the light of these considerations, it seems to the Commissioners that there should in general be no great practical difficulty in achieving a high standard of ventilation in mechanised working.

Practical Standard Needed.

Referring to Section 67 of the Coal Mines Act the statement is made that although it was intended to constitute a standard of withdrawal only and not an adequate standard of ventilation, it is difficult in practice to enforce the distinction. The counter argument sometimes advanced is that if, as regards the presence of firedamp, Section 67 does not deem a place to be dangerous and does permit men to continue to work in it so long as the percentage is below 2½, then the firedamp must be sufficiently diluted to be "harmless" within the meaning of Section 29. A similar difficulty arises by repercussion from Section 67 in the administration of Section 32, which requires the use of safety-lamps in any place in which there is likely to be any such quantity of inflammable gas as to render the use of naked lights dangerous; under Section 67, nothing less than 1¼ per cent. of firedamp in the general body of the air in a naked light working is deemed to be dangerous, although that is a condition which seldom occurs even in safety-lamp mines.

The present law provides neither a clear definition nor standard of adequate ventilation nor any effective powers to enable the Mines Department to fix such a standard based on the "normal" firedamp content of the general body of the air, and the Commissioners agree with the evidence given on behalf of the Department that the inspectors would be in a stronger and happier position, and uniformity of administration would be promoted, if they had a practical standard to work to. A firedamp content of 2½ per cent. in the general body of the air is not satisfactory as a standard of ventilation because such a percentage in the general body of the air in any place is an almost certain indication that somewhere there must be double that percentage, which means the presence of an explosive mixture. Their proposal is to effect a general improvement in ventilation standards by reducing the figure at which workmen must be withdrawn. [This is subject to reservation by Mr. E. O. Forster Brown]. Also, in order to ensure that managers fix and implement their normal working standard well within this limit, and to give H.M. inspectors some measure of control in future over the methods of ventilation adopted, that the normal occurrence of some appropriately chosen firedamp percentage in the general body of the air, below the withdrawal point, should be regarded as a warning of the need for immediate steps to be taken by the management to improve the ventilation.

Withdrawal Standards.

Proceeding to the discussion of withdrawal standards, it seems to the Commissioners that any reduction in the amount of inflammable gas in the air of a mine is a contribution to safety, because it must increase the margin between safety and danger, and because the lower the percentage of gas the smaller is the amount of incombustible dust required to suppress the inflammability of coal dust. It is just as logical and important to have an adequate margin or factor of safety against the danger of inflammable gas as it is in (say) a winding or haulage rope or the gauzes of a safety-lamp or the flameproof enclosure for electrical apparatus.

In France and Russia the withdrawal figure is 2 per cent. and the same figure has been adopted by the United States Government in the Federal Regulations which now apply to all mines working publicly owned coal. In Czechoslovakia the general withdrawal standard is 2½ per cent., but in working places where coal dust is present that has not been rendered harmless by stone-dusting or by watering (i.e., in practically all working faces) the figure is per cent. In Germany the withdrawal standard is understood in effect to be 1 per cent.

In all the circumstances the Commissioners think the balance of the evidence is strongly on the side of a reduction in the withdrawal figure, and that conclusion is supported from a practical point of view by the desirability of fixing the figure which can most easily be definitely recognised on the types of lamps which are required to be in general use by deputies. They therefore recommend (subject to reservation by Mr. E. O. Forster Brown) that the withdrawal figure in safety-lamp mines should be fixed in future at 2 per cent. They are also strongly of opinion that whatever figure is fixed for withdrawal should be of absolutely universal application, and should not be subject to modification by exemption or otherwise in any individual case (subject to reservation by Mr. John Walker). They recognise, however, that in some cases time would be required in order to effect any improvements necessary to comply with this standard. If their recommendations are adopted, there will necessarily be an interval between the announcement of the Government's intentions, and the passage of the legislation giving effect to them. That interval could, and should, be utilised for effecting improvements in anticipation of the new requirements, but, even so, in cases of special difficulty it may be insufficient, and they recommend that provision for giving reasonable time in such cases should be made in any legislation on the subject. They do not believe there are any mines in which the ventilation could not be improved to the required extent, given reasonable time in which to do it.

As regards the withdrawal of workmen in naked light mines, the present withdrawal figure of 1¼ per cent. in the general body of the air appears to the Commissioners to be based on a misconception of the conditions under which the use of naked lights should be permitted. Men should not be permitted to remain at work with naked lights if any gas at all can be found on the flame of a safety-lamp anywhere in the ventilating district in which they are to work or pass, seeing that such a discovery will necessitate the general use of safety-lamps in the seam, unless exemption is granted by the district inspector.

