Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

9th April 1938, Page: 314, Column: 1

Firedamp Detector Regulations

Recommendations of Committee

In the last issue of this journal brief reference was made to the Report of the Committee on the Firedamp Detector Regulations (1s. net, H.M. Stationery Office). The Committee was appointed in December, 1936, the members being Mr. Isaac Foot (chairman), Mr. W. Frowen, O.B.E., J.P., Mr. H. Hicken, Mr. G. P. Hyslop, Mr. A. E. Naylor, and Mr. F. H. Wynne, C.B.E., B.Sc., with Mr. C. H. S. de Peyer as secretary. Messrs. Hyslop and Naylor did not sign the main Report.

When they sat in committee it soon became apparent that the principal points to which they should direct attention were those which had provoked the keenest controversy at the time the Regulations were made, namely: (1) The number of detectors which should be provided; (2) the training in firedamp detection of the men appointed to take charge of the detectors, more particularly where these were flame-safety-lamps ; (3) whether the provision of automatic detectors should in any circumstances be made compulsory.

Use of Detectors.

In regard to the use made of the detectors the committee recommend —

That, after a reasonable interval has been allowed to elapse to enable the necessary arrangements for the transition to be completed, in every case where flame-safety-lamps are used as Detectors under the Regulations, these lamps should be of types which comply with the Lighting Regulations (i.e., should he Schedule A lamps) ; and that the competent workman appointed to carry a Detector should not be provided with any other lamp unless he makes representations to the Manager, and receives written permission from him, to carry an electric lamp also.

Such permission should not be given unless the Manager is satisfied that the Detector will be properly used, and he should of course withdraw the permission if he finds that proper use is not made of the Detector. In this way the Committee think that one of the major difficulties inherent in the present Regulations should be overcome, since the danger that the Detectors will be left out in the gate road and not be taken into the face should, to a large extent, be removed. This, Mr. Humphrys points out, was found to have happened following the Wharncliffe Woodmoor explosion, and many similar discoveries are also reported by other Divisional Inspectors.

Number of Detectors.

Recommendations made as to the number of detectors to be provided are :—

That no lower proportion than one Detector (whether automatic, non-automatic, or with the two types used together) for every eight men employed, should be allowed on such faces (longwall).

That the Regulations should also require a firedamp Detector to be provided to every set of workmen engaged on repair work in return airways.

That a Detector should be provided in every working place at the coal face and in any stone drift or heading in course of being driven.

Training of "Competent Workman."

The questionnaire dealing with the training of the "competent workmen" revealed an absence of uniformity, the training given varying greatly in effectiveness, not only in different parts of the country, but also and to a far greater degree at different collieries. The Committee concerned themselves with only two methods of training. The one involves estimating gas caps as seen on the flame of a safety-lamp and the other does not, and on this point the Committee agree in general with the opinion expressed by Mr. Humphrys that no person should be appointed to have charge of a flame lamp detector unless he has established his competency by being tested with a gas chamber. The Committee accordingly recommend —

That no workman shall be certified as competent unless he has shown his ability to estimate gas caps seen on the actual flame of a safety-lamp whether in a gas chamber or otherwise.

That arrangements should be made by Managers to instruct each Deputy to require every competent workman" in his district to show his familiarity with the operations of testing for firedamp once in every three or four months. To ensure that this is done, the Deputy should report the name of each man whom he has re-tested in this way.

An attractive, simply written pamphlet, containing also a certificate of competency for signature by the Manager, should be specially prepared, in which much of the material contained in the Mines Department Safety Pamphlets on "Firedamp" would be included, together with additional material, making a special appeal to their sense of responsibility, and pointing out the reason why they themselves (the men) should make tests for firedamp.

The Manager should be required to give directions as to use to the competent workmen, and to ensure that the Deputy sees that all Detectors required for his district are in their places.

Clarifying their position in regard to the relationship between firedamp detection by the workmen and firedamp detection by the deputies, the Committee explain that whether automatic or non-automatic methods of firedamp detection are adopted, there is no question of supplanting the statutory inspections of the deputies by the provision of firedamp detecting appliances to the workmen. Firedamp detection by the workmen is intended to supplement the work of the deputies, and not in any sense to be a substitute for it.

