Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

30th July 1938, Page: 24, Column: 2

Strata Movements And Mine Surveying

By A. Winstanley, M.B.E., D.Sc., F.R.S.E.

From paper read before the Institute of Mine Surveyors at Edinburgh on 28th May.

In connection with falls of ground investigations many continuous records of convergence of roof and floor, or the sides of roads, have been obtained with recorders. In some cases separate roof and floor movements have been ascertained by taking floor or roof movements separately by levelling instruments or by water levelling apparatus, and subtracting from the total convergence. Lateral deviation measurements of plugs from theodolite sights have been made, and relative lateral movements of roof and floor plugs have been obtained by plumbing. Absolute lateral movements are difficult to obtain because convenient stationary bases can rarely be found. For certain purposes, strain and deflection measurements of the exposed surfaces of beds have been obtained by dial micrometers and gauges.

The examples given to indicate the general nature of strata movements will refer particularly to longwall workings of the single, double or triple machine, or machine-cut conveyor type, common in Scotland and elsewhere.

(a) In roads leading to longwall faces. — Several tests have been made in narrow roads ahead of longwall faces. Rows of plugs in roof and floor have been levelled, tested for deviation from line and plumbed. In some cases boreholes have been put up to specific beds and the movements of these also recorded.

One of these tests was made in a seam 5' 3" thick, at a depth of 1,180 feet and inclined at 1 in 40. A face 1,100 feet long with solid coal sides was being advanced about 2½ feet daily to the rise. Three roads were brushed, one near each end and one near the centre where there was a road 8' to 10' wide straight ahead in the solid coal. The system of support was by composite steel props 4½ inches diameter set 4 feet apart to corrugated steel straps, there being one row of straps when stripping started and two rows when it was finished. Besides the packs at the sides of the main roads, there were 12-foot intermediate packs 30 feet to 40 feet apart, built from stone obtained from the fallen roof in the wastes.

In the road ahead of the face, steel plugs were fixed in a series of holes 40 inches apart in rows in the roof and floor. The roof and floor began to converge nearly 100 feet ahead of the longwall face and continued very slowly. About 20 feet ahead of the longwall face the rate of convergence increased and continued to grow as the face advanced, reaching a maximum value between the face and the waste. Then it gradually decreased until at 300 feet behind the face both floor and roof movements were very slow, although actual stability was not reached until the face was 600 feet ahead.

In some cases, where the supports, especially the packs, were inadequate, instability, with severe crush causing the roof, floor and sides to squeeze so that roads were continually reducing in section, continued for several years. Indeed, there are large areas in some mines, where it is impossible to find stable ground.

In addition, the roof and flour beds moved outward from the face towards the waste and to right or left in somewhat erratic manner. These movements follow the path of least resistance, and are affected by roof or floor brushings of roads, or by falls of roof in wastes and by the packs.

It may be argued that sight plugs are only intended to maintain road directions approximately, or that the strata movements and subsequent enlarging operations sometimes cause the road itself to be displaced several feet ; nevertheless, there are many important haulage roads, for example, in which the rail tracks cannot he laid straight and the haulage ropes cause trouble because sufficient care has not been taken with the "views" and in checking the disturbance of the sight plugs in moving ground. For a given angular error of the sight plugs the deviation of the road increases with the length of the sight, thus emphasising the need for frequent checking of plugs.

If the road regains stability within a few hundred feet of the face, this being one object of effective control of strata movements, it is not difficult to check back to stable and checked plugs by taking back sights on each occasion before taking the forward sights. Where the stable checked plugs are too far back, frequent checking with surveying instruments is called for.

Well organised surveying at any colliery must include stable and checked base lines for both surveying and levelling, but suitable places for such bases, especially where there are extensive mining operations in several seams, or where permanent instability follows each working face, call for careful investigation, experiment and watchfulness if reasonable accuracy is to be obtained.

(b) On roads in adjoining workings. — In view of the widespread use of the panel or unit system of longwall working, an instance may be given of the disturbance of plugs in roof and floor of a haulage road, 120 feet from the side of another parallel 460 feet wide unit, worked in the same seam two years later.

The seam was 3' 6" thick at a depth of 1,300 feet and inclined at 1 in 20 parallel with the road. In both the original and the new units there were three main roads, and intermediate packs 30 feet apart, built from brushing of dummy roads. Plugs in the roof and floor of the adjacent haulage road were levelled, and plumbed, and convergence recorders operated continuously. Both roof and floor were moving when the face was 100 feet behind, and continued until the face was 300 feet ahead of the plugs. Although the roof and floor plugs only moved 2" each, the movements were much greater in the middle of the road.

