28th January 1939, Page: 230, Column: 1
Stemming In Metal Mines
A paper on "Stemming in Metal Mines" was prepared by
Messrs. J. B. Richardson and J. D. Willson for presentation at
the meeting of the Institution of Mining and Metallurgy on the
19th January. The purpose of the paper was to show that close
attention to the choice, preparation, and use of stemming material
will reduce appreciably the cost of breaking ground in metal
mines, and at the same time lessen the danger to the health of
underground workers.
As the Authors say, the subject of stemming has received closer
study in coal than in metal mines, for the obvious reason that the
coal miner is forced by law to tamp stemming on his explosives
in this and other countries. Even though firing in the presence
of gas is prohibited there is always the risk of igniting dust, and
hence safety considerations compel the use of stemming, quite
apart from the fact that the explosives used have a greater need
for it than the more powerful and rapid detonating explosives
used in metal mining. Moreover, in coal mines, explosives are
used to break down gently the coal which has been already undercut,
in order to produce the greatest possible proportion of lump
material, whereas in metal mines the rock must be broken to a
size small enough to be easily loaded. As, therefore, explosives
form a far higher proportion of the cost of breaking ground, there
is all the more reason for striving to obtain the greatest efficiency
from this expensive commodity.
For most of the points dealt with in their paper Messrs.
Richardson and Willson give references to well-known sources
of authority. Plastic clays are mistakenly preferred in many
mines for stemming, largely because of the ease of moulding them
to the required shape, and because they are frequently to hand.
This kind of stemming need not be supplied in the crude form
of a carload of clay sent to the working place, as there are many
devices for mixing and making it into plugs, pills, or cartridges.
That sand is more efficient than plastic clay was clearly established
by Audibert and Ritson and Stafford. The grape experiment
of Audibert and the tin-can experiment of Ritson, in which
clay stemming was shot out of the drill-hole as a projectile from
a gun, leave no doubt on this score. Modifications of both these
experiments carried out by the Authors (but comparing sand and
clay simultaneously by the same explosive charge) gave conclusive
checks. Sand has a further great advantage over ordinary clay
or other plastic stemming in that it keeps well, clay being difficult
to keep in proper condition in a dry mine, as on drying and
hardening it either crumbles into pieces when handled or remains
in a hard solid lump, and it is clearly troublesome to re-mix it
with water and bring it back to a plastic state. Adding and
mixing in such substances as calcium chloride to increase the
period of plasticity obviously adds to the cost.
Metal Mine Conditions.
All over the world, the Authors proceed to say, the metal miner
seems to have a rooted objection to being forced to use stemming,
and disciplinary action has frequently to be taken to ensure that
he does so. In some cases, the management has given up the
struggle, either through lack of conviction that there is anything
to be gained or because, even if an advantage is admitted, the
rigid enforcement of its proper use is too difficult. The reasons
given by the metal miner against the use of stemming are generally
the following (a) The explosives he uses are so fast that stemming
is unnecessary, (b) proper stemming material is difficult to obtain
underground and costly to bring into the mine, and miss-fire is
more easily cared for if the hole has not been tamped with stemming.
That none of these objections applies to dry sand stemming
can be easily understood by considering each point.
Messrs. Richardson and Willson emphasise in their paper that
in metal mining there is, as a general rule, no question of breaking
ground gently, and the explosive used in any particular ground
is governed largely by economic considerations, the cheapest
explosive of sufficient strength being chosen. The best possible
stemming material, therefore, is desirable to gain the maximum
efficiency of the explosives used. At the same time, they indicate
that a stemming cartridge can be produced, suitable for holes
in any direction, that will not interfere with ease of handling
miss-fired shots — that great bugbear and danger in the operation
of breaking ground. Highly suitable material is not only easily
obtainable in many metal-mining districts, but the devices for
making it into cartridges are so simple to operate that any labour
is sufficiently intelligent to produce satisfactory cartridges, and
the most expensive labour cannot fail to turn out a good product
at a cheap rate.
Lastly, the Authors mention that the two main causes of air
dustiness in metal mines are drilling and blasting. Wet drilling,
if ample water at sufficient pressure is used and especially when
wet collaring is enforced, largely eliminates dust from the first
cause ; but the hazard from dust caused by blasting is not entirely
overcome by ventilation and spraying, as the fine particles of dust
do not adhere to the drops of the sprayed liquid but are carried
round and behind them in the displaced air. They believe that
too little attention has been given to discovering the minimum
amount of explosive force required to break rock, and that the
miner left to himself, even when he pays for his explosives, makes
sure of the success of his round by using an excess, and thus forces
into the surrounding air more dust and noxious gases than is
necessary.
The more perfectly the charge is confined, the less dust and
fumes will pollute the mine atmosphere from the points where
blasting takes place, and they think a close study of stemming
and tamping will assist in lessening this danger and so improve
the health and safety as well as the efficiency of miners.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Audibert, — | | | |
| Richardson, J. B. | | | |
| Ritson, — | | | |
| Stafford, — | | | |
| Willson, J. D. | | | |