|
27th August 1938, Page: 49, Column: 1 Notes On Surveyors' ExaminationCentral Examiner's ReportThe Question Papers set at this Examination (May, 1938) have been published in pamphlet form and are obtainable (2s. net) from H.M. Stationery Office. As shown in the report of the Central Examiner the candidates present at the May (1938) examination for surveyors' certificates numbered 85 (last year 79), and 26 (22) qualified in the written examination. Those who qualified in the practical examination numbered 18 (19), the percentage being 21.2 (24). The percentage qualifying at Sheffield was 36.4, at Wigan 25, at Edinburgh 20, and at Newcastle 19. The candidates present at Cardiff and Birmingham failed to qualify. While the percentage of successful candidates does not quite equal the excellent figures of the last three examinations the Examiner says it is, on the whole, not unsatisfactory. That the results are not better is almost entirely due to the poor showing made by candidates at the three smaller centres (Wigan, Cardiff and Birmingham) where, from a total of 17 candidates, only one solitary success resulted. In the oral and practical examination the percentage of candidates who received qualifying marks was lower than for several recent examinations. As formerly, the most satisfactory work accomplished by candidates was in the surface levelling test. On the other hand, the work performed in the theodolite tests was not generally so satisfactory, and almost every examiner adversely criticises the methods of setting and manipulating, which they say frequently indicated insufficiency of experience. In certain instances it is stated that weakness was shown in knowledge of the principles of trigonometrical levelling. As previously, that part of the tests involving measuring was not always satisfactorily performed, and booking is frequently described as poor. The feature of the examination was the excellence of the work accomplished by candidates at Sheffield, both in the morning and afternoon papers. Edinburgh and, to a less extent, Newcastle were also satisfactory in that part of the examination. The percentage of candidates qualifying in the oral and practical part of the examination was also higher at Sheffield than elsewhere. On the other hand it falls to be stated that the attainments of a large number of the candidates who came forward for examination are still obviously far short of the standard aimed at by the Board. That is clearly demonstrated by the fact that the average marks earned by those 59 candidates who failed to earn qualifying marks in the written examination amounted to only 37 per cent. of the maximum. It has frequently been stated, the report concludes, that the impression conveyed to the mind of the Examiner during his study of the answers is that many candidates do not. give the questions sufficient careful perusal and thought before attempting to answer them. That criticism can quite definitely be applied to the work of many candidates at the examination under review. Comments on Answers. We give herewith the text of the questions set at the examination (plans not reproduced), each question being followed by the comment of the Examiner on the work generally of the candidates. The "comments" are in italics. MORNING SESSION (1) Compulsory Question. — The plan . . . . shows details taken from a Geological Survey map, and a generalised section showing the relative position of the several seams whose outcrops are indicated thereon. Draw in your answer hook, to the same scale as the plan, a longitudinal section on the line AB, showing the position of No. 8 seam in relation to the surface. Assume a thickness of 50 feet of alluvium overlying the rock head. Thereafter give a brief description of the geological structure of the area embraced by the plan in the light of the several details and symbols indicated thereon. (14) Answers generally were somewhat disappointing, the straight forward work of drawing the section being poorer than usual. In addition, many candidates needlessly wasted a great deal of time by inserting in their section the position of all the seams, although the question only asked for the position of No. 8 seam. The descriptive part of the answers was only fair, many candidates erroneously interpreting the symbol d5 as indicating the Millstone Grit. Only a few realised — or at least definitely stated — that with Carboniferous Limestone Measures brought opposite rocks of the Coat Measures, the fault marking the southern limit of the plan was an upthrow to south of very considerable displacement. (2) Undernoted are magnetic hearings of an underground and surface reference line respectively, taken at different times — G.M.T. — on the same day. With the aid of the magnetograph . . . calculate the geographical azimuth of the underground reference line. Assume the surface reference line to have a geographical azimuth of 96°14'20". (12)
This question — which was by no means difficult when the facts indicated by the magnetograph had been properly assimilated and given effect to — was not often attempted. Candidates who did so, however, generally gave fairly satisfactory answers. (3) The co-ordinates of the centres of two shafts A and B in relation to a common point of origin are respectively as follows :—
If the co-ordinates of a point C at the face of a straight roadway being driven from shaft A, and a point D at the face of another straight roadway being driven from shaft B are respectively as stated hereunder, calculate the co-ordinates of the point of intersection of the projected courses of AC and BD. (10)
