Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd December 1938, Page: 164, Column: 1

Choice Of Underground Machinery — I

By John T. Pringle, M.I.M.E.

From paper before the annual general meeting of the Associates and Students' Section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers. Also discussed at meeting on 26th November. A social evening of the Section will be held on 17th December.

The art of coal mining has never before been more closely associated with the applied science of engineering, and the ramifications of this great industry, increasing daily in complexity, calls for an ever expanding knowledge of technical principles hitherto unnecessary for the carrying out of its work. It is obvious that a paper of this title requires the survey of a very wide field that is beset with difficulty; as in the choice of a motor car a person chooses a certain make that will not satisfy another, so is it in the choice of underground machinery, we are at times influenced by factors that may produce adverse results.

Main Pumping.

The choice of the proper and best type of pumping plant is a matter of great importance, and worthy of the most careful consideration, especially where large quantities of water have to be dealt with in mines. The first point of importance is the capacity of the plant required to deal with the maximum quantity of water likely to be met with in the shaft and workings, and whilst it is difficult to estimate this for a shaft that is being sunk in unproven ground, it is a comparatively simple matter to ascertain the feeders in districts which have been well opened out.

The plant should always be capable of raising a larger quantity of water than any ascertained maximum, in order to deal with any sudden flow. The three essential qualities required are (1) Efficiency, (2) Economy, and (3) Freedom from breakdown. This decade will probably see the end of ordinary bucket and ram pumps operated by surface horizontal or vertical steam engines. The question of economy in the period of their use was not of such importance as it has now become, the power for driving was obtained by burning unsaleable fuel, and this latter has by the use of modern cleaning plants been made available for the market, and coal-cutting by machinery has in addition reduced the percentage of small coal produced. The question of economy in fuel burning for steam raising is now of greater importance as the price of coal has gone up.

There was little doubt that many of the steam-driven pumping plants at collieries were very wasteful as regards fuel consumption. It was not uncommon for 10 to 12 per cent. of the total output to be consumed in raising steam for various engines at a colliery, and a consumption of 9 to 10 lb. of fuel per I.H.P. per hour was quite the usual figure. It is incorrect, however, to place all pumping plants of the last decade in the category of low efficiency.

During the last fifteen years the efficiency of steam and electrical pumping plants has been improved at least 45 per cent., so that to-day we have the choice of pumping plant improved to a degree of efficiency far in excess of that possible in the plant of the last decade.

The choice of main pumping plant appears to come into one of two types — multiple ram or turbine pumps, and you will agree that the most suitable power for these is electricity. Having previously decided the maximum capacity of the plant, taking into account all known and estimated feeders, the available standage of water, and the manometric head, one or other of the two types can be selected, and in choosing, the following factors must be taken into consideration (a) The atmospheric pressure conditions ; (b) The temperature of the water ; (c) The size and length of delivery and suction pipes; (d) The area, weight and lift of valves and the control of same; (e) The possibility of rapid wear and adjustment; (f) The capability of dealing with sandy, or acid water; (g) The capability of being operated under water; (h) The speed of power unit, pump and gears; (j) The choice of type; (k) The automatic control ; (l) The general construction (in) The cost of installation, running and maintenance.

Passing over (a) to (d) as common factors we can briefly review (e) to (m).

The possibility of rapid wear can be estimated from the construction by noting the materials of which the pump is made and by seeing that all bearings are of ample length and diameter, and are ring oiled or provided with continuous lubrication elements. The acceptance of email bearings is almost sure to necessitate the use of costly lubricants, which can be avoided by adopting bearings of ample proportions which give maximum efficiency with a medium grade oil.

The gearing should have machine-cut fine teeth of approved shape, the trains being of adequate ratio to give good tooth contact, and the tooth pressure should be kept within safe limits-sections of arms, rims and hubs with shrouding should also be considered so as to give stability to the drives; the shafts are better short and stiff with close up bearings to the gears and power unit. The rams, glands and stuffing boxes should be of sufficient diameter and depth to allow of hydraulic or metallic packing being employed. The guide shoes should have ample hearing surface and be well lubricated, and with ram pumps an alleviator valve should be fitted to the delivery main. A short adequately sized suction with retaining valve, and easy bends in this as well as in the delivery is necessary, and a good margin should be allowed in the suction lift.

