|
19th November 1938, Page: 145, Column: 1 Dumbreck Colliery FirePublished together in one volume (Cmd. 5863, 1s. 8d. by post, H.M. Stationery Office) the reports of Mr. T. Ashley, Divisional Inspector of Mines, and Mr. J. A. B. Horsley, O.B.E., Electrical Inspector of Mines, have been issued on the circumstances attending the fire which occurred at Dumbreck Colliery in Stirlingshire on Sunday, 30th January, 1938. The fire resulted in the loss of nine lives, and the verdict of the jury was a formal one, viz., that the nine men died of asphyxia, caused by the inhalation of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide, as the result of a fire which broke out in the side haulage road in No. 1 Pit. The jury made no observations or recommendations. Dumbreck Colliery is situated about one mile west of Kilsyth and was sunk in 1885. Nos. 1 and 2 shafts are both sunk to the Kilsyth Coking Coal, lying at a depth of 225 fathoms. No. 1 Pit with which the report is concerned, is the downcast, and from it the Kilsyth Coking Coal only is worked. Usually 98 persons are employed underground, 68 on the day shift and 15 on the back and night shifts respectively. Coal is wound only during the day shift, the output being about 110 tons a day. The pit is worked with safety-lamps, the workmen wearing electric cap lamps, and searching Is carried out in accordance with Section 35 of the Act. Ventilation was produced by an exhaust fan at the surface and there was only one main ventilating current in the seam. In his report Mr. Ashley gives a description of the colliery, with references to the ventilation, haulage, method of working, electrical system, cables and telephones. The events prior to the fire are discussed, followed by a narrative of the accident and the work of the rescue brigade, the report concluding with some observations in the course of which it is stated that there is no doubt that the fire originated at the junction-box where the smaller cable was joined to the larger cable. This was the place where the fire was first seen and from which it spread inbye. The first effect of the fire would be to increase the quantity of air along the side haulage road because the increased ventilating pressure produced by the high temperature of the fire would add to that produced mechanically by the surface fan. The origin of the fire was the intense beat produced by the rupturing of the cable, and this, coupled with the large quantity of air passing, nearly 12,000 cubic feet per minute, would soon cause a flaming fire to develop which would produce comparatively little smoke. It is unlikely that this smoke would become fully dispersed in the air-current until it had travelled some distance inbye. If this took place before reaching the foot of Waddell's Brae where the air was split, the density of the smoke in the air would be the same in the air-currents entering both sections. As the smoke from the fire proceeded on its course its particles would gradually be deposited, filtered out, and diffused in the air-current, thus rendering the smoke less visible. But the noxious gases produced by the fire when diffused in the main air-current, would continue to pollute it and render it harmful irrespective of the visibility or otherwise of smoke in that current. Consequently all the time the men remained inbye in Kelly's Section, although they may not have noticed much visible smoke, they would nevertheless be breathing air which contained carbon monoxide. The absence of smoke might, indeed, tend to deceive them. When they became aware of the position their alarm and the exertion of travelling outbye would cause the blood saturation by carbon monoxide to rise this would be accentuated when they entered Waddell's Brae where the gradient was steep and the smoke denser and where it is probable that there would be layers of air highly polluted with carbon monoxide because of insufficient diffusion, The opening of the separation doors on Paterson's Road at about 5 p.m. undoubtedly assisted the fighting of the fire but natural ventilation having been established inbye, the air-current passing inbye over the fire would not be materially, reduced. Moreover, under the circumstances, any reduction in the amount of air passing the fire would increase the proportion of carbon monoxide and the quantity of smoke. On the medical evidence, however, by the time the doors were opened the men must already have been overcome. All the men were certified by Dr. A. C. Blair, the medical practitioner who examined the bodies as they were brought out to the fresh air base, to have died from the effects of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide, the former predominating. The origin of the fire being electrical the relevant aspects are dealt with in the report by Mr. J. A. B. Horsley, H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines. Reference to Mr. Horsley's report will be made in a later issue.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||