|
5th November 1938, Page: 130, Column: 2 Wire RopesCareful Examination EmphasisedThe 16th annual report of the Safety in Mines Research Board (2s. net, H.M. Stationery Office) contains some notes on the latest researches carried out under the executive charge of Dr. M. A. Hogan. It is emphasised that the safety of any winding or haulage installation depends on the skill and care used in the examination of the ropes. The value of any rope examination, and particularly of the special monthly examination required under the Winding and Haulage Regulations, 1937, is greatly enhanced if the person making it is familiar with the various types of deterioration to he met with and can appreciate their relative importance. Similar considerations apply to the opening up and examination of the pieces of rope cut off at recapping. Breakages of two winding ropes as a result of severe external wear and corrosion of external origin are cited to stress the importance of careful examination. One of these was a 1 5/8-inch diameter flattened strand rope working in a moderately wet upcast shaft 1,206 feet deep from the pulley to the cage at the pit bottom. The rope broke while winding coal after 27¼ months service, the point of fracture being 720 feet from the capel. At this part the outside of the rope was affected by severe external wear and the wires were roughened by corrosion. Wear had removed about one-third of the section of the outer wires at the crowns and the wires were also reduced by corrosion on the undersides so that only about one-third of the original cross-section remained. The outer wires were not in hard contact with each other or with the inner wires, and it was possible to look between some of the outer wires and see the broken inner wires. This looseness of the outer wires was a condition which should have been detected by external examination. The severity of the deterioration may be judged from the fact that the estimated aggregate strength of the rope in the neighbourhood of the fracture was only 20 per cent. of the strength when new. It appeared that the very severe deterioration was partly due to the action of return air which entered the shaft from an inset at a point where this part of the rope frequently stood when the cages were at rest. That the deterioration was not entirely local was shown by the fact that a sample taken 15 yards away from the fracture retained only 38 per cent. of the strength of the rope when new. A contributory factor to the failure of this rope was the use of solid triangular strand cores of very hard drawn steel. The tensile strength of the triangular cores was 115 tons as compared with 105 tons for the inner and 108 tons for the outer wires. The use of such high tensile steel for the solid cores of a flattened strand rope is unusual and has serious drawbacks. The strength of the cores is so great that they carry an appreciable part of the load and, if the cores fail in fatigue, the adjoining round wires are liable to be overloaded. Also, since the hardness of the cores is as great as, or greater than, that of the inner wires severe internal wear is caused, particularly at the corners of the triangles. The second winding rope was a 1 1/8i-inch diameter round strand langs lay rope used in a somewhat wet upcast shaft 806 feet deep from the pulley to the cage at the pit bottom. The rope broke during coal winding after 34¼ months service, and the point of fracture was 153 feet from the capel, or just in contact with the drum when the cage was at the bank. The drum of the electrically driven winding engine was wood-lagged, but the rope suffered severe external wear due to the fact that the alignment of the pulley was incorrect, so that the intersection of the plane of the pulley with the drum was about two feet away from the mean position of the rope. The result was that the rope rubbed continuously against one of the pulley flanges. The wear was further accelerated by the fact that about six months previously a new pulley was fitted without machining the rope groove, the surface of which was rough and not truly circular. It is desirable to machine the rough surface of the cast groove so as to make a smooth track for the rope. Close to the fracture the outer wires had been worn more than halfway through, leaving the strand cores exposed, and the diameter had been reduced from 1.10 inch (measured in the dead coils) to 0.90 inch. Since the outer wires were 0.121 inch diameter a loss of 0.20 inch in rope diameter should have drawn attention to the severity of the wear, and the looseness of the outer wires was a further obvious sign of deterioration. The estimated aggregate strength of the rope close to the fracture was only 31 per cent. of the strength when new. Heating of Rope on Drum. The breakage after seven months' service of a 7/8-inch diameter round strand langs lay rope used on a man haulage drew attention to a cause of deterioration which had hitherto escaped notice — the heating of the rope on the drum by the friction of the brake. As stated in the Report haulage was electrically driven and operated on a straight incline 600 yards long on a gradient of 1 in 3. The incline was wet, the water being very corrosive. On the day of the accident a length of 120 yards of rope which showed deterioration by external wear and corrosion was cut off and the rope was recapped. This operation brought into use 38 dead coils of rope off the drum and shortly after the recapping the rope broke while men were being hauled up the incline. The point of fracture was in the part of the rope which had previously been in the dead coils, and was in the coil against the drum cheek where the rope rose from the second to the third layer. Although this part of the rope had done scarcely any work it had suffered severe deterioration by corrosion, and the estimated aggregate strength close to the fracture was only 28 per cent. of that of the rope when new. The severe local corrosion at this point must be attributed to the effect of the heating of the drum cheek by the frictional heat developed by the brake while lowering the set. The rope in contact with the cheek was heated sufficiently to allow the internal lubricant to run out, leaving the wires unprotected against the action of the corrosive water brought on to the drum by the live rope. It is suggested that provision should be made for a lagging of non-inflammable material to protect the end coils on a drum from heating by the brake, and that special attention should be paid to the lubrication of this part of the rope. The breakage of this rope emphasises the importance of the thorough examination of all parts of a rope, and the fallacy of the assumption that the portion on the drum which has never worked must be in good condition. Haulage Rope Capels. Observations made on capels which failed in service have shown that the failure is usually due to some defect in the workmanship rather than to any inherent weakness in the method. Nevertheless, the existence of a liability to errors and mistakes which may impair the security of the capel must be reckoned a serious fault, and many attempts have been made to simplify the process so as to eliminate any possibility of mistake, for example by the insertion in the end of the rope of a solid metal cone grooved to take the strands. With this cone a short socket can be used and high strengths are obtained, but there is some risk of the cone falling out. This risk was eliminated in another type of capel where a smooth white metal cone had a "tail strand" cast into the white metal. The tail strand was run into the rope in place of the core and thus served to retain the cone. The smooth cone had, however, the disadvantage that there was some difficulty in ensuring a uniform distribution of the strands around it, and there was thus a risk that with careless workmanship the rope might be unsymmetrically loaded. In the pre-cast grooved cone type of capel developed by the Board the advantages of the solid grooved cone and the tail strand have been combined. The preliminary experiments showed that a satisfactory grip was afforded by a grooved white metal cone in a long (8 diameters) socket. It was, however, difficult to cause the strands to lie symmetrically in such long grooves, and an attempt was made to use a shorter socket, namely, the B.S. Socket for General Engineering Purposes, Specification No. 463, with a length about four times the rope diameter. This socket was selected as being the shortest type in general use, but it is considered that the detailed design of the socket calls for considerable strengthening to render it suitable for use underground. When cast in B.S. capping metal (5 parts tin, 15 antimony, 80 lead) the short cones are not strong enough to hold the rope. Tests show that if the short cones are made of zinc the strength is adequate and when capels of this type are tested the rope commonly breaks clear of the socket, i.e., the efficiency of the capping is 100 per cent. Pre-cast zinc cones have been tried underground at a number of collieries with satisfactory results. The ropes used in the experiments in which the precast cone type of capel was developed were 1 inch diameter or less, and the question arose as to whether the same method could be applied to the larger ropes used on main slants in South Wales. The position here was complicated in that a long and relatively heavy socket had been standardised, and it was desired to continue to use these sockets. The length of the conical part of the socket was from 9 to 10 rope diameters, and it was found to be quite impossible to enter the strands into grooves 'of this length. A satisfactory compromise was effected by providing grooves in the large end of the cone for a length of 6 rope diameters and continuing the cone at the smaller diameter without grooves for the remaining length.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||