|
21st October 1938, Page: 722, Column: 2 The Markham ExplosionThe report* on the causes and circumstances attending the explosion which occurred at Markham No. 1 (Blackshale) Colliery, Duckmanton, near Chesterfield, Derbyshire, on May 10, 1938, by Mr. P. E. Sandlands, O.B.E., K.C. (commissioner), was issued by the Mines Department on Thursday. The explosion occurred just after 5.30 on the morning of May 10, 1938, and of the 171 men below ground at the time 79 lost their lives and 40 were injured. The pit is owned by the Staveley Coal and Iron Co., Ltd., and it was in the Blackshale seam, some 690 yd. below ground that the explosion occurred. In discussing the general conditions at the mine, Mr. Sandlands states that all were agreed that the mine was exceptionally well managed and extraordinarily well equipped with safety devices. He also refers to the existence of safety committees of workmen and officials and it is clear from the report that no valid criticism can be levied against either management or men so far as the safe and skilful working of the pit are concerned. In examining the events preceding and accompanying the explosion, Mr. Sandlands deals with the possibility of firedamp having been present in dangerous quantities. On one face a very small amount of gas was known to be issuing from a pothole and was dispersed by a brattice cloth, but all the evidence shows that this could not possibly have accumulated in dangerous quantities. It is accordingly accepted that firedamp can have played no part in the explosion. Not only did the evidence show that no material quantities of firedamp existed in any of the faces but in addition it was impossible to discover any means by which firedamp could have been ignited. Cutting and conveying machinery was standing at the time, no shotfiring was being carried out, and all lamps, telephones and signalling apparatus were found to be still in safe condition after the explosion. The explosion must, therefore, have been one of coal dust only. It was made abundantly plain that normal stonedusting in the mine was done much more thoroughly than necessary merely to comply with the Regulations and the maximum amount of combustible matter permitted by the management was only 30 per cent. Indeed the average of all samples from November 1, 1937 to May 9, 1938, showed only a fraction more than 15 per cent. of combustible matter. There were in the pit just prior to the explosion a number of tubs fairly full of material swept up when cleaning round the gear heads and loader ends, but apart from this, Mr. Sandlands considers that there was nothing really abnormal in the amount of coal dust in the East Plane at 5.30 a.m. on May 10. After the explosion a number of tubs was found piled up and it is suggested that these tubs of sweepings, containing a quantity of fine coal dust, had run amain and, on being upset, had caused a cloud of dust to arise. How these tubs ran away is a matter for conjecture only, but Mr. Sandlands considers that they were the only possible source of the coal dust which must have been present for the explosion to occur. Along the East Plane an electric cable was slung high up from the arch supports and close to the scene of the tub smash was a cable joint made in a bitumen-filled Ellison link-box. After the explosion this box was found to be broken. Since no other source of ignition could be discovered it is believed that electrical sparking occurred when the joint box was broken by the tubs which had also raised a cloud of coal dust into the air. Thus it is suggested that the explosion occurred by an almost incredible assemblage of unusual circumstances. A repetition of this most unfortunate series of coincidences is unlikely. Mr. Sandlands makes certain suggestions designed to render a repetition impossible. He suggests that the place where tubs are loaded or assembled should not lie on an incline at all and that roadway sweepings might be transported in covered tubs. More frequent cleaning up might be carried out, more strict attention paid to juts and further efforts be made to design some suction device for collecting dust made at gear heads, etc. Joint boxes might be stronger, of less brittle material than cast iron and located in recesses. He also suggests the more frequent sampling of places where coal dust is made in abnormal quantities and the taking of samples only from the upper layer of dust on the roadway. A mechanical device for spreading stonedust is, Mr. Sandlands suggests, probably preferable to the hand methods commonly employed. An extensive abstract of the report will appear in the next issue of the Colliery Guardian. * Cmd. 5849. H.M. Stationery Office. Price 2s. 6d. net.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 18 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||