Comparison of Detectors.

Flame lamps and automatic detectors are compared in Section 4 of the Report. In competent hands, it may reasonably be claimed that the flame-safety-lamp can be readily used as a detector to determine the extent and composition of a body of firedamp, the percentage in the air-current at different points, and the source from which firedamp originates — valuable information which an automatic detector seems unlikely to provide. The flame lamp is, moreover, inherently accurate, and informs the trained observer what percentage of firedamp he may have found. It is, however, subject to certain limitations. It cannot be under continuous observation, and its useful employment depends on the skill, judgment, and constant watchfulness of the man in whose charge it is placed.

Accumulations of firedamp can, of course, collect, and the firedamp content of the general body of the air can increase, without the fact being noticed by the men working in the contaminated atmosphere. Such contingencies may result from a blower or feeder of firedamp, or from defective ventilation, or from an interference or obstruction in the ventilation arrangements ; and, while it is true that the flame-safety-lamp is extinguished by an explosive mixture of firedamp, and that its extinction could not escape the notice of a man dependent for his illumination solely upon a flame-safety-lamp, this last condition does not often occur, for there are usually other lights near by. Moreover, it may be in doubt why the lamp is extinguished, for there are other and much commoner reasons for lamps going out than the presence of an explosive mixture of firedamp and air. Finally, if the atmosphere is such that a flame lamp is extinguished by it, and if there is an igniting agent present, the damage will have been done.

The main difficulties which have been found to arise in connection with the use of the flame lamp, and which have rendered the Regulations less well-observed than might have been hoped, do not arise in the case of the automatic detector. At the same time, however, there are other disadvantages with the automatic detector which do not apply to the flame lamp. Chief among these is its inability to do more than give an indication of a particular percentage of firedamp at the spot where the instrument is hung. This limitation, which is not found in the flame-safety-lamp, seems likely to be found to some extent in any type of automatic detector, or at least in any type which operates on the same principle as the Ringrose Alarm.

The automatic detector, however, besides being free from certain defects found in the flame-safety-lamp, also possesses positive advantages. Once it has been taken to the face it should act as an ever-alert sentinel standing guard over the men while they get the coal and earn their wages, and indicating in some obvious manner, if not that danger is present, at least that firedamp is present and that a condition of affairs has newly arisen which necessitates immediate investigation by a responsible official.

It is not likely to be an entirely perfect sentinel, none the less, for it remains true that unless the man in charge takes it into the face and keeps it constantly near enough to the men employed to ensure that they will see (Or hear) when the alarm is given, its signals may pass unheeded. To that extent, it is preferable that an automatic detector should also serve as a working light, since the chances of its being left behind or badly positioned are then remote. On the other hand, if it is used for a working light as well as for an alarm, it will obviously be subjected to harder usage, with a possibly detrimental effect upon the mechanism.

Risk Considerations.

In the Committee's opinion, the provisions and facilities in regard to the detection of firedamp by the workmen should be related to the risk to which they are exposed, and the type of detector to be provided should be appropriate to that risk.

The managements of some collieries, in order to avoid any additional risk consequent upon the use of electricity on the face, prefer to use compressed air. Moreover the Inspectorate are empowered by law to object to the use of electricity where they consider it dangerous, and finally, where it is used the Act requires that the current must be switched off if more than 125 per cent. of firedamp is present. These considerations must be taken to indicate that there is potentially a greater degree of danger when electricity is in use on the face than when it is not. The reason why this is so is that, with an electrically-driven machine which, for whatever reason, is not or has ceased to be flameproof, there may be present at any time while it is in use an igniting medium for any explosive mixture of firedamp and air which may be present. Moreover, in the case of a coal-cutter, the very operation of the machine tends to produce conditions resulting in an abnormal emission of firedamp.

General Regulation 132, besides requiring that electrical motors shall be flameproof, also directs that a flame-safety-lamp shall be provided and used with each motor, and by No. 7 of the Firedamp Detector Regulations this lamp may be replaced by any approved detector. But, in view of the continuous nature of the risk of open sparking occurring if the machine is defective, and in view of the impossibility of carrying out continuous tests with the flame lamp, it seemed to the Committee that, provided a satisfactory automatic detector was in existence, there was a case for its compulsory use where electricity was employed on the face, because in those circumstances the outstanding advantage of the automatic detector, namely, continuous detection, assumed a particular importance.

