|
3rd December 1938, Page: 163, Column: 1 Dumbreck Colliery FireSome Electrical AspectsIn his report on the fire which occurred at Dumbreck Colliery (Cmd. 5863, 1s. 8d. by post, H.M. Stationery Office) Mr. J. A. B. Horsley, O.B.E., Electrical Inspector of Mines, says that upon analysis the electrical aspects of the accident present several features of particular interest to those who, in their several capacities, are responsible for the safe use of electricity in mines, especially with regard to the risk of fire in consequence of defects in, or damage to, electrical cables and cable junction-boxes. The earthed concentric system was introduced many years ago by Mr. Sam Mavor and was applied to mining installations, especially in Scotland, with the primary object of guarding against the risk of electric shock, and experience shows that in this respect it has been remarkably effective. At the time of its introduction the use of armoured cable was exceptional, unarmoured single-core cables, insulated with rubber or bitumen, being commonly employed to convey the electric current from the dynamo at the surface to the motors in the mine. Referring to drawbacks of the earthed concentric system Mr. Horsley says they are, firstly, a greater liability to short circuit in the cables by reason of the concentric construction; and, secondly, the impossibility of distinguishing, in normal working, between load current and earth leakage current, from which it results that a leakage indicator cannot be applied to the earthed concentric system and "leakage protection" cannot be used to supplement "overload protection" as a safeguard against any failure of insulation. As to the verbal testimony and circumstantial evidence relating to the accident the only material point upon which there is room for doubt is whether there were in fact two successive electrical faults in the cable at the same place with two consequent trippings of one or other of the two circuit-breakers involved at the surface of the mine, or whether there was only one fault and one occasion upon which both of these circuit-breakers were caused to trip simultaneously. It is apposite to mention that, although the fire raged over a distance of some 50 feet, some 30 feet only of the cable in that area was burned out and that the cable did not continue to burn in either direction beyond the limits of the timber fire and that, outside those limits, the cable was, so far as could be judged by visual examination, substantially in the same condition as other portions of similar cable remote from the fire. It is common ground that a severe short circuit occurred in the cable where it entered a junction-box, and that this was the place of origin and the cause of the fire. Mr. Horsley mentions that General Regulation 129 (f) requires that "cables and conductors, where joined up to motors, transformers, switchgear, and other apparatus, shall be installed so that . . . (ii) the insulating material at each cable end is efficiently sealed so as to prevent the diminution of its insulating properties." He says it must be admitted, however, that there is a widespread, if erroneous, belief that such sealing is not necessary on technical grounds for cables in which the insulating material is vulcanised rubber or bitumen. He proceeds to say it is a fact that in many mines cable ends are not sealed, and this is especially the case as the coal face is approached, because of the impermanence of the cables and the difficulty of conveying the molten compound to the spot. A solution of this problem is to be found in the use of detachable cable sealing end boxes, two units being used to form a coupling where it is desired to join two lengths of cable, while one unit suffices where the cable is to be attached to a switch or motor. The primary purpose of the filling of cable-boxes with molten insulating compound is to prevent access of moisture to the dielectric or insulating material, but where a hard setting compound of the usual description is employed this has the effect also of affording useful support to, and reinforcement of, the insulated conductors. Much care and considerable skill, however, are necessary if such sealing is to be applied to advantage, for it is useless if the compound is melted over a fire without regard for the critical temperature at winch the compound becomes "cracked" or even burned, or if molten compound is poured into a damp box, to mention two elementary matters winch do not always receive necessary attention. In the statement of his conclusions regarding the Dumbreck accident Mr. Horsley says :— "I consider that the cable was not directly set on fire by the electric arc but that the fire arose from the ejection of molten metal, e.g., of the fused brass cone into adjacent timber, which smouldered for some time before it became inflamed. "I have also come to the conclusion that the short circuit was not brought about by any external means, such as a fall of side, but that it was due to softening of the rubber insulation surrounding the inner conductor, and that this softening was caused by heat engendered by the passage of current at some previous time or times, between the outer conductor and the brass cone owing to imperfect electrical connection at this point. "I do not consider that the omission of sealing compound contributed directly to the short circuit but, on the other hand, I regard the cable junction-box as wholly unsuitable for the description of cable to which it was applied, by reason of the lack of suitable accessories for which there was inadequate space within the box. "I do not consider that either the size of fuse or the setting of the overload trips of the circuit-breaker was unreasonable for the circuits for which they afforded automatic protection."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||