Systematic Sampling of Air-current.

There is no statutory provision for systematic tests of the firedamp content of ventilating currents with a record of results, such as there is for the systematic sampling and analysis of the coal-dust content of the dust from mine roadways under the General Regulations of 30th July, 1920. The Commissioners propose that there should be such a provision, the principal object of the proposed sampling being to ascertain the firedamp content of the air-current entering and leaving the working face at the time when it is likely to be highest. Since the emission of gas varies according to the nature of the work which is being done, the samples should be taken during the shift on which, and in that part of the shift when, the percentage of gas is greatest, but it is impossible to lay down a general requirement to determine which shift that is, or at what part of it the percentage reaches its maximum, though usually it will be in the latter part of the stripping shift; the management, if doubtful, can only settle the doubt by trial on each shift for a short period.

It is not intended that this scheme of systematic sampling and analysis should in any respect take the place of frequent regular examinations of the state of the mine air by deputies, shot-firers and persons in charge of electrical apparatus, or be a substitute for the provision of firedamp detectors for use by workmen, all which precautions are designed to detect and deal with sudden, abnormal, or localised accumulations of firedamp, as distinct from the normal state of the mine air in ordinary circumstances.

Summary of Scheme.

The Commissioners present the following summary of their scheme for systematic sampling in safety-lamp mines :—

(i) In all seams in which safety-lamps are used, the percentage of inflammable gas in the general body of the air (hereafter called "the firedamp content") shall be ascertained by systematic measurement, by a competent person appointed in writing by the manager, initially in each shift and subsequently in the shift and at the time where most gas is present.

(ii) The measurements shall be made with an apparatus of approved type, capable of giving readings on the spot, and shall be checked at intervals by analysis.

(iii) The measurements shall be made in each ventilating district . . . If the ventilating district is worked longwall the measurements shall be made (a) at or as near as practicable to a point in the airway ten yards on the return side of the last working place of each working face in the district, (b) in the intake airway at or as near as practicable to a point ten yards from the first working place at the working face which the air enters, and (c) at such other place (if any) on each working face in the district as the district inspector may direct . . . If the ventilating district is worked otherwise than by longwall, the measurements shall be made at such suitable points as the manager shall fix with the approval of the district inspector, whose decision shall be final.

(iv) The measurements shall be made monthly if the firedamp content at any of the fixed points does not exceed 0.75 per cent., weekly if it exceeds 0.75 per cent. but does not exceed 1.25 per cent, and if electric power is not in use within 300 yards of the face, and daily if it exceeds 1.25 per cent. . . . If electric power is in use in any part of the district within 300 yards of the face, the measurements shall be made daily instead of weekly when the firedamp content exceeds 0.75 per cent.

(v) The firedamp contents (together with the fan revolutions or the water-gauge reading at the time, taken under General Regulation 72 and the air measurements taken under General Regulation 77, as modified by other recommendations shall be recorded in a prescribed hook to be kept at the mine for the purpose . . . When the conditions are such that measurements of firedamp content are made weekly or daily, a copy of the measurements shall be sent on the prescribed form to the district inspector. Daily measurements need not, however, be reported to him at shorter intervals than once a week, unless he so requires.

(vi) The inspectors may check the management's measurements by making measurements or taking samples themselves as and when they think fit.

There will no doubt be other details to be worked out and that should be done by the Mines Department in consultation with the industry. The principles of the scheme should then be embodied in the Act, and the details in regulations.

The effect of the above proposals is to provide the management and the inspectors with systematic information about the state of the ventilation on each working face in longwall working or in each ventilating district in bord-and-pillar, and a consideration of this information over a sufficient period will provide a means of assessing what may be called the "representative firedamp content" of the face or district.

According to the proposals, when the representative firedamp content at the return end of a face or district exceeds an assigned level, the management is to be required to take all practicable steps to effect improvements in the system of ventilation, which will at least reduce the firedamp content to that level.

As regards the practice in foreign countries, it may be noted that in France no return airway from any development working may contain more than 1½ per cent. of firedamp at any time, and for all other returns 1 per cent. is the maximum allowed. In Germany the air-current must nowhere contain as much as 1 per cent. A similar rule was until recently in force in Holland, but the limit has now been raised to 1½ per cent., and the Chief Inspector is authorised to allow temporary working at higher percentages under special conditions for a definite period.

The Commissioners have felt bound to conclude that, as far as practicable, the chosen standard must be a common one for the whole country, and, after a careful review of the information available, they propose that improvement in the system of ventilation should in general be required if the "representative firedamp content" (which is not necessarily an average and is to be arrived at on a fair consideration of the samples) exceeds 1½ per cent. In the great majority of mines there should be no difficulty whatever in working to that figure.

