21st October 1938, Page: 735, Column: 2
Labour And Wages
Mineworkers' Federation of Great Britain
The executive of the Mineworkers' Federation considered in London yesterday the reorganising of the Federation. Proposals will be submitted to the districts on the question of forming one big miners' union in place of the existing district federations.
Mr. W. Lawther, acting president, stated that the matter of working hours is being considered by a sub-committee which will put forward proposals in order to launch a campaign for shorter hours in keeping with the declaration at this year's annual
conference of the Federation. It was further announced that the executive is to make a grant of £500 to the British members of the International Brigade who have been fighting in Spain and have now been disbanded and are coming home. The executive
considered proposals from Durham on safety in mines, particularly having regard to the contention that no boys should be employed in the mines until they reach the age of 16. This is being taken up by the miners' M.P.s in furtherance of the policy of
taking steps to obviate accident risk, fatal and non-fatal. When the resignation of Mr. Joseph Jones as president of the Federation, consequent upon his appointment to the new Coal Commission, takes effect, Mr. Lawther will continue to act
as president until the annual conference of the Federation next July, and in the meantime the office of vice-president will not be filled.
Membership of Trade Unions
According to the Ministry of Labour Gazette, the total membership of the trade unions in Great Britain and Northern Ireland at the end of 1937 was approximately 5,851,000, showing an increase of nearly 550,000 or over 10 per cent, compared with
the total at the end of the previous year. The total membership of the coal mining trade unions, 93 in number, amounted to 704,081, as compared with 673,881, an increase of 4.5 per cent.
Holidays with Pay
The Ministry of Labour Gazette publishes the award of the umpire appointed under the Unemployment Insurance Act in a case arising under s. 23 of the Act, holding that payment for holidays under a saving scheme must be regarded as payment of wages in
respect of a recognised holiday (case No. 3515/1938). Under the terms of the Derbyshire District Miners' Holiday Savings Scheme, the claimant received on June 17, 1938, the sum of which in the scheme is designated an "additional sum." The Chief
Insurance Officer appealed against the decision of the court of referees in so far as it allowed the period to count as part of a period of continuous unemployment.
On the appeal two contentions raised by the Derbyshire Miners' Association were : (1) That the period in question was not one of recognised holiday; and (2) that the payment of the "additional sum" was not "wages." Clause 1 of the
scheme reads : "Owing to the reduction in the number of working days in consequence of exigencies of trade and the restrictive effect of the Coal Mines Scheme, it is considered desirable to group together some of those days on which employment is
not or will not be available in the industry into a period of six consecutive working days (excluding Sunday) in each year during which each colliery within the district governed by the Derbyshire district wages board should be closed down except for
necessary work of repair and maintenance. Such period is hereinafter referred to as "the closing down period." The umpire observes that the fact that the material period is designated "the closing down period" and not "the
holiday period" does not prevent that period being a holiday period just as the designation in the title of the scheme "Holiday Savings Scheme" is not conclusive that the period in respect of which payment under the scheme was made was a
holiday. Holidays are frequently taken at a period of slackness of trade because so to do benefits both the employer and the employees. In the case of the employees the taking of a holiday at such a period may entail less loss of wages.
Two other clauses in the scheme were relied upon as indicating that the "closing down period" was not a period of holiday. They were clauses 5 and 8, which read as follows : "5. If in the opinion of any colliery owner the state of trade or
conditions at his colliery do not justify a closing down period the `additional sums' hereinbefore referred to shall be paid to the workmen at such time or times as may be decided by the colliery owner"; "8. Any workman required by the colliery
owner for necessary work of repair or maintenance or other service to continue at work during the closing down period shall nevertheless be entitled to receive the additional sum as hereinbefore mentioned."
With regard to clause 5. the umpire finds it difficult to appreciate that it would ever require to be put into operation. It is not uncommon for employees to agree to abandon for one year a recognised holiday and to work therein and it is not unnatural
that the employees were prepared to agree, on consideration that they received the "additional sums" when their services were required, to forgo in one year a "closing down period" in the unlikely event of it not being practicable to
allow such a period, provided they did not in that year lose the benefit of receiving the additional sums. Clause 8 must be read in conjunction with clause 1, "closed down except for necessary work of repair and maintenance." So read it means
that any workman required for work of necessary repair and maintenance, or required for any service in connection with such work, shall not lose the benefit of receiving "the additional sum." Whether any grade of workman, such as maintenance
men, is excluded from the general body of workmen in relation to a recognised holiday is a question of fact to be decided in each individual case. In practice it appears that a workman who is required to work dining a "closing down period,"
receives the "additional sum" and takes a holiday at a period other than the closing down period.
Looking at the scheme as a whole, it was, in the umpire's opinion, intended that the "closing down period" should be a period of six consecutive days holiday for the workmen. This period of holiday was a recognised holiday by virtue of clause 2
of the scheme which incorporated the conditions of the scheme in the workmen's contracts of service. In these circumstances, the claimant is not entitled to receive benefit during the closing down period at the colliery at which he was employed as it was
for him a period of recognised holiday.
The argument on the question whether "the additional sums" were "wages" was based largely upon the method of ascertaining the percentage to be added to the basis rates, and the effect which the inclusion of these sums in such
ascertainment had upon the percentage increase. Before the scheme came into operation the cost of wages was not deducted from ascertained proceeds for the purpose of the ascertainment. The effect of including the cost of the additional sums as a
deduction from ascertained proceeds is to reduce the increase which thereafter will be added to the basis rates. The result has been that the employer provides a payment for his workpeople during a period when their services are not required, and in
return therefor the workpeople are prepared to accept a lower sum as increase in their basis rate. The umpire says he cannot distinguish "the additional sums" paid under the scheme from other holiday payments which have been treated as
"wages." He notes that the term "wages" as used in the Unemployment Insurance Act is not used in the sense in which it is ordinarily understood. The fact that the colliery owner each month pays the amount which is due from him under
the scheme into a central fund which applies such amounts to the objects of the scheme does not prevent the "additional sums" being wages paid by the employer in respect of the "closing down period."
For the above reasons he agrees with the court of referees that the claimant is not entitled to receive benefit for the period June 20 to 25, 1938, both dates included, but is unable to agree with the court that that period may be treated as a period of
continuous unemployment.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Jones, Joseph | | | |
| Lawther, W. | | | |