Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

17th December 1938, Page: 177, Column: 1

Choice Of Underground Machinery — II

By John T. Pringle, M.I.M.E.

From paper before the annual general meeting of the Associates and Students' Section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers.

Motors and Control Gear.

The first consideration in the choice of electrical equipment is governed by working conditions, high ambient temperature, damp or wet conditions, dust or chippings, exposure to corrosive fumes and to explosive gases.

Since all losses due to the conversion of electrical energy to mechanical power are directly converted to heat, it can be taken as an example that a 20 B.H.P. motor with full load efficiency of 90 per cent. will have heat losses amounting to 10 per cent. or 2 H.P. If the motor is totally enclosed and on full load for one hour, the accumulated heat (minus the small amount radiated by the frame) would be equal to 5,073 B.T. Units, which is sufficient heat to raise 33½ lb. of water from 60°F. to boiling point. Heat due to conversion losses must always be appreciated as an important factor, and every reasonable provision made for its removal.

The rating of electrical motors is based upon temperature rise, hence it is important to remember in considering the types of enclosure that the enclosure affects the temperature rise, and should it be necessary to enclose an electric motor after putting it into service, owing to bad conditions, the output may be seriously affected, and the temperature rise forced up beyond safe limits.

Omitting the consideration of D.C. machines there are about eight A.C. machines that may be employed underground.

(1) The enclosed ventilated squirrel cage motor is defined as a machine with ventilated openings in the frame and end covers protected by wire screens with openings not less than 1/50 square inch and not larger than ½ square inch. Machines having covers less than square inch are to be regarded as totally enclosed machines, as the fine mesh restricts the ventilation. Enclosed ventilated machines are satisfactory where only small quantities of dust are to be dealt with. These machines are often used where an entirely different type of enclosure should be provided, as certain dusts combined with oil can produce a breakdown path over long insulated surfaces.

(2) Enclosed ventilated slip-ring machines are similar to (1) in enclosure.

(3) Totally enclosed squirrel cage low-thermo, fan cooled machines should only be used in extreme circumstances. Such machines are defined as being so enclosed as to prevent circulation of air between the inside and outside of the case, but not sufficiently to be termed airtight. Exposure to excessive moisture or corrosive fumes, inflammable dust or excessive dust are conditions under which total enclosure is necessary.

(4) Enclosed, ventilated, slip-ring machines with third bearing are similar to (2) in enclosure.

(5) Enclosed ventilated squirrel cage machines of vertical type are similar to (1) in enclosure.

(6) Totally enclosed squirrel cage machines are similar in enclosure to (3).

(7) The Cowl ventilated drip-proof slip-ring machine is a motor having openings so protected as to exclude falling moisture or dirt. These machines are wrongly designated as splash-proof. This type is satisfactory in situations where occasional falls of moisture or dirt have to he contended with. It will only give protection against small quantities of any material too heavy for suspension in air in the form of dust.

(8) The totally enclosed slip-ring with flameproof S.R. enclosure is a machine which can withstand without injury any explosion of gas which may occur inside it, without transmitting the explosion to any inflammable gas outside it. Note, that a machine with flameproof slip-ring enclosure only is not a flameproof machine — flameproof machines were primarily designed for colliery work, but are used in many places where similar conditions apply.

Having considered the effect of the type of enclosure upon temperature rise of the motor, output and performance require careful consideration, there remains a tendency to use a larger motor than is actually required. This is due to the days when each manufacturer had a different standard, and uncertainty was the rule in estimating the possibilities of an electric motor.

The cumulative effect of temperature rise makes it evident, if this is excessive, a limit is soon reached in the amount of heat which can be dissipated by the means of ventilation provided. It then becomes necessary to find the period of time taken for the accumulated heat to reach the maximum specified limit; this period varies considerably according to load conditions and efficiency, and so it is convenient to express the rating in the form of a given load for a given time with a given temperature. It is generally recognised that after a full load run for six hours the temperature of a motor becomes fairly stable. Any motor subject to such conditions requires to be continuously rated, i.e., no intermittency factor allowed. A motor which is called upon to deliver full load for short periods only has plenty of time to cool down, so that we arrive at a definite principle: "The rating of an electric motor must be based upon the longest full load period and the shortest rest period, the former being the time that the heat is cumulative, and the latter the period when the heat is naturally radiated."

In choosing motors a clear understanding of the method of rating with an intelligent use of B.S.S. 188 will enable the correct size and rating of a motor to be confidently and correctly specified.

Control Gear.

The subject of control gear is even more complicated than the choice of a motor. Every motor requires (1) a means of isolating it and its starter or controller for the purpose of adjustment or safety ; (2) protective gear in its simplest form is a fuse, circuit breaker, trip coil, or relay which effectively causes the circuit to be broken in case of overload; (3) a means of connecting the motor to the line and safely accelerating it to full speed. These essential components should, whenever possible, be contained in one complete unit.

The above essential gear constitutes a guardian for the motor, and if not of good design, rating and type may mar the performance of both motor and drive. A bad starter may cause damage to a motor and still remain unscathed. It is foolish economy to put a cheap or underrated starter to protect an important drive, and frequent breakdown may eventually cost more in loss of production than many times the value of the starter.

