Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

26th March 1938, Page: 298, Column: 1

Notes On November Examinations

Report of Central Examiners

The Central Examiners have issued their report on the examinations for certificates of Competency as managers and under-managers held in November, 1937. The comments on the work of candidates are given below with the text of the questions, the comments being reproduced in italics. The official Question Papers, containing also the plans and diagrams, are obtainable (2s. net) through H.M. Stationery Office.

Winning and Working (1st Class).

(1) A shaft, 20 feet finished diameter, has been sunk to a depth of 100 yards and walled to 95 yards. Describe with the aid of sketches how you would proceed with the sinking and walling of the next 60 feet length. Assume the shaft to be practically dry. (50)

The majority of candidates showed a good knowledge of sinking procedure. Some omitted any details of the actual sinking work, whilst others failed to make any reference to a bricking scaffold. Wood or cast-iron curbs were usually mentioned, but very few references were made to concrete curbs. Only a small proportion made any provision for lighting and ventilation.

(2) A longwall face 80 yards long in a seam of coal 6 feet thick dipping 1 in 3 and lying to the rise side of a main level haulage road is worked on the line of full dip by means of coal-cutters and conveyors. The under-cut is 4 feet 6 inches deep. To minimise subsidence it has been decided to adopt solid packing. Describe with the aid of sketches the method you would adopt for transporting packing material to the face and getting it into the packs. (40)

Very fair answers in most cases. A few candidates misread the question and explained the method they would adopt on a face set out on the line of strike.

(3) Sketch and describe how you would support with 4 inches hy 2 inches by 2½ inches splayed leg steel arches the junction of four roadways. Assume the roadways to be at right angles to each other and level. (40)

Generally well answered, except in a few instances where the method of support suggested was not in accordance with the question.

(4) In a self-acting incline (not endless rope) 200 yards long the gradient varies, and at certain places in the incline the full tubs have difficulty in overcoming the resistance of the empty tubs, especially when material is being sent inbye. Describe in detail what you consider would be the safest and most efficient method of overcoming this difficulty whilst maintaining essentially the same method of haulage. The regrading of the road is not practicable and compressed air power is available if required. (40)

Most candidates suggested a practical solution to this problem. Some suggestions entailed men being in the incline whilst tubs were in motion, a procedure both inadvisable and unnecessary under the circumstances.

(5) A large fault of unknown dimensions has been met with in the mine workings. Explain how you would proceed to locate the displaced portion of the seam. (40)

Moderately well answered. Boring was the general method adopted. Only a few answers contained any mention of the useful information to be obtained sometimes from fossils.

(6) Describe the following constituents of bituminous coal: (a) Fusain, (b) durain, (c) clarain, (d) vitrain. (40)

Nearly all candidates showed a very fair knowledge of these constituents, but the majority omitted any reference to ash and volatile contents.

(7) Discuss the advantages and disadvantages from the standpoint of safety of a slowly advancing hand-worked face and a rapidly advancing machine-worked face. (40)

A number of answers were incomplete, but the main points were realised by the majority.

Ventilation (1st Class).

(1) On the plan . . . show how you would arrange the distribution of the air-currents, using the signs and colours given in the General Regulations. Sheets to be shown thus f. (50)

Most of the arrangements were, on the whole, satisfactory. In some cases the essential separation doors at the pit bottom were omitted; often the number of doors in each crosscut increased towards the face, instead of the reverse. Explosion-proof stoppings should be placed in all roads connecting intake and return airways which are not to be travelled, and indicated by the regulation sign. The regulator should be placed at the return end of its split.

(2) What impurities are most often met with in the atmosphere of mines? How should they be dealt with? Give particulars of the effects and composition of each gas, and state how its presence is detected. (30)

Some candidates emphasised firedamp and blackdamp as most commonly met with. Others did not put these in their order of frequence. The second part of the question was well answered.

(3) Show how you would arrange the ventilation current in a district where very large quantities of coal, brought by two conveyors, are loaded into tubs at one point, so as to avoid discomfort and danger during the loading. (30)

Although most were aware of the urgency and extent of the problem, the answers were disappointing; the methods of dealing with dust were often not mentioned, and only a few re-arranged the ventilation at the loading point.

