|
16th July 1938, Page: 10, Column: 1 Markham Colliery ExplosionOfficial Inquiry at ChesterfieldThe official inquiry into the explosion at Markham No. 1 (Blackshale) Colliery, near Chesterfield, which occurred on 10th May, and in which 79 men lost their lives, was adjourned by Mr. P. E. Sandlands, K.C., the Commissioner, until Monday, 18th July. Evidence was taken on four days, 27th-30th June. In his opening speech representing the Mines Department Mr. Trustram Eve said he was not suggesting that there was any failure to observe the statutory regulations or absence of proper care in the pit, but they would have to see whether any useful lessons might be learned from the disaster which would minimise the risk from a similar occurrence. The accident happened at the end of the night shift. The evidence of ventilation was particularly good. He was asked particularly to mention the provision of water-hydrants in the east plane and the roads, which proved admirable in dealing with the fires which broke out after the event. The rescue work was, as usual and as they would expect, wonderful, and he paid particular tribute to the volunteer teams those of the day shift and those of the night shift who were physically able to do so, although they had been working all night, helped in the Work. Death in every case was due to carbon monoxide poisoning. There were 171 working underground on the night shift, and of those 79 were killed and 41 injured. Most of the injured had recovered. Although no statutory examinations had been made recently there was at the mine a safety committee, consisting of representatives of the Workmen, who made an underground inspection every month and met the manager for discussions. The last available reports on the mine were made on the day before the disaster, and in the section dealing with ventilation the word "satisfactory" occurred throughout. Mr. Eve thought that ventilation was a matter which would not have to be discussed at the inquiry, and said there was absolutely no evidence of contraband. Electricity was a matter which would have to be investigated. Before the question of firing shots could be eliminated the inquiry would hear witnesses regarding the operations at two points, because, although he could not suggest that the cause lay there, investigations had not yet proved conclusively that it did not. That was the most that could be said. One of the most anxious and difficult parts of the inquiry was the fact that while samples of air were all well within regulation requirements for safety-stone-dusting produced a result well in advance of statutory regulations-an explosion of coal dust could take place extending over a distance of slightly more than one thousand yards. Those instructing him took the view that the cause was not known, nor were they at the moment prepared to indicate any definite place of origin. It might possibly be at one of four places. It was possible almost to eliminate spontaneous combustion, because there Was no history of it in this type of coal. There was no explanation at present why the explosion was such a large one, and not more local. Inquiry into the probable reasons would involve many difficult questions. Dr. S. W. Fisher, Medical Inspector of Mines, said that the blood of the victims was so saturated with carbon monoxide that death was caused quickly in each case. It would have been impossible after the explosion for men to go many steps, so full of carbon monoxide must the pit have been. The ambulance arrangements at the mine were excellent, and he was certain that many lives were saved by the prompt administration of oxygen underground. On the second day of the inquiry survivors of the disaster, who were on the night shift in the early hours of 10th May, gave evidence and spoke of the satisfactory conditions of the mine and the absence of gas on the night of the disaster. The chairman said there was no suggestion that the officials Were in any way negligent. He also complimented the survivors upon the way in which they had given evidence. Horace William Carter, who was in charge of the hauling engine, told how a moment or two after 5-30 a.m. there was a sudden bumping and he was knocked over. "I was a bit confused," he said. "I was on my back, and I could not see what was happening. I switched the engine off, and I got up and switched the lights off." There was a lot of dust in the engine-house. Realising that something serious had happened, he ran out to suggest to the electrician that power should be switched off. John James Bradshaw, a timber drawer, said that the only occasion that he had ever known of gas in the mine was on the Tuesday before the disaster. It was a very small quantity, which was not in the air-current but only in a pocket, and it was cleared in less than ten minutes. During his forty years as a miner he had never worked in a better pit than Markham No. 1, especially with regard to ventilation. Several witnesses spoke of the absence of signs of gas and the normal conditions in the mine that night. They were questioned particularly about the loading and the unloading of tubs and their manipulation. Upon the third day of the hearing John Cedric Scott, an electrician, said that during his tour of the affected part of the mine he found nothing unusual. He carried out no work with a live cable. He was on his way out of the pit when there was a terrific gust of wind and a great cloud of dust. He managed to reach the pit bottom, and saw the overman, who instructed him to switch off the power. That was about ten minutes after the explosion. He found all the switches on, as he had seen them before he left. George Agar, chief colliery electrician, said he was strongly of the impression that the force of the explosion was felt inside the transformer-house. It was possible, he thought, for the main high-tension switch to come out without being pulled out. A bang or a big shot might move it, because it Was of fairly easy action. Some time was taken in hearing evidence about stone-dusting in the pit. There would be no time in the periods between stone-dusting for any large accumulation of coal dust, declared one witness. Many places in the pit were stone-dusted, it was stated, every day at the beginning of the day shift. Evidence was given on the fourth day by Arthur W. Fitch, an overman with a first class manager's certificate, who said he was in charge of the pit on the night of the explosion. He was in his cabin at the pit bottom at 5-30 when he heard a hissing through the separation doors and a banging. He Went out to investigate and finding several men lying about he dragged them into the air-currents. They were in a haze of what appeared to be dust. James Cowan, junior electrical inspector of mines, who examined all the damaged and suspected electrical apparatus in the affected part of the mine after the explosion, said that 70 lengths of cable had been taken to the surface, stripped, and examined, together with the joint-boxes. There was no evidence of fusion, which might in the ordinary course of events have been a source of ignition. Neither was there evidence of fusion in the broken joint-box near a junction in the pit. The shattering of parts of the box showed quite a terrific impact. Announcing the adjournment until 18th July the chairman said he understood that the Mines Department wanted time to investigate and consider the things they heard given in evidence.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||