|
25th February 1939, Page: 265, Column: 1 Dust Produced By Rock DrillingBy A. Shaw and J. Ivon Graham. Extracts from paper on "The Rate of Production and the Free Silica-content of the Fine Dust Produced by Rock Drilling," presented at the 49th annual general meeting of the Institution of Mining Engineers. Investigation of the sources of dust-production in hard headings, and of the composition of the dust dispersed into the atmosphere where it may be breathed by workmen, has formed part of the programme of investigations on silicosis which have been carried out by the Mining Research Laboratory for The British Colliery Owners Research Association. Drilling tests have been carried out under standardised conditions upon large pieces of rocks. which included lumps up to 4 tons in weight, from collieries in South Wales, Kent, Staffordshire, Leicestershire, Durham, and Yorkshire, Cornish granite and lode from a tin mine, quartzites from quarries in Derbyshire, Holyhead, and Worcestershire, and also "banket" from a South African gold mine. Microscopically, it is extremely difficult to identify all the mineral constituents of a dust of respirable size, i.e., particles below 5µ in diameter, so that their quantitative determination by this method becomes practically impossible. Ultimate analysis of the dust by chemical means is of little value in the determination of the proportion of minerals present, but, on the other hand, there are various methods available for the estimation of one constituent mineral, viz., free silica. The application of X-rays to the analysis of dusts shows great promise, but the method is still in the development stage. Analytical difficulties, therefore, form the main obstacle in the collection of information regarding the composition of dusts of respirable size. There are, however, other difficulties, the chief being the collection of samples of dust of definite maximal particle size and in quantity sufficient for analysis. Obviously, if the composition of the dust differs from that of the rock from which the dust is formed, then the composition of the coarse dust may differ from that of the fine. At the present time the various methods available for the collection of air-borne dusts ignore the question of size, with the result that the dust collected depends chiefly on that present in the air, and in some cases upon the rate of sampling of the filtering device. It is, of course, difficult to remove the coarse dust present in practice before collection on a filter, but the collected sample could be treated in the laboratory either by air elutriation or by sedimentation in some liquid, such as alcohol, to remove the coarser dust before analyses were made. Conditions are changing both in factories and mines, so that samples collected at the present time may not now be representative of the conditions which existed some ten or twenty years ago, and which were, no doubt, responsible for the cases of silicosis now being certified. It may be possible, of course, to reproduce old-time conditions, but in coal mines this usually involves the dry drilling of holes in hard rock without any dust-suppression device, a procedure which is not advisable. Although the quantity of dust formed in the tests is probably similar to that formed in actual practice, it was considered desirable that the total amount of fine dust, i.e., below 5µ, formed in the drilling process should be ascertained. The experimental procedure was, consequently, modified to ensure this and also to standardise, wherever possible, the conditions of the tests. Effect of Rate of Drilling. There is in practically every case a small but definite increase in the free silica-content of the dust with a decrease in the rate of drilling, this increase being associated with the production of a greater amount of fine dust during drilling, so that low rates of drilling result in the production of a greater quantity of fine dust with a higher free silica-content than with high rates of drilling. Although the rates of drilling in such rocks as the South African banket are much lower than those probably obtaining in practice, the variation in free silica-content of the dust is not so great as to suggest that the dust produced under practical conditions would have a free silica-content very different from that of the dusts. obtained in the laboratory. The rates of the drilling in most Coal-Measure rocks in the laboratory tests were of the same order as those obtaining in practice, so that the analytical figures in these cases are believed to be representative of actual mining conditions. Although it is impossible to classify all the rocks tested as harmful or harmless from the silicosis-producing point of view, it is significant that such rocks as the South African banket, the Cornish lode, and the Somerset Greys all have a high free silica-dust production while the apparently harmless rocks produce comparatively little free silica. The sample of Somerset Greys used for the drilling test was actually obtained from a quarry and was by no means so highly siliceous as some hand specimens taken from hard headings in some of the Somerset coal mines. These hand specimens contained up to 80 per cent. of free silica and there is little doubt that these harder and more highly siliceous rocks would have a considerably greater free silica-dust production than the sample tested. Dust Concentrations. Estimates of the dust concentrations produced during dry drilling were made in several cases by tests carried out in a closed shed. To enable drilling to be carried on continuously for 7 minutes several holes were necessary in some cases, and although the change-over from one hole to another was made very quickly the cessation of drilling was indicated by a fall in the dust-concentration. In the majority of cases this effect was not very great. In the case of the South Wales sandstone, however, the effect of cessation of drilling during the change-over from hole to hole was marked; in this case the dust produced was either very coarse or agglomerated rapidly, and thus tended to settle out very quickly. As a contrast to this, the dust from the Yorkshire sandstone showed little tendency to settle out and the dust concentration was still rising rapidly at the end of the experiment. Curves obtained showed that the dust concentration varies considerably for various types of rock and bears little relation to the actual amount of fine dust formed as determined in the standardised drilling test. One factor which appears to have a definite effect upon the dust concentration is the moisture-content of the rock. Tests to determine the amount of dust in the air of a hard heading in sandstone in a Glamorganshire steam-coal pit, where the rock was practically saturated with water, showed an inappreciable amount of duet in the air in spite of the fact that the customary "dry" hammer-drill was employed without any precautions for trapping the dust. On the other hand, tests with wet drilling in a dry rock showed clearly that any air leakage down the drill-steel was immediately followed by the production of dust at the mouth of the borehole. The quantity formed varied, depending upon the quantity of air which passed down the drill-steel, and also, no doubt, upon the degree of moisture in the rock itself. The dissemination of dust during wet drilling may be altogether prevented by employment of an external water-feed. Results of Investigations. The results obtained in the investigations may be summarised as follows :— 1. During dry drilling only a portion of the fine dust formed is raised into the air. A large quantity is carried down with coarse dust, and if not removed by dust-trap or rendered damp by wet drilling or by other means, is a source of potential danger in the subsequent operations of shot-firing and shovelling. The employment of a dust-trap together with the use of sharp, correctly hardened drill-steels, along with a sufficiency of air passing down the drill-steel to remove all particles, should reduce to a minimum the possibility of danger to the driller, and probably increase the rate of drilling. 2. The free silica-content of the fine dust is almost always less than that of the rock from which it is formed. The difference is great with soft sandstones but very much less with the Rubery and Holyhead quartzites and with hard conglomerates containing quartz pebbles, such as the South African banket and the South Wales quartzite. 3. The free silica-content of the dust is dependent upon the rate of drilling, being slightly greater the slower the rate of drilling. 4. The free silica-dust production expressed as grammes of free silica-dust (0.5µ) per foot of hole drilled gives a measure of the total exposure to silica-dust of men drilling in these rocks, and may be taken as an indication of the silicosis-producing character of the rock. The results indicate that all rocks from which more than 25 gin. of free silica-dust are formed per foot drilled should be considered harmful, and every precaution should be taken to prevent inhalation of the dust by the workmen.
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||