(4) Sketch and describe an air-bridge or air-crossing and its construction. What are the principal objects aimed at and what precautions should be taken in the operations of putting one to work? (30)

Well answered, except that the sketches giving the two sections often disagreed as to the direction of the girders.

(5) What developments have recently taken place in plant for the generation of the ventilating current in mines? Give a description of one type, in detail, with the necessary arrangements. What percentage of useful effect should be attained? (30)

Satisfactory in nearly every instance. Some of the percentages were rather optimistic.

(6) Discuss fully the effect on the ventilation generally of filling up the whole of the goaf or waste. Deal with the objections usually urged to this course. (30)

Good answers, the case for and against being well put, but the circumstances under which each. practice was preferred were often omitted.

(7) Two adjacent shafts at a new mine, each 20 feet diameter, have been sunk to a depth of 640 yards in fairly level coal measures. One seam 5 feet thick was struck at 600 yards depth and another 6 feet thick at the bottom. It is proposed to work both seams extensively. Show by sketches how you would arrange the roadways near the shaft pillar for ventilating both seams with a maximum of safety and a minimum of leakage. (30)

Many apparently misunderstood the question, not realising that both shafts were sunk to the full depth. Others gave it poor consideration. Few answers were satisfactory.

Explosions, Etc. (1st Class).

(1) In a dry and gassy mine a fire and subsequent explosion. cause the death of a number of persons; another explosion is feared and the rescue workers have to be withdrawn before the bodies can be recovered. It is decided to flood the affected workings before further recovery work is attempted. Set out in detail how you would proceed with the recovery work after the workings have been completely flooded. (30)

The answers were very varied. Many candidates suggested the use of rescue teams working through airlocks, a lengthy and tedious process which is not always necessary in these circumstances. Very few candidates referred to the recovery and removal of the bodies which is attended with a risk of infection if great care is not exercised. Another point of importance often missed was the danger of heating in the area after the water had been cleared, and especially in those places where accumulations of sand might have been left when the first recovery work had been abandoned.

(2) Considerable quantities of coal dust may be produced at points of loading into tubs from face, and gate-road, conveyors. What should be done to reduce the production of this dust, and what arrangements would you make to prevent the dust from being carried by the air-currents and deposited on the road ways? (25)

Every candidate answered this question and many did so very satisfactorily.

(3) What precautionary measures would you adopt in connection with coal-cutting machines, whether driven by compressed air or electricity, to deal promptly with an outbreak of fire which may occur unexpectedly on the coal face, or in connection with the machine or its appurtenances? (25)

A number of very good answers, but some candidates appeared to be unaware of the danger of using extinguishers of the Carbon-Tetrachloride type, the fumes from these being of a dangerous character. Bags of stone dust not too heavy for a man to handle easily, kept at the road heads and some carried on the machine where there is sufficient height, were often suggested.

(4) Which of the two permissible systems of rescue organisation do you prefer? Enumerate their relative advantages and disadvantages. (25)

Some very good answers. Quite a large number of candidates favoured Scheme A, where a permanent team is always available at the Rescue Station, but they very properly stated that the effectiveness of this scheme would be very much impaired if there was only the prescribed number of trained men at the pits. Others favoured Scheme B, but many overlooked the fact that with either scheme the main supply of apparatus and equipment must be kept and maintained in good condition at the Central Rescue Station.

(5) Discuss the relative merits of the longwall and pillar and stall (or stoop and room) systems of working seams of coal liable to spontaneous heating, and describe any modifications and precautions you would take in each case. (25)

The answers were generally satisfactory. Sketches were not asked for; they were frequently given, but in many cases were very crude. Most candidates favoured the longwall system, but in thick and highly inclined seams this is impracticable.

(6) A large dip district has been sealed off with stoppings in the intake and return roadways, with a sampling pipe through each of the stoppings. When and how would you take samples from the pipes for analysis so as to obtain correct information of the state of the atmosphere in the sealed-off district? (25)

Only a little over half of the candidates attempted to answer this question; the proper time and the manner of taking the samples were not well understood. The proper time to take a sample is when the water-gauge indicates a positive pressure from within the sealed-off area; at other times it is exceedingly difficult to get a true sample.