A second set of circumstances in which they thought that the compulsory provision of a proportion of automatic detectors would be justifiable was in the case of broken" workings in bord and pillar operations, since the ventilation current in the outer ring of workings is liable to be fouled by firedamp given off from the goaf, particularly when barometric pressure is low. In such circumstances, prompt detection of the beginning of the process is of particular importance.

Factors Favouring Compulsory Use.

Section 5 deals with the Ringrose Alarm, and discusses the main criticisms advanced relating to illumination, reliability, accuracy, cost and maintenance, and the Committee conclude that while wider experience will no doubt lead to further improvements in the instrument itself, and in the technique of its use, the instrument is already sufficiently developed for compulsory use at mines in the circumstances indicated in Section 4 of the Report.

Granted the existence of a satisfactory automatic detector and granted also its efficient maintenance, a number of other factors bearing upon the desirability of imposing some measure of compulsion to use the instrument fall to be considered.

In the first place the Committee believe that if automatic detectors seem likely, even to a small degree, to increase the safety of the men employed, then that in itself is a powerful argument in favour of compulsion. They freely recognise that opinions may differ in regard to this, and they themselves cannot, of course, venture to say with any degree of confidence that the installation of automatic detectors will, in fact, result in a reduction in the number of explosions. The Committee feel, however, that provided they are accepted with goodwill by managements, and provided they are carefully maintained in the lamprooms and properly used by the workmen, they will afford some additional protection against explosions, although the extent and value of that protection may never be precisely ascertainable.

Secondly, the fact that the representatives of the workmen have long pressed for compulsory use, and are satisfied with the instrument available as a means to increase the safety of those on whose behalf they are acting, must be taken into very serious consideration.

Thirdly, it is clear to them that experience has demonstrated that compulsion is essential in order to secure the full trial of those instruments already available, and of any other similar instrument which may subsequently be developed.

The Committee have had in mind that the best line of development for such instruments as these would have been by the normal process of action and reaction between the manufacturers and the industry based upon the tests of practical use and experience. Such has been the development with numbers of other safety appliances such as sheathed explosives, improved safety-lamps, and protective equipment. Broadly speaking, however, this normal process of development has not been followed in the case of the automatic detector; and, in spite of the substantial improvements effected in the instrument since its original introduction, progress in utilisation has been for so long at a practical standstill that they can now see no alternative but to recommend a measure of compulsion.

The Committee accordingly recommend that after the lapse of a period sufficient to enable all the necessary arrangements to be made, the provision of automatic detectors in any seam in which safety-lamps are required to be used by Section 82 (1) (a) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911, shall be compulsory in the following circumstances —

(a) In conjunction with any electrical motor in use at the working face.

(b) On every longwall face, where electric power is in use, in the proportion of one automatic detector (including any automatic detector required by (a) ) out of every eight detectors required to be provided, unless the firedamp content of the return air from such a face (as ascertained by the Manager within the preceding 12 months, in the manner laid down in Section 82 (4) of the Coal Mines Act, 1911) is normally found to be less than 0.5 per cent. Provided that for a single unit conveyor face not more than two, and for a double unit conveyor face not more than four, automatic detectors shall be required.

(c) In bord and pillar workings one out of every four detectors required to be provided in "broken" workings immediately contiguous to the goaf shall be of an automatic type.

The Committee emphasise, however, that in making these recommendations they also consider that very close regard must be paid to the care and treatment of the Ringrose instruments, and probably of any other automatic detector which may subsequently be approved.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Foot, Isaac      
Frowen, William      Whos Who Page
Hicken, H.      Whos Who Page
Hyslop, George P.      Whos Who Page
Naylor, A. E.      
Peyer, C. H. S. de      
Wynne, Frederick Horton    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
26 Mar 1938  Firedamp Detector Regulations (The Science and Art of Mining)
09 Apr 1938  Firedamp Detector Regulations, Recommendations of Committee (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 Apr 1938  Firedamp Detector Regulations (The Science and Art of Mining)
04 Jun 1938  Firedamp Detectors, Draft Regulations Circulated (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print