Care should be exercised to see that all wearing parts are capable of adjustment and that provision is made for alignment of gears, shafts, barrels, etc. Where the unit is not directly coupled a suitable flexible coupling should be supplied, and this well mounted between the motor and the first bearing of the pinion shaft. In turbo pumps many of the afore-mentioned observations apply, and attention should be paid to the design of the impellers, casings and thrust bearings as well as charging appliances.

The duplication of main pumps is often necessary where feeders are large and uncertain, and it is important to see that the design of rising mains is such as will take the delivery from both pumps, and If one main is used, to ensure that the lead in connections from the pumps enables a free flow of discharge to the main and that one pump delivery does not fell the other.

Pipes and bends should be standardised as well as pump parts, and spares kept down to a minimum in this way.

When power is taken from the Supply Company two units, each clearing the feeders in 16 hours, is a good arrangement. This leaves ample reserve for increased feeders, and the two units may be run together for 8 hours probably on a reduced tariff for night load.

The material in contact with acid or sandy water should be specially selected, and a guarantee of serviceability obtained from the makers.

Operation Under Water. — If flooding is likely the equipment should be designed to ensure that all electrical gear is placed above the flow water and recourse to remote control and over-driven pumps may be necessary.

The Speed of Ram Pumps should be limited to ensure a steady and solid flow of water to the barrels, and for turbo pumps a comparatively high speed can be adopted, thereby cheapening the cost of the pump and motor.

The Choice of Type is a matter for much consideration and depends upon many factors. If feeders are intermittent, the standage small, the pump room is not to he made and is of ample size, and the first cost is not of so much importance, also that automatic control is desired — a ram pump would be chosen. Should the feeders be large and steady, the standage adequate, the pump room small or to be made, a low initial cost desired, and the pump required to be run continuously for set periods — then a turbo unit would be selected.

Automatic Control. — The cost of running by eliminating the pump attendant could be lowered by a system of automatic control, and both types of pump could have this arranged by a system of high and low water Operation of contactor control gear.

The General Construction should consist of a heavy section cast-iron or steel bed frame, properly machined at joints, and with machine strip surfaces for all parts carried by it. The frame must have the joints locked by fitted bolts or machined fillets, and should give a rigid alignment under all conditions of earth movement. It is preferable that gears should be encased in oil baths, the casings designed to prevent drumming, easily detachable with inspection doors in a convenient position. The weight of metal in all parts must be ample to withstand the pressure and other loading, and the whole unit should be accessible.

The Cost of Installation will be determined by the type of pump employed. A three-throw pump will cost more than a turbo for the unit and for its installation, as a large house is necessary as well as heavier foundations, although its serviceability would probably be two or three times as long as a turbo. The running cost would not exceed, and may be less than, that of a turbo, but the maintenance cost would be rather more.

The rough rule of 1,000 gallons per minute and 1,000 feet head as a dividing line between turbo and three-throw can I think now be discarded, as many turbos have been made to deal successfully with capacities above this margin, and it is just a matter of the stages employed.

Auxiliary Pumping.

Auxiliary pumping will consist of face pumps or pumps placed in a mid position between the face and the main shaft pump. They will mostly be driven by electricity or compressed air, and the face machine should be a simple single ram or leather plunger type with an enclosed or totally enclosed motor, or the dook type of turbo pump with self-priming device and similar motor. If air-driven they can be of the direct type of Tangye-Evans or other make. It should be a special point to see that any gears employed for motor speed reduction are entirely enclosed in oil, and that the pump is light and portable with flexible pipe joint connections and accessible in construction. Intermediate pump units can be of similar type, or usually of larger size of more robust construction mounted on bed frames permanently set down.

The standage for these is often sufficient to allow of feeders from several face pumps, and the choice will be with pumps that may be required to run a set number of hours per shift.

Main and Auxiliary Haulage.

The main haulage choice will usually be limited to main-and-tail and endless rope gears, and for the former it is suggested that special attention be paid to steel construction of drums ; these should be of ample width and diameter to ensure a depth of shelving that will stabilise any tendency to springing of the drum sides at the barrel joint. To the drums should be fitted renewable brake paths of ample width and diameter, and these should have fabric-lined brakes of band or post type. Drum naves should have ample strength to take the clutch gear, whether of claw or friction type, and the naves should be brass bushed if required to run free on the shaft. Accessible lubricators should be placed outside the drums for safety purposes. In large type drums inspection manholes should be provided, and as much riveting as possible should be embodied in the construction in place of bolts, but only so far as easy detachability is ensured.