Machinery (1st Class).

(1) Electric cables may be insulated by bitumen, rubber, paper or cambric. Which of these materials would you use for cables for the following purposes? Give reasons for your choice: (a) To carry electric current along an underground road at 3,300 volts, 3-phase. (b) To serve an electrical sinking pump in a shaft. (c) To supply power to an electric coal-cutting machine on a longwall face. (d) To connect the slip-rings of an induction motor with a metallic resistance. (28)

For a high tension cable in an underground road most candidates preferred paper insulation. To serve an electrical sinking pump, more candidates would use bitumen rather than rubber, and no candidate suggested using both materials. For a coal-cutter trailing cable, all candidates correctly chose rubber. For the connection between motor slip-rings and resistance, no candidate mentioned single core rubber insulated cables. The types mostly mentioned were paper and bitumen.

(2) The following readings were noted at a switchboard on a 3-phase electric system: Voltmeter, 2,200 volts; ammeter, 60 amperes; power factor meter, 0.8 lagging. Calculate the Board of Trade unite that would pass in 6 hours. (28)

This proved an easy mark-earner for those who knew the formula. Some candidates went wrong in working the kilowatt hours after getting the kilowatts correctly. Common arithmetical mistakes spoiled a number of answers.

(3) What is the importance of earthing in connection with electrical plant? In an electric-power plane comprising alternators, switchgear, transformers and motors, what parts would be earthed and how would you ensure a good earth? (28)

The avoidance of shock was always mentioned, but the advantages of earthing the neutral in alternators and transformers were often missed.

(4) What are the materials commonly used for the casing, impellers, guide vanes, shafts, sleeves, bushes and bearings of multi-stage, centrifugal or turbine pumps? If the water is acid or corrosive what changes may be made in the materials used to cope with it? (28)

This question was not well answered. The differences between brass, gunmetal and phosphor bronze are often not known, and stainless steel for acid water was mentioned only infrequently.

(5) Make full-size drawings of the following: (a) One of the studs for securing the cover to a steam cylinder, the stud being 1 inch diameter, 3½ inches long, and the cover 1 inch thick. (b) A setscrew ½ inch diameter, 2 inches long, for securing a loose collar to a shaft. (c) A bolt inch diameter, 4 inches long, with hexagon head, square neck, and square nut. Show useful dimensions. Indicate the threads (of Whitworth type) and state the number of threads per inch. (28)

The commonest mistake was to make the stud with a head, i.e., a tap bolt instead of a stud. The numbers of threads per inch in Whitworth screws were seldom known. The indications of thread were often of left-handed threads.

(6) A shaft 16 feet diameter is to be sunk to a depth of 600 feet. The inflow of water is expected to be up to 900 gallons per minute. Give in outline a specification of the complete pumping plant that you would install in and about the shaft for raising the water and to keep the bottom fit for the sinkers to work in. Assume that any kind of power is available. (38)

Most candidates would use one pump only, whereas for the rate of water inflow two pumps are essential. Some candidates confined their answers to the pump and its motor only. Some candidates would secure the rising main and the electric cable to the shaft sides.

(7) In connection with an electric power plant enumerate and describe in a few words the instruments and apparatus that may be installed for ascertaining the performance of the steam raising plant. (28)

This question was well answered, though in some cases instruments and apparatus received a bare mention only.

(8) On the indicator diagram given on a separate sheet mark the point of cut-off of the steam and the point of closing of the release and calculate the mean effective pressure. (28)

The point of cut-off was always correct, but a number of candidates showed the opening of the release for the closing which was asked for. In arriving at the mean effective pressure candidates used the numerous lines shown on the drawing, whereas they could have taken every other line. Some candidates ignored the portion of the diagram below the atmospheric line in working the mean effective pressure.

[To be Continued.]


Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
14 Aug 1937  Board For Mining Examinations (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Feb 1938  Examination Results (The Science and Art of Mining)
12 Mar 1938  Notes On Surveyors' Examination, Central Examiner's Report (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Mar 1938  Notes On November Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
09 Apr 1938  Notes On November Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)
23 Apr 1938  Notes On November Examinations, Report of Central Examiners (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print