For underground use the type of enclosure will be one of three distinct types of totally enclosed starter. The first type is a starter with enclosed gear, the protection in this case being against accidental contact or access. The resistance is ventilated and protected, but has a higher rating in comparison with totally enclosed resistance. The second type is the enclosed starter of H.O. type; all parts including resistances are enclosed in sheet-steel covers, that of the door being on hinges for inspection purposes. The covers are not airtight or watertight. The third type is of more massive construction with cast-iron or welded-steel covers to all parts which offer protection against fumes, dust, or damp, and if suitable fittings are provided at the joints of the covers the enclosure is watertight. In the last category come flameproof starters with joints in the covers so made, and the covers of such construction, that they will withstand any explosion of gas inside the cover, without transmitting flames to ignite gas in the surrounding air, and for underground work these latter may be oil-immersed.

A.C. Starters.

The switch starter is the simplest form for squirrel cage motors and may be air-break or oil-immersed type. There are two classes — ordinary duty in which the motor does not require starting more than twice per hour, and heavy duty in which the number of starts required is not more than 10 per hour. The latter type are usually oil-immersed, but they can he obtained of the air-break type for heavy duty.

Switch starters are of star-delta, series parallel, or direct switching types, and the construction shall be such that it is not possible to switch into the running position without a suitable pause in the starting position. The starting, running, and off positions must be clearly marked. Under B.S.S. No. 141 (1923) the current ratings are given as standard sizes 30, 60 and 100 amperes, the equivalent H.P. range being easily obtained from full load current tables.

We have also A.C. drum type starters for slip-ring motors in both air and oil-immersed types ; these may have resistances for ordinary or heavy duty in sizes from 1 to 100 H.P. Auto-transformer starters are suitable in standard ratings for starting periods of 15 seconds plus of a second for each H.P. of the starter rating, and should withstand two successive starts with twice the normal rest period of fifty times the starting period.

The temperature rise should not exceed 50°C. Each transformer shall have at least 40, 60 and 75 per cent. of line voltage.

If the conditions are more severe a special starter is required which is not standard and which must have a special rating. Under B.S.S. No. 167 (1923) manual auto-transformer starters are standardised up to 200 H.P. and in voltages up to 6,000.

A.C. contactor starters are rated on the same basis as drum type starters, and in case of slip-ring starters the current peaks are similar to those on D.C. drum starters. They are made in the same sizes as D.C. contactor starters and come under the same B.S.S.

Resistances may be of three types — ventilated, totally enclosed, or oil-immersed. The type to be used should always be specified before the rating, since the type of enclosure affects both cost and size. In small powers the resistances are built in with the starter and controller, but are usually separate units in larger sizes. The rating of all resistances is based upon the maximum heating period and the minimum cooling period.

Passing over D.C. equipment as becoming a thing, of the past we can consider A.C. gears as being mostly used. The direct starter is used for small power motors, as here the full load starting torque requires six times the full load current except in high torque type motors. Star-delta can be used for 3-phase machines, as this gives the starting torque required for average work. If frequent starting is required the down type of contact gives the best results. Diverse opinions are current on the merits of oil-immersed compared with air-break units, and the tendency is to revert to the latter type of good design.

Overload and no-volt releases are usual on A.C. starters, but in most designs the releases are inoperative during the starting period. Whilst this is not detrimental in the squirrel cage type it is not permissible in the slip-ring type. Most A.C. starters fitted with no-volt releases can he used for emergency stopping and inching is a permissible operation with a switch starter of correct rating.

Then we have auto-transformer starters which are not suitable in the standard form for heavy duty, and with these care should be taken in every case to limit the number of successive starts, or if this be not possible a specially rated transformer should be employed.

Drum type starters are made in all types of A.C. starters, the slip-ring type only presenting any different features. The construction is robust and suited for heavy duty provided the resistances are correctly rated. In this type the control of both starter and rotor currents should be by one handle ; this allows full interlocking, and with this arrangement it is possible by the use of a contactor for the stator current to obtain inching, emergency stopping and full interlocking over the whole sequence of starting.

Rotor starters are capable of being made in two types, one in which the slip-rings are open circuited and one in which the full resistance is left in circuit in the off position. The latter ensures that the rotor is never subjected to maximum rotor voltage, and prevents burning of the contacts on the first step. In the first type the motor will not start until the first step of resistance is put into circuit.

A.C. drum controllers are used for A.C. motors of the slip-ring type, but squirrel cage motors, except the pole-changing type, are not generally suitable for regulating control. In the slip-ring controller the drum contacts are arranged for control of both stator and rotor currents, and large sires may call for two controllers geared together to give the amount of control required. The control of slip-ring motors by the insertion of resistance in the rotor circuit is inefficient, but use of this method is sometimes necessary. The rating of the resistance is important, since they are called to deal with heavier currents at a lower voltage than is customary with D.C. machines.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Pringle, John T.      



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
03 Dec 1938  Choice Of Underground Machinery — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Dec 1938  Choice Of Underground Machinery — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Dec 1938  Choice Of Underground Machinery — III (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Choice Of Underground Machinery. — IV. (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print