The recommendation of the Commissioners is put briefly in the following form :—

If, on a fair consideration of the measurements over a sufficient period, the district inspector finds that the representative firedamp content at the return end of any face exceeds 1½ per cent., he may (if he wishes) require a ventilation survey to be made.

If the district inspector is satisfied, with or without a survey, that it is reasonably practicable for steps to be taken to bring the representative firedamp content below 1½ per cent. he shall have power to require the manager of the mine to inform him what steps are to be taken to make the necessary improvement in the ventilation and within what period this is to be done. The district inspector may either approve the manager's proposals or require further or other steps to be taken or fix some shorter period for completion.

If the district inspector is satisfied that it is not reasonably practicable to bring the representative gas content below 1½ per cent, he may, subject to such safeguards as he considers appropriate, accept the continuance of a higher figure than 1½ per cent. but not higher than the withdrawal figure.

Any disputes with the manager as to the practicability or otherwise of keeping the representative gas content below 1½ per cent., or as to the steps to be taken and/or the time for their completion, or as to the figure (if any) which is to be substituted for 1½ shall be referred to the Secretary for Mines, whose decision shall be final.

Ventilation Practice.

In the course of their inquiry the Commissioners have considered numerous suggestions involving the regulation of what may be described broadly as ventilation practice, that is the means by which adequate ventilation is produced, as distinct from the end which is required to be achieved. They have been invited to propose statutory requirements for the purpose of minimising leakage, prescribing minima for the number and size of airways, regulating the manner and direction in which air should be coursed and split, limiting the size of ventilation splits either by the number of persons at work in a split at any one time, or the length of working face, putting some limitations either upward or downward on air-velocity, and so on. These problems are all discussed in detail and the following brief excerpts are from their Report

They propose that in addition to being measured at the downcast shaft and in every split at the point where the split commences, the quantity of air should be measured, at least once in every month, at or as near as practicable to a point ten yards back from the first working place at the working face which the air enters, and at or as near as practicable to a point ten yards on the return side of the last working place at the working face which the air leaves. In either case the district inspector should have power, if circumstances render it desirable, to substitute some other distance for the ten yards.

They recommend that, except at "small" mines, all new upcast shafts and, within a period of three years, all existing upcast shafts should be required to be equipped with properly constructed air-locks, provided that the Secretary for Mines may exempt from this requirement any shaft on the ground that it is infrequently used for winding or that the requisite space is not available or on other similar special grounds.

They recommend that there should be a provision requiring at least two doors or two sheets to be provided and so arranged that, if one is open, at least one other doing the same work is shut. When the airways are main airways, sheets should not be used for this purpose, and they recommend that only properly constructed doors shall be permitted in connecting roads between main intakes and main returns.

On general grounds it is preferable to utilise as much as possible of the rubbish produced in working the mine for packing the wastes than to transport it to the surface and leave it there in the form of useless and unsightly pit-heaps. From the ventilation point of view they wish to emphasise the advantages of continuous stowing in many cases, and while they do not feel it to be practicable to suggest that such stowing should be compulsory, they think that the Mines Department should take the matter up with the industry with a view to the practice being more widely adopted than it is at present.

The Commissioners think it desirable in the interests of adequate ventilation that all new development should be based on a minimum standard of three airways. They see no reason why that should not be made a general requirement, though they do not see any need to specify whether the three airways should consist of two intakes and one return or one intake and two returns.

For roads which are normally airways and nothing else the Commissioners are prepared to accept the figure of four feet square offered by the Mining Association, except that, having regard to the purpose of the requirement, they should prefer to express it in terms of minimum area, and allow of some elasticity in height or width. They recommend, therefore, that such airways shall be required to have a minimum area of 16 square feet, clear of all obstructions, subject to the width being not less than three feet, and the height not less than four feet. If, however, the airway, though not normally used for travelling or transport of mineral, constitutes an alternative means of egress, these dimensions would be insufficient, and the minimum area should then, they recommend, be 20 square feet, with a minimum of four feet for both width and height. In their view the dimensions proposed can reasonably be required right up to the face-ripping, provided the inspectors have power to grant exemptions to meet special conditions.

They recommend that there should be specific provision in the statute requiring that in all headings and fast ends the ventilation must be constantly taken up to the face of the working or the fast end, as the case may be, by means of brattice, air-pipes, or otherwise.

If the place, road, or level is to be regarded as abandoned and left unventilated, steps will be necessary to prevent persons from getting in, and, so far as practicable, any accumulated gas from coming out. Fencing, in the ordinary sense of the term, is not sufficient to serve either of those purposes, and the Commissioners recommend that abandoned places, roads, or levels, if not adequately ventilated, should be required to be stowed up or walled off by means of a stopping constructed in the manner laid down in General Regulation 91.

