14th October 1938, Page: 698, Column: 1
Notes From The Coal Fields
The Midlands
[Local Correspondence]
Miners' Welfare Fund badges won by young miners who attended introductory courses at the Mining Department of the North Staffordshire Technical College during the 1937-38 session were distributed at the college on October 7 by Mr. T. Yates,
president of the North Staffordshire Colliery Owners' Association. Mr. Hugh Leese (president of the North Stafford Miners' Federation) presided, supported by Mr. Yates, Mr. J. E. Brown (head of the mining department), Mr. H. J.
Crofts and Mr. John Walker. Mr. Yates, after presenting the badges, said that owners, managers and officials, generally were deeply interested in the problem of safety in pits. It was a very lamentable thing to see the toll of death and
injury from year to year. Notwithstanding all their efforts, they did not seem able to make any appreciable reduction. Great efforts were being made in North Staffordshire by individual collieries, and by committees representative of management and men.
The men, to his knowledge, responded wonderfully, and did their level best to improve safety in the pits. The accident rate to boys, continued Mr. Yates, was greater than it ought to be, and the safety classes the students had been attending were
inaugurated with the idea of instructing them in the possible dangers of their work.
The serious damage caused by mining subsidence was emphasised at a conference of local authorities in Birmingham on Thursday, October 6, convened by the Stoke-on-Trent City Council, to consider the Mining Subsidence Bill, which provides for the payment
of compensation for such damage. In the circular calling the conference it was stated that the provisions relating to compensation are based on the recommendations of the Royal Commission on Mining Subsidence, with the addition that local authorities are
included in the Bill as it is considered that the large housing undertakings of local authorities justify such inclusion. The position of many owners of property in various coal fields is serious, the circular stated, and every step should be taken to
secure some alleviation of the position. Ald. J. H. Dale, of Stoke-on-Trent, who presided, explained the purpose of the conference, and the reasons for the Bill. The case of Stoke-on-Trent for compensation for mining subsidence had been placed
before the former and the present Secretary for Mines ; and both agreed a good case had been made out. The sponsors of the Bill had been met in the House of Commons and they called together a number of members of Parliament. The grievances at
Stoke-on-Trent were brought before that meeting, and it was eventually decided that the Stoke-on-Trent City Council should convene a conference of local authorities affected by mining subsidence. At Stoke-on-Trent much loss was caused by mining
subsidence, and something ought to be done by way of compensation for the damage caused. Each year in Stoke-on-Trent, about £40,000 was spent consequent on subsidence caused by mining operations. Mr. Alan Todd said he thought the Bill
required amendment. Damage which existed to-day through mining subsidence might have been caused 100 years ago. There should be safeguard against bankruptcy. He favoured a tonnage levy which should be paid into a central compensation fund. The town clerk
of Swansea, who moved the resolution for the appointment of a committee, said the object of the conference was to ensure as much protection as possible for municipal authorities. He thought it would be wrong to define any particular line of procedure at
the conference; the better course was to refer the matter to a committee so that it could modify or improve the Bill. In its present form the Bill presented difficulties. Ald. John Evans, chairman of the Glamorgan County Council, said his council
had approved the principle of the Bill, which aimed at placing some liability upon persons extracting minerals to make compensation to the owners of surface property which was damaged by underground workings, notwithstanding any provision to the contrary
in any lease or conveyance, if such damage was manifest at the time of the passing of the Act, or became manifest thereafter. Although his council had approved the principle of the Bill in the abstract, it might become a matter for consideration as to
whether it was called upon to support the whole Bill, or whether there would be an opportunity for considering any modification. His council might find itself in some little difficulty on account of conflicting interests. On the one hand, the council was
the owner of considerable property in the coal mining areas, consisting of schools, police stations, hospitals and other buildings, some of which had already been more or less damaged by subsidence caused by coal mining operations, in respect of which
there was no remedy under the deed which gave the title to the land. Many local authorities were also the owners of housing estates and much other property. On the other hand, the council had vested in it considerable charity property underlain with
minerals. If a charity was called upon to bear the burden of compensation contemplated by the Bill, it would seem beyond doubt that the value of the charity for educational purposes would be greatly diminished. On general grounds, it appeared most
reasonable that any person who took land from a landowner in order to erect a house or other building should be secured from damage attributable to causes beyond the control of the owner of the surface buildings. On general principles his council was in
accord with the aims of the Bill, but it might well be that some opportunities for consideration of its details should be afforded so that, in the interests of the Bill itself, nothing should be proposed to Parliament which on balance would leave the
community in a worse position than at present. In the discussion, the principle of the Bill was accepted and the general view was that it required amendment. Sir Ben Turner, a former Secretary for Mines, was present and was invited to speak. He
said it was important that action should be taken in regard to compensation for mining subsidence. Resolutions were passed welcoming and approving the proposals contained in the Bill, and requesting members of Parliament representing mining areas to
introduce the Bill in the next session of Parliament in the event of one of their number being successful in the private members' ballot. The following resolution was also agreed to : "That this conference places on record its appreciation of the
council of the city of Stoke-on-Trent for its initiative in calling the conference, and that a committee be appointed to consider the Bill and the best method of securing its presentation to, and progress through, Parliament." It was suggested that
a further conference be convened to consider the findings of the committee, and this was added to the resolution.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Brown, J. E. | | | |
| Crofts, H. J. | | | |
| Dale, J. H., Alderman | | | |
| Evans, John, Alderman | | | |
| Leese, Hugh | | | |
| Todd, Alan | | | |
| Turner, Ben, Sir | | | |
| Walker, John | | | |
| Yates, T. | | | |