Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

7th May 1938, Page: 342, Column: 1

The Holditch Colliery Explosion

Chief Inspector's Report

Thirty persons lost their lives and eight were injured as the result of the explosion at Holditch Colliery which occurred on the 2nd July, 1937. In the Mines Department Report (Cmd. 572) on the causes of, and circumstances attending the explosion, by Mr. F. H. Wynne, C.B.E., B.Sc., H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines, it is explained that the Holditch Colliery, known locally as Brymbo Pit, is about two miles N.N.W. of Newcastle-under-Lyme, Staffordshire. The two shafts are approximately 2,000 feet deep to the stone drifts from which the two working seams, the Great Row and the Four Feet, were reached. From the shafts two parallel stone drifts or "cruts" had been driven, dipping in a south-westerly direction to tap the Four Feet Seam through the Apedale fault, estimated to be of 700 yards upthrow. The intake crut is level for a distance of 125 yards from the downcast shaft, and continues in a straight line for a further distance of half a mile at a dipping gradient of 1 in 11 to, and through, the Apedale fault. At this point the gradient was increased, at first to 1 in 4 and later to 1 in 3, until the seam was reached at 1,190 yards from the shaft. From that point the roadway continued in a direct line in the seam, dipping at 1 in 22, and at the date of the explosion had progressed 200 yards from where the seam was struck. There was, therefore, a straight road, 1,390 yards long from the downcast shaft bottom to the face, serving as the main haulage road and, for most of its length, as the intake airway. On the morning of 2nd July two coal-cutter men (Herman Payne and William Beardmore) were flitting a Samson compressed-air-driven coal-cutter down the face in order to start cutting 3 yards or so to the right or dip of the main haulage road. The machine, having arrived at this spot, was fitted with sharp picks, jibbed in and commenced to cut uphill. After it had cut about 2 yards, there was a fall of coal on the compressed-air hosepipe, which was cleared in a few minutes and cutting proceeded. At about 5-45 a.m. the machine had cut past the gate-end and the back end of the machine was about 3 yards beyond the left-hand gateside pack when Beardmore, who was shovelling away the cuttings, saw a flame which seemed to run round with the picks for a moment and then extended under the cut coal. The flame flashed back along the holing to where cutting had commenced, i.e., a distance of about 7 or 8 yards, came out of the cut and spread up the coal face towards the roof. It was described by Beardmore as being "like a wall of fire." The Report describes the steps taken to combat the fire which followed, and the Chief Inspector's references to the cause of the calamity are reproduced as follows :—

The Cause of the Calamity.

"There were three separate occurrences, each of which contributed its quota either to the roll of dead or injured, or both. First of all, there was the fire at the coal-cutting machine at about 5-50 a.m. There is, in my opinion, no room for doubt that the deaths of 9380507jHaystead and Stanton* were due to exposure to poisonous gases from this fire after they had lost their way in the smoke when endeavouring to escape. Secondly, there was the explosion at 6-50 am, which caused the death of Hassell, and injury to Bentley, who were in the Right Hand Carving at the moment when it occurred. It may be stated here that since the inquiry was closed the body of Hassell has been recovered. It was found in the extreme right-band corner of the coal face against the end of the rib pack of the Right Hand Carving and between a roadside chock and the coal rib. If the evidence of Bentley is correct (and there is no reason to doubt his word), it must be assumed that, when the explosion occurred, Hassell was so dazed by it that, instead of making his way outbye to safety, he wandered inbye, passing over or alongside Bentley, who, as he stated in evidence, had turned round and lain down, and when he came to himself, proceeded to crawl out in the dark. Thirdly, there was the devastating explosion at 10-10 a.m. which caused the holocaust of 27 lives and from which only one person (Salt) of the 28 exposed to its force and flame escaped.

"The Cause of the Fire. — The evidence is quite clear that a fire originated at the coal-cutting machine, and there can be little doubt that it was due to heat produced by the friction of the picks in the cut, for minute examination of the machine after it had been recovered and brought out to the surface has revealed no other possible cause. Indeed, the machine, even after its exposure, first to the fire, then to water incidental to the flooding of the area which was resorted to as the best means of ensuring the extinction of the fire, and finally, to possible damage by falls of ground, was, surprisingly, found to be practically in working order. There were no signs at all of any undue friction between any of the moving and fixed parts, i.e., between the chain and its path around the jib, or the sprocket and its shaft and its bearings in the banjo. In the absence of any such signs only the conclusion stated above can be drawn.

"The Cause of the Explosions. — It would be superfluous to discuss at any length the causes of the several explosions. They were all, of course, due to the presence, in the face, of firedamp which was ignited from time to time by the fire which was burning there. Although normally, owing to the adequacy of the ventilation, the atmosphere in the workings of the Four-feet seam appears to have been free from firedamp, there can be no question that in the absence of adequate ventilation firedamp would rapidly collect.

"It is reasonable to assume that shortly after the fire started the quantity of air passing along the Right Hand Carving was very considerably curtailed on account, firstly, of the facilities for a short cut via the Main Dip, and, secondly, of falls of roof in the face when the roof supports became weakened to breaking point by the flames from the fire. Later, exploration by the rescue brigade showed that there was a fall at the ripping of the Right Hand Carving and this, too, would add to the general obstruction of the intake air. This assumption is confirmed by the fact that, when Mr. Cocks came, the question was raised as to whether or not the doors and sheets in the Main Dip, which had been displaced by the earlier explosions, should be restored. It was decided not to restore them for fear that the firedamp which was known to have accumulated in the right hand side of the workings would be driven on to the fire.

Firedamp Ignition by Sparks.

