




























































|
| Newspaper Articles |
|
Newspaper Articles |
 |
|
 |
28th October 1938, Page: 783, Column: 1
Notes From The Coal Fields
South Wales and Monmouthshire
[Local Correspondence]
An inquiry by the South Wales District Committee of Investigation at Cardiff on Monday into the price charged for supplies of bunker coals for the use of Cardiff trawlers, was held as the result of a complaint made by Neale and West, Ltd., who were
represented by Mr. H. O. Cropley, secretary of the company, Mr. Morley Neale, Mr. Howard Neale, and Mr. W. E. Hinde. Mr. J. T. Richards, J.P., presided, and the investigation committee consisted of Messrs. J. C.
Radcliffe, C. Mitchell, C. E. Oliver Harris, G. E. Aeron-Thomas, D.L., and Lieut.-Col. J. G. Coulthard Thompson, the secretary. The executive and control boards were represented by Messrs. W. H. F. Barklam,
Finlay Gibson, H. F. Perkins (vice-chairman of the control board), W. Moeller secretary of the control board), Ewart R. Evans (Powell Duffryn Associated Collieries, Ltd.), and R. W. Pinnick (Tredegar Associated
Collieries, Ltd.) represented the two collieries concerned. Mr. Cropley in submitting the case for the trawler owners said the complaint they were referring to the committee of investigation was in respect of the price quoted in the South Wales
district for his firm's bunker coal requirements for the ensuing year, and the grounds of the complaint were that the suggested price was unfair and inequitable and was likely to have an effect contrary to the public interest. In view of experience of
the price paid under the last contract for bunkers, the future welfare of the business undoubtedly rested on a substantial reduction in the cost of coal, otherwise its existence was endangered. The conditions at the time of entry into the last contract
were such as to cause his firm to hesitate to pay the price then fixed, and they entertained serious misgivings as to their ability to bear the extra burden imposed by the then substantial increase. They determined, however, to make an effort to meet the
situation, encouraged by hopes based on the possibility of a Government subsidy or other assistance to the fishing industry. These expectations had not been realised. Working expenses, apart from coal, had increased beyond the possibility of any
compensating economies, and revenue had shown some decline. Taking 1935 as a standard year for comparisons, he said contracts entered into in June 1935, were for coal at 13s. per ton net f.o.b. ; in July 1936, minimum 15s. 6d. (18,000 tons taken at 16s.
per ton), and in July 1937, £1 0s. 6d. per ton net f.o.b. It would be seen from that comparison that the 1937 price was 7s. 6d. more than in 1935. On a consumption of not less than 38,000 tons the increase of 7s. 6d. per ton represented an
additional cost of £14,250. Next to wages, coal was the largest item in the working expenses of their vessels. They could not bunker abroad without extending the duration of the trip, which was 12 days, or curtailing the fishing time, and either
proposition would be economically unsound. Consequently they were compelled to obtain their supplies of bunker coal from local sources. Simultaneous with the big increase in the cost of coal the price of fish had materially decreased. While there was
much to be said for the legislative and administrative efforts made to put the mining industry in a stronger position and to improve the conditions of the miner, he said, it seemed a suicidal policy to carry these aims to the point of strangling other
industries dependent on coal supplies, or of compelling them to limit their present demands by laying up a number of their vessels and also to consider alternatives to coal, particularly as regards any new construction they might have in mind. They put
forward as a basis for discussion the suggestion that the price should revert to that appertaining for the period covered by the 1936 contract, namely, 15s. 6d. per ton. Mr. W. E. Hinde, a coal factor at Cardiff, said he had been supplying the
firm of Neale and West with coal for about 30 years. Their ships had been modernised and used washed small coals, but they had had to take one-third through coals and two-thirds washed small. That was not satisfactory because they were not getting any
better performance for the more expensive coal than for the washed smalls. They considered that they should be allowed to go to any colliery they liked to buy the class of coal required. Mr. Morley Neale, a director of the company, said that they
could buy spot coal at 18s. per ton at the dock, but they could not enter into a contract even for a month below 19s. 8d. Because of the high price of coal they had postponed purchasing two new trawlers. They had asked provisionally for specifications
for oilburning vessels, and these were now being considered. The case for the executive board and the control board under the South Wales District (Coal Mines) Scheme, 1930, was presented by Mr. W. H. F. Barklam. He submitted that the price quoted
was fair and equitable and said that since 1935, and as a consequence of Government pressure, the statutory boards regulating the production and sales of coal and the colliery owners concerned were obliged to raise the prices of coal in order to meet the
demand for extra wages on the part of the men engaged in the industry, which was followed by a rise in the cost of other material necessary for the production of coal in a mine. The rise in prices of coal in a case of business such as the complainants
had been no greater for the type of coal concerned than was the case with other consumers, although at first sight it might seem that an increase of price from 13s. per ton to 19s. 8d. per ton might need some explanation. In the case of small coals the
price had been unduly low in 1935 and, therefore, did not provide a fair basis upon which to assess the justification for an increase. Moreover, with the general rise in prices of coal along with other commodities which took place in the year 1937,
consumers naturally chose, if it was suitable for their purpose, those types of coal which were less in price and as was known, without any special proof thereof, other things being equal, small coal was less in price than large, he said. That very fact
caused a congestion in the demand for certain types of coal with the necessary result that prices had to be adjusted accordingly, in order to ensure that those types of coal should not be overburdened and other types of coal made practically saleless.