It is the case in cheaply constructed main haulages to see cast-iron drums on billet steel shafts with cast-iron claw clutches, cast-iron moulded gears of coarse pitch and plain bearings. The shafts in some cases are long with end supports, and the bearings have thin white metal linings run without shells into the solid castings. The drum sides are deep, and when extension to the haulage takes place the additional coils strain the drums, often bursting them. Clutches also fail, and undetachable brake rims mean scrapping a whole drum when breakage occurs.

The breaking of shafts is another item causing stoppage and expense, as is the type of gearing. Long shafts cause whipping under load that brings about gear failure and bearing friction is often excessive.

In a good main-and-tail haulage gear it is advisable to have steel drums, detachable clutches, the drums being built up in sections. and the clutches should be specially chosen to ensure durability and easy adjustment. Many types of clutches are misleading, and those of expanding or contracting type should be given special consideration before being selected.

Slow moving shafts should have plain gunmetal lined bearings of ample length, and other shaft bearings should be ring oiled and lined with a suitable grade of Parsons No. 1 or equal metal.

All bearings should be adjustable on their beds to ensure correct wheel rolling circles. The gears should be machine-cut of steel or good close-gained cast-iron in oil bath semi-castings, or completely cased in if this can be afforded. It is better to have a solid coupling between the motor and the first pinion, and the pinion shaft should have two double shoulder bearings.

A suitable road contour indicator is advisable, for main units, this driven from the drum shaft, and it should indicate the position of the set at any point of the plane — electrical indicators to show a continuous green light when all is working normally during the trip or alternatively a red light when a dangerous overload is likely to occur. This enables the driver to slow up or stop the machine before serious damage takes place.

There are some excellent main-and-tail haulage gears with single 10 to 1 reduction power plant wheels and 5' 0" drums driven by 100 h.p. slipring motors, and others with two trains of machine-cut wheels upon billet steel first and second motion shafts. These gears have forged steel drum shafts with Ferodo lined brakes and friction clutches, overload warning devices, contour indicator, short first and second shafts well supported on machined steel bed frames so ensuring perfect alignment under all conditions of service. These machines give excellent service and their cost is very little more than the inferior type of haulage.

In selection the minimum space should be occupied by the gear, but this should only take second place to accessibility to all parts of the equipment.

If these factors are selected in conformity with the details given you can he sure of low running and maintenance cost for your gear in all sizes up to 600 H.P. Above this size it is mainly a question of adding strength to the construction by design or by the use of special materials.

It is known that a careful survey of the haulage plane is necessary. The easing of gradients, curves, undersize binders, and sufficient carriers for the ropes, along with proper lubrication of rolling stock, will cheapen your first cost by lowering the horse-power of your haulage gear, and the increased efficiency of the system by dealing with these factors will lower your maintenance.

For endless rope haulage the same applies as for main-and-tall gears, in so far as shafts, gears, hearings and frames are concerned, but with this type a flexible coupling can he used with the motor, this of the pin or strip type allowing slight end movement of the motor shaft.

For mine purposes it would be better if these gears up to 400 H.P. were totally enclosed in oil baths, although this would add to the initial cost of the machine. The saving in oil and in wear would soon pay for this, as many gears at present selected have to operate by means of remote control, and lubrication is often effected by great waste of oil, and cleaning is entirely neglected.

The fleeting wheels should be of ample diameter with taper renewable machined treads. It will be found that for a totally enclosed higher priced gear the housing will be cheaper than for an open gear, and it will be more suitable to remote control.

Endless haulage gears are sometimes chosen with double fleeting wheels ; these are quite good for working two separate branch roads, but there are cases where a main haulage system has one of these gears placed in the centre of it. Half of the plane is worked by one fleeting wheel and the other half is worked by the other fleeting wheel.

The gear may be placed at a bend in the plane, and by an arrangement of this kind it is readily seen that the tubs must be detached from one section and re-attached to the other. Cost will therefore be increased by this selection, as had a single gear been properly placed on the plane the initial cost of the gear would have been reduced by one-third and the running cost would also be considerably reduced.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Pringle, John T.      



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
03 Dec 1938  Choice Of Underground Machinery — I (The Science and Art of Mining)
17 Dec 1938  Choice Of Underground Machinery — II (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Dec 1938  Choice Of Underground Machinery — III (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1939  Choice Of Underground Machinery. — IV. (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print