The Chief Inspector of Mines includes some notes in his report relating to ignition of firedamp from sparks, as under :—

"The Ignition of Firedamp by Coal-cutting Machines and its Prevention. — The question of the ignition of firedamp by the heat of impact of coal-cutter picks against rocks is not a new one; it is merely brought into greater prominence by the occurrence at Holditch Colliery. Much work on the subject has already been done by the Safety in Mines Research Board, and the results of part of that work have been published in two papers, namely, Safety in Mines Research Board Papers Nos. 54 and 70. The subject matter of these papers was confined to the ignition of firedamp by the impact of coal-cutter picks against hard rock, the actual experiments being carried out on certain types of hard siliceous rock, specially selected on account of their texture and hardness.

"Endeavours to ignite firedamp by sparks from pyrites had, up to this time, proved abortive. On account, however, of several authentic reports of ignitions in cuts where pyrites was present and siliceous rock absent, further experiments in which the laboratory conditions were changed so as better to simulate mining practice were made. These experiments are described in the Annual Report of the Safety in Mines Research Board for 1936, from which it emerges that firedamp can be ignited by sparks produced by picks striking nodules of pyrites. There is no hard siliceous rock in connection with the Four Feet seam at Holditch Colliery which could give rise to incendive sparks, but the seam does carry irregular concretionary masses of foreign matter, some of which, though not all, have a pyritic appearance.

"Since the possibility of ignition by sparks from pyrites has been established, it would appear that little advantage is to be gained from further experimentation merely in regard to that. I venture to suggest, however, that there is room for further investigation, in a general way, of the cutting conditions that most readily give rise to incendive sparking or heating whether in sandstone or pyrites for it seems to me that information on the subject of pick shapes, pick speeds and pick arrangements, and rate of advance of the cutting machine, must all he important factors. Possibly the composition of the steel used for the pick points has some hearing, although I gather that as the result of several investigations it is thought that the composition of the steel is a factor of minor importance. It is to be hoped that in course of time such a fundamental investigation may lead to improvements in cutting practice which will, as a first line of defence, minimise the risk of ignition.

"I am afraid, however, this risk could never be entirely eliminated, and something to constitute a second line of defence is therefore called for. One of these has already been suggested in Safety in Mines Research Board Paper No. 81, which gives the results of laboratory experiments with the proprietary commercial product "Drikold," which is carbon dioxide in solid form. Although the paper referred to was published in 1933, little appears to have been done as yet to test "Drikold" as a practical working adjunct of a coal-cutting machine in a pit. An improvised equipment has been tried and the results were considered promising enough to justify further tests with a machine having a "Drikold" container specially built into the carriage. It is eminently desirable that these further tests should be carried out, and the results of them published with as little delay as possible.

The function of the chemical is to act as an inhibitor of ignition. The actual chemical composition of an inhibitor is, of course, of little moment so long as it fulfils its function and does not vitiate the atmosphere. A further line of defence — the third and the simplest as regards ease of provision, but likely in some emergencies, of which the Holditch fire is an example, to prove inefficacious — is the provision of ordinary fire-fighting measures. This matter is one of the items of draft General Regulations recently promulgated by the Secretary for Mines. Where the conditions at the face permit, there is no reason why some means of dealing with incipient fires should not be carried actually on coal-cutting machines, in the form either of a supply of stone dust or a fire extinguisher."


* These two men, who were engaged in building a pack in the middle waste between the Back Dip and the Left Hand Carving, failed to come out. It is a mystery why they failed to escape, unless it be that, the Report suggests, by the time they realised their danger and made their effort, the smoke was so dense that, instead of retreating by either the Back Dip or the Left Hand Carving, they lost their way and wandered into another waste, and were there overcome.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Beardmore, William    Coal Cutter  
Bentley, —    Miner  
Cocks, John   57 Manager  Deceased, Individual Page
Hassell, John   35 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Haystead, W.   45 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Payne, Herman    Coal Cutter  
Salt, —    Miner  
Stanton, Arthur Richard   31 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wynne, Frederick Horton    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Holditch Colliery  Holditch Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
09 Jul 1937  The Chesterton Disaster (The Colliery Guardian)
09 Jul 1937  Brymbo Colliery Disaster (The Colliery Guardian)
16 Jul 1937  Notes from the Coal Fields, Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
17 Jul 1937  The Holditch Disaster (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 Jul 1937  Notes from the Coal Fields, The Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
30 Jul 1937  Notes from the Coal Fields, The Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
31 Jul 1937  Holditch Mine Explosion (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 Aug 1937  Notes from the Coal Fields, Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
14 Aug 1937  Holditch Inquiry (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Aug 1937  Notes from the Coal Fields, The Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
10 Sep 1937  Notes from the Coal Fields, The Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
17 Sep 1937  The Holditch Explosion, Official Inquiry Opened (The Colliery Guardian)
24 Sep 1937  The Holditch Explosion, Official Inquiry Concluded (The Colliery Guardian)
25 Sep 1937  The Holditch Inquiry (The Science and Art of Mining)
01 Oct 1937  The Brymbo Inquiry, Igniting Firedamp By The Impact Of Steel On Pyrites (The Colliery Guardian)
08 Oct 1937  Notes from the Coalfields, The Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
15 Oct 1937  Notes from the Coalfields, The Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
29 Oct 1937  Notes from the Coalfields, The Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
04 Feb 1938  Notes from the Coal Fields, The Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
11 Feb 1938  Notes from the Coal Fields, The Midlands (The Colliery Guardian)
09 Apr 1938  French Award To Rescue Workers (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 May 1938  The Holditch Colliery Explosion, Chief Inspector's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Aug 1938  Award of Edward Medal (London Gazette)
13 Aug 1938  Rescue Team Captain Honoured (The Science and Art of Mining)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Holditch
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print