Existing auxiliary fans might in the opinion of the Commissioners be continued in use subject to the district inspector being given the power to object in any individual instance, in which case the manager, if not prepared to comply with the inspector's ruling, should have the right to appeal to the local tribunal. In future, however, no fan should be newly installed below ground, except for the auxiliary ventilation of headings, drifts or tunnels, without the district inspector's prior approval. The movement of the fan from one place to another should be regarded as a new installation. They recommend that Section 31 (2) be amended accordingly.

Another means of auxiliary ventilation is the use of compressed air. There may be occasions, as for example in driving long narrow places in a seam preparatory to working it by retreating longwall, when the use of compressed air is a surer means of supplying adequate ventilation than the use of air-pipes. But the use of compressed air for ventilation purposes may lead to grave abuse. The temptation to use compressed air in the wrong way, if it is used at all, is so strong that they think its use for ventilation purposes should be prohibited, except with the express consent of the district inspector.

The view is expressed that the law should require the ventilation to be adequate not only to dilute and render harmless any noxious or inflammable gases but also to maintain conditions of temperature and humidity which are not prejudicial to health, or likely to cause such fatigue or discomfort as to increase the risk of accident.

In their discussion on deep and hot mines the Commissioners recommend that the Mines Department should make general regulations which would require the management to have systematic readings taken and recorded by a competent person with a kata-thermometer at appropriate points on working faces where the wet-bulb temperature in the return air exceeds, say, 78 degrees Fahrenheit, and the air velocity (as indicated by the statutory air-measurements) is less than 150 feet per minute. In any case where the ventilation is found to fall short of the required standard, the management should be given a reasonable time, according to the circumstances, in which to effect the necessary improvements. The time should be fixed by the district inspector, having regard to the nature of the work to be done, and the management should have the right of appeal to the local tribunal if the time so fixed were considered unreasonable, but not on any other grounds.

Further research into the subject should be actively pursued and the results should be kept under review by the Mines Department with the object of substituting some better standard if one can be found.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Forster Brown, Edward Otto      Whos Who Page
Walker, John      



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
18 Dec 1935  Safety Of Mine Workers, Royal Commission Personnel (The Yorkshire Post)
04 Jan 1936  Personnel Of Royal Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Feb 1936  Royal Commission Operating (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Feb 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Some Points in Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Mar 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Deputy's Prayer (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  Safety In Mines, Inspectors Offer Suggestions (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 May 1936  First Hand Studies (The Science and Art of Mining)
20 Jun 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Reason Given for More Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
18 Jul 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Midland and Southern Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Under-Managers Give Evidence (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Swansea Division (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Recommendations for Scottish Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Aug 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Northern Division Conditions (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, The Cardiff Area (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Sep 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Dividing Divisions into Districts (The Science and Art of Mining)
10 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, New Conditions Created (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Oct 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Firemen's Associations (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Evidence of Research Stations Director (The Science and Art of Mining)
21 Nov 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Major Hudspeth's Evidence on Researches (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Under-managers' Views before Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Dec 1936  The Personal Factor (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Dec 1936  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Officials' Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
02 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
16 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Electricity in Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Medical Problems Considered (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Feb 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, More About Silicosis (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Feb 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Mar 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Colliery Managers' Statement (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Mar 1937  Mines Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 Apr 1937  Mine Haulage Problems, Some Commission Pointers (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Apr 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Mineworkers' Federation (The Science and Art of Mining)
08 May 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Mining Association's Views (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Jun 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dust Prevention Methods (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Dangerous Conditions or Occurrences (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Jul 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Education of Mine Workers (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Aug 1937  Safety In Coal Mines, Views of Institution Council (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Dec 1938  Mines Safety Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Dec 1938  Safety Commission's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Problems For Mining Community (The Science and Art of Mining)
28 Jan 1939  Safety In Coal Mines, Royal Commission's Recommendations (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Development Of Safety Legislation (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Feb 1939  Mines Safety Bill Proposed (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Feb 1939  How Mining Industry Has Changed (The Science and Art of Mining)
11 Mar 1939  Colliery Ventilation (The Science and Art of Mining)
25 Mar 1939  Support Of Workings (The Science and Art of Mining)
22 Apr 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 May 1939  Colliery Explosions And Fires — II, Shot-Firing Standards (The Science and Art of Mining)
03 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Jun 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — III (The Science and Art of Mining)
15 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — IV, Safety Organisation at Mines (The Science and Art of Mining)
29 Jul 1939  Commission's Miscellaneous Pointers — V, Occupational Diseases (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print