(c) Another instance showed the effects of a double conveyor face in a seam 2' 10" thick at a depth of 780 feet, advancing beneath a haulage road nearly parallel with the face and in workings advanced at right angles over the same ground in a seam 3 feet thick and 90 feet above. The intervening strata consisted of sandstone and blaes beds, the thickest sandstone being 12 feet.

Convergence recorders had been set between some pairs of plugs in the roof and floor of the upper seam haulage road. Other plugs 50 feet apart in straight lines were levelled with the theodolite, and lateral deviations from a sight line with this instrument were also measured. Movements of roof plugs relative to those in the floor were ascertained by plumbing.

The road over the whole width of the lower seam working started to lower very slowly when the face was 100 feet away in plan and had lowered 4½ inches at the centre when the face was exactly below. At this stage the road for about 100 feet beyond the sides of the under working was lowering slightly. When the face had passed the road lowered faster, reaching a total of 11 inches over a length of 300 feet, and less amounts nearer the sides of the under working, when the face was 300 feet beyond.

(d) Effects on workings below. — In a seam 3 feet thick at a depth of 900 feet a face 360 feet long had advanced daily by machine cutting 6 feet deep. There were main roads at each end and roof brushed roads to provide intermediate packs 30 feet apart.

Six months later a similar face in a seam 2' 7" thick and 12 feet above, was advanced in the same direction over the same area. This seam had a soft black floor bed 1 foot thick into which the props penetrated under loads less than 3 tons. The roof of this seam was coarse fragile sandstone, and a system of chocking to supplement the propping was necessary to prevent severe "weights" and roof breaks.

From roads in the lower seam, boreholes 3¼ inches diameter were put up to the floor of the upper seam and then bored through 2¾ inches diameter to the roof of this seam. By means of water levelling apparatus and convergence recorders installed in the boreholes, the roof and floor movements in both seams were recorded continuously as the upper seam face advanced. In addition to the vertical movements there were lateral movements of the roof and beds above, relative to the floor of the lower seam.

Similar tests have been made in seams as much as 70 feet apart and renewed movements, both greater in magnitude and extent, have been found where excessive damage has been caused by the earlier workings.

The information obtained from the boreholes shows that the beds not only subside independently but also move laterally, relative to one another. As the beds have different dimensions and strength properties, unless there is sufficient natural adhesion it is inevitable that one bed should draw away from that above, leaving a cavity, and causing increased pressure to be transmitted at the boundaries of the cavity. But the positions of these cavities are continually changing, and so are the pressures transmitted to the supports. Props, chocks, packs and road supports affect, and are affected by, this differential movement of the beds in the disturbed ground. For example, a cavity boundary or even several such boundaries may occur between the roof beds above and parallel with the face, and as a consequence excessive pressure transmitted at these cavity boundaries causes serious damage to the roof, falls, and "weights" at the face. By more effective resistance from props, chocks and packs, the boundary of each cavity may be moved back to the Waste edge where its effects are relatively harmless. Moreover, effective supports prevent large and wide cavities, and thus avoid extremely high pressures at the cavity boundaries. Involved in this subject, among other important matters, is the issue of firedamp, especially sudden large scale issues which are so dangerous. In fact, large scale cavity movements accompany shot-firing and coal-cutting, which may provide the source of ignition for the firedamp.

Differential subsidence probably goes on right to the surface, strong rigid beds such as sandstones permitting large cavities to form below them and causing erratic subsidence when they fracture from time to time. Soft and flexible beds such as clays and coals may permit only small cavities and thus tend to even out subsidence.

(e) Surface movements. — Records of surface movements induced by mining operations have been before you since large scale mining operations began, and many experiences and experimental results have been published. Much, however, remains to be done by continuous records of surface and underground movements to determine the effects of the more important beds, including the immediate surface layer. Differential subsidence, as indicated in the borehole tests, is an additional complication in a problem already difficult because there are many variables affecting each case.

Although the strata movements briefly described must be well known to mine surveyors, and to my knowledge some take endless pains to counteract their effects by careful selection and checking of base plugs, these measures are sometimes looked upon as superfluous refinements by those who are content to go on adding quarterly surveys and levels to their plans with little regard for the stability of plugs used for bases. Even if the consequences of inaccuracy may not seem to have serious effects on the working of a face, cases must arise from time to time where accuracy is an essential factor. Accuracy all the time must be the guiding star of the true surveyor. Unstable ground resulting from mining operations must be a serious matter in some mines,


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Winstanley, Arthur      Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print