The South Wales coal industry could not bear any further reduction in price as was shown by the ascertainments of the profits of the industry certified by the joint accountants. It would be observed that whilst in the three months ended January 1936
(being the period nearest the period 1935), the industry showed a net trading credit of 6.66d. per ton, the results of the ascertainment nearest to the present investigation, namely, the three months ended July 1938, showed a credit of only 3.03d. per
ton. Although the average proceeds at pithead had tended to rise, costs of production and costs of the actual wages had tended to rise to a greater degree. Mr. H. F. Perkins, the vice-chairman of the control board, gave evidence of the manner in
which the price was fixed. Mr. Finlay Gibson (secretary to the executive board) said that, in his opinion, the price of 19s. 8d. per ton was not excessive. Mr. Ewart R. Evans, of the Powell Duffryn Co., and Mr. R. W. Pinnick, of the
Tredegar Associated Companies, gave evidence of supplying the coals and of submitting a contract price of 19s. 8d. per ton. After retiring, the committee found that on the evidence submitted the price of 19s. 8d. for the class of coal supplied was not
unjust or unreasonable. They felt that the executive board might well explore the possibility of more closely meeting the requirements of the complainants as to the class of coal supplied.
Messrs. Bevan and Davies, Ammanford, have undertaken to open a small colliery at Garnant, to be known as the Gwmdwngwyn Colliery. The seam to be worked is the Red Vein.
Measures to protect mines and miners in time of air raids and the difficulties to be overcome were discussed at a meeting of the South Wales and Monmouthshire branch of the National Association of Colliery Managers at Swansea on Saturday, October 15,
Ald. C. H. McCale, Cardiff, presiding. Capt. Tal. E. Richards, the secretary, said it was needless to emphasise the importance of colliery managers considering at once what precautions could be taken. The dangers to be expected were from
high explosive bombs, from incendiary bombs, and from bombs containing poisonous gases. Taking first the case of a high explosive bomb falling in proximity to the pit tops, he asked (a) what arrangements could be made for bringing out the workmen
imprisoned below ; (b) what plans could be made to house and feed the men below, assuming that it was possible that they could not be brought to the surface for a week; (c) could they make arrangements for the utilisation of natural ventilation in case
of the fan being deranged; (d) what could they do now to protect colliery structures and the men working therein? In dealing with the incendiary bombs, (a) what necessary materials would they require to extinguish the fires, knowing that a stream of
water was useless for extinguishing thermite ; (b) what precautions could they now gradually carry out which would minimise the danger from fires, knowing the possibility of the water mains being damaged ? Lastly, there was the possibility of gas bombs,
(a) What could they do now to prevent poisonous gas going down the pit; (b) what arrangements could they make now. to protect their workmen from being affected by the gas ; (c) what plan could they devise to short-circuit the ventilation so as to protect
the workmen? Other points were :— (a) What arrangements should they make by organisation so that the colliery and its employees were adequately protected? (b) How could they camouflage the buildings, arrange for light restrictions and other
precautions, knowing that they would have only about 10 minutes' warning of a raid? Each colliery would have to take into consideration its own peculiar conditions, such as levels, slants, and pits, and build up an organisation which could deal
adequately with each according to its necessities. The chairman said the secretary had given them a great deal to think about and it would take some consideration to reply to the various questions. They could not under-estimate the importance of taking
steps to protect their water as much as possible. Mr. W. S. Jones, Forchaman, Aberdare, spoke of the steps being taken at his colliery, where all key men, including the manager, had been through a course of training and taken their civilian
certificates. He thought separate arrangements were desirable for the surface and the underground. They were also making a surface bomb-proof shelter. The head ambulance man on the surface was, in their case, the chief warden, who would take charge. With
their system they had decided that in the event of a raid it would be best to stop work immediately. The only men who would remain at their posts would be fan men and telephone operators. Others would go into the bomb-proof shelter. Underground the
problem was different. The hitcher was their chief warden. They had a system of telephones all through the pit. and the switchboard operator and the hitcher would remain at their posts, but other men would move to places of safety. Wardens in charge of
short circuiting doors should be trained and in telephonic communication. Mr. G. Holdings suggested that colliery managers should see that they had an adequate number of first-aid men for a station. He did not know of one instance where managers
had got into touch with the local authority for a first-aid post at the colliery. It was decided to discuss the matter further at future meetings.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Aeron-Thomas, G. E. | | | |
| Barklam, W. H. F. | | | |
| Barklam, W. H. F. | | | |
| Cropley, H. O. | | | |
| Evans, Ewart R. | | | |
| Gibson, Finlay | | | |
| Harris, C. E. Oliver | | | |
| Hinde, W. E. | | | |
| Holdings, G. | | | |
| Jones, W. S. | | | |
| McCale, C. H., Alderman | | | |
| Mitchell, C. | | | |
| Moeller, W. | | | |
| Neale, Howard | | | |
| Neale, Morley | | | |
| Perkins, H. F. | | | |
| Perkins, H. F. | | | |
| Pinnick, R. W. | | | |
| Radcliffe, J. C. | | | |
| Richards, J. T. | | | |
| Richards, Tal. E., Captain | | | |
| Thompson, J. G. Coulthard, Lieut.-Col. | | | |
|
|