This straightforward practical question was attempted by almost every candidate. Results were not nearly so goad as they ought to have been, only about one-third of the answers being correct or even approximately correct. (4) Assume that in your capacity as chief surveyor you have had instructions to prepare a plan showing the boundaries and surface features of a mineral field about to be developed by two shafts in process of sinking, and that your surface survey is almost completed. The mineral field is of such extent that a plan approximately 10' x 6' is required. Describe, in detail, the successive steps which you would take in the preparation of the plan, commencing from the purchase of the necessary paper. (8) The majority of answers were on the whole satisfactory, although the necessity for stipulating that only well-seasoned paper should be used, and that it should be spread out flat for a considerable time before the commencement of grid construction, was often omitted. (5) ABC is a colliery railway line of which the part AB bears due north, while BC bears towards the west on a curve of 10 chains radius. One chain to the east of AR and parallel to it is another straight railway line DE. It is proposed to join BC and DE by a curve of 18 chains radius. At what distance from B must that curve leave BC to join DE? (8) Surprisingly few candidates attempted to answer this question, which was capable of speedy and easy solution by the adoption of similar triangles. AFTERNOON SESSION: (1) Compulsory Question. — The sketch is taken from a colliery plan. It shows part of a cross measures drift AB, and also part of a roadway CDE in an overlying seam. The azimuths and lengths of the lines joining the several traverse stations shown in the sketch are respectively as follow :—
The co-ordinates and relative levels of the stations B and C are as follow :—
It is proposed to drive from a point F in the line DE a cross measure drift FG dipping at 6 inches to the yard in the direction BA which will ultimately connect with AR produced in direction and gradient. Calculate the distance from the point D at which the drift PG must he set away, and the distance which AB will travel before it holes through on that drift. (14) Answers to this question were also somewhat disappointing, only eleven candidates obtaining correct or approximately correct solutions. As a rule candidates calculated with reasonable accuracy the position of the starting point of the drift, but the subsequent calculations to determine the point of intersection of the two converging dipping drifts proved too much for the majority. (2) A colliery leasehold contains three seams of coal whose thickness and position relatively to each other in the strata are respectively as follow: Upper seam, 3 feet; strata, 100 feet; mid seam, 6 feet; strata, 58 feet ; lower seam, 8 feet. The plan . . . shows a mansion house, and workings in the upper and lower seams which have been brought opposite each other at the point A by a fault which hades at 30° from the vertical. It is a condition of the mineral lease that in no seam shall the workings be carried nearer to the mansion house than to a line drawn laterally therefrom at a distance equal to one-half of the vertical depth of such seam from the surface thereat. Draw on the plan from the details indicated thereon the outline of the area of protection in the mid seam, on the assumption that the fault extends northwards under and beyond the mansion house, and that the surface is level. (12) Answers were no better than fair. Only five candidates gave evidence of having appreciated that with the strata rising northward at 1 in 7 and 1 in 4.5 respectively on the west and east sides of the fault, the barren area due to the hade of the fault would be greater under the mansion house than at the point A. In the great majority of the answers the exact position and breadth of the fault in the Mid Seam was not properly indicated, many candidates simply producing the single line from A northwards to define it. (3) The colliery reservoir, ABCDEFG.... has vertical brick sides, is 3 feet deep along wall AR, and has bottom dipping 1 in 175 at right angles to AR. Buildings which necessitated the irregular wall CDEFG have now been removed, and it is desired to increase the surface area of the reservoir to the extent of 50 per cent, by constructing a new wall parallel to AR in the vicinity of the line XY, the same gradient of bottom being continued thereto. Calculate the distance from AR at which the new wall should be constructed, and the number of gallons which the enlarged reservoir will contain when completely filled. (12) This question was not very often attempted, but candidates who did so generally gave satisfactory answers. The calculations to determine the position of the wall were as a rule more accurate than those to determine the volume. (4) A heap of debris at an abandoned colliery is about to be utilised for brick-making purposes, and it has been arranged that a royalty of 3d. per cubic yard shall be paid on the material uplifted. Measurements to determine the amount of royalty payable are to be made half-yearly. The heap varies from 40 to 60 feet in height, and has been deposited on undulating ground with a plan area of 8 acres or thereby. State clearly the method which you would adopt in order that the half-yearly measurements may be determined with the maximum of accuracy. Illustrate your answer by a sketch. (10) Many answers to this question provided obvious evidence of the lack of practical experience of the work required satisfactorily to meet the circumstances stated. With only a few exceptions, sketches were poor in the extreme. (5) Calculate the difference in length of an arc of 10 of longitude at latitude 550 and latitude 560 respectively. Assume the radius of the earth at the equator to be 3,962.8 miles. (8) Rather more than one-half of the candidates attempted this question. Answers on the whole were good. (6) Describe the method of measuring a base line for a surface survey of a large mineral field, and the several corrections generally found necessary for the purpose of obtaining the net length at datum level. State also how you would correlate the base line to the magnetic and geographical meridians, and what particular use you would make of these meridians at a colliery. (8) Satisfactory answers were generally obtained from candidates who attempted this question.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||